Patient safety, resident well-being and continuity of care with different resident duty schedules in the intensive care unit: a randomized trial
Christopher S Parshuram, Andre C K B Amaral, Niall D Ferguson, G Ross Baker, Edward E Etchells, Virginia Flintoft, John Granton, Lorelei Lingard, Haresh Kirpalani, Sangeeta Mehta, Harvey Moldofsky, Damon C Scales, Thomas E Stewart, Andrew R Willan, Jan O Friedrich, Canadian Critical Care Trials Group, Christopher S Parshuram, Andre C K B Amaral, Niall D Ferguson, G Ross Baker, Edward E Etchells, Virginia Flintoft, John Granton, Lorelei Lingard, Haresh Kirpalani, Sangeeta Mehta, Harvey Moldofsky, Damon C Scales, Thomas E Stewart, Andrew R Willan, Jan O Friedrich, Canadian Critical Care Trials Group
Abstract
Background: Shorter resident duty periods are increasingly mandated to improve patient safety and physician well-being. However, increases in continuity-related errors may counteract the purported benefits of reducing fatigue. We evaluated the effects of 3 resident schedules in the intensive care unit (ICU) on patient safety, resident well-being and continuity of care.
Methods: Residents in 2 university-affiliated ICUs were randomly assigned (in 2-month rotation-blocks from January to June 2009) to in-house overnight schedules of 24, 16 or 12 hours. The primary patient outcome was adverse events. The primary resident outcome was sleepiness, measured by the 7-point Stanford Sleepiness Scale. Secondary outcomes were patient deaths, preventable adverse events, and residents' physical symptoms and burnout. Continuity of care and perceptions of ICU staff were also assessed.
Results: We evaluated 47 (96%) of 49 residents, all 971 admissions, 5894 patient-days and 452 staff surveys. We found no effect of schedule (24-, 16- or 12-h shifts) on adverse events (81.3, 76.3 and 78.2 events per 1000 patient-days, respectively; p = 0.7) or on residents' sleepiness in the daytime (mean rating 2.33, 2.61 and 2.30, respectively; p = 0.3) or at night (mean rating 3.06, 2.73 and 2.42, respectively; p = 0.2). Seven of 8 preventable adverse events occurred with the 12-hour schedule (p = 0.1). Mortality rates were similar for the 3 schedules. Residents' somatic symptoms were more severe and more frequent with the 24-hour schedule (p = 0.04); however, burnout was similar across the groups. ICU staff rated residents' knowledge and decision-making worst with the 16-hour schedule.
Interpretation: Our findings do not support the purported advantages of shorter duty schedules. They also highlight the trade-offs between residents' symptoms and multiple secondary measures of patient safety. Further delineation of this emerging signal is required before widespread system change.
Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov, no. NCT00679809.
© 2015 Canadian Medical Association or its licensors.
Figures
References
- Parshuram CS, Dhanani S, Kirsh JA, et al. Fellowship training, workload, fatigue and physical stress: a prospective observational study. CMAJ 2004;170:965–70.
- Wu AW. Medical error: the second victim. The doctor who makes the mistake needs help too. BMJ 2000;320:726–7.
- Veasey S, Rosen R, Barzansky B, et al. Sleep loss and fatigue in residency training: a reappraisal. JAMA 2002;288:1116–24.
- Committee on Optimizing Graduate Medical Trainee (Resident) Hours and Work Schedules to Improve Patient Safety. Resident duty hours: enhancing sleep, supervision and safety. Washington: The National Academies Press; 2009.
- National Steering Committee on Resident Duty Hours. Fatigue, risk and excellence: towards a pan-Canadian consensus on resident duty hours. Ottawa: Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada; 2013.
- Borowitz SM, Waggoner-Fountain LA, Bass EJ, et al. Adequacy of information transferred at resident sign-out (in-hospital handover of care): a prospective survey. Qual Saf Health Care 2008;17:6–10.
- Segall N, Bonifacio AS, Schroeder RA, et al. Can we make postoperative patient handovers safer? A systematic review of the literature. Anesth Analg 2012;115:102–15.
- Parshuram CS. The impact of fatigue on patient safety. Pediatr Clin North Am 2006;53:1135–53.
- Gandhi TK. Fumbled handoffs: one dropped ball after another. Ann Intern Med 2005;142:352–8.
- Vidyarthi AR, Arora V, Schnipper JL, et al. Managing discontinuity in academic medical centers: strategies for a safe and effective resident sign-out. J Hosp Med 2006;1:257–66.
- Fletcher KE, Parekh V, Halasyamani L, et al. Work hour rules and contributors to patient care mistakes: a focus group study with internal medicine residents. J Hosp Med 2008;3:228–37.
- Asch DA, Parker RM. The Libby Zion case. One step forward or two steps backward? N Engl J Med 1988;318:771–5.
- Jagsi R, Kitch BT, Weinstein DF, et al. Residents report on adverse events and their causes. Arch Intern Med 2005;165: 2607–13.
- Landrigan CP, Rothschild JM, Cronin JW, et al. Effect of reducing interns’ work hours on serious medical errors in intensive care units. N Engl J Med 2004;351:1838–48.
- Kerlin MP, Small DS, Cooney E, et al. A randomized trial of nighttime physician staffing in an intensive care unit. N Engl J Med 2013;368:2201–9.
- Parshuram CS, Kirpalani H, Mehta S, et al. In-house, overnight physician staffing: a cross-sectional survey of Canadian adult and pediatric intensive care units. Crit Care Med 2006;34:1674–8.
- Baker GR, Norton PG, Flintoft V, et al. The Canadian Adverse Events Study: the incidence of adverse events among hospital patients in Canada. CMAJ 2004;170:1678–86.
- Brennan TA, Leape LL, Laird NM, et al. Incidence of adverse events and negligence in hospitalized patients. Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study I. N Engl J Med 1991;324:370–6.
- Rothschild JM, Landrigan CP, Cronin JW, et al. The Critical Care Safety Study: the incidence and nature of adverse events and serious medical errors in intensive care. Crit Care Med 2005; 33:1694–700.
- Hoddes E, Zarcone V, Smythe H, et al. Quantification of sleepiness: a new approach. Psychophysiology 1973;10:431–6.
- Stanford Sleepiness Scale. Palo Alto (CA): Stanford University School of Medicine; 1997. Available: (accessed 2015 Jan. 28).
- Pilcher JJ, Ott ES. The relationships between sleep and measures of health and well-being in college students: a repeated measures approach. Behav Med 1998;23:170–8.
- Maslach C, Schaufeli WB, Leiter MP. Job burnout. Annu Rev Psychol 2001;52:397–422.
- Pronovost P, Berenholtz S, Dorman T, et al. Improving communication in the ICU using daily goals. J Crit Care 2003;18:71–5.
- Bartel P, Offermeier W, Smith F, et al. Attention and working memory in resident anaesthetists after night duty: group and individual effects. Occup Environ Med 2004;61:167–70.
- Knaus WA, Draper EA, Wagner DP, et al. APACHE II: a severity of disease classification system. Crit Care Med 1985;13:818–29.
- Marshall JC, Cook DJ, Christou NV, et al. Multiple organ dysfunction score: a reliable descriptor of a complex clinical outcome. Crit Care Med 1995;23:1638–52.
- Snedecor GW, Cochran WG. Statistical methods. Ames (IA): Iowa State University Press; 1989.
- Dyrbye LN, West CP, Shanafelt TD. Defining burnout as a dichotomous variable. J Gen Intern Med 2009;24:440, author reply 441.
- Van Dongen HP, Bender AM, Dinges DF. Systematic individual differences in sleep homeostatic and circadian rhythm contributions to neurobehavioral impairment during sleep deprivation. Accid Anal Prev 2012;45(Suppl):11–6.
- Bismilla Z, Breakey VR, Swales J, et al. Prospective evaluation of residents on call: before and after duty-hour reduction. Pediatrics 2011;127:1080–7.
- Volpp KG, Shea JA, Small DS, et al. Effect of a protected sleep period on hours slept during extended overnight in-hospital duty hours among medical interns: a randomized trial. JAMA 2012;308:2208–17.
- Ahmed N, Devitt KS, Keshet I, et al. A systematic review of the effects of resident duty hour restrictions in surgery: impact on resident wellness, training, and patient outcomes. Ann Surg 2014;259:1041–53.
- Desai SV, Feldman L, Brown L, et al. Effect of the 2011 vs. 2003 duty hour regulation-compliant models on sleep duration, trainee education, and continuity of patient care among internal medicine house staff: a randomized trial. JAMA Intern Med 2013;173:649–55.
- Gopal R, Glasheen JJ, Miyoshi TJ, et al. Burnout and internal medicine resident work-hour restrictions. Arch Intern Med 2005; 165:2595–600.
- Landrigan CP, Fahrenkopf AM, Lewin D, et al. Effects of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education duty hour limits on sleep, work hours, and safety. Pediatrics 2008; 122:250–8.
- Lockley SW, Barger LK, Ayas NT, et al. Effects of health care provider work hours and sleep deprivation on safety and performance. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf 2007;33(11 Suppl):7–18.
- Reason J. Human error: models and management. West J Med 2000;172:393–6.
Source: PubMed