The Effect of Metrics Based Performance Based Progression in Provision of Labor Epidural Analgesia
The Effect of Metrics Based Performance Based Progression in Provision of Labor Epidural Analgesia on Clinical Performance and Clinical Outcome
Procedural skills are an important determinant of clinical outcomes for certain patient groups. Training for procedural skills in the medical profession is still largely based on an apprenticeship model. For example, trainees learning to perform epidural anaesthesia do so by "practicing" on patients under direct supervision by seniors (consultants or senior registrars/residents). Learning a complex and high risk procedural skill on patients is not ideal.
As medical training moves from apprentice based to competency based training along and as for the number of clinical learning opportunities for trainees is less, it is necessary to develop a comprehensive training programme which enables effective and efficient learning without compromising on patient safety. Metrics-based performance based progression has shown to improve clinical performance not only in novices but also in experts.
We envisage a standard methodology which could address the deficiencies in procedural training currently. This would entail development and validation of a set of metrics for a particular procedure, evaluation of a proficiency based progression training programme based on those metrics to and demonstration of improved clinical performance and clinical outcome associated with that programme. Although elements of this "end -end" approach have been demonstrated previously for various procedures, we propose to apply this methodology in its entirety to placement of a lumbar epidural catheter for analgesia for patients in labor. To date we have developed and are validating a set of metrics for this procedure. Proficiency based training leading to better procedural skills leading to better patient outcomes has not been studied so far. Epidural analgesia during labor lends itself as an excellent model for evaluating the whole process. It has a specific procedural skill which is closely linked to patient outcome which is measurable and occurs in finite time interval.
The hypothesis of the study is that in novice anaesthetic trainees, training with metrics based performance based progression in addition to improving the clinical performance will also reduce the failure rates of labor epidural analgesia to 5% when compared to 25% achieved by conventional training.
연구 개요
상세 설명
This will be a prospective, randomized, double blind control study. Ethical committee approval and consent from both participating anaesthetist and patients will be obtained.
Trainees will be recruited from Cork University Hospital. Anaesthetic trainees with less than 2 years of experience in anaesthesia and who has performed less than 50 epidurals in the preceding 2 years (not limited to labor epidurals) will be requested to participate in the study.
The trainees will be randomized in to group 1 and group 2. In group 1, standardized conventional teaching and training for labor epidural analgesia will be used. In group 2, they will be trained by metrics based simulation to predetermined level of proficiency. Each trainee will then perform 10 labor epidural catheter insertions and the procedures will be video recorded with patients consent.
Observers blinded to the groups will be used for the data collection, outcome assessment and analysis. Failure rate of epidural will be assessed based on the occurrence of one or more of the following events,
- Inadequate analgesia at 45 minutes from start of epidural needle placement.
- Resiting epidural or abandoning the procedure.
- Accidental Dural puncture.
- Supervisor take over. The primary end point of the study is to compare difference in epidural failure rates between the two groups. Secondary end point will include assessment of clinical performance using metrics based assessment by two blinded reviewers based on video recordings and patient satisfaction with epidural analgesia. In addition to demographic data of the patients, duration of labor, cervical dilation at the time of insertion of the catheter, length of catheter inserted, time of insertion of catheter, experience of the operator and position of the patient during epidural placement will be noted. Age, sex and anaesthesia experience of the trainees will also be collected.
The estimated labor epidural failure rates for year 1 trainees is 25%.6 We hope to reduce the failure rate in interventional group to 5%. 48 procedures per group will be sufficient to show a statistically significant difference between the groups with p value of 0.05% and power of 80%. To allow for dropouts, 8 trainees per group will be recruited and each will perform 10 procedures making it a total of 80 procedures per group.
연구 유형
등록 (실제)
단계
- 해당 없음
연락처 및 위치
연구 장소
-
-
Cork
-
Cork,Ireland, Cork, 아일랜드
- Cork University Hospital
-
-
참여기준
자격 기준
공부할 수 있는 나이
건강한 자원 봉사자를 받아들입니다
연구 대상 성별
설명
Inclusion Criteria:
- Anaesthetic trainees with less than 2 years of experience in anaesthesia and who has performed less than 50 epidurals in the preceding 2 years (not limited to labor epidurals) will be requested to participate in the study.
Exclusion Criteria:
- No tmeeting inclusion criteria
- Not consenting for study
공부 계획
연구는 어떻게 설계됩니까?
디자인 세부사항
- 주 목적: 다른
- 할당: 무작위
- 중재 모델: 병렬 할당
- 마스킹: 더블
무기와 개입
참가자 그룹 / 팔 |
개입 / 치료 |
|---|---|
|
활성 비교기: Group C
Conventional training for epidural catheter placement as per department protocols will be given to the trainees in this arm.
Access to epidural simulator for 2 days will be given.
|
Conventional training for epidural catheter placement as per department protocols will be given to the trainees in this arm.
Access to epidural simulator for 2 days will be given.
|
|
실험적: Group M
Conventional training for epidural catheter placement as per department protocols will be given to the trainees in this arm as well.Trainees in this arm in addition will be subjected to training to proficiency based on the metrics developed for labor epidural catheter placement in a epidural simulator.
|
Conventional training for epidural catheter placement as per department protocols will be given to the trainees in this arm as well.Trainees in this arm in addition will be trained to proficience based on the metrics developed for labor epidural catheter placement in a epidural simulator.
|
연구는 무엇을 측정합니까?
주요 결과 측정
결과 측정 |
측정값 설명 |
기간 |
|---|---|---|
|
Epidural failure rate
기간: within 48 hours after completion of epidural
|
Failure rate of epidural will be assessed based on the occurrence of one or more of the following events,
|
within 48 hours after completion of epidural
|
2차 결과 측정
결과 측정 |
측정값 설명 |
기간 |
|---|---|---|
|
assessment of clinical performance using metrics based assessment
기간: within 36 months after aquiring the video of epidrual catheter insertion procedure
|
assessment of clinical performance using metrics based assessment will be done by two blinded reviewers based on video recordings
|
within 36 months after aquiring the video of epidrual catheter insertion procedure
|
|
patient satisfaction with epidural analgesia
기간: within 48 hours of completion of insertion of labor epidural catheter
|
Patient will be asked to rate eidural as (a) satisfied, will want it again (b) Not satisfied - give reason in free text
|
within 48 hours of completion of insertion of labor epidural catheter
|
공동 작업자 및 조사자
간행물 및 유용한 링크
연구 기록 날짜
연구 주요 날짜
연구 시작
기본 완료 (실제)
연구 완료 (실제)
연구 등록 날짜
최초 제출
QC 기준을 충족하는 최초 제출
처음 게시됨 (추정)
연구 기록 업데이트
마지막 업데이트 게시됨 (실제)
QC 기준을 충족하는 마지막 업데이트 제출
마지막으로 확인됨
추가 정보
이 정보는 변경 없이 clinicaltrials.gov 웹사이트에서 직접 가져온 것입니다. 귀하의 연구 세부 정보를 변경, 제거 또는 업데이트하도록 요청하는 경우 register@clinicaltrials.gov. 문의하십시오. 변경 사항이 clinicaltrials.gov에 구현되는 즉시 저희 웹사이트에도 자동으로 업데이트됩니다. .
진통에 대한 임상 시험
-
Bingol UniversityAtaturk University아직 모집하지 않음수술 전 불안 | 두려움 | PAIN
-
Aydin Adnan Menderes University완전한노동 기간 | Labor Bain | 생리적 질식 분만 중 만족감과 출산 만족감터키 (Türkiye)
-
Weill Medical College of Cornell UniversityNew York University; National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)모병
-
Istanbul University모병Masticatory Muscle Pain | 근시 통증 증후군 (MP)칠면조
-
Istanbul University모병이갈이 | 근막 통증 증후군 | Masticatory Muscle Pain | 현지 근육통터키 (Türkiye)
Conventional training에 대한 임상 시험
-
Foundation University Islamabad모병
-
University of SalamancaINSTITUTO DE INVESTIGACION BIOMEDICA DE SALAMANCA (IBSAL); Colegio Profesional Fisioterapeutas...모병보조 | 보행 분석 | 서모그래피 | 지구력 | 걷는 속도, 메쉬 ID D000072797 | 단계 시간과 길이스페인
-
King's College LondonUniversity College, London; Brighton & Sussex Medical School완전한
-
MMSx Authority Institute for Movement Mechanics...완전한
-
Istanbul University - Cerrahpasa아직 모집하지 않음허약한 노인 | 노쇠 증후군 | 노인병 | 프리프레일 노인