The effect of sugar-free versus sugar-sweetened beverages on satiety, liking and wanting: an 18 month randomized double-blind trial in children

Janne C de Ruyter, Martijn B Katan, Lothar D J Kuijper, Djin G Liem, Margreet R Olthof, Janne C de Ruyter, Martijn B Katan, Lothar D J Kuijper, Djin G Liem, Margreet R Olthof

Abstract

Background: Substituting sugar-free for sugar-sweetened beverages reduces weight gain. A possible explanation is that sugar-containing and sugar-free beverages cause the same degree of satiety. However, this has not been tested in long-term trials.

Methods: We randomized 203 children aged 7-11 years to receive 250 mL per day of an artificially sweetened sugar-free beverage or a similarly looking and tasting sugar-sweetened beverage. We measured satiety on a 5-point scale by questionnaire at 0, 6, 12 and 18 months. We calculated the change in satiety from before intake to 1 minute after intake and 15 minutes after intake. We then calculated the odds ratio that satiety increased by 1 point in the sugar-group versus the sugar-free group. We also investigated how much the children liked and wanted the beverages.

Results: 146 children or 72% completed the study. We found no statistically significant difference in satiety between the sugar-free and sugar-sweetened group; the adjusted odds ratio for a 1 point increase in satiety in the sugar group versus the sugar-free group was 0.77 at 1 minute (95% confidence interval, 0.46 to 1.29), and 1.44 at 15 minutes after intake (95% CI, 0.86 to 2.40). The sugar-group liked and wanted their beverage slightly more than the sugar-free group, adjusted odds ratio 1.63 (95% CI 1.05 to 2.54) and 1.65 (95% CI 1.07 to 2.55), respectively.

Conclusions: Sugar-sweetened and sugar-free beverages produced similar satiety. Therefore when children are given sugar-free instead of sugar-containing drinks they might not make up the missing calories from other sources. This may explain our previous observation that children in the sugar-free group accumulated less body fat than those in the sugar group.

Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT00893529 https://ichgcp.net/clinical-trials-registry/NCT00893529.

Conflict of interest statement

Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Figures

Figure 1. Randomization and follow-up of the…
Figure 1. Randomization and follow-up of the study participants.
In the sugar-free group, allergy was reported as an adverse event for one child. In the sugar-group, allergy was reported as an adverse event for one child, and weight increase was reported as an adverse event for one child.
Figure 2. Time schedule for filling out…
Figure 2. Time schedule for filling out the questionnaire.
The timeline is indicative because each school had its own timing of the morning break.
Figure 3. Satiety after intake minus satiety…
Figure 3. Satiety after intake minus satiety before intake of the beverages at 18 months in 146 children.
Satiety was scored from 1 (not full at all) to 5 (very full). Bars indicate the shift in satiety from before to after intake of the beverages. Panel A shows satiety 1 minute after intake; Panel B, 15 minutes after intake. An increase of 1 means any increase of 1 point on the 5-point scale.
Figure 4. Arithmetic mean scores for satiety,…
Figure 4. Arithmetic mean scores for satiety, liking, and wanting over the course of the trial.
Dashed lines, sugar group; solid lines, sugar-free group. T bars indicate one standard deviation

References

    1. de Ruyter JC, Olthof MR, Seidell JC, Katan MB (2012) A trial of sugar-free or sugar-sweetened beverages and body weight in children. N Engl J Med 367: 1397-1406. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1203034. PubMed: .
    1. Ebbeling CB, Feldman HA, Chomitz VR, Antonelli TA, Gortmaker SL et al. (2012) A randomized trial of sugar-sweetened beverages and adolescent body weight. N Engl J Med 367: 1407-1416. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1203388. PubMed: .
    1. Blundell J, de Graaf C, Hulshof T, Jebb S, Livingstone B et al. (2010) Appetite control: methodological aspects of the evaluation of foods. Obes Rev 11: 251-270. doi:10.1111/j.1467-789X.2010.00714.x. PubMed: .
    1. Cassady BA, Considine RV, Mattes RD (2012) Beverage consumption, appetite, and energy intake: what did you expect? Am J Clin Nutr 95: 587-593. doi:10.3945/ajcn.111.025437. PubMed: .
    1. Tordoff MG, Alleva AM (1990) Effect of drinking soda sweetened with aspartame or high-fructose corn syrup on food intake and body weight. Am J Clin Nutr 51: 963-969. PubMed: .
    1. Porikos KP, Booth G, Van Itallie TB (1977) Effect of covert nutritive dilution on the spontaneous food intake of obese individuals: a pilot study. Am J Clin Nutr 30: 1638-1644. PubMed: .
    1. Rolls BJ, Kim S, Fedoroff IC (1990) Effects of drinks sweetened with sucrose or aspartame on hunger, thirst and food intake in men. Physiol Behav 48: 19-26. doi:10.1016/0031-9384(90)90254-2. PubMed: .
    1. Holt SH, Sandona N, Brand-Miller JC (2000) The effects of sugar-free vs sugar-rich beverages on feelings of fullness and subsequent food intake. Int J Food Sci Nutr 51: 59-71. doi:10.1080/096374800100912. PubMed: .
    1. Canty DJ, Chan MM (1991) Effects of consumption of caloric vs noncaloric sweet drinks on indices of hunger and food consumption in normal adults. Am J Clin Nutr 53: 1159-1164. PubMed: .
    1. Van Wymelbeke V, Béridot-Thérond ME, de La Guéronnière V, Fantino M (2004) Influence of repeated consumption of beverages containing sucrose or intense sweeteners on food intake. Eur J Clin Nutr 58: 154-161. doi:10.1038/sj.ejcn.1601762. PubMed: .
    1. Beridot-Therond ME, Arts I, Fantino M, De La Gueronniere V (1998) Short-term effects of the flavour of drinks on ingestive behaviours in man. Appetite 31: 67-81. doi:10.1006/appe.1997.0153. PubMed: .
    1. Berridge KC (1996) Food reward: brain substrates of wanting and liking. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 20: 1-25. doi:10.1016/0149-7634(95)00033-B. PubMed: .
    1. Mela DJ (2006) Eating for pleasure or just wanting to eat? Reconsidering sensory hedonic responses as a driver of obesity. Appetite 47: 10-17. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2006.02.006. PubMed: .
    1. de Ruyter JC, Olthof MR, Kuijper LD, Katan MB (2012) Effect of sugar-sweetened beverages on body weight in children: design and baseline characteristics of the Double-blind, Randomized INtervention study in Kids. Contemp Clin Trials 33: 247-257. doi:10.1016/j.cct.2011.10.007. PubMed: .
    1. Faith MS, Kermanshah M, Kissileff HR (2002) Development and preliminary validation of a silhouette satiety scale for children. Physiol Behav 76: 173-178. doi:10.1016/S0031-9384(02)00702-3. PubMed: .
    1. Léon F, Couronne T, Marcuz MC, Köster EP (1999) Measuring food liking in children: a comparison of non verbal methods. Food Qual Preference 10: 93-100. doi:10.1016/S0950-3293(98)00046-9.
    1. Liem DG, Zandstra LH (2009) Children's liking and wanting of snack products: Influence of shape and flavour. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 6: 38. doi:10.1186/1479-5868-6-38. PubMed: .
    1. RIVM (2011) NEVO-online versie. Bilthoven: p. 2011/3.0.
    1. Donders-Engelen M, Van der Heijden L, Hulshof K (2003) Maten, Gewichten en Codenummers (English translation: Units, Weights and Codes 2003) Wageningen. Wageningen University, TNO.
    1. Rolls BJ, Laster LJ, Summerfelt A (1989) Hunger and food intake following consumption of low-calorie foods. Appetite 13: 115-127. doi:10.1016/0195-6663(89)90109-8. PubMed: .
    1. Anton SD, Martin CK, Han H, Coulon S, Cefalu WT et al. (2010) Effects of stevia, aspartame, and sucrose on food intake, satiety, and postprandial glucose and insulin levels. Appetite 55: 37-43. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2010.03.009. PubMed: .
    1. Zandstra EH, de Graaf C, van Trijp HC (2000) Effects of variety and repeated in-home consumption on product acceptance. Appetite 35: 113-119. doi:10.1006/appe.2000.0342. PubMed: .
    1. Rolls ET, de Waal AW (1985) Long-term sensory-specific satiety: evidence from an Ethiopian refugee camp. Physiol Behav 34: 1017-1020. doi:10.1016/0031-9384(85)90032-0. PubMed: .
    1. Hetherington MM, Bell AC, Rolls BJ (2000) Effects of repeat consumption on pleasantness, preference and intake. Br Food J 102: 507-521. doi:10.1108/00070700010336517.
    1. Rolls BJ, Rolls ET, Rowe EA, Sweeney K (1981) Sensory specific satiety in man. Physiol Behav 27: 137-142. doi:10.1016/0031-9384(81)90310-3. PubMed: .
    1. Birch LL, Deysher M (1985) Conditioned and unconditioned caloric compensation: Evidence for self-regulation of food intake in young children. Learn Motiv 16: 341-355. doi:10.1016/0023-9690(85)90020-7.
    1. Bellisle F, Drewnowski A, Anderson GH, Westerterp-Plantenga M, Martin CK (2012) Sweetness, satiation, and satiety. J Nutr 142: 1149S-1154S. doi:10.3945/jn.111.149583. PubMed: .
    1. Erlanson-Albertsson C (2005) Appetite regulation and energy balance. Acta Paediatr Suppl 94: 40-41. doi:10.1080/08035320510035249. PubMed: .
    1. Rolls BJ, Hetherington M, Laster LJ (1988) Comparison of the effects of aspartame and sucrose on appetite and food intake. Appetite 11 Suppl 1: 62-67. doi:10.1016/S0195-6663(88)80048-5. PubMed: .
    1. Tournier A, Louis-Sylvestre J (1991) Effect of the physical state of a food on subsequent intake in human subjects. Appetite 16: 17-24. doi:10.1016/0195-6663(91)90107-4. PubMed: .
    1. Mattes RD, Campbell WW (2009) Effects of food form and timing of ingestion on appetite and energy intake in lean young adults and in young adults with obesity. J Am Diet Assoc 109: 430-437. doi:10.1016/j.jada.2008.11.031. PubMed: .
    1. Schönbeck Y, Talma H, van Dommelen P, Bakker B, Buitendijk SE et al. (2011) Increase in prevalence of overweight in dutch children and adolescents: a comparison of nationwide growth studies in 1980, 1997 and 2009. PLOS ONE 6: e27608. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0027608. PubMed: .
    1. Cole TJ, Flegal KM, Nicholls D, Jackson AA (2007) Body mass index cut offs to define thinness in children and adolescents: international survey. BMJ 28: 166-167. PubMed: .
    1. Cole TJ, Bellizzi MC, Flegal KM, Dietz WH (2000) Establishing a standard definition for child overweight and obesity worldwide: international survey. Bmj 320: 1240-1243. doi:10.1136/bmj.320.7244.1240. PubMed: .

Source: PubMed

スポンサーと協力者

医学的状態

薬物療法

3
購読する