- ICH GCP
- 미국 임상 시험 레지스트리
- 임상시험 NCT07240363
진행성 자궁내막증 환자에서의 일차 치료 수술 또는 보조생식기술을 이용한 일차 불임 치료 (EndoSOFT)
진행성 자궁내막증 환자에서 일차 치료 수술 또는 보조생식기술을 이용한 일차 불임 치료: 전국 다기관 무작위 대조군 임상시험
자궁내막증은 생식 연령 여성의 약 10%에 영향을 미치는 만성 질환입니다. 이 질환은 골반 통증과 불임과 강한 연관성이 있습니다. 질병의 진행 단계(3-4기)를 가진 여성들은 일반 인구에 비해 현저히 낮은 생식력을 보입니다. 스웨덴 연구에 따르면 체외 수정(IVF)과 같은 보조 생식 기술(ART) 치료를 받는 여성의 약 22%가 자궁내막증의 영향을 받고 있습니다.
진행성 자궁내막증과 불임을 가진 여성들의 최적의 치료 방법은 여전히 불확실합니다. 일부 임상의들은 직접 IVF를 진행할 것을 주장하는 반면, 다른 의사들은 임신 가능성을 높이기 위해 IVF 전에 자궁내막증 병변을 수술적으로 제거할 것을 제안합니다. 현재 증거는 소수의 관찰 연구로 제한되어 있습니다. 두 건의 관찰 연구와 한 건의 메타분석은 심부 자궁내막증을 가진 여성에서 IVF 단독 치료와 비교하여 IVF 전 수술이 임신률과 생존 출생률을 모두 증가시킬 수 있음을 시사했습니다. 그러나 이 중요한 임상적 질문에 답하기 위한 무작위 대조 시험(RCT)은 아직 수행되지 않았습니다.
이 연구는 진행성 자궁내막증과 불임을 가진 여성에서 수술 후 IVF와 IVF 단독 치료를 비교하는 첫 번째 전국적 다기관 무작위 대조 시험이 될 것입니다. 스웨덴의 모든 고도전문 자궁내막증 수술 및 생식 치료 센터들이 참여할 것입니다.
적격 참가자는 생식 치료를 원하는 39세 미만의 3-4기 자궁내막증을 가진 여성들입니다. 참가자들은 1:1 비율로 두 그룹 중 하나에 무작위 배정됩니다:
- IVF 전 수술 (자궁내막증 병변의 복강경 절제술 후 IVF)
- 사전 수술 없이 직접 IVF 주요 결과 지표는 무작위 배정 및 할당된 치료 시작 후 3년 이내의 누적 생존 출생률입니다. 2차 결과 지표에는 임신률, 임신까지의 시간, 치료 관련 합병증, 환자 보고 삶의 질, 그리고 비용 효율성이 포함됩니다.
우리의 가설은 진행성 자궁내막증을 가진 여성에서 사전 수술 없이 IVF만 시행하는 것보다 IVF 전 수술이 더 높은 누적 생존 출생률로 이어질 것이라는 것입니다.
이 시험의 결과는 임상 실무와 국제 지침에 상당한 영향을 미칠 것으로 예상됩니다. 결과에 관계없이, 이 연구는 치료 전략을 안내하고, 진행성 자궁내막증과 불임을 가진 여성들의 치료를 개선하며, 가장 효과적인 임신 달성 경로를 확인함으로써 의료 비용을 잠재적으로 절감할 수 있는 견고한 증거를 제공할 것입니다.
연구 개요
상세 설명
WHY THIS TRIAL IS NEEDED
BACKGROUND
Endometriosis Endometriosis is a prevalent condition affecting 10% of female population of reproductive age, leading to pain and sub-fertility. An earlier systematic literature reviews and meta-analysis suggests that women with advanced endometriosis (revised American Society for Reproductive Medicine classification of endometriosis (rASRM) stage III-IV) have a lower likelihood of achieving clinical pregnancy/live birth compared to women without endometriosis, while this difference has not been observed for mild disease (stage I-II).
Gynaecological Ultrasound and staging The prevalence of endometrioma and deep endometriosis found through systematic transvaginal ultrasound on women referred for ART treatment in Sweden has been estimated at 21.8%. Additionally, 75.8% of those with endometriosis were unaware of their condition prior to diagnosis. In recent years, two staging systems, namely the American Association of Gynecologic Laparoscopists (AAGL) Endometriosis classification and #ENZIAN have gained prominence owing to their accuracy when juxtaposed with surgical findings.
Surgical Treatment Women with endometriosis seem to experience pain relief after bowel surgery due to endometriosis. Consensus from the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) indicates that surgery can be performed prior to treatment with assisted reproductive technologies (ART). Additionally, the number of spontaneous pregnancies is high after surgery on patients with deep endometriosis. Furthermore, in patients with endometriosis stage I-II or in infertile patients with endometriomas, surgery can in some cases be considered to improve fertility. However, the risk of severe complications in patients undergoing rectal surgery is up to 10% including anastomosis leakage and fistulas.
Fertility treatment An earlier meta-analysis found that the number of oocytes and fertilization rates are lower in women with endometriosis as compared to those without, although not necessarily impacting the live birth rate. Still, some previous studies have shown lower likelihood of live birth and pregnancy after in vitro fertilisation (IVF) in women with endometriosis compared to women with unexplained or tubal infertility. Even though there is some controversy when it comes to the evidence of association between endometriosis and adverse reproductive outcome after IVF, there is biological plausibility for this type of association, especially in women with advanced endometriosis (chronic inflammation affecting folliculogenesis, technical difficulties at oocyte retrieval due to endometriomas or adhesions, increased risk of pelvic infection after oocyte pick-up).
RATIONALE FOR STUDY
Only a few comparative retrospective studies on first-line surgery versus first-line ART have been performed, with no available randomised controlled trials (RCTs). In two retrospective register studies, first-line surgery in patients with deep endometriosis (DE) in the anterior compartment or colorectal DE showed improved live birth rates (LBR) and pregnancy rates (PR) compared to first-line ART. An important limitation in the previous studies on patients with endometriosis has been the challenge of staging and characterizing the disease consistently using preoperative imaging techniques. Currently, the decision regarding the choice between surgery and IVF is collaborative and individualised, considering various factors such as the patient's medical and surgical history, presence of pain symptoms, age, results of ovarian reserve testing, and semen analysis. Lack of randomised RCTs or at least robust prospective cohort studies comparing these two approaches is noteworthy. Hence, there is an obvious need for a randomised controlled trial to address the impact of surgery prior to ART on the reproductive outcomes in women with endometriosis AAGL stage III-IV, to help patients and health-care workers with decision-making, with the overall aim to improve patient-outcomes.
STUDY OBJECTIVES
HYPOTHESIS First line surgery (prior to ART treatment) in women with endometriosis AAGL stage III-IV will result in improved cumulative live birth rate (CLBR) as compared to first line ART.
PRIMARY OBJECTIVE To assess whether surgery conducted prior to ART treatments in women with endometriosis AAGL stage III-IV increases chances of CLBR as compared to first line ART.
SECONDARY OBJECTIVES
To evaluate whether surgery prior to ART treatments in women with endometriosis AAGL stage III-IV will result in:
- improved cumulative pregnancy rate (CPR) and lower miscarriage rate as compared to first line ART.
- shorter time to live birth or pregnancy as compared to first line ART.
- better reproductive outcomes per IVF cycle and a lower rate of recurrent implantation failure (RIF).
- lower rate of infections after oocyte pick-up requiring treatment with antibiotics as compared to first line ART.
- higher Quality of life and less pain measured with Endometriosis Health Profile (EHP-30) and Numeric Rating Scale (NRS) before ART, i) at the time of oocyte retrieval, ii) two months after ART and iii) at the three-year follow-up visit as compared to first line ART.
- reduced pregnancy and delivery complications, as well as fewer complications within 8 weeks postpartum.
To explore whether surgery prior to ART treatments in women with endometriosis AAGL stage III-IV will be cost effective compared with first line ART.
To investigate whether serum progesterone level on the day of frozen embryotransfer in hormone replacement cycles in patients with severe endometriosis is associated with reproductive outcomes (LBR, pregnancy rate, miscarriage rate) and to determine if there is any difference in p-progesterone level between the two different study groups first line ART vs first line surgery in women with endometriosis AAGL stage III-IV.
PRIMARY OUTCOME MEASURE Cumulative live-birth rate within three years from first treatment (surgery or ART treatment).
SECONDARY OUTCOME MEASURES (see below in the protocol)
STUDY ENROLLMENT
SCREENING PROCEDURE AND PARTICIPANT IDENTIFICATION
All women with stage III-IV AAGL endometriosis with infertility referred and/or eligible for surgery and/or ART-treatment such as IVF or ICSI will undergo screening for this trial. The results of this screening will be documented in a screening log. After obtaining oral and written informed consent, patients will be registered and randomised. Registration data will be entered to an electronic Case Report Form (eCRF).
STAGING
At baseline, a specialised transvaginal and abdominal ultrasound examination, supplemented with transabdominal ultrasound if indicated will be performed according to the International Deep Endometriosis Analysis (IDEA) group recommendations to identify endometriosis lesions. Ultrasound and, if needed, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings will be classified using the #ENZIAN and AAGL classification system.
The presence of adenomyosis will also be documented and characterized according to the Morphological Uterus Sonographic Assessment (MUSA) group recommendation. Women with and without suspected adenomyosis will receive the same treatment protocols. Presence of adenomyosis will not influence allocation but will be considered during the discussion of the final analysis of study results.
The use of hormonal treatment for endometriosis, prior to the surgery/ first ART-treatment or between the surgery and ART-treatment, will be documented and considered in the discussion of the outcomes.
RANDOMISATION
After verification of eligibility, signed informed written consent participants will be randomly assigned to either undergo first-line ART or first-line surgery, followed by ART by equal allocation, 1:1. The randomisation procedure will be stratified for participating center (permuted block design). Randomisation will be performed at each site using the web-based instrument Red Cap. All inclusion criteria and no exclusion criteria must be met. One month before first treatment (IVF or surgery), inclusion and exclusion criteria are entered into the randomisation/registration application RedCap. Patients withdrawn from the study after randomisation but before treatment will be substituted by newly enrolled patients. Patients withdrawn from the study after first treatment will not be substituted. Username and password are required to log in; each investigator authorised to register patients has a personal login username and password. If all criteria are met, patients are registered, and the allocated patient number is recorded in the patients' medical file.
There could be some uncertainty surrounding participants' willingness to engage in a Randomised Controlled Trial (RCT) comparing two fundamentally distinct approaches. Therefore, we intend to offer women who fullfill eligibility criteria but decline randomisation. the opportunity to take part in a parallel study - a prospective cohort study, that would provide valuable real-world outcomes of two different approaches to treatment of endometriosis -associated infertility. This parallel study will evaluate identical outcomes to those in the randomised trial. However, instead of random assignment, participation decisions will be made by the patients themselves, resulting in what is commonly referred to as a patient preference trial.
DEFINITION START OF TRIAL
Start of trial will be defined as start of first treatment which will be either surgery or first ART cycle (e.g. start of FSH injections).
DEFINITION END OF TRIAL
The study will end when all patients enrolled in trial have been followed for 3 years after first treatment, withdrawn consent, or are lost to follow-up. Data from study participants that are lost to follow will be included in the final analysis. The trial steering committee may end enrolment at any time if it is deemed that this is in the best interest of the patients.
STUDY TREATMENT
Time from randomization to first treatment (surgery or first ART cycle) should be minimized with a goal of three months and should preferably not exceed six months. Complications due to treatments (IVF or surgery) will be register in the eCRF and treated according to clinical routine at each hospital.
EXPERIMENTAL TREATMENT
First line endometriosis surgery followed by ART such as IVF or ICSI.
STANDARD/CONTROL TREATMENT
First line ART such as IVF or ICSI.
QUALITY ASSURANCE OF SURGERY AND FERTILITY TREATMENT PARTICIPATING CENTERS
All participating surgical centers have been selected by the National Board of Health and Welfare following an application process to perform highly specialised advanced endometriosis surgery at a national level. A quality assessment form including institutional experience with endometriosis surgery and ART, annual volume of benign gynaecological complex cases must be completed. Moreover, surgical variables (e.g. operation time, blood loss) and complications within 30 days after surgery according to Clavien Dindo (22) must be reported . Furthermore, the infrastructure to participate in the trial must be satisfactory. In addition, the institution's ability to perform staging of endometriosis is considered. All ART-clinics authorised to provide publicly funded fertility care report their results continuously to the National Quality Registry for Assisted Reproduction (Q-IVF).
During the study, it is at the discretion of the coordinating investigators and Trial steering committee to close centers with a higher-than-average rate of postoperative major complications or poor quality of surgery or ART, from further accrual, temporarily or irrevocably after consultation with the Data Safety Monitoring Board.
PARTICIPATING SURGEONS
All included surgeons must be approved by the coordination investigators or/and trial steering committee ensuring adherence to protocol. In the site identification and quality assessment form the participating surgeons experience and annual caseload will be reported for review. It is at the discretion of the coordinating investigators or/and steering committee to select or deselect individual surgeons from participating in the trial. Only surgeons stated in the Quality assessment form are allowed being lead surgeons, amendments during the trial can be made.
Robot-assisted laparoscopic or traditional laparoscopic endometriosis surgery All included surgeons must have a previous experience of at least 20 advanced endometriosis surgeries.
PROSPECTIVE COHORT STUDY
For patients who decline participation in randomization or are excluded after randomization, an option to be included in an observational prospective cohort study will be provided. Participants in this study will adhere to the same study protocol as in the RCT, except for the randomisation itself. Analyses for this cohort will adjust for confounding factors using regression models, as described in the statistical methods section.
LONG-TERM FOLLOW-UP
There will be an opportunity for inclusion in a long-term follow-up, where participants from both the randomised controlled study and the cohort study will be eligible if they consent. In the long-term follow-up, conducted 10 years post-inclusion, we will utilise the unique Swedish personal identification number and gather data after study conclusion on i) infertility treatments from the National Register of ART in Sweden (Q-IVF), ii) live births from the Swedish Medical Birth Register (MFR) and The National Pregnancy Register and iii)number of recurrent endometriosis surgeries from Gynop.
P-PROGESTERONE ON THE DAY OF TRANSFER OF THE CRYOPRESERVED EMBRYO IN HORMONE REPLACEMENT THERAPY-CYCLES
Patients suffering of endometriosis may differ in their response to exogenous progesterone when undergoing frozen embryo transfer cycles (FET) with standard hormone replacement therapy, HRT. The aim of this sub-study is to investigate possible association between P-progesterone levels on the day of FET in HRT cycles and reproductive outcomes. Primary outcome is live birth rate, secondary outcomes include clinical pregnancy rate and miscarriage rate. Potential difference in P-progesterone levels between the two different study groups (surgery first vs IVF first) will also be investigated.
PATIENT REPORTED OUTCOMES (PROMS)
When evaluating quality of life among women with endometriosis many different scales have been used, mostly of generic character that are not specific to the disease. One of these is 30-item Endometriosis Health Profile (EHP30), a scale that perform well in clinical practice in the routine evaluation of Health-Related Quality of life (HRQoL) The use of EHP30 is recommended by the National Board and Welfare in Sweden, the ASRM and ESHRE. Using EHP-30, a small study has shown an improvement in HRQoL in the follow-up after endometriosis surgery, an effect that may last for up to 6.8 years . Two recent studies show postoperative improvement in HQQoL measured by EHP-30 10 weeks and 3 months after surgery, respectively. Especially women with deep endometriosis (DE) showed a more significant benefit from surgery. However, HRQoL can also be affected by infertility, and in this trial, infertility treatment will be delayed in one arm, thus, HRQoL is an important measurement.
HEALTH ECONOMICS
Health economics will be analyzed both with respect to Swedish conditions and with an international perspective.
DIRECT COSTS To evaluate healthcare costs, the internal accounting and billing systems within hospitals will be utilised to estimate direct costs based on Cost Per Patient (CPP) principles for individual treatments and/or Diagnosis-Related Groups (DRG) for surgery and fertility treatment. We will also obtain CPP and/or DRG-based cost data from the hospitals where the included women receive care in connection with surgery, fertility treatment. We will also obtain CPP and/or DRG-based cost data from the hospitals where the included women receive care in connection with surgery, fertility treatments, pregnancy, childbirth, and postpartum follow-up. In addition, data on employment status at baseline will be collected.
INDIRECT COSTS To assess indirect costs related to the disease, both study arms will be examined with regard to estimating productivity costs, specifically the level of decline in production.
STATISTICAL CONSIDERATIONS
The primary exposure is the randomised allocation (surgery prior to ART vs ART alone). All analyses will follow the intention-to-treat (ITT) principle, meaning participants are analyzed according to their randomised group regardless of adherence. Per-protocol and as-treated analyses will be conducted as sensitivity analyses to assess robustness. An interim analysis at the halfway point is planned to monitor potential adverse effects and ensure the safety of the interventions.
No formal adjustment for multiplicity will be made; the primary endpoint will be tested at a two-sided α=0.05, while secondary endpoints are considered supportive and exploratory. Sensitivity analyses will address protocol deviations, handling of missing data, and robustness to alternative modelling approaches.
DATA ANALYSES
Baseline demographic and patient's characteristics will be summarised by treatment group. Continuous variables will be described with mean, standard deviation, median, interquartile range, minimum and maximum, and categorical variables with counts and percentages.
Primary endpoint The primary endpoint of the study is the Cumulative Live Birth Rate (CLBR), defined as the proportion of participants achieving at least one live birth within three years following the initiation of treatment.
Primary analysis The primary analysis will compare proportions between treatment groups and report the crude relative risk (RR) with 95% confidence intervals. Adjusted analyses will use log-binomial regression (or modified Poisson with robust variance if convergence fails), including pre-specified covariates (age, BMI, AMH, ART type, center). A two-sided α=0.05 will be used.
Exploratory subgroup analyses Exploratory subgroup analyses will be conducted using treatment-by-subgroup interaction terms in regression models. Subgroups of interest include type of ART (IVF vs ICSI), age (<35 vs ≥35 years), ovarian reserve (AMH categories), and surgical characteristics (adnexal surgery yes/no; anterior vs posterior deep endometriosis, KVÅ codes). These analyses are exploratory and not adjusted for multiplicity.
Secondary endpoints
Time-to-Event outcomes Cumulative Live Birth Rate (CLBR) and Cumulative Pregnancy Rate (CPR) will be analysed as time-to-event outcomes, defined as the proportion of participants achieving a live birth or pregnancy within three years following initiation of treatment. Kaplan-Meier curves will be used to display cumulative incidence, and groups will be compared with stratified log-rank tests. Treatment effects will be estimated using Cox proportional hazards models, stratified by center and adjusted for pre-specified covariates. Hazard ratios with 95% confidence intervals will be reported.
Cycle-Specific Outcomes Live birth and pregnancy rates per IVF/ICSI cycle will be analysed using log-binomial regression or modified Poisson regression with robust variance to account for within-patient correlation. Other cycle-specific outcomes (e.g. number of oocytes retrieved, fertilisation rate, embryo transfer characteristics, miscarriage rates) will be summarised descriptively and compared between groups using appropriate regression models.
Quality of Life and Health Status Measures:
EHP-30 (continuous, 0-100 scale): Analysed using a linear mixed-effects model (LMM) with random intercepts for participants. Fixed effects will include treatment group, time, and the treatment×time interaction, adjusting for pre-specified covariates (age, BMI, AMH, center).
EQ-5D (continuous index 0-1): Analysed using the same LMM framework as EHP-30 (random intercepts, treatment, time, treatment×time, pre-specified covariates).
NRS pain (ordinal: mild 1-3, moderate 4-6, severe 7-10): Analysed using a generalised linear mixed model (GLMM) with cumulative logit link (ordinal logistic regression), including random intercepts for participants, fixed effects for treatment, time, and treatment×time, and pre-specified covariates (age, BMI, AMH, center).
Health economics A cost-effectiveness analysis will be conducted from the healthcare perspective. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER) will be calculated based on QALYs, and probabilistic sensitivity analyses will be performed to address parameter uncertainty.
Additional analysis
- Exploratory subgroup analyses will not be adjusted for multiplicity.
- Safety outcomes will be summarised descriptively by treatment group (frequency, severity, relation to treatment).
- All available data will be used, including outliers.
- Missing outcome data will be handled under the missing-at-random assumption via maximum likelihood in mixed models; for regression models requiring complete covariates, complete-case analysis will be applied.
Covariates Primary and secondary outcomes will be adjusted for pre-specified covariates (age, BMI, AMH, ART type, center), chosen based on clinical relevance and prior evidence.
POWER CALCULATION AND SAMPLE SIZE
The sample size calculation was based on a two-sample comparison of proportions with a two-sided α=0.05 and 80% power. Based on observational data, the cumulative live birth rate (CLBR) after three IVF cycles was assumed to be 55% in the ART-only group and 71% in the surgery+ART group (relative risk ≈1.29). This yields a required sample size of 142 participants per arm (284 total). Allowing for 20% attrition, the planned total sample size is 350 participants.
The necessary sample size for this study is estimated to 323 patients to accommodate a statistical analysis method. This estimation uses the 'pwr' package in R, specifically employing the power.prop.test method, which is designed to compare two proportions. This method is more aligned with contemporary statistical practices and provides a clear, transparent methodology for determining the required sample size based on expected success rates.
This means inclusion of 29 patients from/each center/year and 15 surgeries/year. In a Swedish study published in 2022 the prevalence of endometriosis in patients referred for ART-treatment was 21.8% and 17.2% of women had DE. In 2021 almost 10 500 IVF cycles were performed in Sweden, while more than 5 500 of those were first-time IVF/ICSI with autologous gametes.
INTERIM ANALYSIS AND STOPPING RULES An independent safety and monitoring board (DSMB) will conduct one interim analysis 1.5 years after the randomisation of the first patient or when when 175 patients have completed surgery or first IVF treatment, whichever occurs first. Because each participant has a three-year follow-up and recruitment will be completed within three years, only a limited proportion of primary outcomes will be available at the interim analysis. The analysis will therefore primarily address recruitment feasibility, participant safety including comparison of complication rates between study centers. The DSMB will monitor adverse events in both arms. For surgery, expected complication rates have been described previously in this protocol (9.9% Clavien-Dindo grade 1-2, 3.3% grade ≥3), while ART carries a different spectrum of risks (e.g. ovarian hyperstimulation, infection, or bleeding). A substantially higher-than-expected complication rate in either arm, major discrepancies between centers or other safety concerns may prompt the DSMB to recommend protocol modifications or early termination.
Recommendations from the DSMB will exclusively be communicated to the Trial Steering Committee.
ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS
RISK-BENEFIT CONSIDERATION By addressing the research questions, we aim to provide evidence to improve patient outcomes in a population that currently faces challenges in fertility treatment due to endometriosis. The research has the potential to benefit participants by improving their chances of successful conception and live birth rates.
Participants in the study may face several direct risks, including physical risks associated with surgery and assisted reproductive technologies, such as infection, or pre- and postoperative complications. Additionally, there may be psychological risks related to the emotional stress of undergoing medical procedures and the uncertainty of treatment outcomes. Furthermore, there are also risks associated with the collection and storage of sensitive medical data, which must be mitigated through robust data protection measures.
In the long term, the research may contribute to improving the understanding and management of endometriosis-related infertility, thereby potentially benefiting future patients.
INSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARD/ETHICS COMMITTEE
The study protocol, patient information, and informed consent are approved by Swedish Ethical Review Authority ( dnr: 2024-04293-01, approved 7th October 2024, Amendment, dnr: 2025-03699-02, approved 17th June 2025). Any significant protocol modifications must be submitted to the relevant Independent Ethics Committee or Institutional Review Board for review and approval before implementation. Upon approval from the appropriate committee or board, the investigator will proceed with implementing such protocol modifications. However, in cases of urgent safety concerns, protocol modifications will be promptly implemented without prior approval.
INFORMED CONSENT AND WITHDRAWAL
Before being enrolled in the study, patients will receive both oral and written information on the study objectives, all treatment procedures, and the anticipated and potential adverse events. They will be informed about the strict confidentiality measures regarding their patient data, ensuring that only their treating physician and authorized study personnel will have access to their medical records. Patients will have the freedom to withdraw their consent for study participation at any time, with or without providing a reason, and this decision will not impact their subsequent treatment options or care.
Written informed consent must be obtained from all participants before they are enrolled in the study. The investigator who provided the written and verbal information should also sign the Informed Consent Form during the same encounter. The signed Informed Consent Form should be retained in the Investigator's File, and a copy should be provided to the study participant.
Participants will consent to the following:
- Participation in the study.
- Regulatory authorities and the sponsor's representatives (e.g., monitor) gaining full access to hospital records.
- The control and collection of data for the study.
- The recording, collection, processing, and storage of data in a database.
- Using of data and images for education, lectures, scientific presentations and publications.
PATIENT PROTECTION AND GOOD CLINICAL PRACTICE
The responsible investigator will ensure that the study is conducted in accordance with the principles outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki and/or relevant Swedish or National laws and regulations, whichever offers the highest level of protection for the patient. Participants will be clearly informed that the data collected in the study will adhere to the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) (EU 2016/679), ensuring that no subject participating in the study will be identifiable. Women participating in the study will receive treatment in alignment with the international guidelines on Good Clinical Practice (GCP) as defined by the European Parliament (EG596/200).
SUBJECT IDENTIFICATION
Participating patients will be assigned a study-specific code, comprising a two to six-digit number. This code will be utilised for patient registration in the study database. The woman's social identification number will not be included in the database. The key to decipher the code will be accessible solely to the investigator.
GENDER PERSPECTIVE
Endometriosis is a prevalent condition, yet it is rarely acknowledged as a public health concern, despite its pervasive impact across patients' lifecycles. National guidelines were not issued until 2018, and many women with endometriosis report a lack of awareness and understanding of the disease within society. Diagnostic delays are documented in some studies, indicating that patients can suffer from symptoms of this disease up to ten years before a diagnosis of endometriosis is made and treatment is started.
A Swedish epidemiological study conducted in 2019 revealed that 45% of teenage girls experience frequent school absences due to dysmenorrhea, yet only 7% of these girls were given the advice to seek doctor consultation. Sub-fertility often arises as a consequence of endometriosis. In another Swedish study involving women seeking assistance for fertility issues, 75.8% of patients were unaware of their endometriosis diagnosis upon initial consultation at the reproductive medicine center. This suggests that society commonly perceives menstrual pain as a normal discomfort that women are expected to endure.
SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDY
Clinical significance Endometriosis is a prevalent disease among women with infertility, with negative impact on psychological and physical well-being. The management of infertility in women with severe endometriosis is a subject of ongoing debate, with a lack of robust evidence for optimal treatment strategies. Both surgery and ART-treatments in this population may lead to serious complications and are associated with significant costs to society. To date, there are no results from RCTs evaluating potential benefits of endometriosis surgery prior to ART on subsequent reproductive outcomes. This study has the potential to significantly impact the clinical approach to infertility treatment in women with advance endometriosis. Despite the challenges and the coordinated effort required for this RCT, the results promise to be valuable for the scientific and clinical communities.
Implementation Endometriosis is a very prevalent condition (22 % of infertile women) and this research project will indeed affect many patients, regardless of the results. The research group is presently drafting national guidelines for the treatment of infertility in patients with advanced endometriosis. The findings of this study will be integrated into these guidelines to assist decision-making for women with severe endometriosis and infertility.
Additionally, in a consensus document from the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) on endometriosis, it is noted that there is a dearth of randomized controlled trials regarding surgery prior to assisted reproductive technology.
The results of the study will most probably affect guidelines and care for women with severe endometriosis and infertility. It will possibly also lead to insights how to treat women with less severe endometriosis. Other aspects, such as centralisation of advanced surgery as a concept will also be tested.
연구 유형
등록 (추정된)
단계
- 해당 없음
연락처 및 위치
연구 장소
-
-
-
Malmo, 스웨덴
- 아직 모집하지 않음
- Skåne University Hospital, Malmö
-
수석 연구원:
- Ligita Jokubkiene, MD, Associate Professor
-
Uppsala, 스웨덴
- 아직 모집하지 않음
- Uppsala University Hospital, Uppsala
-
연락하다:
- Ann-Britt Lundberg Research nurse, Midwife
- 전화번호: +46186110000
- 이메일: ann-britt.lundberg@akademiska.se
-
연락하다:
- Malin Järv Research nurse, Midwife
- 이메일: malin.jarv@regionuppsala.se
-
수석 연구원:
- Christine Asciutto, MD, PhD
-
부수사관:
- Evangelia Elenis, MD, Associate Professor
-
-
Stockholm County
-
Stockholm, Stockholm County, 스웨덴, 11883
- 모병
- Sodersjukhuset
-
연락하다:
- Maria Fursäter, Midwife Research nurse
- 전화번호: +46812387518
- 이메일: maria.fursater@regionstockholm.se
-
연락하다:
- Ann-Christin Wideberg, Midwife Research nurse
- 전화번호: +46812387518
- 이메일: ann-christin.wideberg@regionstockholm.se
-
수석 연구원:
- Malin Brunes, MD, PhD
-
수석 연구원:
- Anna Marklund, MD, PhD
-
부수사관:
- Kristin Wennmo Zuk, MD, Doctoral Student
-
-
Västra Götaland County
-
Gothenburg, Västra Götaland County, 스웨덴
- 아직 모집하지 않음
- Sahlgrenska University Hospital
-
연락하다:
- Maria Engberg Research nurse, Midwife
- 전화번호: +46 70 673 26 12
- 이메일: maria.engberg@vgregion.se
-
수석 연구원:
- Maria Forslund, MD, Associate Professor
-
부수사관:
- Julia Wängberg, MD, Doctoral student
-
부수사관:
- Jynfiaf Francis, MD
-
-
참여기준
자격 기준
공부할 수 있는 나이
- 성인
건강한 자원 봉사자를 받아들입니다
설명
포함 기준:
- 만 18세 - 38세
- AAGL 3기-4기 자궁내막증
- 불임 진단과 무관하게 IVF 또는 ICSI와 같은 체외수정 치료(28) (사회적 이유로 정자 기증 주기를 포함)를 위해 의뢰되었거나 적격한 자, 및/또는 자궁내막증으로 인한 성교통/월경통으로 인한 불임
- 체질량 지수 18-35 kg/m2
- 승인된 동의서에 서명한 환자
제외 기준:
- 진단적 복강경을 제외한 자궁내막증 이전 수술 이력
- 이전 IVF/ICSI 주기 (이전 난임 보존 주기 포함)
- 혈관낭종 및/또는 수관낭종
- 요관 협착증이나 장 폐색 증상과 같은 명확한 수술 적응증
- 악성 종양 의심
- 점막하 섬유종 (국제산부인과학회(FIGO) 분류 0-1기, 모든 크기) 또는 근층내 섬유종 (FIGO 2-5기, 최대 근종 직경 > 4 cm) (29)
- 자궁 기형 (ESHRE/ESGE 분류에 따른 U1-U6 등급) (30)
- 수술 금기증이 있는 환자
- 기증 난자를 이용한 체외수정을 받는 환자
공부 계획
연구는 어떻게 설계됩니까?
디자인 세부사항
- 주 목적: 치료
- 할당: 무작위
- 중재 모델: 병렬 할당
- 마스킹: 없음(오픈 라벨)
무기와 개입
참가자 그룹 / 팔 |
개입 / 치료 |
|---|---|
|
간섭 없음: 초회 항레트로바이러스 치료
ART 군에 배정된 여성은 최대 3주기의 조절난자채취법(COS)을 거쳐 난자 채취 및 배아 이식을 진행하게 됩니다.
스웨덴에서는 40세 미만이며 현재 관계에서 자녀가 없는 여성의 ART 치료 비용은 세금으로 운영되는 의료 시스템에서 부담하며, 최대 3회의 IVF/ICSI 치료가 가능합니다. 단, 의학적으로 의미가 있다고 판단되고 각 자극 주기가 여성이 40세(39세)가 되기 전에 시작되는 경우에 한합니다.
치료 결과 냉동 보존된 배아가 있는 경우, 새로운 COS를 시작하기 전에 이식할 계획입니다.
여성들은 각 생식 단위의 정상적인 임상 프로토콜에 따라 관리됩니다.
자극 프로토콜은 협력 생식 단위의 표준 절차에 따라 각 여성의 나이와 난소 보유량을 고려하여 임상의가 개별적으로 선택합니다.
|
|
|
실험적: 일차 수술 후 항레트로바이러스 치료
수술은 자궁내막증 전문 수술 분야에서 전국적으로 특성화된 4개 센터(스톡홀름 쇠데르슈카우셋, 예테보리 살그렌스카 대학병원, 말뫼/룬드 스코네 대학병원, 웁살라 대학병원) 중 한 곳에서 수행됩니다.
수술은 자궁내막종 및 심부 자궁내막증 수술에 대한 ESHRE 권고안(32, 33)에 따라 진행됩니다.
필요한 경우 대장외과 의사와 비뇨기과 의사를 포함한 다학제적 접근으로 수술이 이루어집니다.
자궁내막증은 양성 질환이므로, 수술의 목표는 가능한 한 많은 자궁내막증 병변을 제거하면서도 장기 기능에 대한 부정적 영향을 최소화하는 것입니다.
직장 자궁내막증은 병변의 크기와 직장 벽 내 위치에 따라 직장 소파술, 원판형 절제술 또는 부분 절제술로 제거됩니다.
복강경 낭종 적출술은 "금기준"으로 간주됩니다.
난소 보유량이 이미 감소된 경우에는 더 온화한 소작 방법을 사용할 수 있습니다
|
자궁내막증 수술 후 체외수정술
|
연구는 무엇을 측정합니까?
주요 결과 측정
결과 측정 |
측정값 설명 |
기간 |
|---|---|---|
|
누적 생존아 출생률 (CLBR)
기간: 최초 치료(수술 또는 ART 치료) 후 3년
|
CLBR은 첫 치료부터 추적 관찰 종료 시점(첫 ART 치료 또는 수술 또는 연구 중도 포기 중 먼저 도래하는 시점부터 3년)까지의 모든 생존 출생을 의미합니다.
|
최초 치료(수술 또는 ART 치료) 후 3년
|
2차 결과 측정
결과 측정 |
측정값 설명 |
기간 |
|---|---|---|
|
누적 임신율 (CPR)
기간: 첫 번째 치료(수술 또는 ART)부터 3년 추적 관찰까지
|
누적 임신율(CPR)은 첫 치료(수술 또는 체외수정)부터 3년간의 추적 관찰 기간 동안 초음파로 확인된 모든 임신을 의미합니다.
|
첫 번째 치료(수술 또는 ART)부터 3년 추적 관찰까지
|
|
임신까지의 시간 및 생존 출산
기간: 치료 시작 후 최대 3년까지 시간이 측정됩니다
|
임신까지의 시간은 첫 치료(수술 또는 보조생식술)부터 초음파로 확인된 첫 임신까지의 기간으로 정의됩니다.
생존아 출산까지의 시간은 첫 치료(수술 또는 보조생식술)부터 첫 생존아 출산까지의 기간으로 정의됩니다.
|
치료 시작 후 최대 3년까지 시간이 측정됩니다
|
|
자발적 임신률
기간: 첫 치료와 추적 관찰 종료(3년) 사이
|
자발적 임신률은 첫 번째 치료부터 추적 관찰 종료 시점까지 발생하는 모든 자발적 임신으로 정의됩니다.
|
첫 치료와 추적 관찰 종료(3년) 사이
|
|
유산율 및/또는 자궁외 임신
기간: 첫 치료 시작부터 추적 관찰 종료(3년)까지 발생하는
|
유산률은 첫 치료 시점부터 추적 관찰 종료 시점까지 발생한 임상적 및 생화학적 임신 중 임신 22주 이전의 자발적 유실 빈도와 비율 및/또는 자궁강 외 임신(자궁강에 위치하지 않은 임신)으로 정의됩니다.
|
첫 치료 시작부터 추적 관찰 종료(3년)까지 발생하는
|
|
IVF/ICSI 주기당 난자 수
기간: 각 IVF/ICSI 주기별 난자 채취 당일
|
채취된 난자 수 (성숙 및 총)
|
각 IVF/ICSI 주기별 난자 채취 당일
|
|
수정률
기간: 각 IVF/ICSI 주기에서 난자 채취 다음 날
|
수정된 성숙 난자의 비율 (%)
|
각 IVF/ICSI 주기에서 난자 채취 다음 날
|
|
IVF/ICSI 주기 당 신선 배아 이식
기간: 이전 시점 또는 배양 종료 시점(최대 6일차까지), IVF/ICSI 주기 당
|
신선 배아 이식 - 아니오/예 및 예인 경우 - 2일차, 3일차 또는 5일차
|
이전 시점 또는 배양 종료 시점(최대 6일차까지), IVF/ICSI 주기 당
|
|
주기별 동결 배반포 수
기간: 난자 채취 후 6일차(배양 종료 시점)
|
동결 보존된 배반포 수
|
난자 채취 후 6일차(배양 종료 시점)
|
|
배아 이식(ET) 당 임신 결과
기간: 배양부터 출산까지(최대 10개월)
|
임신율(6-8주 초음파로 확인된 임신), 유산율(임신 20주까지), 생존 분만율(이식 후 최대 10개월까지 분만 시)
|
배양부터 출산까지(최대 10개월)
|
|
IVF/ICSI 주기별 누적 생식 결과
기간: 각 IVF/ICSI 주기의 시작부터 해당 주기의 모든 배아 이식 완료 시까지(최대 12개월)
|
누적 임신율 누적 유산율 누적 생존 출생율
|
각 IVF/ICSI 주기의 시작부터 해당 주기의 모든 배아 이식 완료 시까지(최대 12개월)
|
|
연구 기간 종료 시 평가된 재발성 착상 실패(RIF) 비율 (20)
기간: 연구 기간 종료 시(무작위 배정 후 3년) 평가
|
연구 기간 종료 시 평가된 RIF(반복 착상 실패). RIF는 여기서 35세 미만 여성에서 3회의 ET 후 임신이 없고 35-39세 여성에서 4회의 ET 후 임신이 없는 경우로 정의됩니다(20). P-프로게스테론은 FET 당일에 수집되며, 검사 결과는 하위 그룹 분석으로 eCRF에 기록됩니다. 하위 그룹 분석에는 초음파 및 수술로 진단된 자궁내막증 AAGL 3-4기 환자의 HRT-FET 주기만 포함됩니다. 자궁내막 준비는 일반적으로 월경 2일차 또는 3일차에 시작하여 Progynon(4-6 mg/일)을 경구 투여하고 지역 관행에 따라 경피적 에스트로겐을 추가할 수 있는 방식으로 수행됩니다. Cyclogest(400 mg/12시간) 또는 유사한 효능의 다른 질 프로게스테론 제제는 담당 의사가 자궁내막을 적절하다고 판단할 때(일반적으로 7 mm 이상) 시작해야 합니다. 배반포 이식은 프로게스테론 보충 6일차에 예정되어야 합니다(45). |
연구 기간 종료 시(무작위 배정 후 3년) 평가
|
|
난모세포 채취 후 감염
기간: 각 난자 채취 시점부터 이후 2개월 이내
|
난포 채취 후(즉, 각 IVF/ICSI 시술 후 2개월 이내) 최소 1회 이상 감염 진단을 받은 각 연구 군 내 여성의 비율, 필요한 치료에 따라 추가 분류: 항생제만; 재입원; 수술적 중재
|
각 난자 채취 시점부터 이후 2개월 이내
|
|
삶의 질과 통증
기간: 첫 번째 치료 시행 전 1개월 이내; 난자 채취 시; 체외수정 또는 수술 후 2개월; 및 3년 추적 관찰 시
|
건강 관련 삶의 질(HRQoL)과 통증은 연구 참가자가 선호하는 방식으로 전자적 환자 보고 결과 측정 또는 병원 방문 시(수기로 양식 작성, 접근 가능한 컴퓨터 또는 우편으로) 작성한 설문지, 자궁내막증 건강 프로파일(EHP-30), EQ5D 및 숫자 등급 척도(NRS)를 통해 평가됩니다. EHP-30 (0-100, 높을수록 나쁨) EQ-5D (0-1, 높을수록 좋음) 숫자 등급 척도 (0-10, 높을수록 통증 심함) |
첫 번째 치료 시행 전 1개월 이내; 난자 채취 시; 체외수정 또는 수술 후 2개월; 및 3년 추적 관찰 시
|
|
Clavien-Dindo 및 Classic 시스템에 따른 수술 전후 및 수술 후 2개월 합병증 분류
기간: 수술 후 최대 두 달까지의 합병증
|
수술 중 합병증은 Classic 시스템(21)에 따라 분류됩니다.
수술 후 2개월 합병증은 Clavien-Dindo(22) 시스템에 따라 정의됩니다.
|
수술 후 최대 두 달까지의 합병증
|
|
의료비
기간: 무작위 배정부터 시험 종료 시까지
|
무작위 배정 시점부터 시험 종료 시점까지의 의료 비용.
직접 비용은 병원 내부 회계 및 청구 시스템을 평가하여 사용하며, 환자 1인당 비용(CPP)을 포함합니다.
또한 중재를 통해 획득한 질량 조정 생명년(QALYs)을 측정하고 이를 통해 비용-효용 분석을 수행할 것입니다.
QALY 계산은 시험 참가자의 생식 능력 상태 측정치를 기반으로 하며, 생식 능력 상태 변화와 삶의 질 변화에 대한 가치는 EQ-5D를 기반으로 평가됩니다.
|
무작위 배정부터 시험 종료 시까지
|
|
산과적 결과 및 합병증
기간: 임신 22주부터 출산 후 8주까지
|
각 연구 군에서 임신 관련 합병증(조기 분만, 자간전증, 임신성 당뇨병, 태반 장애), 분만 관련 합병증(응급 제왕절개, 골반저 외상, 출혈, 수기 태반 제거), 산후 합병증(분만 후 8주 이내: 감염, 잔류 조직, 진통제 사용)을 경험하는 환자의 비율
|
임신 22주부터 출산 후 8주까지
|
기타 결과 측정
결과 측정 |
측정값 설명 |
기간 |
|---|---|---|
|
HRT 주기의 냉동 배아 이식 당일 P-프로게스테론 수치
기간: 동결배아이식 당일(이식 0일차)
|
HRT 주기에서 동결 배아 이식 당일의 프로게스테론 수치.
혈청 프로게스테론 농도 (ng/mL).
|
동결배아이식 당일(이식 0일차)
|
|
자궁선근증
기간: 첫 ART 또는 수술 치료 후 추적 관찰 종료 시점까지(3년)
|
초음파 및/또는 MRI에서 의심되는 자궁선근증의 존재는 Morphological Uterus Sonographic Assessment (MUSA) (26, 27)에 따라 기준선에서 기록되고 기술될 것입니다.
자궁선근증의 존재는 배분에 영향을 미치지 않지만, 연구 종료 시 하위 그룹 분석으로 결과 해석에 사용될 것입니다.
|
첫 ART 또는 수술 치료 후 추적 관찰 종료 시점까지(3년)
|
공동 작업자 및 조사자
수사관
- 수석 연구원: Malin Brunes, MD, PhD, Karolinska Institutet
- 수석 연구원: Anna Marklund, MD, PhD, Karolinska Institutet
간행물 및 유용한 링크
연구 기록 날짜
연구 주요 날짜
연구 시작 (실제)
기본 완료 (추정된)
연구 완료 (추정된)
연구 등록 날짜
최초 제출
QC 기준을 충족하는 최초 제출
처음 게시됨 (실제)
연구 기록 업데이트
마지막 업데이트 게시됨 (실제)
QC 기준을 충족하는 마지막 업데이트 제출
마지막으로 확인됨
추가 정보
이 연구와 관련된 용어
추가 관련 MeSH 약관
기타 연구 ID 번호
- 2024-04293-01
개별 참가자 데이터(IPD) 계획
개별 참가자 데이터(IPD)를 공유할 계획입니까?
IPD 계획 설명
IPD 공유 기간
IPD 공유 액세스 기준
방법론적으로 건전한 제안을 제공하고 데이터 사용 제안이 독립 검토 위원회의 승인을 받은 연구자. 데이터 공유 계약도 필요합니다.
문의: malin.brunes@regionstockholm.se
IPD 공유 지원 정보 유형
- 연구_프로토콜
- 수액
- ICF
약물 및 장치 정보, 연구 문서
미국 FDA 규제 의약품 연구
미국 FDA 규제 기기 제품 연구
이 정보는 변경 없이 clinicaltrials.gov 웹사이트에서 직접 가져온 것입니다. 귀하의 연구 세부 정보를 변경, 제거 또는 업데이트하도록 요청하는 경우 register@clinicaltrials.gov. 문의하십시오. 변경 사항이 clinicaltrials.gov에 구현되는 즉시 저희 웹사이트에도 자동으로 업데이트됩니다. .