Large Language Model Assistance for Clinical Decision-Making Among Rural Physicians
Effect of Large Language Model Assistance on Clinical Decision-Making Among Rural Physicians: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Studieöversikt
Status
Betingelser
Detaljerad beskrivning
Rural physicians play an essential role in the diagnosis and management of common and frequently occurring conditions, referral decision-making, chronic disease management, and patient education. In resource-constrained primary care settings, they often face limited access to medical information and specialist support, delays in updating clinical knowledge and guidelines, and substantial pressure in clinical decision-making. These challenges are particularly relevant in northwestern China, where primary care resources are relatively limited. Improving rural physicians' abilities in diagnostic assessment, recognition of clinical warning signs, and rational prescribing is therefore an important priority for strengthening primary healthcare services.
Large language models (LLMs) can support medical information retrieval, organization of diagnostic and management approaches, differential diagnosis, medication-related decision-making, patient education, and follow-up planning, and may therefore serve as accessible tools for supporting clinical decision-making in primary care. However, general-purpose LLMs were not specifically developed for use in resource-constrained primary care settings and have not been adequately evaluated among rural physicians. Their responses may contain factual errors or fabricated evidence, overlook warning signs, provide insufficient medication safety warnings, or recommend investigations and treatments that are not feasible in local primary care settings. Without adequate verification skills, physicians may fail to benefit from LLM assistance and may even introduce new safety risks. It is therefore important to evaluate how rural physicians use LLMs and whether structured training can improve the safe and effective use of these tools before their wider implementation.
This randomized controlled trial will evaluate the effects of LLM assistance and brief training on clinical decision-making among rural physicians. Participants will complete clinical cases involving common conditions encountered in primary care, with tasks assessing diagnostic judgment, recognition of warning signs, rational treatment, and patient education. Some participants will also use the LLM as a second-opinion tool to review and revise their initial decisions. All responses will be independently evaluated by reviewers blinded to group assignment using standardized scoring criteria to assess overall clinical decision-making performance and safety.
Studietyp
Inskrivning (Beräknad)
Fas
- Inte tillämpbar
Kontakter och platser
Studiekontakt
- Namn: Liyuan Tao, MD
- Telefonnummer: +86 82265732
- E-post: tendytly@163.com
Studieorter
-
-
Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region
-
Karamay, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region, Kina
- Xinjiang Second Medical College
-
Kontakt:
- Zejiang Ma, Master of Medicine
- Telefonnummer: +86 18811331959
- E-post: 18811331959@163.com
-
-
Deltagandekriterier
Urvalskriterier
Åldrar som är berättigade till studier
- Vuxen
- Äldre vuxen
Tar emot friska volontärer
Beskrivning
Inclusion Criteria:
- Currently engaged in clinical practice at a rural primary healthcare institution in northwestern China.
- Has received formal medical education and holds a relevant diploma or degree.
- Able to read and understand clinical case materials in Chinese.
- Able to use a computer to complete the study tasks.
- Willing to participate and able to provide written informed consent.
Exclusion Criteria:
- Previously involved in the development of the clinical case tasks, reference answers, or scoring rubric for this study.
- Previously participated in pilot testing involving the same clinical case tasks or study procedures.
Studieplan
Hur är studien utformad?
Designdetaljer
- Primärt syfte: Hälsovårdsforskning
- Tilldelning: Randomiserad
- Interventionsmodell: Faktoriell uppgift
- Maskning: Enda
Vapen och interventioner
Deltagargrupp / Arm |
Intervention / Behandling |
|---|---|
|
Aktiv komparator: Conventional Resources Followed by LLM Second Opinion
Participants receive no LLM-use training.
During the initial 60-minute assessment, they complete the clinical cases using conventional non-LLM resources only.
After submitting their initial responses, they receive an additional 30 minutes to use the study-provided LLM as a second-opinion tool to review and revise their responses.
|
During the initial 60-minute assessment, participants complete primary care clinical cases using conventional non-LLM resources only, including clinical guidelines, textbooks, drug labels, training materials, medical websites, and standard search engines.
Participants are not permitted to use LLMs during this phase.
After completing and submitting their initial responses using conventional non-LLM resources, participants receive an additional 30 minutes to use the study-provided DeepSeek-V4 as a second-opinion tool.
They may review, verify, and revise their initial clinical decisions before submitting their final responses.
|
|
Experimentell: Direct LLM Assistance
Participants receive no LLM-use training and may use the study-provided LLM throughout the initial 60-minute assessment to complete the clinical cases.
They submit their final responses at 60 minutes and do not participate in the additional second-opinion phase.
|
During the initial 60-minute assessment, participants may use the study-provided DeepSeek-V4 to assist with medical information retrieval, diagnostic and management reasoning, identification of warning signs, referral decisions, rational prescribing, patient education, and follow-up planning.
Participants remain responsible for their final clinical decisions and responses.
|
|
Experimentell: LLM Training and Conventional Resources Followed by LLM Second Opinion
Participants receive brief structured training on the safe and effective use of LLMs.
During the initial 60-minute assessment, they complete the clinical cases using conventional non-LLM resources only.
After submitting their initial responses, they receive an additional 30 minutes to use the study-provided LLM as a second-opinion tool to review and revise their responses.
|
During the initial 60-minute assessment, participants complete primary care clinical cases using conventional non-LLM resources only, including clinical guidelines, textbooks, drug labels, training materials, medical websites, and standard search engines.
Participants are not permitted to use LLMs during this phase.
After completing and submitting their initial responses using conventional non-LLM resources, participants receive an additional 30 minutes to use the study-provided DeepSeek-V4 as a second-opinion tool.
They may review, verify, and revise their initial clinical decisions before submitting their final responses.
Before completing the clinical cases, participants receive brief structured training on the safe and effective use of LLMs.
The training covers the role and limitations of LLMs, structured prompting and follow-up questioning, identification of warning signs and referral indications, medication safety, verification of LLM-generated information, high-risk situations in which LLMs should not be relied upon, and protection of patient privacy.
|
|
Experimentell: LLM Training and Direct LLM Assistance
Participants receive brief structured training on the safe and effective use of LLMs and may use the study-provided LLM throughout the initial 60-minute assessment to complete the clinical cases.
They submit their final responses at 60 minutes and do not participate in the additional second-opinion phase.
|
During the initial 60-minute assessment, participants may use the study-provided DeepSeek-V4 to assist with medical information retrieval, diagnostic and management reasoning, identification of warning signs, referral decisions, rational prescribing, patient education, and follow-up planning.
Participants remain responsible for their final clinical decisions and responses.
Before completing the clinical cases, participants receive brief structured training on the safe and effective use of LLMs.
The training covers the role and limitations of LLMs, structured prompting and follow-up questioning, identification of warning signs and referral indications, medication safety, verification of LLM-generated information, high-risk situations in which LLMs should not be relied upon, and protection of patient privacy.
|
Vad mäter studien?
Primära resultatmått
Resultatmått |
Åtgärdsbeskrivning |
Tidsram |
|---|---|---|
|
Overall Clinical Decision-Making Score
Tidsram: At the end of the initial 60-minute assessment
|
Participants' responses to primary care clinical cases will be evaluated using a prespecified scoring rubric.
The overall score will reflect performance across key components of clinical decision-making.
Higher scores indicate better overall clinical decision-making performance.
|
At the end of the initial 60-minute assessment
|
Sekundära resultatmått
Resultatmått |
Åtgärdsbeskrivning |
Tidsram |
|---|---|---|
|
Diagnostic Judgment Domain Score
Tidsram: At the end of the initial 60-minute assessment
|
Participants' diagnostic judgment in response to primary care clinical cases will be evaluated using a predefined scoring rubric.
Higher scores indicate better diagnostic judgment.
|
At the end of the initial 60-minute assessment
|
|
Clinical Warning Sign Recognition Domain Score
Tidsram: At the end of the initial 60-minute assessment
|
Participants' ability to identify clinically important warning signs in primary care clinical cases will be evaluated using a predefined scoring rubric.
Higher scores indicate better recognition of clinical warning signs.
|
At the end of the initial 60-minute assessment
|
|
Treatment Plan Domain Score
Tidsram: At the end of the initial 60-minute assessment
|
Participants' proposed treatment plans for primary care clinical cases will be evaluated using a predefined scoring rubric.
Higher scores indicate better treatment planning performance.
|
At the end of the initial 60-minute assessment
|
|
Change in Overall Clinical Decision-Making Score After LLM Review
Tidsram: Change from 60 to 90 minutes after the start of the assessment
|
Among participants assigned to the LLM second-opinion phase, the change in overall clinical decision-making score will be calculated as the score after LLM-assisted review minus the score before LLM-assisted review.
Positive values indicate improvement in overall clinical decision-making performance.
|
Change from 60 to 90 minutes after the start of the assessment
|
Samarbetspartners och utredare
Sponsor
Samarbetspartners
Studieavstämningsdatum
Studera stora datum
Studiestart (Beräknad)
Primärt slutförande (Beräknad)
Avslutad studie (Beräknad)
Studieregistreringsdatum
Först inskickad
Först inskickad som uppfyllde QC-kriterierna
Första postat (Faktisk)
Uppdateringar av studier
Senaste uppdatering publicerad (Faktisk)
Senaste inskickade uppdateringen som uppfyllde QC-kriterierna
Senast verifierad
Mer information
Termer relaterade till denna studie
Andra studie-ID-nummer
- IRB00006761-M20260614
Plan för individuella deltagardata (IPD)
Planerar du att dela individuella deltagardata (IPD)?
Läkemedels- och apparatinformation, studiedokument
Studerar en amerikansk FDA-reglerad läkemedelsprodukt
Studerar en amerikansk FDA-reglerad produktprodukt
Denna information hämtades direkt från webbplatsen clinicaltrials.gov utan några ändringar. Om du har några önskemål om att ändra, ta bort eller uppdatera dina studieuppgifter, vänligen kontakta register@clinicaltrials.gov. Så snart en ändring har implementerats på clinicaltrials.gov, kommer denna att uppdateras automatiskt även på vår webbplats .