Accuracy of Full-Arch Implant Placement Using Two Guided Surgical Workflows in Terminal Mandibular Dentition
Accuracy of Full-Arch Implant Placement in the Terminal-Dentition Mandible Using Stackable Versus Sequential Tooth-Supported Surgical Guides: A Retrospective Comparative Clinical Study
This retrospective clinical study aims to evaluate the accuracy of full-arch dental implant placement in patients with terminal mandibular dentition using two different computer-guided surgical approaches.
Patients with terminal mandibular dentition often require extraction of their remaining teeth and placement of multiple dental implants to support a fixed full-arch prosthesis. Accurate implant placement is important for achieving a favorable prosthetic outcome and avoiding anatomical complications.
The study will compare two surgical workflows. The first uses a stackable surgical guide system in patients who require reduction of the jawbone to create adequate space for the final prosthesis. The second uses sequential tooth-supported surgical guides in patients who do not require bone reduction. These guides are used in stages during tooth extraction and implant placement to help transfer the digitally planned implant positions to the patient's jaw.
The researchers will review the clinical records, original digital treatment plans, and radiographic images of previously treated patients at the Faculty of Dentistry, Menoufia University. Patients treated between 2024 and 2026 who meet the study eligibility criteria will be considered.
The accuracy of implant placement will be assessed by comparing the planned implant positions with the actual positions identified from postoperative three-dimensional imaging. The researchers will measure differences at the implant platform and tip, as well as differences in implant angulation.
The study aims to determine whether the two guided surgical workflows differ in implant placement accuracy and to provide clinical information that may help clinicians select an appropriate guided surgical approach for patients requiring mandibular full-arch implant rehabilitation.
研究概览
地位
详细说明
This retrospective comparative clinical study will evaluate the accuracy of computer-guided full-arch implant placement in patients with terminal mandibular dentition treated using two different indication-based surgical workflows.
The study will be conducted at the Department of Prosthetic Dental Science, Faculty of Dentistry, Menoufia University, through a retrospective review of clinical records, preoperative digital treatment plans, surgical documentation, and postoperative radiographic datasets of patients treated between 2024 and 2026.
**Study population and group classification**
Adult patients aged 45-65 years who underwent mandibular full-arch implant rehabilitation for terminal dentition will be screened for eligibility. Eligible patients must have available preoperative cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) images, intraoral scans, original digital implant planning files, postoperative CBCT datasets, and adequate surgical documentation.
Patients will be categorized into two groups according to the surgical workflow originally selected during their clinical treatment:
**Group I: Stackable surgical guide workflow**
This group will include patients who required alveolar ridge reduction to establish adequate restorative space and appropriate residual ridge morphology. An anatomical-form basal guide initially supported by the remaining natural teeth will be used. Following tooth extraction, the guide will transition to a bone-supported configuration through its fixation mechanism. Subsequent stackable components will facilitate alveolar ridge reduction and guided implant placement.
**Group II: Sequential tooth-supported surgical guide workflow**
This group will include patients who did not require alveolar ridge reduction because adequate restorative space and residual ridge morphology were available. Separate tooth-supported surgical guide components will be used sequentially during tooth extraction and implant placement. Depending on the remaining dental support, the guide configuration may be modified to obtain combined tooth- and mucosa-supported stabilization during the subsequent surgical stages.
The original indication for each surgical approach will be verified using the preoperative digital treatment plan and surgical records. Group allocation will not be randomized.
**Digital planning and surgical procedures**
Preoperative CBCT datasets and intraoral scanning files will be integrated using dedicated implant planning software. Virtual implant positioning will follow prosthetically driven principles, considering the available bone dimensions, anatomical structures, planned definitive prosthesis, implant distribution, and restorative requirements.
Both groups will be treated using the same implant manufacturer and implant system. Implant placement may be performed immediately following tooth extraction or in previously healed extraction sites, according to the original surgical plan. The timing of implant placement will be recorded for each implant.
An intended immediate-loading protocol will be used in both groups. Implant primary stability, insertion torque, and/or implant stability quotient values will be extracted from the original clinical records. Immediate loading will be defined as connecting a provisional prosthesis in functional occlusion within one week following implant placement.
**Assessment of implant placement accuracy**
The primary objective will be to compare the accuracy of the two surgical workflows by assessing the discrepancy between virtually planned and actual postoperative implant positions.
Preoperative and postoperative CBCT datasets will be registered using stable mandibular anatomical structures that were not altered during surgery. In patients who underwent alveolar ridge reduction, unaffected anatomical regions will be used for image registration rather than the surgically modified alveolar crest.
The planned and actual implant positions will then be superimposed in a common coordinate system, and the following parameters will be evaluated:
- Three-dimensional coronal deviation (mm): The distance between the centers of the planned and actual implant platforms.
- Three-dimensional apical deviation (mm): The distance between the planned and actual implant apex positions.
- Angular deviation (degrees): The angular difference between the longitudinal axes of the planned and actual implants.
Three-dimensional coronal deviation will represent the primary accuracy outcome, while apical and angular deviations will represent secondary outcomes.
**Measurement reliability**
Measurements will be performed by an independent calibrated examiner who will be blinded to the treatment group whenever feasible. A randomly selected subset of implants will undergo repeated measurements after an interval of at least two weeks. Intra-examiner reliability will be assessed using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).
**Additional variables and statistical analysis**
Demographic, anatomical, implant-related, and surgical variables will be extracted from the original clinical records. These will include age, sex, smoking status, systemic health conditions, mandibular bone dimensions, implant position, implant dimensions, implant placement timing, primary stability measurements, guide support configuration, fixation mechanisms, surgical duration, and documented complications.
Continuous variables will be summarized using means and standard deviations or medians and interquartile ranges, as appropriate. Categorical variables will be presented as frequencies and percentages.
Linear mixed-effects models will be used to compare implant placement accuracy between the two surgical workflows while accounting for the hierarchical structure of the data, with multiple implants nested within individual patients. Patient identification will be incorporated as a random effect, and surgical workflow will be included as the main explanatory variable. Potential patient- and implant-level covariates will be considered in adjusted analyses when clinically and statistically appropriate.
Effect estimates with 95% confidence intervals and corresponding P values will be reported. Statistical significance will be established at P < .05.
The findings are expected to provide clinical evidence regarding the accuracy of two indication-based digital guided surgical workflows for mandibular full-arch implant rehabilitation.
研究类型
注册 (估计的)
联系人和位置
学习联系方式
- 姓名:Mohammed A. El-Sawy, PhD
- 电话号码:00201061314522
- 邮箱:Dr_Sawy@windowslive.com
研究联系人备份
- 姓名:Mohammed A. Lecturer, PhD
- 电话号码:00201061314522
- 邮箱:mohamed.elsawy@dent.menofia.edu.eg
学习地点
-
-
Menoufia
-
Shibīn al Kawm、Menoufia、埃及、2266166
- 招聘中
- Faculty of Dentistry, Menoufia University
-
接触:
- Mohammed A. El-Sawy, PhD
- 电话号码:00201061314522
- 邮箱:mohamed.elsawy@dent.menofia.edu.eg
-
-
参与标准
资格标准
适合学习的年龄
接受健康志愿者
有资格学习的性别
取样方法
研究人群
Patients aged 45-65 years with terminal mandibular dentition who underwent full-arch implant-supported rehabilitation using either a stackable surgical guide system or sequential tooth-supported surgical guides at the Faculty of Dentistry, Menoufia University, between 2024 and 2026. Eligible patients must have adequate preoperative digital planning records, postoperative CBCT datasets, and complete clinical and surgical documentation to permit retrospective assessment of implant placement accuracy.
描述
Inclusion Criteria
- Adult patients aged 45-65 years.
- Presence of terminal mandibular dentition requiring extraction of the remaining natural teeth and full-arch implant-supported rehabilitation.
- Treatment performed using either a stackable surgical guide system or sequential tooth-supported surgical guides.
- Availability of preoperative CBCT imaging and digital intraoral scans suitable for virtual implant planning.
- Availability of the original virtual implant planning files documenting the planned implant positions, dimensions, and angulations.
- Availability of postoperative CBCT datasets of sufficient quality to identify the actual implant positions and implant apices.
- Availability of adequate clinical and surgical records documenting the guide configuration, bone reduction requirements, and implant placement sequence.
Exclusion Criteria
- Patients with incomplete or unavailable preoperative digital planning records.
- Cases with missing or inadequate postoperative CBCT datasets that prevent reliable implant position assessment.
- Patients who underwent extensive simultaneous bone augmentation procedures that substantially altered the planned surgical workflow.
- Cases involving freehand implant placement rather than the intended guided surgical approach.
- Patients with incomplete surgical records regarding the type of surgical guide or the indication for alveolar ridge reduction.
- Cases in which severe metallic artifacts or image distortion prevent reliable identification of the implant platform or apex.
学习计划
研究是如何设计的?
设计细节
- 观测模型:COHORT
- 时间观点:RETROSPECTIVE
队列和干预
团体/队列 |
干预/治疗 |
|---|---|
|
Stackable Surgical Guide Group
Patients with terminal mandibular dentition who underwent full-arch implant rehabilitation using a stackable surgical guide system because preoperative prosthetic and surgical planning indicated the need for alveolar ridge reduction. The guide system was initially supported by the remaining natural teeth and subsequently transitioned to a bone-supported configuration following tooth extraction to facilitate alveolar ridge reduction and guided implant placement. |
A computer-guided surgical workflow previously used in patients requiring alveolar ridge reduction before full-arch implant rehabilitation. The procedure involved initial tooth-supported positioning of an anatomical-form basal guide, transition to bone-supported positioning following tooth extraction, guided alveolar ridge reduction, and subsequent guided implant placement using stackable guide components. |
|
Sequential Tooth-Supported Surgical Guide Group
Patients with terminal mandibular dentition who underwent full-arch implant rehabilitation using sequential tooth-supported surgical guides because adequate restorative space and residual ridge morphology were available without alveolar ridge reduction. Separate guide components were used sequentially during tooth extraction and guided implant placement, with modifications to guide support according to the remaining natural teeth. |
A computer-guided surgical workflow previously used in patients who did not require alveolar ridge reduction. Separate tooth-supported surgical guide components were used sequentially during tooth extraction and implant placement, with guide support modified according to the remaining natural teeth and, when necessary, combined tooth- and mucosa-supported stabilization. |
研究衡量的是什么?
主要结果指标
结果测量 |
措施说明 |
大体时间 |
|---|---|---|
|
Three-Dimensional Coronal Deviation (mm)
大体时间:At the time of postoperative CBCT assessment following implant placement (retrospective evaluation of available radiographic records).
|
The three-dimensional Euclidean distance (mm) between the center of the virtually planned implant platform and the center of the actual implant platform identified on postoperative CBCT images. This outcome will be used to compare implant placement accuracy between the stackable surgical guide group and the sequential tooth-supported surgical guide group. Measurements will be recorded for each implant. |
At the time of postoperative CBCT assessment following implant placement (retrospective evaluation of available radiographic records).
|
|
Three-Dimensional Apical Deviation (mm)
大体时间:At the time of postoperative CBCT assessment following implant placement (retrospective evaluation of available radiographic records).
|
The three-dimensional Euclidean distance (mm) between the planned implant apex and the actual implant apex identified on postoperative CBCT images. This outcome will be used to compare apical implant positioning accuracy between the stackable surgical guide group and the sequential tooth-supported surgical guide group. Measurements will be recorded for each implant. |
At the time of postoperative CBCT assessment following implant placement (retrospective evaluation of available radiographic records).
|
合作者和调查者
研究记录日期
研究主要日期
学习开始 (实际的)
初级完成 (估计的)
研究完成 (估计的)
研究注册日期
首次提交
首先提交符合 QC 标准的
首次发布 (实际的)
研究记录更新
最后更新发布 (实际的)
上次提交的符合 QC 标准的更新
最后验证
更多信息
与本研究相关的术语
关键字
其他研究编号
- ADMNF220926
计划个人参与者数据 (IPD)
计划共享个人参与者数据 (IPD)?
IPD 计划说明
Up on reasonable request from the corresponding author.
药物和器械信息、研究文件
研究美国 FDA 监管的药品
研究美国 FDA 监管的设备产品
此信息直接从 clinicaltrials.gov 网站检索,没有任何更改。如果您有任何更改、删除或更新研究详细信息的请求,请联系 register@clinicaltrials.gov. clinicaltrials.gov 上实施更改,我们的网站上也会自动更新.