Endoscopic Versus Open Carpal Tunnel Release

Abstract

Purpose of review: Carpal tunnel syndrome is the most common compressive neuropathy encountered by hand and upper extremity surgeons. The predominant presentation includes symptomatic paresthesias in the median nerve distribution of the affected hand, frequently causing nocturnal disturbances. Surgical treatment requires division of the transverse carpal ligament, which can be performed through open and endoscopic means. Endoscopic techniques have evolved significantly since they were first introduced in the late 1980s. This manuscript reviews the literature to summarize the current state of carpal tunnel surgery.

Recent findings: While endoscopic techniques have demonstrated superior early functional outcomes and a more rapid recovery, there are lingering concerns over the potential for nerve, vessel, and tendon injuries. These concerns have not been validated by the hand surgery literature, which ascribes similar rates of complications for both open and endoscopic surgical approaches. Moreover, patients report greater satisfaction with endoscopic surgical approaches compared with open techniques. In summary, the debate between proponents of open versus endoscopic carpal tunnel surgery continues. While surgeons who employ endoscopic techniques appear to be in the minority, there is a plethora of evidence to suggest that both approaches are comparably safe and equally effective.

Keywords: Carpal tunnel syndrome; Endoscopic carpal tunnel surgery; Neuropraxia; Open carpal tunnel surgery; Return to work.

Conflict of interest statement

Eon K. Shin declares that he owns stock and intellectual property in Mission Surgical Innovations, serves on the scientific advisory board for In2Bones, and receives consultation payments from DePuy Synthes.

Figures

Fig. 1

According to a recent survey of the members of the American Association for Hand Surgery, only 20% of respondents utilize endoscopic techniques to divide the transverse carpal ligament in carpal tunnel surgery

Fig. 2

a In endoscopic carpal tunnel surgery, the transverse fibers of the transverse carpal ligament must be clearly visualized prior to its division. b The endoscopic knife blade can then be deployed to safely cut the ligament. c Intraoperative photograph of the cut fibers using the SafeView Soft Tissue Release System from Mission Surgical Innovations (Wayne, PA). The cannula is slightly rotated to see each cut end of the ligament

Fig. 3

With endoscopic techniques, unusual or abnormal anatomy can be visualized. The recurrent motor branch of the median nerve is shown here while the endoscope is directed palmarly toward the transverse carpal ligament using the synchronized endoscopic guide system by SegWay Orthopaedics (Carlsbad, CA)