Assessing prevalence of missed laboratory-confirmed sexually transmitted infections among women in Kingston, Jamaica: results from a secondary analysis of the Sino-Implant clinical trial

Abstract

Objectives: To assess potentially missed sexually transmitted infections (STIs), we compared clinically diagnosed STIs to laboratory-confirmed diagnoses of gonorrhoea (GC), chlamydia (CT) and trichomonas (Tvag).

Design: Secondary analysis of a randomised controlled trial.

Setting: We used data and specimens previously collected for the Sino-Implant Study in Kingston, Jamaica.

Participants: The Sino-Implant Study randomised 414 women to receive a levonorgestrel implant at either baseline or 3 months post-enrolment to evaluate unprotected sex after implant initiation. This analysis used 254 available vaginal swab samples.

Outcome measures: Clinically diagnosed STIs were determined from medical records by assessing clinical impressions and prescriptions. Laboratory-confirmed STIs included GC, CT and Tvag tested by Aptima Combo 2 for CT/GC and Aptima Tvag assays (Hologic, San Diego, California, USA). Log-binomial regression models fit with generalised estimating equations were used to estimate associations of clinically diagnosed STIs with laboratory-confirmed diagnoses and demographic and behavioural characteristics.

Results: Overall, 195 (76.8%) women had laboratory-confirmed STI (CT, GC or Tvag) while only 65 (25.6%) women had clinically diagnosed cervicitis and/or vaginitis during the study period. Clinical diagnosis missed 79.7% of laboratory-confirmed STIs: 85% of GC (n=17/20), 78.8% of CT (n=141/179) and 80.0% of Tvag (n=180/225). Hormonal contraceptive use in the month prior to the study visit was significantly associated with clinical diagnosis at any time point (prevalence ratio (PR): 1.65, 95% CI 1.07 to 2.54). As age increased, clinically missed infections significantly decreased (PR: 0.98 per year increase, 95% CI 0.97 to 1.00).

Conclusions: The prevalence of laboratory-confirmed STIs was much higher than what was captured by clinical diagnosis. GC, CT and Tvag were not accurately detected without lab confirmation. Missed diagnoses decreased with older age. Increased laboratory capacity and refinement of the syndromic approach are needed to protect the health of sexually active Jamaican women.

Trial registration number: NCT01684358.

Keywords: epidemiology; international health services; reproductive medicine.

Conflict of interest statement

Competing interests: None declared.

© Article author(s) (or their employer(s) unless otherwise stated in the text of the article) 2018. All rights reserved. No commercial use is permitted unless otherwise expressly granted.

Figures

Figure 1

Total and missed laboratory detected cases and clinical diagnoses, by overall total and by study visit. *Laboratory-detected cases include unmatched cases, defined as cases where the expected clinical STI code was identified in accordance with the lab results of GC, CT and/or Tvag or when the clinical STI code indicated yeast infection, HSV/HPV or other undetermined STI. There were 61 total unmatched cases, of which 3 were GC, 31 CT and 21 Tvag. **Defined as cases that were clinically diagnosed as healthy but had a laboratory-confirmed STI. ~Cervicitis includes diagnoses of CT, GC and unspecified cervicitis. ^ Vaginitis includes diagnoses of bacterial vaginosis, Tvag and unspecified vaginitis. CT, chlamydia; GC, gonorrhoea; HPV, human papilloma virus; HSV, herpes simplex virus; STI, sexually transmitted infection; Tvag, trichomonas.