Medical Economic Evaluation and of Quality of Life of the Kidney Living Donors. (DOVIREIN)
Medical Economic Evaluation and of Quality of Life of the Kidney Living Donors. Comparison of the Taking of Kidney by cœliosurgery (Pure or " Hand-assisted "), by cœliosurgery Assisted by Robot and by the Classic Technique of Open Donor Nephrectomy.
The main objective of this multicentre study is to conduct the evaluation of cost-efficiency of various techniques of kidney taking with regard the quality of life of the kidney living donors.
It will allow to compare three techniques of taking (open donor nephrectomy, cœliosurgery pure or " hand-assisted " and cœliosurgery assisted by robot) and to determine their respective advantages in quality of life, then their medico-economic consequences in a cost-efficiency approach from the point of view of the society.
The evaluation will concern the donor and the receiver followed three months after the taking.
The open donor nephrectomy will be the technique of reference with which will be compared the two others.
研究概览
地位
条件
详细说明
Context : The most efficient treatment of the terminal chronic renal insufficiency is the renal transplantation, but in spite of the realization of more than 2000 transplants a year in France, the waiting list increases every year in a important way. The decrease of the offer of transplants from deathly donors led numerous countries to develop the renal transplant from alive donors. This type of transplantation represents in 2007 only 8,1 % of transplants in France (report of ABM on 2007), but the deficit in renal transplants and the new laws of bioethics should increase this donation (it represents until 70 % of the renal transplantations in certain centres of North America or the Northern Europe).
Although the French urology is at the top of the laparoscopic technique, the classic surgical taking by lombotomie stays the reference technique, practised by 58 % of the centres, with for the patient its consequences in terms of pain, of duration of hospitalization, convalescence and possible side effects. The development of the taking by cœliosurgery, mini-invasive technique, allowed to increase the number of wishes of organ donation in the centres which developed it. It is however a difficult technical gesture, requiring an important experience. This technique has the inconvenience of a more painful scar and more subject to complications than the section known pubic of "Pfannenstiel" used for the taking by pure cœliosurgery.
The surgical robot Da Vinci (Intuitive Surgical, Sunnyvale, California), with a 3D mink, the joints of the instruments inside the body, the reduction of the movements, the best ergonomics, improves the precision of the cœlioscopic gesture, but has a sharply upper cost. The CHU of Nancy was the pioneer in Europe to develop this technique from 2002, with very encouraging results on a series from now on more than 80 patients.
Only retrospective studies compared the quality of life between these techniques, and in spite of the major financial impacts (10 years of dialysis represent 100 K€; the price of the robot is of 1700 K€) and the important differences of quality of life according to these various surgical approaches, no prospective comparative medico-economic study was realized up to now. In France, where the hospital bears the load of all the expenses concerning the donor, including its daily allowances during its medical certificate, the shortening of the hospitalization and of the convalescence of the donor as well as the results improved by the transplantation at the receiver of a kidney living donor would allow a fast amortization of these expensive technologies.
Main objective : To compare the cost and the efficiency of the three techniques of taking of kidney living donor.
Main assessment criterion : The quality of life of the donor tested by generic measuring instruments EUROQOL and SF-36 (both to D-1 (the day before the renal transplantation), D4 (4 days after) and D90 (3 months after) and SF-36 to D-1 and D90). It will be realized at the donor's in preoperative (D-1), in postoperative (D4) and in the visit of follow-up in 3 months (D90). It will be also collected at the receiver's in preoperative (D-1), postoperative immediate (D4) and in the visit of follow-up in 3 months (D90).
The combination with the cost estimate will allow to build the marginal cost-efficiency ratio.
Secondary objectives envisaged:
- The evaluation of the quality of life of the receiver by measuring instrument becomes generic EUROQOL and SF-36 to D-1, D4 (only Euroqol) and D90.
- The comparison of the comfort of the surgeon and his physical and psychic investment by index card(form) of specific evaluation (Borg and NASA-TLX).
- The comparison of the coelio-surgical techniques : pure coelioscopy, coelioscopy " hand-assisted " and coelioscopy assisted by robot will concern the quality of life and the marginal cost-efficiency ratio.
研究类型
注册 (实际的)
联系人和位置
学习地点
-
-
-
Besancon、法国、25030
- CHU Saint Jacques de Besançon
-
Caen、法国、14000
- CHU Côte de Nacre de CAEN
-
Clermont-ferrand、法国、63003
- CHU Montpied de Clermont-Ferrand
-
Creteil、法国、94010
- CHU Henri Mondor
-
Grenoble、法国、38043
- CHU Hôpital Michallon de Grenoble
-
Le Kremlin Bicetre、法国、94275
- Chu Bicetre
-
Lille、法国、59000
- Hôpital Claude Huriez
-
Lyon、法国、69000
- CHU Lyon Sud
-
Lyon、法国、69437
- Hôpital Edouard Herriot de Lyon
-
Marseille、法国、13274
- CHU Hôpital de la Conception
-
Montpellier、法国、34295
- CHU Lapeyronie
-
Nancy、法国、54000
- CHU Brabois
-
Nantes、法国、44093
- Chu Hotel Dieu
-
Nice、法国、06002
- CHU Pasteur
-
Paris、法国、75970
- Hôpital Tenon
-
Paris、法国、75651
- Hôpital Pitie Salpétrière
-
Paris、法国、75015
- Hopital Necker
-
Paris、法国、75970
- Hôpital Saint-Louis
-
Rouen、法国、76038
- Hôpital Charles Nicolle
-
Saint Etienne、法国、42000
- CHU Saint Etienne
-
Strasbourg、法国、67091
- CHU Hautepierre
-
Suresnes、法国、92151
- CMC Foch
-
Toulouse、法国、31059
- Hôpital de Rangueil
-
Tours、法国、37000
- CHU Bretonneau
-
-
参与标准
资格标准
适合学习的年龄
- 孩子
- 成人
- 年长者
接受健康志愿者
有资格学习的性别
取样方法
研究人群
Couples living donor - receiver of the services of urology and nephrology of 24 CHU in France practicing one of three techniques :
- Classic surgical taking by lombotomie : Besançon, Bicêtre, Caen, Lille, Marseille, Strasbourg, Tenon;
- Taking by coeliosurgery pure or hand-assisted : Clermont-Ferrand, Créteil, Foch, Grenoble, La Pitié Salpêtrière, Lyon Sud, Montpellier, Nantes, Necker,Saint-Etienne,Saint-Louis,Toulouse, Rouen;
- Coeliosurgical taking assisted by robot : Nancy, Nice, Lyon, Tours.
描述
Inclusion Criteria:
- The receiver is registered on the ABM list;
- The receiver is on dialysis or in preterminal renal insufficiency;
- The donor is a member of the circle of acquaintances of the receiver.
Exclusion Criteria:
- Risk of difficulties of follow-up during 3 months following the transplant (ex: patient not living in France);
- Refusal of participation of the donor.
学习计划
研究是如何设计的？
设计细节
队列和干预
团体/队列 |
干预/治疗 |
|---|---|
|
couples kidney living donor - receiver
Three groups for each technique of taking of kidney :
|
open donor nephrectomy
standard and hand-assisted laparoscopic donor nephrectomy
laparoscopic robotic-assisted nephrectomy
|
研究衡量的是什么？
主要结果指标
结果测量 |
措施说明 |
大体时间 |
|---|---|---|
|
Quality of life of the donor
大体时间：D-1 (day before nephrectomy), D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy)
|
Quality of life of the donor as measured by EUROQOL (score 0 to 1) and SF 36 self-administered questionnaires (score 0 to 100 in each of 8 dimensions , at D-1 (the day before nephrectomy), D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy). biological values of the donor and the receiver |
D-1 (day before nephrectomy), D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy)
|
次要结果测量
结果测量 |
措施说明 |
大体时间 |
|---|---|---|
|
Sociodemographic data
大体时间：D-1, the day before nephrectomy
|
At D-1 (the day before nephrectomy), sociodemographic data are collected
|
D-1, the day before nephrectomy
|
|
Comfort, physical and mental investment of the surgeon measured by the Borg and the NASA-TLX scale
大体时间：Day 0, the actual day of nephrectomy for each donor
|
The Borg scale consists of 7 questions corresponding to the level of discomfort in 7 body segments of the surgeon with responses ranging from 0 (no discomfort) to 10 (very very strong discomfort).
The surgeon is questioned every 30 minutes during the surgery.
The NASA-TLX scale consists in 8 questions about physical and mental investment with responses ranging from 0 (low) to 100 (high).
The surgeon completes this scale immediately at the end of the surgical procedure.
|
Day 0, the actual day of nephrectomy for each donor
|
|
Biological values of the donor and the receiver
大体时间：D-1 (day before nephrectomy), D2 (2 days after nephrectomy) D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy)
|
Blood count and serum electrolyte levels are collected.
biological values of the donor and the receiver
|
D-1 (day before nephrectomy), D2 (2 days after nephrectomy) D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy)
|
|
Treatments administered to the donor
大体时间：D0 (the actual day of nephrectomy for each donor), D2 (2 days after nephrectomy), D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy)
|
Treatments administered to the donor from D0 (the actual day of nephrectomy for each donor) to D90 (90 days after nephrectomy).
|
D0 (the actual day of nephrectomy for each donor), D2 (2 days after nephrectomy), D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy)
|
|
Medical exams performed on the donor
大体时间：D-1 (day before nephrectomy), D2 (2 days after nephrectomy) D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy)
|
Medical exams performed on the donor from D0 (the actual day of nephrectomy for each donor) to D90 (90 days after nephrectomy).
|
D-1 (day before nephrectomy), D2 (2 days after nephrectomy) D4 (4 days after nephrectomy) and D90 (90 days after nephrectomy)
|
|
Information on surgical technique employed to achieve nephrectomy and description of the graft.
大体时间：Day 0, the actual day of nephrectomy for each donor
|
Type of surgery (open donor nephrectomy, standard or hand-assisted laparoscopic donor nephrectomyor laparoscopic robotic-assisted nephrectomy), Duration of surgery and of ischemia and description of the graft.
|
Day 0, the actual day of nephrectomy for each donor
|
合作者和调查者
出版物和有用的链接
研究记录日期
研究主要日期
学习开始
初级完成 (实际的)
研究完成 (实际的)
研究注册日期
首次提交
首先提交符合 QC 标准的
首次发布 (估计)
研究记录更新
最后更新发布 (估计)
上次提交的符合 QC 标准的更新
最后验证
更多信息
与本研究相关的术语
其他研究编号
- 10.039
此信息直接从 clinicaltrials.gov 网站检索，没有任何更改。如果您有任何更改、删除或更新研究详细信息的请求，请联系 register@clinicaltrials.gov. clinicaltrials.gov 上实施更改，我们的网站上也会自动更新.