Effectiveness, Patient Acceptance, and Cost Estimation of 3D-printed Retainer Compared to Hawley Retainer in Expansion Case: a Randomized Controlled Trial
2026년 6월 15일 업데이트: ASMA ASHARI, National University of Malaysia
Expansion of the arches is generally considered highly unstable and prone to relapse regardless of the type of expansion.
Retention appliances play a vital role in preserving these changes.
Hawley retainer users often avoid wearing them due to speech difficulties and less aesthetic appeal.
They are also more prone to breakage, costlier, and require more labour.
Despite the relatively recent introduction of 3D-printed retainers, they offer potential advantages in orthodontics, including the accuracy of digitally scanned images, reduced labour and material costs, and improved patient comfort.
While 3D-printed retainers are quite new, most studies focus on laboratory testing of their mechanical properties, there is limited evidence directly comparing their effectiveness in retaining arch width increases, patient acceptance, and cost estimation.
This knowledge gap creates uncertainty about the optimal choice of retainer for long-term stability, necessitating a comparative assessment of their performance.
This study addresses this knowledge gap by evaluating the retention of arch width increases achieved using Hawley retainers versus 3D-printed retainers
연구 개요
상세 설명
Maxillary dentoalveolar expansion is a procedure to correct transverse discrepancies between the maxillary and mandibular arches by applying forces to widen the maxillary arch.
This procedure is inherently unstable and is susceptible to relapse.
While Hawley retainers (HR) have served as the established standard for retention after maxillary expansion, recent studies have shown that modified thermoforming retainers can be as effective as HR.
The emergence of computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing (CAD-CAM) and three-dimensional (3D) printing technology has significantly streamlined fabricating appliances and prostheses.
3D printing material is more rigid, with superior compression and tensile strength.
Thus, a normal shape 3D-printed retainer may be a viable choice for the retention of maxillary expansion.
A recent systematic review highlighted a critical gap in knowledge regarding the long-term clinical efficacy and durability of 3D-printed retainers.
Thus, the present study aimed to address this research gap by investigating the long-term clinical effectiveness, patient acceptance, and cost estimation of 3D-printed retainers in expansion cases.
This study will be carried out as a multicentre prospective randomized controlled clinical trial (RCT) conducted at Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM), Universiti Malaya (UM), and Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM).
Orthodontic patients who fulfil the inclusion criteria will be randomly allocated into the HR or 3D-printed retainer groups.
Dental casts of patients will be measured at intercanine width (ICW), inter-premolar width (IPMW), inter-first molar mesiobuccal cusp width 1 (IFMW1), and inter-first molar distobuccal cusp width 2 (IFMW2) for both groups at debond(T0), 3(T1), 6(T2), and 12(T3).
The outcome assessor and data analyst will be blinded to the retention method.
The researcher will evaluate the patient's acceptance at T2 & T3 and conduct a cost analysis at T1 post-debond.
The findings of this study will contribute valuable data to the field of orthodontics, aiding clinicians in determining the most effective long-term retention strategy for patients who have undergone maxillary dentoalveolar expansion.
연구 유형
중재적
등록 (추정된)
28
단계
- 해당 없음
연락처 및 위치
이 섹션에서는 연구를 수행하는 사람들의 연락처 정보와 이 연구가 수행되는 장소에 대한 정보를 제공합니다.
연구 연락처
- 이름: Asma Ashari, BDS Adel, MClinDent Lon, MOrth
- 전화번호: +603 8921 5555
- 이메일: asmaashari@ukm.edu.my
연구 연락처 백업
- 이름: ALIZAE MARNY FADZLIN SYED MOHAMED
- 전화번호: +6038921 5555
- 이메일: alizaemarny@ukm.edu.my
연구 장소
-
-
Kuala Lumpur
-
Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur, 말레이시아, 50300
- National University of Malaysia
-
연락하다:
- Fakulti pergigian UKM
- 전화번호: +6039289 7741
- 이메일: asmaashari@ukm.edu.my
-
수석 연구원:
- Mei Ling Cheng
-
Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur, 말레이시아, 50603
- University Malaya
-
연락하다:
- May Nak Lau
- 전화번호: +60379674802
- 이메일: minalau@um.edu.my
-
부수사관:
- Zhang Yi Tan
-
-
Selangor
-
Sungai Buloh, Selangor, 말레이시아, 47000
- University Teknologi Mara Selangor branch
-
연락하다:
- Nik Mukhriz Nik Mustapha
- 전화번호: +6036126 6103
- 이메일: nikmukhriz@uitm.edu.my
-
부수사관:
- Siti Nor Hafizah Salehun
-
-
참여기준
연구원은 적격성 기준이라는 특정 설명에 맞는 사람을 찾습니다. 이러한 기준의 몇 가지 예는 개인의 일반적인 건강 상태 또는 이전 치료입니다.
자격 기준
공부할 수 있는 나이
- 어린이
- 성인
- 고령자
건강한 자원 봉사자를 받아들입니다
예
설명
Inclusion Criteria:
- Patients aged 16 years or older at the time of debonding
- Treatment plan of extraction or non-extraction followed by straight wire appliances in the upper arch only or both arches
- Undergone expansion treatment in the upper arch causing an arch width increase of 3-10mm, either using a Quadhelix, expansion with archwires, or URA with midline screw
- Had pretreatment dental cast
- Had no chronic medical condition.
Exclusion Criteria:
- Cleft lip and palate
- Chronic medical conditions
- Broken teeth or bubbles on study model at site of measurement.
공부 계획
이 섹션에서는 연구 설계 방법과 연구가 측정하는 내용을 포함하여 연구 계획에 대한 세부 정보를 제공합니다.
연구는 어떻게 설계됩니까?
디자인 세부사항
- 주 목적: 다른
- 할당: 무작위
- 중재 모델: 병렬 할당
- 마스킹: 하나의
무기와 개입
참가자 그룹 / 팔 |
개입 / 치료 |
|---|---|
|
활성 비교기: Hawley retainer
A screening will be done to select suitable patients for the study.
Only patients who fulfil the criteria will be invited to participate in this study.
Following informed consent, eligible subjects will be randomly allocated into one of two groups wither hawley retainer or 3D printed retainer.
Fabrication of Hawley retainers will be done using a standardized design across all centres.
|
Hawley retainers have served as the established standard for retention after maxillary expansion.
Standard design of Hawley Retainer: - Labial bow (0.8mm hard stainless steel) from canine to canine - Adam clasp on the molar (0.7mm hard stainless steel) - acrylic baseplate (2-3mm thickness) .
|
|
실험적: 3D printed retainer
A screening will be done to select suitable patients for the study.
Only patients who fulfil the criteria will be invited to participate in this study.
Following informed consent, eligible subjects will be randomly allocated into one of two groups wither hawley retainer or 3D printed retainer.
Fabrication of 3d printed retainers will be done using a standardized design at one main centres by one technician using Nextdent Orhtoflex Resin.
|
3D-printed retainer Using Nextdent Orthoflex resin Standard design of 3D printed retainer:
|
연구는 무엇을 측정합니까?
주요 결과 측정
결과 측정 |
측정값 설명 |
기간 |
|---|---|---|
|
Retention of the maxillary expansion
기간: 12 months
|
|
12 months
|
2차 결과 측정
결과 측정 |
측정값 설명 |
기간 |
|---|---|---|
|
Patient acceptance
기간: 12 months
|
Subjects will be given and asked to complete a questionnaire on patient acceptance (see attachment) at 6 and 12 months post-debond. The Questionnaire has been validated and published by (Saw et al. 2025). It uses a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) to ask six questions related to subject acceptance of orthodontic retainers in fitting, speech, appearance, oral hygiene, durability, and comfort. Refer to Attachment 1 (Malay version) and Attachment 2 (English Version) for the questionnaires. |
12 months
|
|
cost estimation
기간: 6 months
|
To estimate and compare the costs associated with the implementation and provision of 3D-printed retainers between clinics with existing in-house 3D-printing facilities and clinics planning to acquire 3D-printing services.
The analysis will include direct costs such as equipment acquisition, materials, software, maintenance, laboratory procedures, and staff chairside time.
|
6 months
|
공동 작업자 및 조사자
여기에서 이 연구와 관련된 사람과 조직을 찾을 수 있습니다.
수사관
- 연구 책임자: Asma Ashari, MClinDent Lon, National University of Malaysia
간행물 및 유용한 링크
연구에 대한 정보 입력을 담당하는 사람이 자발적으로 이러한 간행물을 제공합니다. 이것은 연구와 관련된 모든 것에 관한 것일 수 있습니다.
일반 간행물
- Hichens L, Rowland H, Williams A, Hollinghurst S, Ewings P, Clark S, Ireland A, Sandy J. Cost-effectiveness and patient satisfaction: Hawley and vacuum-formed retainers. Eur J Orthod. 2007 Aug;29(4):372-8. doi: 10.1093/ejo/cjm039.
- Naeem OA, Bencharit S, Yang IH, Stilianoudakis SC, Carrico C, Tufekci E. Comparison of 3-dimensional printing technologies on the precision, trueness, and accuracy of printed retainers. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2022 Apr;161(4):582-591. doi: 10.1016/j.ajodo.2021.03.016.
- Firlej M, Zaborowicz K, Zaborowicz M, Firlej E, Domagala I, Pieniak D, Igielska-Kalwat J, Dmowski A, Biedziak B. Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Orthodontic Retainers. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 May 9;19(9):5775. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19095775.
- Tsoukala E, Lyros I, Tsolakis AI, Maroulakos MP, Tsolakis IA. Direct 3D-Printed Orthodontic Retainers. A Systematic Review. Children (Basel). 2023 Apr 3;10(4):676. doi: 10.3390/children10040676.
- Saw ZK, Yuen JJX, Ashari A, Ibrahim Bahemia F, Low YX, Nik Mustapha NM, Lau MN. Forward-backward translation, content validity, face validity, construct validity, criterion validity, test-retest reliability, and internal consistency of a questionnaire on patient acceptance of orthodontic retainer. PLoS One. 2025 Jan 3;20(1):e0314853. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0314853. eCollection 2025.
- Nakornnoi T, Bunjerdjin P, Santiwong P, Sipiyaruk K, Neoh SP, Chintavalakorn R. The Influence of Thickness on the Mechanical Behaviors of 3D Printing Resins for Orthodontic Retainers. Int J Biomater. 2024 Jun 25;2024:7398478. doi: 10.1155/2024/7398478. eCollection 2024.
- Ashari A, Xian L, Syed Mohamed AMF, Wahab RMA, Kit YC, Tata MD, Sinnasamy S, Kuppusamy E. One-year comparative assessment of retention of arch width increases between modified vacuum-formed and Hawley retainers. Angle Orthod. 2022 Mar 1;92(2):197-203. doi: 10.2319/050921-363.1.
- Ashari A, Nik Mustapha NM, Yuen JJX, Saw ZK, Lau MN, Xian L, Syed Mohamed AMF, Megat Abdul Wahab R, Yeoh CK, Deva Tata M, Sinnasamy S. A two-year comparative assessment of retention of arch width increases between modified vacuum-formed and Hawley retainers: a multi-center randomized clinical trial. Prog Orthod. 2022 Aug 26;23(1):40. doi: 10.1186/s40510-022-00424-5.
- Stoev YY, Uzunov TT, Stoyanova NS, Grozdanova-Uzunova RG, Kosturkov DN, Taneva IK. Mechanical properties of materials for 3D printed orthodontic retainers. Folia Med (Plovdiv). 2023 Dec 31;65(6):986-992. doi: 10.3897/folmed.65.e107299.
- Neoh SP, Khantachawana A, Chintavalakorn R, Santiwong P, Srikhirin T. Comparison of physical, mechanical, and optical properties between thermoplastic materials and 3-dimensional printing resins for orthodontic clear retainers. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2025 Jan;167(1):95-109.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.ajodo.2024.06.010.
연구 기록 날짜
이 날짜는 ClinicalTrials.gov에 대한 연구 기록 및 요약 결과 제출의 진행 상황을 추적합니다. 연구 기록 및 보고된 결과는 공개 웹사이트에 게시되기 전에 특정 품질 관리 기준을 충족하는지 확인하기 위해 국립 의학 도서관(NLM)에서 검토합니다.
연구 주요 날짜
연구 시작 (추정된)
2026년 6월 1일
기본 완료 (추정된)
2027년 12월 1일
연구 완료 (추정된)
2027년 12월 1일
연구 등록 날짜
최초 제출
2026년 6월 8일
QC 기준을 충족하는 최초 제출
2026년 6월 15일
처음 게시됨 (실제)
2026년 6월 22일
연구 기록 업데이트
마지막 업데이트 게시됨 (실제)
2026년 6월 22일
QC 기준을 충족하는 마지막 업데이트 제출
2026년 6월 15일
마지막으로 확인됨
2026년 6월 1일
추가 정보
이 연구와 관련된 용어
기타 연구 ID 번호
- JEP 2025-630 (기타 식별자: National university of Malaysia)
개별 참가자 데이터(IPD) 계획
개별 참가자 데이터(IPD)를 공유할 계획입니까?
미정
IPD 계획 설명
Only data relevant to the study analyses will be provided.
All personal identifiers and information that could reveal participant identity will be removed to protect confidentiality and comply with ethical requirements.
약물 및 장치 정보, 연구 문서
미국 FDA 규제 의약품 연구
아니
미국 FDA 규제 기기 제품 연구
아니
이 정보는 변경 없이 clinicaltrials.gov 웹사이트에서 직접 가져온 것입니다. 귀하의 연구 세부 정보를 변경, 제거 또는 업데이트하도록 요청하는 경우 register@clinicaltrials.gov. 문의하십시오. 변경 사항이 clinicaltrials.gov에 구현되는 즉시 저희 웹사이트에도 자동으로 업데이트됩니다. .