Group assessments of resident physicians improve reliability and decrease halo error
Matthew R Thomas, Thomas J Beckman, Karen F Mauck, Stephen S Cha, Kris G Thomas, Matthew R Thomas, Thomas J Beckman, Karen F Mauck, Stephen S Cha, Kris G Thomas
Abstract
Background: Individual faculty assessments of resident competency are complicated by inconsistent application of standards, lack of reliability, and the "halo" effect.
Objective: We determined whether the addition of faculty group assessments of residents in an ambulatory clinic, compared with individual faculty-of-resident assessments alone, have better reliability and reduced halo effects.
Design: This prospective, longitudinal study was performed in the outpatient continuity clinics of a large internal medicine residency program.
Main measures: Faculty-on-resident and group faculty-on-resident assessment scores were used for comparison.
Key results: Overall mean scores were significantly higher for group than individual assessments (3.92 ± 0.51 vs. 3.83 ± 0.38, p = 0.0001). Overall inter-rater reliability increased when combining group and individual assessments compared to individual assessments alone (intraclass correlation coefficient, 95% CI = 0.828, 0.785-0.866 vs. 0.749, 0.686-0.804). Inter-item correlations were less for group (0.49) than individual (0.68) assessments.
Conclusions: This study demonstrates improved inter-rater reliability and reduced range restriction (halo effect) of resident assessment across multiple performance domains by adding the group assessment method to traditional individual faculty-on-resident assessment. This feasible model could help graduate medical education programs achieve more reliable and discriminating resident assessments.
Figures


Source: PubMed
Bevorstehende klinische Studien
-
Kanglin Biotechnology (Hangzhou) Co., Ltd.Noch keine RekrutierungParkinson-Krankheit (PD) | Advanced Primary PDChina
-
Carilion ClinicRekrutierungChronisches Subduralhämatom | WiederkehrendVereinigte Staaten
-
Mahidol UniversityNoch keine RekrutierungBrustkrebs | Duktales Karzinom in situ
-
Biosensors Europe SANoch keine RekrutierungNSTEMI | Instabile Angina pectoris (UA) | Angina (stabil)Vereinigtes Königreich
-
CooperVision International Limited (CVIL)Noch keine Rekrutierung
-
Shanghai Yueyang Integrated Medicine HospitalRekrutierungSarkopenie bei älteren MenschenChina
-
University of Management and Technology LahoreNoch keine RekrutierungFarward Head PosturePakistan
-
China National Center for Cardiovascular DiseasesNoch keine RekrutierungMedikamentenbeschichteter Ballon | Intravaskulärer Ultraschall | De Novo Large Coronary VesselChina
-
Korea University Anam HospitalNoch keine RekrutierungAF - VorhofflimmernSüdkorea
-
Jijun WangRekrutierung
-
DiproBio (Shanghai) Co., Ltd.Noch keine RekrutierungPsychische Gesundheit | Psychologischer StressChina
-
Emory UniversityNoch keine RekrutierungSchwangerschaft bezogen | Hypertensive Disorder of Pregnancy (HDP)Vereinigte Staaten