International differences in understanding recovery: systematic review

M Slade, M Leamy, F Bacon, M Janosik, C Le Boutillier, J Williams, V Bird, M Slade, M Leamy, F Bacon, M Janosik, C Le Boutillier, J Williams, V Bird

Abstract

Aims: Mental health policy internationally varies in its support for recovery. The aims of this study were to validate an existing conceptual framework and then characterise by country the distribution, scientific foundations and emphasis in published recovery conceptualisations.

Methods: Update and modification of a previously published systematic review and narrative synthesis of recovery conceptualisations published in English.

Results: A total of 7431 studies were identified and 429 full papers reviewed, from which 105 conceptualisations in 115 papers were included and quality assessed using established rating scales. Recovery conceptualisations were identified from 11 individual countries, with 95 (91%) published in English-speaking countries, primarily the USA (47%) and the UK (25%). The scientific foundation was primarily qualitative research (53%), non-systematic literature reviews (24%) and position papers (12%). The conceptual framework was validated with the 18 new papers. Across the different countries, there was a relatively similar distribution of codings for each of five key recovery processes.

Conclusions: Recovery as currently conceptualised in English-language publications is primarily based on qualitative studies and position papers from English-speaking countries. The conceptual framework was valid, but the development of recovery conceptualisations using a broader range of research designs within other cultures and non-majority populations is a research priority.

Figures

Fig. 1.
Fig. 1.
Flow diagram for identification of recovery models.

References

    1. Adams N, Grieder DM (2005). Treatment Planning for Person-Centered Care. Elsevier: Burlington, MA.
    1. Amering M, Schmolke M (2007). Recovery. Das Ende der Unheilbarkeit. Psychiatrie-Verlag: Bonn.
    1. Andresen R, Oades L, Caputi P (2011). Psychological Recovery: Beyond Mental Illness. John Wiley: London.
    1. Anthony WA (1993). Recovery from mental illness: the guiding vision of the mental health system in the 1990s. Innovations and Research 2, 17–24.
    1. Arvidsson H (2011). Recovered or dead? A Swedish study of 321 persons surveyed as severely mentally ill in 1995/96 but not so ten years later. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences 20, 55–63.
    1. Asmundsdottir EE (2009). Creation of new services: collaboration between mental health consumers and occupational therapists. Occupational Therapy in Mental Health 25, 115–126.
    1. Barbic S, Krupa T, Armstrong I (2009). A randomized controlled trial of the effectiveness of a modified recovery workbook program: preliminary findings. Psychiatric Services 60, 491–497.
    1. Bellack A (2006). Scientific and consumer models of recovery in schizophrenia: concordance, contrasts, and implications. Schizophrenia Bulletin 32, 432–442.
    1. Bird V, Leamy M, Le Boutillier C, Williams J, Slade M (2011). REFOCUS: Promoting Recovery in Community Mental Health Services. Rethink ( London.
    1. Boyle D, Harris M (2009). The Challenge of Co-production. New Economics Foundation: London.
    1. Care Services Improvement Partnership, RCoP, Social Care Institute for Excellence (2007). A Common Purpose: Recovery in Future Mental Health Services. CSIP: Leeds.
    1. Clark J (2003). How to peer review a qualitative manuscript In Peer Review in Health Sciences (ed. Godlee F and Jefferson T), pp. 219–235. BMJ Books: London.
    1. Clarke SP, Oades LG, Crowe T, Deane F (2006). Collaborative goal technology: theory and practice. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal 30, 129–136.
    1. Compagni A, Adams N, Daniels A (2007). International Pathways to Mental Health System Transformation: Strategies and Challenges. California Institute for Mental Health: California.
    1. Cross T, Earle K, Echo-Hawk-Solie H, Manness K (2000). Cultural strengths and challenges in implementing a system of care model in American Indian communities Systems of Care: Promising Practices in Children's Mental Health, 2000 Series, 1, 8–14.
    1. Davidson L, Miller R, Flanagan E (2008a). What's in it for me? The utility of psychiatric treatments from the perspective of the person in recovery. Epidemiologia e Psichiatria Sociale 17, 177–181.
    1. Davidson L, Schmutte T, Dinzeo T, Andres-Hyman R (2008b). Remission and recovery in schizophrenia: practitioner and patient perspectives. Schizophrenia Bulletin 34, 5–8.
    1. Davidson L, Tondora J, Lawless MS, O'Connell M, Rowe M (2009). A Practical Guide to Recovery-Oriented Practice Tools for Transforming Mental Health Care. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
    1. Davidson L, Rakfeldt J, Strauss J (2010a). The Roots of the Recovery Movement in Psychiatry. Wiley-Blackwell: Chichester.
    1. Davidson L, Roe D, Andres-Hyman R, Ridgway P (2010b). Applying stages of change models to recovery from serious mental illness: contributions and limitations. Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences 47, 2010–2221.
    1. Department of Health (2011). Framework for Recovery-oriented Practice. Mental Health, Drugs and Regions Division: Melbourne.
    1. Dilks S, Tasker F, Wren B (2010). Managing the impact of psychosis: a grounded theory exploration of recovery processes in psychosis. British Journal of Clinical Psychology 49, 1–107.
    1. Doughty C, Tse S (2005). The Effectiveness of Service User-run or Service User-led Mental Health Services for People with Mental Illness: A Systematic Literature Review. Mental Health Commission: Wellington.
    1. EPHPP (1998). Effective Public Health Practice Project .
    1. Flood J (1991). Archaeology of the Dreamtime: The Story of Prehistoric Australia and Its People. Collins: Sydney.
    1. Green T, Batson A, Gudjonsson G (2011). The development and initial validation of a service-user led measure for recovery of mentally disordered offenders. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology 22, 252–265.
    1. Greenfield TK, Stoneking BC, Humphreys K, Sundby E, Bond J (2008). A randomized trial of a mental health consumer-managed alternative to civil commitment for acute psychiatric crisis. American Journal of Community Psychology 42, 135–144.
    1. Holm AL, Severinsson E (2011). Struggling to recover by changing suicidal behaviour: narratives from women with borderline personality disorder. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing 20, 165–173.
    1. Kartalova-O'Doherty Y, Tedstone Doherty D (2010). Recovering from recurrent mental health problems: giving up and fighting to get better. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing 19, 3–15.
    1. Kelly M, Lamont S, Brunero S (2010). An occupational perspective of the recovery journey in mental health. British Journal of Occupational Therapy 73, 129–135.
    1. Kogstad RE, Ekeland TJ, Hummelvoll JK (2011). In defence of a humanistic approach to mental health care: recovery processes investigated with the help of clients' narratives on turning points and processes of gradual change. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 18, 479–486.
    1. Lapsley H, Nikora LW, Black R (2002). Kia Mauri Tau! Narratives of Recovery from Disabling Mental Health Problems. Mental Health Commission: Wellington.
    1. Le Boutillier C, Leamy M, Bird VJ, Davidson L, Williams J, Slade M (2011). What does recovery mean in practice? A qualitative analysis of international recovery-oriented practice guidance. Psychiatric Services 62, 1470–1476.
    1. Leamy M, Bird V, Le Boutillier C, Williams J, Slade M (2011). A conceptual framework for personal recovery in mental health: systematic review and narrative synthesis. British Journal of Psychiatry 199, 445–452.
    1. Libermann RP, Kopelowicz A (2002). Recovery from schizophrenia: a challenge for the 21st century. International Review of Psychiatry 14, 242–255.
    1. Mansell W, Powell S, Pedley R, Thomas N, Jones SA (2010). The process of recovery from bipolar 1 disorder: a qualitative analysis of personal accounts in relation to an integrative cognitive model. British Journal of Clinical Psychology 49, 193–216.
    1. Mead S (2005). Intentional Peer Support: An Alternative Approach. Shery Mead Consulting: Plainfield, NH.
    1. Mental Health ‘Recovery’ Study Working Group (2009). Mental Health ‘Recovery’: Users and Refusers. Wellesley Institute: Toronto.
    1. Mezey GC, Kavuma M, Turton P, Demetriou A, Wright C (2010). Perceptions, experiences and meanings of recovery in forensic psychiatric patients. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology 21, 2010–2696.
    1. Mind (2008). Life and Times of a Supermodel. The Recovery Paradigm for Mental Health. Mind: London.
    1. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (2009). The Guidelines Manual. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence: London.
    1. Noiseux S, Tribble St-Cyr D, Corin E, St-Hilaire PL, Morissette R, Leclerc C, Fleury D, Vigneault L, Gagnier F (2010). The process of recovery of people with mental illness: the perspectives of patients, family members and care providers: part 1. BMC Health Services Research 10, 161.
    1. Oades L, Deane F, Crowe T, Lambert WG, Kavanagh D, Lloyd C (2005). Collaborative recovery: an integrative model for working with individuals who experience chronic and recurring mental illness. Australasian Psychiatry 13, 279–284.
    1. O'Hagan M (2004). Recovery in New Zealand: lessons from Australia? Australian e-journal for the Advancement of Mental Health 3 ().
    1. Onken SJ, Craig CM, Ridgway P, Ralph RO, Cook JA (2007). An analysis of the definitions and elements of recovery: a review of the literature. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal 31, 9–22.
    1. Poloni N, Callegari C, Buzzi A, Aletti F, Beranzini F, Vecchi F, Vender S (2010). [The Italian version of ISOS and RSQ, two suitable scales for investigating recovery style from psychosis]. Validazione della versione italiana delle Scale ISOS e RSQ per lo studio del recovery style nei disturbi psicotici. Epidemiologia e Psichiatria Sociale 19, 352–359.
    1. Popay J, Roberts H, Sowden A, Petticrew M, Arai L, Rodgers M, Britten N, Roen K, Duffy S (2006). Guidance on the Conduct of Narrative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews. Results of an ESRC Funded Research Project (Unpublished Report) University of Lancaster: Lancaster.
    1. Prochaska JO, Di Clemente CC (1982). Transtheoretical therapy: toward a more integrative model of change. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice 19, 276–288.
    1. Ralph RO (2000). Recovery. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Skills 4, 480–517.
    1. Ralph RO (2005). Verbal definitions and visual models of recovery: focus on the recovery model In Recovery in Mental Illness. Broadening Our Understanding of Wellness (ed. Ralph RO and Corrigan PW), pp. 131–145. American Psychological Association: Washington, DC.
    1. Ramon S, Healy B, Renouf N (2007). Recovery from Mental Illness as an Emergent Concept and Practice in Australia and the UK. International Journal of Social Psychiatry 53, 108–122.
    1. Rapp C, Goscha RJ (2006). The Strengths Model: Case Management With People With Psychiatric Disabilities. 2nd edn. Oxford University Press: New York.
    1. Resnick SG, Rosenheck RA (2006). Recovery and positive psychology: Parallel themes and potential synergies. Psychiatric Services 57, 120–122.
    1. Romano DM, McCay E, Goering P, Boydell K, Zipursky R (2010). Reshaping an enduring sense of self: the process of recovery from a first episode of schizophrenia. Early Intervention in Psychiatry 4, 243–250.
    1. Romme M, Escher S, Dillon J, Corstens D, Morris M (2009). Living with Voices: 50 Stories of Recovery. PCCS: Ross-on-Wye.
    1. Schön U (2010). Recovery from severe mental illness, a gender perspective. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences 24, 557–564.
    1. Schrank B, Slade M (2007). Recovery in psychiatry. Psychiatric Bulletin 31, 321–325.
    1. Secker J, Membrey H, Grove B, Seebohm P (2002). Recovering from Illness or recovering your life? Implications of clinical versus social models of recovery from mental health problems for employment support services. Disability and Society 17, 403–418.
    1. Semisa D, Casacchia M, Di Munzio W, Neri G, Buscaglia G, Burti L, Pucci C, Corlito G, Bacigalupi M, Parravani R, Roncone R, Cristofalo D, Lora A, Ruggeri M, Gruppo S-DS, Asioli F, Balbi A, Buscaglia C, Carra G, Erlicher A, Lasalvia A, Marinoni A, Miceli M, Morganti C, Morosini P, Iacchetti D, Pegoraro M, Scavo V, Alderighi M, Lorenzo P, Lecci F, Tanini A, Cefali T, Caneschi A, Ottanelli R, Magnani N, Bardicchia F, Pescosolido R, Allevi L, Ferrigno J, Giusto G, Rolando P, Dall'Agnola R, Bissoli S, Cassano AM, Ciampolillo G, Fracchiolla P, Lupoi S, Visani E, Pismataro CP, Mari L, Gazale MF, Bianchi I, Milano MC, Amideo F, Basile F, Santelia S, Vanetti M, Carnevale L, Debernardi C, Fiorica L, Pollice R, Cavicchio A, Pioli R, Cicolella G, Riva E, Pismataro CP, Leng G, Levav I, Losavio T, Maj M, Pilling S, Saxena S, Tansella M (2008). [Promoting recovery of schizophrenic patients: discrepancy between routine practice and evidence. The SIEP-DIRECT'S Project]. Promuovere il recupero dei pazienti con schizofrenia: discrepanze fra pratiche di routine ed evidenze. Il Progetto SIEP-DIRECT'S. Epidemiologia e Psichiatria Sociale 17, 331–348.
    1. Slade M (2009a). 100 Ways to Support Recovery. Rethink ( London.
    1. Slade M (2009b). The contribution of mental health services to recovery. Journal of Mental Health 18, 367–371.
    1. Slade M (2009c). Personal Recovery and Mental Illness. A Guide for Mental Health Professionals. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.
    1. Slade M (2010a). Measuring recovery in mental health services. Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences 47, 206–212.
    1. Slade M (2010b). Mental illness and well-being: the central importance of positive psychology and recovery approaches. BMC Health Services Research 10, 26.
    1. Slade M, Hayward M (2007). Recovery, psychosis and psychiatry: research is better than rhetoric. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 116, 81–83.
    1. Slade M, Amering M, Oades L (2008). Recovery: an international perspective. Epidemiologia e Psichiatria Sociale 17, 128–137.
    1. Slade M, Bird V, Chandler R, Fox J, Larsen J, Tew J, Leamy M (2010). The contribution of advisory committees and public involvement to large studies: case study. BMC Health Services Research 10, 323.
    1. Slade M, Bird V, Le Boutillier C, Williams J, McCrone P, Leamy M (2011). REFOCUS Trial: protocol for a cluster randomised controlled trial of a pro-recovery intervention within community based mental health teams. BMC Psychiatry 11, 185.
    1. Slade M, Adams N, O'Hagan M (2012). Recovery: past progress and future challenges. International Review of Psychiatry 24, 1–4.
    1. Song LY, Shih CY (2009). Factors, process and outcome of recovery from psychiatric disability the utility model. International Journal of Social Psychiatry 55, 348–360.
    1. South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust (2010). Social Inclusion and Recovery (SIR) Strategy 2010–2015. SLAM: London.
    1. Stickley T, Wright N (2011a). The British research evidence for recovery, papers published between 2006 and 2009 (inclusive). Part One: a review of the peer-reviewed literature using a systematic approach. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 18, 247–256.
    1. Stickley T, Wright N (2011b). The British research evidence for recovery, papers published between 2006 and 2009 (inclusive). Part Two: a review of the grey literature including book chapters and policy documents. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 18, 297–307.
    1. Sung KM, Kim S, Puskar KR, Kim E (2006). Comparing life experiences of college students with differing courses of schizophrenia in Korea: case studies. Perspectives in Psychiatric Care 42, 82–94.
    1. Tse S, Cheung E, Kan A, Ng R, Yau S (2012). Recovery in Hong Kong: Service user participation in mental health services. International Review of Psychiatry 24, 40–47.
    1. Turton P, Demetriou A, Boland W, Gillard S, Kavuma M, Mezey G, Mountford V, Turner K, White S, Zadeh E, Wright C (2011). One size fits all: or horses for courses? Recovery-based care in specialist mental health services. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 46, 127–136.
    1. Vogel-Scibilia SE, McNulty KC, Baxter B, Miller S, Dine M, Frese III FJ (2009). The recovery process utilizing Erikson's stages of human development. Community Mental Health Journal 45, 405–414.
    1. Wood L, Price J, Morrison A, Haddock G (2010). Conceptualisation of recovery from psychosis: A service-user perspective. Psychiatrist 34, 465–470.

Source: PubMed

스폰서 및 공동 작업자

건강 상태

약물 개입

3
구독하다