Эта страница была переведена автоматически, точность перевода не гарантируется. Пожалуйста, обратитесь к английской версии для исходного текста.

Patient AI Trust Dynamics Before and After Orthopedic Consultation (ORTHO-OP-GPT) (ORTHO-OP-GPT)

26 августа 2026 г. обновлено: Utku Gürhan

Longitudinal Pre-Post Patient AI Trust Dynamics in Orthopedic Outpatients: A Mixed-Methods Observational Study With Matched Physician-Patient Dyads

Patients increasingly consult artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots such as ChatGPT for health information before clinical visits, yet the impact of an actual orthopedic consultation on patient trust in AI-derived information remains unknown. This prospective longitudinal observational study quantifies how a single orthopedic outpatient consultation modifies patient trust in AI chatbots, the concordance between AI-derived and physician-delivered information, and patient anxiety, using a paired pre-post survey design supplemented by a matched physician-side assessment. Adult patients (18 years and older) presenting to two orthopedic outpatient clinics in Cyprus complete a brief pre-consultation questionnaire (T0) capturing demographics, AI use patterns, prior AI consultation regarding the current complaint, baseline trust, expectations, and anxiety. Immediately after their consultation they complete a second questionnaire (T1) assessing concordance with physician advice, trust change, consultation facilitation, post-consultation anxiety, and future intention. The consulting physician completes a brief 30-second post-visit form capturing whether AI was discussed, the medical accuracy of AI-derived information conveyed by the patient, and the effect of the AI discussion on consultation duration. The primary outcomes are the paired within-patient change in AI trust between T0 and T1 and physician-patient concordance on AI versus physician advice. Target enrollment was 180 to obtain 150 paired completed assessments; 350 participants were enrolled.

Обзор исследования

Статус

Завершенный

Условия

Подробное описание

Background and Rationale: Cross-sectional surveys have documented increasing patient use of AI chatbots for health information seeking. However, no published study has assessed how an actual physician consultation modifies patient trust in AI in a paired pre/post design, nor has any study captured the physician perspective on the same encounter in a matched dyad. Routine clinical encounters may be the primary mechanism by which patients calibrate their trust in AI-derived medical information.

Setting and Population: Two university-affiliated orthopedic outpatient clinics in North Cyprus.

Procedures:

  • T0 (pre-consultation, waiting room, approximately 5 minutes): 14-item self-report questionnaire.
  • Consultation: usual care.
  • T1 (post-consultation, departure, approximately 5 minutes): 10-item self-report questionnaire.
  • Physician form (post-consultation, approximately 30 seconds): 5-item brief assessment.
  • Patient and physician forms are linked by an anonymous Participant ID.

Statistical Analysis Plan: Paired t-tests or Wilcoxon signed-rank tests for paired continuous outcomes; McNemar test or Stuart-Maxwell for paired categorical outcomes; Cohen's kappa for inter-rater agreement (AI versus physician); multinomial logistic regression for predictors of trust shift. All analyses two-sided, alpha equals 0.05. SPSS version 28.

Data Management: Anonymous CSV stored locally, encrypted, retained for 5 years per institutional policy. De-identified participant-level data available upon reasonable request after publication.

No formal pilot study is conducted. Instead, the first 20 participants will be prospectively monitored for protocol feasibility (mean completion time, drop-out rate, item-level missing data) as an embedded running pilot.

Тип исследования

Наблюдательный

Регистрация (Действительный)

350

Контакты и местонахождение

В этом разделе приведены контактные данные лиц, проводящих исследование, и информация о том, где проводится это исследование.

Места учебы

  • Кипр
      • Kyrenia, Кипр
        • University of Kyrenia, Dr. Suat Gunsel Hospital - Orthopedic Outpatient Clinic
      • Nicosia, Кипр
        • Near East University Hospital - Orthopedic Outpatient Clinic

Критерии участия

Исследователи ищут людей, которые соответствуют определенному описанию, называемому критериям приемлемости. Некоторыми примерами этих критериев являются общее состояние здоровья человека или предшествующее лечение.

Критерии приемлемости

Возраст, подходящий для обучения

  • Взрослый
  • Пожилой взрослый

Принимает здоровых добровольцев

Нет

Метод выборки

Невероятностная выборка

Исследуемая популяция

Consecutive adult patients (18 years and older) presenting to the participating orthopedic outpatient clinics during the recruitment window who consent to participate. No specific orthopedic diagnosis is required.

Описание

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Age 18 years or older
  • Presenting to an orthopedic outpatient clinic for any consultation
  • Able to read and respond to a Turkish-language questionnaire
  • Provides informed consent

Exclusion Criteria:

  • Inability to complete a self-report questionnaire (e.g., severe cognitive impairment, language barrier)
  • Re-presentation within the same recruitment window (each patient is enrolled only once)
  • Refusal of consent for either T0 or T1

Учебный план

В этом разделе представлена ​​подробная информация о плане исследования, в том числе о том, как планируется исследование и что оно измеряет.

Как устроено исследование?

Детали дизайна

Что измеряет исследование?

Первичные показатели результатов

Мера результата
Мера Описание
Временное ограничение
Mean within-patient change in self-reported trust in artificial intelligence-derived health information, measured by a study-specific 5-point Likert item (T0.11) and a study-specific 3-level categorical change item (T1.4).
Временное ограничение: Baseline (within 15 minutes pre-consultation in the orthopaedic outpatient waiting room) and immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit, same-day index visit).
Trust in AI-derived health information is assessed pre-consultation by a study-specific single-item 5-point Likert scale (item T0.11: "How much do you trust the AI's answer?"; anchors 1 = not at all, 5 = completely), administered only to patients who reported pre-consultation AI use (item T0.9 = Yes). Post-consultation, trust change is reassessed by a study-specific 3-level categorical item (item T1.4: increased trust / unchanged / decreased trust). For paired analysis, the post-consultation score is derived by mapping T1.4 categories to integer shifts (+1 / 0 / -1, with floor 1 and ceiling 5) relative to T0.11. Unit of measure: Likert score points on a 1-5 scale (continuous derived score) and proportion of patients per 3-level category. Primary analysis: paired Wilcoxon signed-rank test on the derived continuous score; sensitivity analysis: McNemar test on the 3-level categorical change.
Baseline (within 15 minutes pre-consultation in the orthopaedic outpatient waiting room) and immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit, same-day index visit).
Patient-physician concordance on artificial intelligence-versus-physician medical advice agreement, measured by Cohen's kappa coefficient between a study-specific 4-category patient item (T1.2) and a study-specific 5-point physician-rated AI medical accu
Временное ограничение: Immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), for both patient (T1.2) and physician (H2) forms; same-day index visit.
Concordance is assessed by Cohen's kappa coefficient comparing patient-reported AI-physician concordance (item T1.2: fully concordant / partially concordant / discordant / physician did not address; dichotomized to concordant vs. non-concordant) and physician-reported AI medical accuracy (item H2: 5-point Likert anchored 1 = entirely incorrect to 5 = entirely correct; dichotomized at ≥ 3 as concordant). Unit of measure: kappa coefficient (range -1 to +1) with 95% confidence interval, and percentage of dyads classified as concordant on each instrument.
Immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), for both patient (T1.2) and physician (H2) forms; same-day index visit.

Вторичные показатели результатов

Мера результата
Мера Описание
Временное ограничение
Percentage of enrolled patients reporting pre-consultation artificial intelligence use for the current orthopaedic complaint, measured by a study-specific single-item yes/no question (T0.9).
Временное ограничение: Baseline (within 15 minutes pre-consultation, same-day index visit).
Proportion of enrolled patients responding "Yes" to item T0.9 ("Before today's appointment, did you ask an AI chatbot a question about this health concern?"). Unit of measure: percentage of participants, reported with exact (Clopper-Pearson) 95% confidence interval.
Baseline (within 15 minutes pre-consultation, same-day index visit).
Percentage of pre-consultation artificial-intelligence users whose physician independently confirmed that AI was raised during the consultation, measured by a study-specific yes/no physician item (H1).
Временное ограничение: Baseline (T0.9, pre-consultation) and immediately after the consultation (H1, within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Among patients responding "Yes" to T0.9, the proportion in whom the treating physician independently reported "Yes" to item H1 ("Did the patient raise AI during this consultation?"). Unit of measure: percentage of patients with exact 95% confidence interval.
Baseline (T0.9, pre-consultation) and immediately after the consultation (H1, within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Percentage of consultations in which the physician reported that the artificial-intelligence discussion shortened, did not change, or prolonged the encounter, measured by a study-specific 3-category physician item (H3).
Временное ограничение: Immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Among consultations in which the patient raised AI (H1 = Yes), the physician's categorical rating of effect on consultation duration (H3: "shortened" / "no change" / "prolonged"). Unit of measure: percentage of consultations per category (descriptive).
Immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Mean patient rating of how prior artificial-intelligence use facilitated the consultation, measured by a study-specific 5-point Likert item (T1.4b: 1 = much more difficult, 5 = much easier).
Временное ограничение: Immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Among patients with T0.9 = Yes, patient-reported facilitation by prior AI use (item T1.4b). Unit of measure: Likert score points (mean with standard deviation), and percentage of participants endorsing scores ≥ 4.
Immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Mean patient-reported future intention to use and to recommend artificial intelligence for health information, measured by two study-specific 5-point Likert items (T1.7 future use; T1.8 recommendation to a friend).
Временное ограничение: Immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Future-use intention (item T1.7: 1 = definitely will not, 5 = definitely will) and recommendation intention (item T1.8: 1 = definitely will not, 5 = definitely will). Unit of measure: Likert score points (mean with standard deviation), and percentage of participants endorsing scores ≥ 4 on each item.
Immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Mean within-patient change in consultation-related anxiety, measured by a study-specific six-item instrument (four-item anxiety subscale, range 4-20).
Временное ограничение: Baseline (within 15 minutes pre-consultation) and immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.
Anxiety is measured immediately before and immediately after the consultation using a study-specific six-item instrument modelled on the Amsterdam Preoperative Anxiety and Information Scale, with the referent moved from an impending procedure to the outpatient consultation. The anxiety subscale is the sum of four items (range 4-20). Protocol change: the 0-10 visual analogue scale originally registered for this outcome (items T0.14 and T1.5) was replaced by this instrument before data collection began and was never administered. Unit of measure: scale points. Analysis: paired t-test, with analysis of covariance for between-group comparison.
Baseline (within 15 minutes pre-consultation) and immediately after the consultation (within 15 minutes of consultation exit), same-day index visit.

Другие показатели результатов

Мера результата
Мера Описание
Временное ограничение
Exploratory association between categorical post-consultation trust change and demographic predictors, estimated by multinomial logistic regression with the study-specific 3-level trust change item (T1.4) as the outcome and age band, sex, education level
Временное ограничение: Through study completion, an average of 12 months from first enrolment.
Multinomial logistic regression model: outcome = T1.4 (decreased / unchanged / increased trust, reference category = unchanged); predictors = age band (5-level), sex (3-level), education (5-level), employment status, weekly internet-use frequency. Unit of measure: adjusted odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals.
Through study completion, an average of 12 months from first enrolment.
Internal consistency of a four-item artificial-intelligence trust subscale, measured by Cronbach's alpha across items T0.11 (baseline trust), T1.4 (post-consultation trust change, linearly recoded), T1.7 (future-use intention), and T1.8 (recommendation
Временное ограничение: Through study completion, an average of 12 months from first enrolment.
Cronbach's alpha is estimated on the final analytic sample using the four trust-related Likert items listed. Unit of measure: alpha coefficient (range 0 to 1) with bootstrap 95% confidence interval.
Through study completion, an average of 12 months from first enrolment.

Соавторы и исследователи

Здесь вы найдете людей и организации, участвующие в этом исследовании.

Спонсор

Utku Gürhan

Следователи

  • Главный следователь: Utku Gurhan, MD, University of Kyrenia

Публикации и полезные ссылки

Лицо, ответственное за внесение сведений об исследовании, добровольно предоставляет эти публикации. Это может быть что угодно, связанное с исследованием.

Общие публикации

Даты записи исследования

Эти даты отслеживают ход отправки отчетов об исследованиях и сводных результатов на сайт ClinicalTrials.gov. Записи исследований и сообщаемые результаты проверяются Национальной медицинской библиотекой (NLM), чтобы убедиться, что они соответствуют определенным стандартам контроля качества, прежде чем публиковать их на общедоступном веб-сайте.

Изучение основных дат

Начало исследования (Действительный)

1 июня 2026 г.

Первичное завершение (Действительный)

31 июля 2026 г.

Завершение исследования (Действительный)

31 июля 2026 г.

Даты регистрации исследования

Первый отправленный

18 мая 2026 г.

Впервые представлено, что соответствует критериям контроля качества

1 июня 2026 г.

Первый опубликованный (Действительный)

8 июня 2026 г.

Обновления учебных записей

Последнее опубликованное обновление (Действительный)

31 августа 2026 г.

Последнее отправленное обновление, отвечающее критериям контроля качества

26 августа 2026 г.

Последняя проверка

1 августа 2026 г.

Дополнительная информация

Термины, связанные с этим исследованием

Ключевые слова

Другие идентификационные номера исследования

  • ORTHO-OP-GPT-2026

Планирование данных отдельных участников (IPD)

Планируете делиться данными об отдельных участниках (IPD)?

ДА

Информация о лекарствах и устройствах, исследовательские документы

Изучает лекарственный продукт, регулируемый FDA США.

Нет

Изучает продукт устройства, регулируемый Управлением по санитарному надзору за качеством пищевых продуктов и медикаментов США.

Нет

Эта информация была получена непосредственно с веб-сайта clinicaltrials.gov без каких-либо изменений. Если у вас есть запросы на изменение, удаление или обновление сведений об исследовании, обращайтесь по адресу register@clinicaltrials.gov. Как только изменение будет реализовано на clinicaltrials.gov, оно будет автоматически обновлено и на нашем веб-сайте. .

Подписаться