Dipstick Spot urine pH does not accurately represent 24 hour urine PH measured by an electrode
Mohamed Omar, Carl Sarkissian, Li Jianbo, Juan Calle, Manoj Monga, Mohamed Omar, Carl Sarkissian, Li Jianbo, Juan Calle, Manoj Monga
Abstract
Objectives: To determine whether spot urine pH measured by dipstick is an accurate representation of 24 hours urine pH measured by an electrode.
Materials and methods: We retrospectively reviewed urine pH results of patients who presented to the urology stone clinic. For each patient we recorded the most recente pH result measured by dipstick from a spot urine sample that preceded the result of a 24-hour urine pH measured by the use of a pH electrode. Patients were excluded if there was a change in medications or dietary recommendations or if the two samples were more than 4 months apart. A difference of more than 0.5 pH was considered na inaccurate result.
Results: A total 600 patients were retrospectively reviewed for the pH results. The mean difference in pH between spot urine value and the 24 hours collection values was 0.52±0.45 pH. Higher pH was associated with lower accuracy (p<0.001). The accuracy of spot urine samples to predict 24-hour pH values of <5.5 was 68.9%, 68.2% for 5.5 to 6.5 and 35% for >6.5. Samples taken more than 75 days apart had only 49% the accuracy of more recent samples (p<0.002). The overall accuracy is lower than 80% (p<0.001). Influence of diurnal variation was not significant (p=0.588).
Conclusions: Spot urine pH by dipstick is not an accurate method for evaluation of the patients with urolithiasis. Patients with alkaline urine are more prone to error with reliance on spot urine pH.
Conflict of interest statement
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
None declared.
Figures
References
- Desai RA, Assimos DG. Accuracy of urinary dipstick testing for pH manipulation therapy. J Endourol. 2008;22:1367–1370.
- Ogawa Y, Yonou H, Hokama S, Oda M, Morozumi M, Sugaya K. Urinary saturation and risk factors for calcium oxalate stone disease based on spot and 24-hour urine specimens. Front Biosci. 2003;8:a167–a176.
- Tiselius HG. Patients’ attitudes on how to deal with the risk of future stone recurrences. Urol Res. 2006;34:255–260.
- Ayres JW, Weidler DJ, MacKichan J, Wagner JG. Circadian rhythm of urinary Ph vin man with and without chronic antacid administration. Eur J Clin Pharmacol. 1977;12:415–420.
- Xu XJ, Wan MH, Ouyang JM. Effect of urinary pH value on the composition of urinary nanocrystals. Guang Pu Xue Yu Guang Pu Fen Xi. 2009;29:273–276.
- Kwong T, Robinson C, Spencer D, Wiseman OJ, Karet Frankl FE. Accuracy of urine pH testing in a regional metabolic renal clinic: is the dipstick accurate enough? Urolithiasis. 2013;41:129–132.
- Khandalavala J, Van Geem TA. Evaluating vaginal pH. Accuracy of two comercial pH papers in comparison to a hand-held digital pH meter. J Reprod Med. 1999;44:76–80.
Source: PubMed