Effectiveness of agricultural interventions that aim to improve nutritional status of children: systematic review

Edoardo Masset, Lawrence Haddad, Alexander Cornelius, Jairo Isaza-Castro, Edoardo Masset, Lawrence Haddad, Alexander Cornelius, Jairo Isaza-Castro

Abstract

Objective: To assess the effectiveness of agricultural interventions in improving the nutritional status of children in developing countries.

Design: Systematic review.

Data sources: Published and unpublished reports (after 1990) in English identified by searching 10 databases (Agris, Econlit, Eldis, IBSS, IDEAS, IFPRI, Jolis, PubMed, Web of Science, and World Bank), websites, previous systematic reviews, and reference lists and by contacting experts.

Study selection: Included studies assessed effects of agricultural interventions aiming at improving the nutritional status of children (bio-fortification, home gardens, small scale fisheries and aquaculture, dairy development, and animal husbandry and poultry development). Only studies that used a valid counterfactual analysis were included. Before/after studies and participants/non-participants comparisons affected by selection bias were excluded. Data analysis Results were analysed for four intermediate outcomes (programme participation, income, dietary diversity, and micronutrient intake) and one final outcome (prevalence of under-nutrition). Analysis was by summary tables of mean effects and by meta-analysis (for vitamin A absorption).

Results: The review included 23 studies, mostly evaluating home garden interventions. The studies reviewed did not report participation rates or the characteristics of participants in programmes. The interventions had a positive effect on the production of the agricultural goods promoted, but not on households' total income. The interventions were successful in promoting the consumption of food rich in protein and micronutrients, but the effect on the overall diet of poor people remains unclear. No evidence was found of an effect on the absorption of iron, but some evidence exists of a positive effect on absorption of vitamin A. Very little evidence was found of a positive effect on the prevalence of stunting, wasting, and underweight among children aged under 5.

Conclusions: The question posed by the review cannot be answered with any level of confidence. The data available show a poor effect of these interventions on nutritional status, but methodological weaknesses of the studies cast serious doubts on the validity of these results. More rigorous and better designed studies are needed, as well as the establishment of agreed quality standards to guide researchers in this important area.

Conflict of interest statement

Competing interests: All authors have completed the ICMJE uniform disclosure form at www.icmje.org/coi_disclosure.pdf (available on request from the corresponding author) and declare: all authors had financial support from the UK Department for International Development (DFID) for the submitted work; no financial relationships with any organisations that might have an interest in the submitted work in the previous three years; no other relationships or activities that could appear to have influenced the submitted work.

Figures

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/4788286/bin/mase889519.f1_default.jpg
Fig 1 Pathways of effect of agricultural interventions on nutrition
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/4788286/bin/mase889519.f2_default.jpg
Fig 2 Effect of intervention on serum retinol concentrations in children aged under 5

References

    1. Haddad L. A conceptual framework for assessing agriculture-nutrition linkages. Food Nutr Bull 2000;21:367-73.
    1. Berti P, Krasevec J, Fitzgerald S. A review of the effectiveness of agricultural interventions in improving nutrition outcomes. Public Health Nutr 2003;7:599-609.
    1. Karawazuka N. The contribution of fish intake, aquaculture, and small-scale fisheries to improving food and nutrition security: a literature review. World Fish Center, 2010. (Working paper No 2106.)
    1. Leroy JL, Frongillo EA. Can interventions to promote animal production ameliorate undernutrition? J Nutr 2007;137:2311-6.
    1. Ruel MT. Can food-based strategies help reduce vitamin A and iron deficiencies? A review of recent evidence. International Food Policy Research Institute, 2001.
    1. World Bank. From agriculture to nutrition: pathways, synergies and outcomes. World Bank Agriculture and Rural Development Department, 2007.
    1. Masset E, Haddad L, Cornelius A, Isaza-Castro J. A systematic review of agricultural interventions that aim to improve nutritional status of children. EPPI-Centre, Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education, University of London, 2011.
    1. Smith LC, Haddad L. Overcoming child malnutrition in developing countries: past achievements and future choices. International Food Policy Research Institute, 2000.
    1. Kidala D, Greiner T, Gebre-Medhin M. Five-year follow-up of a food-based vitamin A intervention in Tanzania. Public Health Nutr 2000;3:425-31.
    1. Borenstein M, Hedges LV, Higgins JPT, Rothstein HR. Introduction to meta-analysis. Wiley, 2009.
    1. Gunaratna NS, De Groote H, Nestel P, Pixley KV, McCabe GP. A meta-analysis of community-based studies on quality protein maize. Food Policy 2010;3:202-10.
    1. Bushamuka VN, de Pee S, Talukder A, Kiess L, Panagides D, Taher A, et al. Impact of a homestead gardening program on household food security and empowerment of women in Bangladesh. Food Nutr Bull 2005;26:17-25.
    1. Olney DK, Talukder A, Iannotti LL, Ruel MT, Quinn V. Assessing impact and impact pathways of a homestead food production program on household and child nutrition in Cambodia. Food Nutr Bull 2009;30:355-69.
    1. Talukder A, Haselow NJ, Osei AK, Villate E, Reario D, Kroeun H, et al. Homestead food production model contributes to improved household food security and nutrition status of young children and women in poor populations—lessons learned from scaling-up programs in Asia (Bangladesh, Cambodia, Nepal and Philippines). Field Actions Science Report, 2010.
    1. Hoorweg J, Leegwater PH, Veerman W. Nutrition in agricultural development: intensive dairy farming by rural smallholders. Ecol Food Nutr 2000;39:395-416.
    1. Marsh R. Household food security through home gardening—evidence from Bangladesh. Food Security and Innovations—International Symposium on Food Security and Innovations—Successes and Lessons Learned,1997:247-60.
    1. Murshed-e-Jahan K, Ahmed M, Belton B. The impacts of aquaculture development on food security: lessons from Bangladesh. Aquaculture Research 2010;41:481-95.
    1. Nielsen H, Roos N, Thilsted SH. The impact of semi-scavenging poultry production on the consumption of animal source foods by women and girls in Bangladesh. J Nutr 2003;133(11 suppl 2):4027-30S.
    1. Schipani S, van der Haar F, Sinawat S, Maleevong K. Dietary intake and nutritional status of young children in families practicing mixed home gardening in northeast Thailand. Food Nutr Bull 2002;23:175-80.
    1. Roos N, Islam MM, Thilsted SH. Small indigenous fish species in Bangladesh: contribution to vitamin A, calcium and iron intakes. J Nutr 2003;133(11 suppl 2):4021-6S.
    1. Low JW, Arimond M, Osman N, Cunguara B, Zano FT. Ensuring the supply of and creating demand for a biofortified crop with a visible trait: lessons learned from the introduction of orange-fleshed sweet potato in drought-prone areas of Mozambique. Food Nutr Bull 2007;28(2 suppl S):S258-70.
    1. Attig GA, Smitasiri S, Ittikom K, Dhanamitta S. Promoting home gardening to control vitamin A deficiency in northeastern Thailand. Food, Nutrition and Agriculture 1993;7:18-25.
    1. De Pee S, Bloem MW, Gorstein J, Sari M, Satoto YR, Shrimpton R, et al. Reappraisal of the role of vegetables in the vitamin A status of mothers in central Java, Indonesia. Am J Clin Nutr 1998;68:1068-74.
    1. Faber M, Phungula MSA, Venter SL, Dhansay MA, Benadé A, Spinnler J. Home gardens focusing on the production of yellow and dark-green leafy vegetables increase the serum retinol concentrations of 2-5-year-old children in South Africa. Am J Clin Nutr 2002;76:1048-54.
    1. Greiner T, Mitra SN. Evaluation of the impact of a food-based approach to solving vitamin A deficiency in Bangladesh. Food Nutr Bull 1995;16:193-205.
    1. Jones KM, Specio SE, Shrestha PK, Brown KH, Allen LH. Nutrition knowledge and practices, and consumption of vitamin A rich plants by rural Nepali participants and nonparticipants in a kitchen-garden program. Food Nutr Bull 2005;26:198-208.
    1. Laurie SM, Faber M. Integrated community-based growth monitoring and vegetable gardens focusing on crops rich in beta-carotene: project evaluation in a rural community in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. J Sci Food Agric 2008;88:2093-101.
    1. Makhotla L, Hendriks S. Do home gardens improve the nutrition of rural pre-schoolers in Lesotho? Dev South Afr 2004;21:575-81.
    1. Shmidt MI, Vorster HH. The effect of communal vegetable gardens on nutritional status. Dev South Afr 1995;12:713-24.
    1. Smitasiri S, Sa-ngobwarchar K, Kongpunya P, Subsuwan C, Banjong O, Chitchumroonechokchai C, et al. Sustaining behavioural change to enhance micronutrient status through community- and women-based interventions in north-east Thailand: vitamin A. Food Nutr Bull 1999;20:243-51.
    1. Vijayaraghavan K, Uma Nayak M, Bamji MS, Ramana GNV, Reddy V. Home gardening for combating vitamin A deficiency. Food Nutr Bull 1997;18:337-43.
    1. Aiga H, Matsuoka S, Kuroiwa C, Yamamoto S. Malnutrition among children in rural Malawian fish-farming households. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 2009;103:827-33.

Source: PubMed

Sponsors et collaborateurs

Les conditions médicales

Interventions en matière de drogue

3
S'abonner