Using Registry Data to Construct a Comparison Group for Programmatic Effectiveness Evaluation: The New York City HIV Care Coordination Program
McKaylee M Robertson, Levi Waldron, Rebekkah S Robbins, Stephanie Chamberlin, Kate Penrose, Bruce Levin, Sarah Kulkarni, Sarah L Braunstein, Mary K Irvine, Denis Nash, McKaylee M Robertson, Levi Waldron, Rebekkah S Robbins, Stephanie Chamberlin, Kate Penrose, Bruce Levin, Sarah Kulkarni, Sarah L Braunstein, Mary K Irvine, Denis Nash
Abstract
Many nonrandomized interventions rely upon a pre-post design to evaluate effectiveness. Such designs cannot account for events external to the intervention that may produce the outcome. We describe a method to construct a surveillance registry-based comparison group, which allows for estimating the effectiveness of the intervention while controlling for secular trends in the outcome of interest. Using data from the population-based, human immunodeficiency virus Surveillance Registry in New York City, we created a contemporaneous comparison group for persons enrolled in the New York City human immunodeficiency virus Care Coordination Program (CCP) from December 2009 to March 2013. Inclusion in the Registry-based (non-CCP) comparison group required meeting CCP eligibility criteria. To control for secular trends in the outcome, we randomly assigned persons in the non-CCP, Registry-based comparison group a pseudoenrollment date such that the distribution of pseudoenrollment dates matched the distribution of enrollment dates among CCP enrollees. We then matched CCP to non-CCP persons on propensity for enrollment in the CCP, enrollment dates, and baseline viral load. Registry-based comparison group estimates were attenuated relative to pre-post estimates of program effectiveness. These methods have broad applicability for observational intervention effectiveness studies and programmatic evaluations for conditions with surveillance registries.
Figures

Source: PubMed
Upcoming Clinical Trials
-
October University for Modern Sciences and ArtsRecruiting
-
Uskudar UniversityNot yet recruitingMusculoskeletal Pain | Occupational DiseasesTurkey (Türkiye)
-
Milton S. Hershey Medical CenterAxogen CorporationNot yet recruitingParotid Cancer | Parotidectomy | Frey's Syndrome | Parotidectomy, Patient-reported Outcomes | Parotid Gland Tumor
-
University of the Italian SwitzerlandUniversita di VeronaNot yet recruitingCaregiver Burden | Psychological DistressSwitzerland
-
Ain Shams UniversityNot yet recruitingHip Abductor Insufficiency Following Total Hip Arthroplasty
-
University of CalgaryNot yet recruitingHypospadias | Ureteropelvic Junction ObstructionCanada
-
Reinovax Biologics Co., LTDNot yet recruitingA Phase Ⅲ Clinical Trial of an Investigative 24-valent Pneumococcal Polysaccharide Conjugate VaccinePneumococcal Infectious DiseaseChina
-
Research IncRecruitingPostoperative Nasal Fibrosis After RhinoplastyColombia
-
Abramson Cancer Center at Penn MedicineNot yet recruiting
-
Aligos TherapeuticsNot yet recruitingHealthy ParticipantsUnited States
-
PT Equilab InternationalNestle IndonesiaRecruiting
-
Stanford UniversityNot yet recruiting