The health benefits and constraints of exercise therapy for wheelchair users: A clinical commentary

Terry J Ellapen, Henriëtte V Hammill, Mariette Swanepoel, Gert L Strydom, Terry J Ellapen, Henriëtte V Hammill, Mariette Swanepoel, Gert L Strydom

Abstract

Background: There are approximately 1 billion people living with chronic lower limb disability, many of whom are wheelchair users.

Objectives: Review cardiometabolic and neuromuscular risk profiles of wheelchair users, benefits of regular exercise and the causes of neuromuscular upper limb and hip injuries that hinder regular adherence.

Method: Literature published between 2013 and 2017 was adopted according to the standard practices for systematic reviews (PRISMA) through Crossref Metadata and Google Scholar searches. Individual paper quality was evaluated using a modified Downs and Black Appraisal Scale.

Results: The literature search identified 16 600 papers which were excluded if they were non-English, non-peer-reviewed or published before 2013. Finally, 25 papers were accepted, indicating that sedentary wheelchair users have poor cardiometabolic risk profiles (PCMRP) because of a lack of physical activity, limiting their quality of life, characterised by low self-esteem, social isolation and depression. Their predominant mode of physical activity is through upper limb exercises, which not only improves their cardiometabolic risk profiles but also precipitates neuromuscular upper limb overuse injuries. The primary cause of upper limb injuries was attributed to poor wheelchair propulsion related to incorrect chair setup and poor cardiorespiratory fitness.

Conclusion: Wheelchair users have a high body mass index, body fat percentage and serum lipid, cholesterol and blood glucose concentrations. Empirical investigations illustrate exercise improves their PCMRP and cardiorespiratory fitness levels. Although literature encourages regular exercise, none discusses the need to individualise chair setup in order to eliminate wheelchair pathomechanics and upper limb neuromuscular injuries. Wheelchair users must be encouraged to consult a biokineticist or physiotherapist to review their wheelchair setup so as to eliminate possible incorrect manual wheelchair propulsion biomechanics and consequent overuse injuries.

Conflict of interest statement

The authors declare that they have no financial or personal relationship that may have inappropriately influenced the writing of this article.

Figures

FIGURE 1
FIGURE 1
Conceptualisation of the review process.
FIGURE 2
FIGURE 2
Frontal plane analysis identifying dropped shoulders.
FIGURE 3
FIGURE 3
Sagittal plane analysis identifying poor posture.

References

    1. Abdullah A.M., McDonald R. & Jaberzadeh S, 2012, ‘The effects of backpack load and placement on postural deviation in healthy students: A systematic review’, International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications 2(6), 466–481.
    1. Apple D.F., Cody R. & Allen A, 2004, Overuse syndrome of the upper limb in people with spinal cord injury, in rehabilitation research and development service: Physical fitness: A guide for individuals with spinal cord injury, Diane Publishers, Atlanta, GA.
    1. Chen M., Chen K., Chang C., Chang Y., Cheng Y. & Huang H, 2016, ‘Elastic band exercises improved the activities of daily living and the functional fitness of wheelchair-bound older adults with cognitive impairment: A cluster randomised control trial’, American Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation 95(11), 789–799.
    1. Cloud B.A., Zhao K., Ellingson A., Nassr A., Windebank A. & Kai-Nan A, 2017, ‘Increased seat dump angle in a manual wheelchair is associated with changes in thoracolumbar lordosis and scapular kinematics during propulsion’, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, in press.
    1. Cryzter T.M., Dicianno B.E. & Kapoor R, 2013, ‘Physical activity, exercise and health related measures of fitness in adults with spina bifida: A review of literature’, Annals of Physical and Medical Rehabilitation 5(12), 1051–1062.
    1. Da Silva Alves E., De Aquino-Lemos V., Da Silva F.R., Lira F.S., Dos Santos R.V.T., Rosa J.P.R. et al. , 2013, ‘Low grade inflammation and spinal cord injury: Exercise as therapy?’, Mediators of Inflammation 2013, 971841
    1. De Groot S., Post W.M., Snoek G.J., Schuitemaker M. & Van der Woude L, 2013, ‘Longitudinal study between lifestyle and coronary heart disease risk factors among individuals with spinal cord injury’, Spinal Cord 51, 314–318.
    1. Downs S.H. & Black N, 1998, ‘The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomized and non-randomized studies of health care interventions’, Journal of Epidemiology in Community Health 52, 377–384.
    1. Durstine L.J., Moore G.E., Painter P.L. & Roberts S.O, 2011, ACSM’s exercise management for persons with chronic diseases and disabilities, 3rd edn, Human Kinetics, New York.
    1. Ekelman B.A, Allison D.L., Duvnjak D., DiMarino R., Jodzio J. & Iannarelli P.V, 2017, ‘A wellness program for men with spinal cord injury: Participation and meaning’, OTJR: Occupation, Participation and Health 37(1), 30–39.
    1. Ellapen T.J., Paul Y., Swanepoel M. & Strydom G.L, 2017, ‘A comparative overview of exercise and health related professions: Athletic training, clinical exercise physiology and biokinetics’, African Journal for Physical Activity and Health Sciences 23(1.1), 1–12.
    1. Froehlich-Grobe K., Lee J., Aaronson L., Nary D.E., Washburn R.A. & Little T.D, 2014, ‘Exercise for everyone: A randomized controlled trial of project workout on wheels in promoting exercise among wheelchair users’, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 95(1), 20–28.
    1. Gorber S.C., Tremblay M., Mober D. & Gorber B, 2007, ‘A comparison of direct vs. self-report measures for assessing height, weight and body mass index: A systematic review’, Obesity Reviews 8, 307–326.
    1. Grogery A.S., Dolbow D.R., Dolbow J.D., Khalil R.K., Castillo C. & Gater D.R, 2014, ‘Effects of spinal cord injury on body composition and metabolic profile – Part 1’, The Journal of Spinal Cord Medicine 37(6), 693–702.
    1. Jordaan A., Swanepoel M. & Ellapen T.J, 2017, ‘What is the status of exercise therapy exercise among spinal cord injured patients in relation to metabolic risk factors: A systematic review’, African Journal for Physical Activity and Health Sciences, in review.
    1. Kate S, 2015, ‘Disability and rehabilitation: Essential considerations for equitable, accessible and poverty reducing health care in South Africa’, South African Health Review 1, 89–99.
    1. Kim D.I., Lee H., Lee B.S., Kim J. & Jeon Y.S, 2015, ‘Effects of a 6-week indoor hand-bike exercise program on health and fitness levels in people with spinal cord injury: A randomized controlled trial study’, Archives in Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 96(11), 2033–2040.
    1. Kressler J., Burns P.A., Betancourt L. & Nash M.S, 2014, ‘Circuit training and protein supplementation in persons with chronic tetraplegia’, Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 46(7), 1277–1284.
    1. La Fountaine M.F., Cirringliaro C.M., Emmons R.R., Kirshblum S.C., Galea M., Spungen A.M. et al. , 2015, ‘Lipoprotein heterogeneity in persons with spinal cord injury: A model of prolonged sitting and restricted physical activity’, Lipids in Health & Disease 14(81), 1–10.
    1. Leaman J. & Hung M.L, 2015, ‘A comprehensive review of smart wheelchairs: Past, present and future’, in Handbook of smart textiles, Xiaoming Tao, Springer Science Business Media, Inc., Singapore.
    1. Lu X., Battistuzzo C., Zoghi M. & Galea M, 2014, ‘Effects of training on upper limb function after spinal cord injury: A systematic review’, Clinical Rehabilitation 29(1), 313.
    1. Mansfield P.J. & Neumann D.A, 2015, Essentials of kinesiology for the physical therapist assistant, Mosby, Inc., St. Louis, MI.
    1. McArdle W.D., Katch F.I. & Katch V.L, 1996, Exercise physiology, Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, MD.
    1. Nightingale T.E., Metcalfe R.S., Vollaard N.B.J. & Bilzon J.L.J, 2017, ‘Exercise guidelines to promote cardiometabolic health in spinal cord injured humans: Time to raise the intensity?’, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 98(8), 1693–1704.
    1. Nooijen C.J., Stam H.J., Bergen M.P., Bongers-Jassen M.H., Valent J., Van Langeveld S. et al. , 2016, ‘Behavioural intervention increases physical activity in people with subacute spinal cord injury: A randomised trial’, Journal of Physiotherapy 62, 35–41.
    1. Oliveira A., Jacome C. & Marques A, 2014, ‘Physical fitness and exercise training on individuals with Spina Bidifa’, Research Development Disabilities 35(5), 1119–1136.
    1. PEDro Scale , 1999, Physiotherapy Evidence Database, Neura, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia.
    1. Qi L., Wakeling J., Grange S. & Ferguson-Pell M, 2014, ‘Patterns of shoulder muscle coordination vary between wheel chair propulsion techniques’, Neural System and Rehabilitation England 22, 559–566.
    1. Schuld C., Franz S., Van Hedel H.J.A., Moss-burger J., Maier D., Abel R. et al. , 2014, ‘International standards for neurological classification of spinal cord injury: Classification skills of clinicians versus computational algorithms’, Spinal Cord 53, 324–331.
    1. Sindall P., Lenton J.P., Malone L., Douglas S., Cooper R.A., Hiremath S. et al. , 2013, ‘Effect of low compression on wheelchair tennis match play’, International Journal of Sports Medicine 35(5), 424–431.
    1. Slowik J.S., Requejo P.S., Mulrey S.J. & Neptune R.R, 2016, ‘The influence of wheel chair hand patterns on upper extremity muscle power and stress’, Journal of Biomechanics 49, 1554–1561.
    1. Sprigle S, 2014, ‘Measure it: Proper wheelchair fit is key to ensuring function while protecting skin integrity’, Advance Skin Wound Care 27(12), 561–572.
    1. Tanhoffer R.A., Tanhoffer P.I.A., Raymond J., Hills P.A. & Davis G.M, 2014, ‘Exercise, energy expenditure and body composition in people with spinal cord injury’, Journal of Physical Activity and Health 11, 1393–1400.
    1. Thompson E., Snodgrass S. & Osmotherly P, 2015, ‘Injuries, practices and perceptions of wheelchair sports participants’, Physiotherapy 101(1), 1515–1516.
    1. Torhaug T., Brurok B., Hoff J., Helgerud J. & Leivseth G, 2016, ‘The effect from maximal bench press strength training on work economy during wheelchair propulsion in men with spinal cord injury’, Spinal Cord 54(10), 838–842.
    1. Tweedy S.M., Beckman E.M., Geraghty T.J., Theisen D., Perret C., Harvey L.A. et al. , 2016, ‘Exercise and sports science Australia (ESSA) position statement on exercise and spinal cord injury’, Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport 20(2), 108–115.
    1. Van der Scheer J.W., De Groot S., Posetma K., Veerger D.H.E. & Van der Woude L.H.V, 2015, ‘Low-intensity wheelchair training in inactive people with long-term spinal cord injury’, American Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 94(11), 975–986.
    1. Van Straaten M.G., Cloud B.A. & Morrow M.M, 2014, ‘Effectiveness of home exercise on pain, function and strength on manual wheelchair users with spinal cord injury: A high dose shoulder program with telerehabilitation’, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 95(10), 1810–1817.
    1. Vosloo J., Ntsiea M.V. & Becker P, 2016, ‘Energy expenditure of people with spinal cord injury whilst walking compared to able-bodied population’, South African Journal of Physiotherapy 72(1), a255
    1. West C.R., Taylor B.J., Campbell I.G. & Romer L.M, 2014, ‘Effects of inspiratory muscle training on exercise responses in paralympic athletes with cervical spinal cord injury’, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sport 24(5), 764–772.
    1. Will K., Engsberg J.R., Foreman M., Klaesner J., Birkenmeier R. & Morgan K, 2015, ‘Repetition bases training for efficient propulsion in new manual wheel chair users’, Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation in Disabilities 1(001), 1–9.
    1. Wong S., Van Middendorp J., Belci M., Van Nes I., Roels E., Smith E. et al. , 2015, ‘Knowledge, attitudes and practise of medical staff towards obesity management in patients with spinal cord injuries: An International survey for four western European countries’, Spinal Cord 53, 24–31.
    1. World Health Organization (WHO) , 2016, World report on disability, World Health Organization, Geneva.
    1. Zolot J. & Rosenberg K, 2016, ‘Wheelchair bound patients who exercise can prevent further disabilities’, American Journal of Nursing 116(6), 69–70.

Source: PubMed

Sponsors et collaborateurs

Les conditions médicales

Interventions en matière de drogue

3
S'abonner