A successful approach to minimizing attrition in racial/ethnic minority, low-income populations

Glenn Flores, Alberto Portillo, Hua Lin, Candy Walker, Marco Fierro, Monica Henry, Kenneth Massey, Glenn Flores, Alberto Portillo, Hua Lin, Candy Walker, Marco Fierro, Monica Henry, Kenneth Massey

Abstract

Background: Recruiting and retaining minority participants in clinical trials continue to be major challenges. Although multiple studies document lower minority trial enrollment, much less is known about effective minority retention strategies. Our objectives were to evaluate an innovative approach to high RCT retention of minority children, and identify child/caregiver characteristics predicting attrition.

Methods: The Kids' HELP trial examined the effects of Parent Mentors on insuring uninsured minority children. We tested a retention strategic framework consisting of: 1) optimizing cultural/linguistic competency; 2) staff training on participant relationships and trust; 3) comprehensive participant contact information; 4) an electronic tracking database; 5) reminders for upcoming outcomes-assessment appointments; 6) frequent, sustained contact attempts for non-respondents; 7) financial incentives; 8) individualized rapid-cycle quality-improvement approaches to non-respondents; 9) reinforcing study importance; and 10) home assessment visits. We compared attrition in Kids' HELP vs. two previous RCTs in similar populations, and conducted bivariate and multivariable analyses of factors associated with Kids' HELP attrition.

Results: Attrition in Kids' HELP was lower than in two similar RCTs, at 10.9% vs. 37% and 40% (P <0.001). After multivariable adjustment, missing the first outcomes follow-up assessment was the only factor significantly associated with attrition (relative risk=1.5; 95% confidence interval, 1.1-2.0).

Conclusions: A retention strategic framework was successful in minimizing attrition in minority, low-income children. Participants missing first assessment appointments were at highest risk of subsequent attrition. These findings suggest that deploying this framework may help RCT retention of low-income minority children, particularly those at the highest risk of subsequent attrition.

Keywords: African Americans; Hispanic Americans; Patient dropouts; minority groups; randomized controlled trials; research subject recruitment.

Conflict of interest statement

Conflict of interest The authors report no conflict of interest.

References

    1. Glickman S.W., Anstrom K.J., Lin L., Chandra A., Laskowitz D.T., Woods C.W., Freeman D.H., Kraft M., Beskow L.M., Weinfurt K.P., Schulman K.A., Cairns C.B. Challenges in enrollment of minority, pediatric, and geriatric patients in emergency and acute care clinical research. Ann. Emerg. Med. 2008;51(6):775–780. e3.
    1. Castillo-Mancilla J.R., Cohn S.E., Krishnan S., Cespedes M., Floris-Moore M., Schulte G., Pavlov G., Mildvan D., Smith K.Y. ACTG Underrepresented Populations Survey Group. Minorities remain underrepresented in HIV/AIDS research despite access to clinical trials. HIV Clin. Trials. 2014;15(1):14–26.
    1. Scalici J., Finan M.A., Black J., Harmon M.D., Nicolson W., Lankes H.A., Brady W.E., Rocconi R.P. Minority participation in gynecologic oncology group (GOG) studies. Gynecol. Oncol. 2015;138(2):441–444.
    1. Eshera N., Itana H., Zhang L., Soon G., Fadiran E.O. Demographics of clinical trials participants in pivotal clinical trials for new molecular entity drugs and biologics approved by FDA from 2010 to 2012. Am. J. Ther. 2015;22(6):435–455.
    1. Dhalla S., Poole G. Effect of race/ethnicity on participation in HIV vaccine trials and comparison to other trials of biomedical prevention. Hum. Vaccin Immunother. 2014;10(7):1974–1984.
    1. Baxter J., Vehik K., Johnson S.B., Lernmark B., Roth R., Simell T. TEDDY Study Group. Differences in recruitment and early retention among ethnic minority participants in a large pediatric cohort: the TEDDY Study. Contemp. Clin. Trials. 2012;33(4):633–640.
    1. Osann K., Wenzel L., Dogan A., Hsieh S., Chase D.M., Sappington S., Monk B.J., Nelson E.L. Recruitment and retention results for a population-based cervical cancer biobehavioral clinical trial. Gynecol. Oncol. 2011;121(3):558–564.
    1. Cui Z., Seburg E.M., Sherwood N.E., Faith M.S., Ward D.S. Recruitment and retention in obesity prevention and treatment trials targeting minority or low-income children: a review of the clinical trials registration database. Trials. 2015;16:564.
    1. Flores G., Abreu M., Chaisson C.E., Meyers A., Sachdeva R.C., Fernandez H., Francisco P., Diaz B., Diaz A.M., Santos-Guerrero I. A randomized, controlled trial of the effectiveness of community-based case management in insuring uninsured Latino children. Pediatrics. 2005;116(6):1433–1441.
    1. Flores G., Bridon C., Torres S., Perez R., Walter T., Brotanek J., Lin H., Tomany-Korman S. Improving asthma outcomes in minority children: a randomized, controlled trial of parent mentors. Pediatrics. 2009;124(6):1522–1532.
    1. Flores G., Walker C., Lin H., Lee M., Fierro M., Henry M., Massey K., Portillo A. Design, methods, and baseline characteristics of the Kids' Health Insurance by Educating Lots of Parents (Kids' HELP) trial: a randomized, controlled trial of the effectiveness of parent mentors in insuring uninsured minority children. Contemp. Clin. Trials. 2015;40:124–137.
    1. Flores G., Lin H., Walker C., Lee M., Currie J.M., Allgeyer R., Fierro M., Henry M., Portillo A., Massey K. Parent Mentors and insuring uninsured children: a randomized controlled trial. Pediatrics. 2016;137(4) pii: e20153519.
    1. Flores G., Walker C., Lin H., Lee M., Fierro M., Henry M., Massey K., Portillo A. A successful program for training parent mentors to provide assistance with obtaining health insurance for uninsured children. Acad. Pediatr. 2015;15(3):275–281.
    1. Zhang J., Yu K.F. What's the relative risk? A method of correcting the odds ratio in cohort studies of common outcomes. JAMA. 1998;280(19):1690–1691. PMID: 9832001.
    1. Robbins A.S., Chao S.Y., Fonseca V.P. What's the relative risk? A method to directly estimate risk ratios in cohort studies of common outcomes. Ann. Epidemiol. 2002;12(7):452–454. PMID: 12377421.
    1. Kleinman L.C., Norton E.C. What's the Risk? A simple approach for estimating adjusted risk measures from nonlinear models including logistic regression. Health Serv. Res. 2009;44(1):288–302.
    1. Ford M.E., Siminoff L.A., Pickelsimer E., Mainous A.G., Smith D.W., Diaz V.A., Soderstrom L.H., Jefferson M.S., Tilley B.C. Unequal burden of disease, unequal participation in clinical trials: solutions from African American and Latino community members. Health Soc. Work. 2013;38(1):29–38. PMCID: PMC3943359.
    1. Wallace D.C., Bartlett R. Recruitment and retention of African American and Hispanic girls and women in research. Public Health Nurs. 2013;30(2):159–166.
    1. Haack L.M., Gerdes A.C., Lawton K.E. Conducting research with Latino families: examination of strategies to improve recruitment, retention, and satisfaction with an at-risk and underserved population. J. Child. Fam. Stud. 2014;23(2):410–421.
    1. Warner E.T., Glasgow R.E., Emmons K.M., Bennett G.G., Askew S., Rosner B., Colditz G.A. Recruitment and retention of participants in a pragmatic randomized intervention trial at three community health clinics: results and lessons learned. BMC Public Health. 2013;13:192.
    1. Coday M., Boutin-Foster C., Goldman Sher T., Tennant J., Greaney M.L., Saunders S.D., Somes G.W. Strategies for retaining study participants in behavioral intervention trials: retention experiences of the NIH Behavior Change Consortium. Ann. Behav. Med. 2005;(Suppl:55–65):29. PMID: 15921490.
    1. Robinson K.A., Dennison C.R., Wayman D.M., Pronovost P.J., Needham D.M. Systematic review identifies number of strategies important for retaining study participants. J. Clin. Epidemiol. 2007;60(8):757–765. PMID: 17606170.
    1. Robinson K.A., Dinglas V.D., Sukrithan V., Yalamanchilli R., Mendez-Tellez P.A., Dennison-Himmelfarb C., Needham D.M. Updated systematic review identifies substantial number of retention strategies: using more strategies retains more study participants. J. Clin. Epidemiol. 2015;68(12):1481–1487.
    1. Booker C.L., Harding S., Benzeval M. A systematic review of the effect of retention methods in population-based cohort studies. BMC Public Health. 2011;11:249.
    1. Brueton V.C., Tierney J.F., Stenning S., Meredith S., Harding S., Nazareth I., Rait G. Strategies to improve retention in randomised trials: a Cochrane systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open. 2014;4(2):e003821.
    1. Buscemi J., Blumstein L., Kong A., Stolley M.R., Schiffer L., Odoms-Young A., Bittner C., Fitzgibbon M.L. Retaining traditionally hard to reach participants: lessons learned from three childhood obesity studies. Contemp. Clin. Trials. 2015;42:98–104.
    1. Peterson J.C., Pirraglia P.A., Wells M.T., Charlson M.E. Attrition in longitudinal randomized controlled trials: home visits make a difference. BMC Med. Res. Methodol. 2012;12:178.
    1. Zook P.M., Jordan C., Adams B., Visness C.M., Walter M., Pollenz K., Logan J., Tesson E., Smartt E., Chen A., D'Agostino J., Gern J.E. Retention strategies and predictors of attrition in an urban pediatric asthma study. Clin. Trials. 2010;7(4):400–410.
    1. Helzer E.G., Dunning D. Why and when peer prediction is superior to self-prediction: the weight given to future aspiration versus past achievement. J. Pers. Soc. Psychol. 2012;103(1):38–53.
    1. Katz K.S., El-Mohandes P.A., Johnson D.M., Jarrett P.M., Rose A., Cober M. Retention of low income mothers in a parenting intervention study. J. Community Health. 2001;26(3):203–218. PMID: 11478566.

Source: PubMed

스폰서 및 공동 작업자

건강 상태

약물 개입

3
구독하다