A systematic review of prophylactic braces in the prevention of knee ligament injuries in collegiate football players

Brian G Pietrosimone, Terry L Grindstaff, Shelley W Linens, Elizabeth Uczekaj, Jay Hertel, Brian G Pietrosimone, Terry L Grindstaff, Shelley W Linens, Elizabeth Uczekaj, Jay Hertel

Abstract

Objective: To determine the relative risk reduction associated with prophylactic knee braces in the prevention of knee injuries in collegiate football players.

Data sources: An exhaustive search for original research was performed using the PubMed, SportDiscus, and CINAHL databases from 1970 through November 2006, with the search terms knee brace, knee braces, knee bracing and football, prophylactic brace, and prophylactic knee braces.

Study selection: Seven studies comparing knee injuries among braced and non-braced collegiate football players were included. Study methods were assessed using the Physiotherapy Evidence Database (PEDro) scale. PEDro scores ranged from 2 to 5.

Data extraction: The number of participants and frequency of knee injuries were used to calculate the relative risk reduction or increase.

Data synthesis: We found a relative risk reduction for 3 studies with point estimates of 10% (36% to -26%), 58% (25% to 76%), and 56% (13% to 77%). Four studies demonstrated an increased risk of injury, with point estimates of 17% (19% to -71%), 49% (-31% to -69%), 114% (23% to -492%), and 42% (-18% to -70%).

Conclusions: Data from existing research are inconsistent. Based on a Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy level of evidence of 2 with a grade B recommendation, we cannot conclusively advocate or discourage the use of prophylactic knee braces in the prevention of knee injuries in collegiate football players.

Keywords: injury prevention; protective equipment.

Figures

Figure 1. Numbers needed to treat to…
Figure 1. Numbers needed to treat to benefit or numbers needed to treat to harm for the 7 studies: Hewson et al, Teitz et al, Rovere et al, Albright et al, Sitler et al, Zemper, and Hansen et al.
Figure 2. Relative risk increase or relative…
Figure 2. Relative risk increase or relative risk reduction demonstrated by the 7 studies: Hewson et al, Teitz et al, Rovere et al, Albright et al, Sitler et al, Zemper, and Hansen et al.

References

    1. Canale S.T, Cantler E.D, Jr, Sisk T.D, Freeman B.L., III A chronicle of injuries of an American intercollegiate football team. Am J Sports Med. 1981;9(6):384–389.
    1. Hardin G.T, Farr J, Stiene H.A. Prophylactic knee braces for football: do they work. Indiana Med. 1993;86(4):308–311.
    1. Turbeville S.D, Cowen L.D, Owen W.L, Asal N.R, Anderson M.A. Risk factors for injury in high school football players. Am J Sports Med. 2003;31(6):974–980.
    1. Baltzer A.W, Ghadamgahi P.D. American football injuries in the German Federal League: risk of injuries and pattern of injuries. Unfallchirurg. 1998;24(2):60–65.
    1. Dick R, Ferrara M.S, Agel J, et al. Descriptive epidemiology of collegiate men's football injuries: National Collegiate Athletic Association Injury Surveillance System, 1988–1989 through 2003–2004. J Athl Train. 2007;42(2):221–233.
    1. DeLee J.C, Farney W.C. Incidence of injury in Texas high school football. Am J Sports Med. 1992;20(5):575–580.
    1. Carey J.L, Huffman G.R, Parekh S.G, Sennett B.J. Outcomes of anterior cruciate ligament injuries to running backs and wide receivers in the National Football League. Am J Sports Med. 2006;34(12):1911–1917.
    1. Griffin L.Y, Agel J, Albohm M.J, et al. Noncontact anterior cruciate ligament injuries: risk factors and prevention strategies. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2000;8(3):141–150.
    1. Patterson P.E, Eason J. The effects of prophylactic brace construction materials on the reactive responses of the MCL during repetitive impacts. J Athl Train. 1996;31(4):329–333.
    1. Erickson A.R, Yasuda K, Beynnon B, Johnson R, Pope M. An in vitro dynamic evaluation of prophylactic knee braces during lateral impact loading. Am J Sports Med. 1993;21(1):26–35.
    1. Salvaterra G.F, Wang M, Morehouse C.A, Buckley W.E. An in vitro biomechanical study of the static stabilizing effect of lateral prophylactic knee bracing on medial stability. J Athl Train. 1993;28(2):113–119.
    1. France E.P, Paulos L.E. In vitro assessment of prophylactic knee brace function. Clin Sports Med. 1990;9(4):823–841.
    1. Baker B.E. The effect of bracing on the collateral ligaments of the knee. Clin Sports Med. 1990;9(4):843–851.
    1. Baker B.E, VanHanswyk E, Bogosian S I.V, Werner F.W, Murphy D. A biomechanical study of the static stabilizing effect of knee braces on medial stability. Am J Sports Med. 1987;15(6):566–570.
    1. Paulos L.E, Cawley P.W, France E.P. Impact biomechanics of lateral knee bracing: the anterior cruciate ligament. Am J Sports Med. 1991;19(4):337–342.
    1. Deppen R.J, Landfried M.J. Efficacy of prophylactic knee bracing in high school football players. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1994;20(5):243–246.
    1. Grindstaff T.L, Hammill R, Tuzson A.E, Hertel J. Neuromuscular control training programs and noncontact anterior cruciate ligament injury rates in female athletes: a numbers-needed-to-treat analysis. J Athl Train. 2006;41(4):450–456.
    1. Hewson G.F, Jr, Mendini R.A, Wang J.B. Prophylactic knee bracing in college football. Am J Sports Med. 1986;14(4):262–266.
    1. Albright J.P, Powell J.W, Smith W, et al. Medial collateral ligament knee sprains in college football: effectiveness of preventive braces. Am J Sports Med. 1994;22(1):12–18.
    1. Sitler M, Ryan C, Hopkinson W, et al. The efficacy of a prophylactic knee brace to reduce knee injuries in football: a prospective, randomized study at West Point. Am J Sports Med. 1990;18(3):310–315.
    1. Teitz C.C, Hermanson B.K, Kronmal R.A, Diehr P.H. Evaluation of the use of braces to prevent injury to the knee in collegiate football players. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1987;69(1):2–9.
    1. Rovere G.D, Haupt H.A, Yates C.S. Prophylactic knee bracing in college football. Am J Sports Med. 1987;15(2):111–115.
    1. Zemper E. A two year prospective study of prophylactic knee braces in a national sample of college football players. Sports Train Med Rehabil. 1990;1:287–296.
    1. Hansen B.L, Ward J.C, Diehl R.C. The preventive use of the Anderson Knee Stabilizer in football. Physician Sportsmed. 1985;13(9):75–81.
    1. Sherrington C, Herbert R.D, Maher C.G, Moseley A.M. PEDro: a database of randomized trials and systematic reviews in physiotherapy. Man Ther. 2000;5(4):223–226.
    1. Randall F, Miller H, Shurr D. The use of prophylactic knee orthoses at Iowa State University. Orthot Prosthet. 1984;37(4):54–57.
    1. Chatellier G, Zapletal E, Lemaitre D, Menard J, Degoulet P. The number needed to treat: a clinically useful nomogram in its proper context. BMJ. 1996;312(7028):426–429.
    1. Altman D.G. Confidence intervals for number needed to treat. BMJ. 1998;317(7168):1309–1312.
    1. Levels of evidence. Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine. . Accessed January 29, 2008.
    1. Ebell M.H, Siwek J, Weiss B.D, et al. Strength of recommendation taxonomy (SORT): a patient-centered approach to grading evidence in medical literature. J Am Board Fam Pract. 2004;17(1):59–67.
    1. Stocker B.D, Nyland J.A, Caborn D.N, Sternes R, Ray J.M. Results of the Kentucky high school football knee injury survey. J Ky Med Assoc. 1997;95(11):458–464.
    1. Waldén M, Hägglund M, Ekstrand J. High risk of new knee injury in elite footballers with previous anterior cruciate ligament injury. Br J Sports Med. 2006;40(2):158–162.
    1. Osternig L.R, Robertson R.N. Effects of prophylactic knee bracing on lower extremity joint position and muscle activation during running. Am J Sports Med. 1993;21(5):733–737.

Source: PubMed

スポンサーと協力者

医学的状態

薬物療法

3
購読する