A Comparison of High-intensity Interval Training Protocols on Health and Fitness

March 11, 2019 updated by: Elise Brown, Oakland University

A Comparison of High-intensity Interval Training Protocols on Cardiometabolic Markers, Physical Performance, and Psychosocial Markers in College Females

Recently, it has been demonstrated that multimodal high-intensity interval training (MM-HIIT) (utilizing resistance-based and functional movements) can produce similar aerobic adaptations compared to high-intensity interval training (HIIT) using rowing but with greater muscle performance in females. In addition, HIIT has been shown to be more enjoyable than continuous training, and this may lead to enhanced self-efficacy and increased physical activity. To the investigators' knowledge, however, the cardiometabolic effects (blood pressure, abdominal/visceral fat, blood sugar, blood lipids/fats) of MM-HIIT have not been reported. The investigators aim to compare MM-HIIT with HIIT using a traditional aerobic fitness exercise (rowing) for the degree of cardiometabolic, physical performance (strength, endurance, power), and psychosocial (self-efficacy and enjoyment) adaptations. They will also determined sustained effects of the intervention by completing a 9-month follow-up.

Study Overview

Status

Completed

Conditions

Detailed Description

The PI will verify age with a drivers license or other form of identification to ensure that the study participants are at least 18 years of age to participate. After obtaining consent, the PI will then administer a pre-exercise screening tool, the Physical Activity Readiness Questionnaire for Everyone, to the participant for them to complete in order to aid in determining study eligibility. If the participant is deemed eligible, 3 other questionnaires will be emailed to participants for completion: Physical Activity Enjoyment Scale, Exercise Self-efficacy Scale, and the International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) short form. Given that the participants will be instructed to not change any physical activity habits outside of the study, the IPAQ will be used to control for this pre- and post-intervention and weekly throughout the duration of the intervention. All forms must be completed and submitted to the PI prior to further data collection. Data collection will consist of a (1) blood collection visit, (2) exercise testing and abdominal/visceral fat measurement session, (3) three exercise/movement familiarization sessions (only conducted pre-intervention), (4) three strength, muscular endurance, and muscular power testing sessions before and after the intervention, and 12 weeks of training three times per week as described below. Excluding the consent obtaining meeting, participants will attend 8 sessions prior to beginning the intervention as detailed below. During the intervention, participants will be wearing heart rate monitors in order to monitor their training intensity. The PI will lead all data collection procedures with the assistance of School of Health Science students and Dr. Myung Choi except for the blood collection and analysis which will be supervised by Dr. Kristen Landis-Piwowar. All measures will be assessed pre- and post-intervention. Blind copy emails will be sent to remind the participants about upcoming data collection sessions and to schedule a data collection appointment.

Day 1: Prevention Research Center (blood collection visit)

Following 12-hr fast, assessments include:

  • weight, height, waist circumference
  • resting heart rate
  • blood pressure
  • venipuncture (blood sugar and fat)
  • blood analysis

Day 2: Prevention Research Center (exercise testing and visceral fat visit)

Assessments include:

  • dual-x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) to measure visceral adipose tissue
  • bicycle VO2max test with standard warm-up and clinical monitoring to assess aerobic endurance
  • Physical Activity Enjoyment Scale and Exercise Self-efficacy Scale (post-intervention)

Days 3-5: Oakland University (OU) Recreation Center (familiarization visits)

Familiarization sessions include:

  • teaching movements used in subsequent testing and training
  • assessment of musculoskeletal limitations
  • intervention leader and assistants will attend sessions as part of training

Days 6-8: OU Recreation Center (performance testing visits)

Assessments include:

  • Day 6: one repetition maximum (1 RM) testing for back squat (muscular strength); 70% 1RM back squat for max effort repetitions unbroken (muscular endurance)
  • Day 7: 1 RM overhead press (muscular strength)
  • Day 8: 1 RM deadlift (muscular strength) and max broad jump (muscular power)
  • standardized warm-up prior to cool-down following each session
  • at least 48 hours of rest between each session

Pre- and post-intervention health measurements: Prevention Research Center Anthropometrics and vital sign measures such as height (using a stadiometer), weight (using an eye-level beam scale), heart rate and blood pressure (sitting with a sphygmomanometer) will be obtained.

Pre- and post-intervention endurance measurements: Prevention Research Center Aerobic fitness will be directly assessed by a VO2max bicycle test. Each participant will be allowed to warm-up on the bicycle for 5 minutes at a low intensity. The VO2max bicycle test will include 3 minute stages with increasing intensity each stage of 30 - 60 watts. The required cadence will be maintained at 60 revolutions per minute (RPM) for each stage. The test will be terminated at volitional fatigue defined as the participant no longer able to maintain 60 RPMs for 20 seconds after encouragement from the testers. For most people, the test will take approximately 10 minutes.

Pre- and post-intervention strength measurements: OU Recreation Center Prior to strength testing, three familiarization sessions will be conducted whereby participants will be taught and given a chance to practice the movements to be used for testing and training. During these sessions, participants will be assessed for any musculoskeletal limitations such as a lack of hip and ankle mobility that may require movement/exercise modifications to ensure safe technique. Following the familiarization sessions, each participant will complete three further days of testing, with at least 48 hours between testing days. These testing sessions will occur at OU Recreation Center. Each of these test sessions will be preceded by a standardized warmup and instruction regarding the upcoming session. On separate days, muscle strength will be assessed using 1-repetition maximum (1RM) testing for back squat, press, and deadlift using standardized protocols. The back squat will be performed to below parallel (hip crease below the apex of the patella), the press will be initiated with the bar on the clavicles, and the deadlift will performed in the conventional stance. All testing days will be repeated following training.

Pre- and post-intervention muscle endurance and muscle power: OU Recreation Center Muscle endurance will be assessed by repetitive back squats to voluntary exhaustion. The load will be set at 70% of the pre-training

1RM back squat for both pre- and post-training tests. This test will be conducted immediately after the 1 RM testing for back squat. Movement standards will be the same as those for the 1RM test, and the total number of successful repetitions achieved without a rest will be recorded. Muscle power will be assessed using a static broad jump. The best horizontal distance achieved out of 3 trials will be recorded. This test will be conducted immediately after the 1 RM testing for the deadlift.

Pre- and post-intervention biochemistry measurements: Prevention Research Center Following a 12-hour fast, participants will complete venipuncture collection procedures. Two invasive needle sticks will be performed during this investigation (one needle stick pre-intervention and another needle stick post-intervention). Four milliliters (mL) of blood will be collected both pre- and post-intervention for measurement of: total cholesterol, high-density lipoprotein cholesterol, triglycerides, alanine aminotransferase, aspartate aminotransferase, glucose, and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol. This total amount of blood (8mL) collected during this trial will equate to 1.6 teaspoons of blood (5mL = 1 teaspoon). The risks of blood draw may include: infection, delayed healing, bruising and/or inflammation at the site of vein puncture, physical discomfort, mental discomfort, fainting and feeling faint and injury to a nerve or vessel. These risks will be minimized by the use of a trained professional (Dr. Kristen Landis-Piwowar) experienced with performing the blood draws, sterile technique and single use, disposable, materials who will be supervising the blood draw and analysis. Study participants may refuse to participate at any time and withdraw from the study without penalty.

Pre- and post-intervention visceral fat measurement using dual x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) scan: Prevention Research Center For this measurement of visceral fat, each participant will be asked to lie flat on a special table below the DXA scan. A trained technician (Elise Brown, Ryan Tyler, Myung Choi, or Samantha Orr) will position each participant's body under the scan and then perform the scan, which will only take < 5 minutes.

Pre- and post-intervention psychosocial questionnaires The purpose of including these psychosocial assessments in the proposed study is to assess changes in physical activity enjoyment and exercise self-efficacy. High-intensity interval training has been shown to be more enjoyable than continuous training, and this may lead to enhanced self-efficacy. These questionnaires will be emailed to participants for completion: Physical Activity Enjoyment Scale and Exercise Self-efficacy Scale.

Nine months following the intervention, participants will complete all assessments again.

The intervention will be led by students (one leader and at least 2 assistants) who will be trained by the PI, and exercise protocols are as follows:

MM-HIIT Group: This group will train using multimodal exercises for 5 sets of 60 seconds of all out work, followed by 3 minutes of rest (a total of 20 minutes each session). Each session will have the same exercises within each set, but every session will be different than the others for movements utilized. There will be three movements used in each set. The first movement will be a strength movement (such as overhead press, squat, deadlift) for 4-6 repetitions. The second movement follows the first immediately and is a faster body weight or light implement power movement such as lunges, body weight squats, or push ups for 6-8 repetitions. The third movement follows the second immediately and is a very fast, sprint-like movement such as box jumps, ball slams, or jump rope for the remainder of the 60 seconds. The intent of each set is to be completed with as much effort as possible across the full 60 seconds. The intervention leader will record weight used for each exercise and will instruct participants to increase intensity (up to 110% of previous intensity used) at subsequent session once maximum prescribed repetitions have been.

R-HIIT Group: This group will train using a rowing ergometer for 5 sets of 60 seconds of all out work, followed by 3 minutes of rest (a total of 20 minutes each session). Each training session will be the same across the 12 weeks. The intent of each set is to be completed with as much effort as possible across the full 60 seconds.

Control Group: This group will be instructed to continue with any activity they were involved in prior to the study and to not begin any new exercise programs during the course of the study. To incentive participation in this group, the control group will be offered the MM-HIIT intervention the following semester at no cost.

Study Type

Interventional

Enrollment (Actual)

16

Phase

  • Not Applicable

Contacts and Locations

This section provides the contact details for those conducting the study, and information on where this study is being conducted.

Study Locations

    • Michigan
      • Rochester, Michigan, United States, 48309
        • Oakland University

Participation Criteria

Researchers look for people who fit a certain description, called eligibility criteria. Some examples of these criteria are a person's general health condition or prior treatments.

Eligibility Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study

18 years to 40 years (ADULT)

Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Yes

Genders Eligible for Study

Female

Description

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Potential participants will be non-obese (waist circumference ≤ 88 cm) recreationally active females aged 18 - 40 years who do not engage in a regular training program. Recreationally active is defined as periodically participating in physical activity or exercise between 1 - 3 hours a week for at least a month, but not involved in a systematic endurance or weight training activity.

Exclusion Criteria:

  • Potential participants will be excluded if they have a history of exercise-limiting cardiovascular, respiratory, metabolic, or musculoskeletal illness/injury or if they are currently taking medication that would alter the physiological responses to exercise. They will also be excluded if they are pregnant or have a history of fainting while giving blood.

Study Plan

This section provides details of the study plan, including how the study is designed and what the study is measuring.

How is the study designed?

Design Details

  • Primary Purpose: PREVENTION
  • Allocation: RANDOMIZED
  • Interventional Model: PARALLEL
  • Masking: NONE

Arms and Interventions

Participant Group / Arm
Intervention / Treatment
EXPERIMENTAL: Multimodal
Multimodal High-Intensity Interval Training Intervention. This group will train using multimodal exercises for 5 sets of 60 seconds of all out work, followed by 3 minutes of rest. Each session will have the same exercises within each set, but every session will be different than the others for movements utilized. There will be three movements used in each set. The first movement will be a strength movement for 4-6 repetitions. The second movement follows the first immediately and is a faster body weight or light implement power movement for 6-8 repetitions. The third movement follows the second immediately and is a very fast, sprint-like movement for the remainder of the 60 seconds. The intent of each set is to be completed with as much effort as possible across the full 60 seconds.
The intervention will occur 3 times per week for 12 weeks and include a warm-up, MM-HIIT or R-HIIT training protocol, and a cool down.
ACTIVE_COMPARATOR: Rowing
Multimodal High-Intensity Interval Training Intervention. This group will train using a rowing ergometer for 5 sets of 60 seconds of all out work, followed by 3 minutes of rest (a total of 20 minutes each session). Each training session will be the same across the 12 weeks. The intent of each set is to be completed with as much effort as possible across the full 60 seconds.
The intervention will occur 3 times per week for 12 weeks and include a warm-up, MM-HIIT or R-HIIT training protocol, and a cool down.
NO_INTERVENTION: Control
Multimodal High-Intensity Interval Training Intervention. This group will be instructed to continue with any activity they were involved in prior to the study and to not begin any new exercise programs during the course of the study. To incentive participation in this group, the control group will be offered the MM-HIIT intervention the following semester at no cost.

What is the study measuring?

Primary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure
Measure Description
Time Frame
Aerobic fitness
Time Frame: 15 minutes
Aerobic fitness will be directly assessed by a VO2max bicycle test. Each participant will be allowed to warm-up on the bicycle for 5 minutes at a low intensity. The VO2max bicycle test will include 3 minute stages with increasing intensity each stage of 30 - 60 watts. The required cadence will be maintained at 60 RPMs (revolutions per minute) for each stage. The test will be terminated at volitional fatigue defined as the participant no longer able to maintain 60 RPMs for 20 seconds after encouragement from the testers. For most people, the test will take approximately 10 minutes.
15 minutes

Secondary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure
Measure Description
Time Frame
Triglycerides
Time Frame: 10 minutes
Following a 12-hour fast, participants will complete venipuncture collection procedures. Two invasive needle sticks will be performed during this investigation (one needle stick pre-intervention and another needle stick post-intervention). Four milliliters (mL) of blood will be collected both pre- and post-intervention for measurement of triglycerides (mmol/L). This total amount of blood (8mL) collected during this trial will equate to 1.6 teaspoons of blood (5mL = 1 teaspoon).
10 minutes
Physical Activity Enjoyment scale
Time Frame: 5 minutes
The purpose of including this psychosocial assessment in the proposed study is to assess changes in physical activity enjoyment. Physical Activity Enjoyment Scale
5 minutes

Other Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure
Measure Description
Time Frame
Muscular Endurance
Time Frame: 5 minutes
Muscle endurance will be assessed by repetitive back squats to voluntary exhaustion. The load will be set at 70% of the pre-training 1RM back squat for both pre- and post-training tests. The total number of repetitions will be recorded.
5 minutes
Total Cholesterol
Time Frame: 5 minutes
Following a 12-hour fast, participants will complete venipuncture collection procedures. Two invasive needle sticks will be performed during this investigation (one needle stick pre-intervention and another needle stick post-intervention). Four milliliters (mL) of blood will be collected both pre- and post-intervention for measurement of: total cholesterol (mmol/L), alanine aminotransferase, aspartate aminotransferase, glucose, and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol. This total amount of blood (8mL) collected during this trial will equate to 1.6 teaspoons of blood (5mL = 1 teaspoon).
5 minutes
Visceral Fat
Time Frame: 5 minutes
For this measurement of visceral fat, each participant will be asked to lie flat on a special table below the DXA scan. A trained technician will position each participant's body under the scan and then perform the scan.
5 minutes
Muscular Strength
Time Frame: 90 minutes
Each participant will complete three days of testing, with at least 48 hours between testing days. These testing sessions will occur at OU Recreation Center. Each of these test sessions will be preceded by a standardized warmup and instruction regarding the upcoming session. On separate days, muscle strength will be assessed using 1-repetition maximum (1RM) testing for back squat, press, and deadlift using standardized protocols. The back squat will be performed to below parallel (hip crease below the apex of the patella), the press will be initiated with the bar on the clavicles, and the deadlift will performed in the conventional stance. All testing days will be repeated following training.
90 minutes
Muscular Power
Time Frame: 10 minutes
Muscle power will be assessed using a static broad jump. The best horizontal distance achieved out of 3 trials will be recorded. This test will be conducted immediately after the 1 RM testing for the deadlift.
10 minutes
High-density lipoprotein cholesterol
Time Frame: 10 minutes
Following a 12-hour fast, participants will complete venipuncture collection procedures. Two invasive needle sticks will be performed during this investigation (one needle stick pre-intervention and another needle stick post-intervention). Four milliliters (mL) of blood will be collected both pre- and post-intervention for measurement of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (mmol/L). This total amount of blood (8mL) collected during this trial will equate to 1.6 teaspoons of blood (5mL = 1 teaspoon).
10 minutes
Alanine Aminotransferase
Time Frame: 10 minutes
Following a 12-hour fast, participants will complete venipuncture collection procedures. Two invasive needle sticks will be performed during this investigation (one needle stick pre-intervention and another needle stick post-intervention). Four milliliters (mL) of blood will be collected both pre- and post-intervention for measurement of alanine aminotransferase (U/L). This total amount of blood (8mL) collected during this trial will equate to 1.6 teaspoons of blood (5mL = 1 teaspoon).
10 minutes
Asparate Aminotransferase
Time Frame: 10 minutes
Following a 12-hour fast, participants will complete venipuncture collection procedures. Two invasive needle sticks will be performed during this investigation (one needle stick pre-intervention and another needle stick post-intervention). Four milliliters (mL) of blood will be collected both pre- and post-intervention for measurement of asparate aminotransferase (U/L). This total amount of blood (8mL) collected during this trial will equate to 1.6 teaspoons of blood (5mL = 1 teaspoon).
10 minutes
Glucose
Time Frame: 10 minutes
Following a 12-hour fast, participants will complete venipuncture collection procedures. Two invasive needle sticks will be performed during this investigation (one needle stick pre-intervention and another needle stick post-intervention). Four milliliters (mL) of blood will be collected both pre- and post-intervention for measurement of glucose (mmol/L). This total amount of blood (8mL) collected during this trial will equate to 1.6 teaspoons of blood (5mL = 1 teaspoon).
10 minutes
Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol
Time Frame: 10 minutes
Following a 12-hour fast, participants will complete venipuncture collection procedures. Two invasive needle sticks will be performed during this investigation (one needle stick pre-intervention and another needle stick post-intervention). Four milliliters (mL) of blood will be collected both pre- and post-intervention for measurement of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (mmol/L). This total amount of blood (8mL) collected during this trial will equate to 1.6 teaspoons of blood (5mL = 1 teaspoon).
10 minutes
Exercise Self-Efficacy Scale
Time Frame: 5 minutes
The purpose of including this psychosocial assessments in the proposed study is to assess changes in exercise self-efficacy. Exercise Self-efficacy Scale.
5 minutes
Body Mass Index
Time Frame: 1 minutes
Anthropometrics such as height (cm) using a stadiometer and weight (kg) using an eye-level beam scale will be obtained. Height and weight will then be converted to body mass index (kg/m2)
1 minutes
Weight
Time Frame: 1 minutes
Anthropometrics such as weight (kg) using an eye-level beam scale will be obtained. Height and weight will then be converted to body mass index (kg/m2)
1 minutes
Height
Time Frame: 1 minutes
Anthropometrics such as height (cm) using a stadiometer will be obtained. Height and weight will then be converted to body mass index (kg/m2)
1 minutes
Waist Circumference
Time Frame: 5 minutes
Anthropometrics such as waist circumference (cm) using a Gulick tape will be obtained.
5 minutes
Blood Pressure
Time Frame: 10 minutes
Vital sign measures such as and blood pressure (mmHg) sitting using a sphygmomanometer will be obtained.
10 minutes
Heart Rate
Time Frame: 2 minutes
Vital sign measures such as heart rate (bpm) will be obtained.
2 minutes

Collaborators and Investigators

This is where you will find people and organizations involved with this study.

Investigators

  • Principal Investigator: Elise Brown, PhD, Oakland University

Publications and helpful links

The person responsible for entering information about the study voluntarily provides these publications. These may be about anything related to the study.

Study record dates

These dates track the progress of study record and summary results submissions to ClinicalTrials.gov. Study records and reported results are reviewed by the National Library of Medicine (NLM) to make sure they meet specific quality control standards before being posted on the public website.

Study Major Dates

Study Start (ACTUAL)

July 17, 2017

Primary Completion (ACTUAL)

August 23, 2018

Study Completion (ACTUAL)

August 23, 2018

Study Registration Dates

First Submitted

March 17, 2017

First Submitted That Met QC Criteria

March 27, 2017

First Posted (ACTUAL)

March 28, 2017

Study Record Updates

Last Update Posted (ACTUAL)

March 13, 2019

Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria

March 11, 2019

Last Verified

March 1, 2019

More Information

Terms related to this study

Plan for Individual participant data (IPD)

Plan to Share Individual Participant Data (IPD)?

NO

Drug and device information, study documents

Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated drug product

No

Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated device product

No

This information was retrieved directly from the website clinicaltrials.gov without any changes. If you have any requests to change, remove or update your study details, please contact register@clinicaltrials.gov. As soon as a change is implemented on clinicaltrials.gov, this will be updated automatically on our website as well.

Clinical Trials on Healthy

Clinical Trials on Multimodal High-Intensity Interval Training Intervention

3
Subscribe