Indigenous Youth Peer-Led Health Promotion in Canada, New Zealand, Australia, and the United States: A Systematic Review of the Approaches, Study Designs, and Effectiveness

Daniel Vujcich, Jessica Thomas, Katy Crawford, James Ward, Daniel Vujcich, Jessica Thomas, Katy Crawford, James Ward

Abstract

Background: Youth peer-led interventions have become a popular way of sharing health information with young people and appear well suited to Indigenous community contexts. However, no systematic reviews focusing on Indigenous youth have been published. We conducted a systematic review to understand the range and characteristics of Indigenous youth-led health promotion projects implemented and their effectiveness.

Methods: A systematic search of Medline, Embase, and ProQuest Social Sciences databases was conducted, supplemented by gray literature searches. Included studies focused on interventions where young Indigenous people delivered health information to age-matched peers.

Results: Twenty-four studies were identified for inclusion, based on 20 interventions (9 Australian, 4 Canadian, and 7 from the United States of America). Only one intervention was evaluated using a randomized controlled study design. The majority of evaluations took the form of pre-post studies. Methodological limitations were identified in a majority of studies. Study outcomes included improved knowledge, attitude, and behaviors.

Conclusion: Currently, there is limited high quality evidence for the effectiveness of peer-led health interventions with Indigenous young people, and the literature is dominated by Australian-based sexual health interventions. More systematic research investigating the effectiveness of peer-led inventions is required, specifically with Indigenous populations. To improve health outcomes for Indigenous youth, greater knowledge of the mechanisms and context under which peer-delivered health promotion is effective in comparison to other methods of health promotion is needed.

Keywords: Aboriginal health; Indigenous health; first nations health research; health promotion; peer education; systematic review; young people; youth.

Figures

Figure 1
Figure 1
Search result PRISMA diagram (17).

References

    1. Gracey M, King M. Indigenous health part 1: determinants and disease patterns. Lancet (2009) 374(9683):65–75.10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60914-4
    1. Australian Government. Fourth National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Blood-Borne Viruses and Sexually Transmitted Infections Strategy 2014–2017. Department of Health; (2014). Available from:
    1. Queensland Government. Queensland Sexual Health Strategy 2016. Department of Health; (2016). Available from:
    1. West Kimberley Youth Sector Conference Working Party. Youth Strategy 2014–2016. Kimberley Institute; (2014). Available from:
    1. Government of Canada. Acting on What We Know: Preventing Youth Suicide in First Nations. Government of Canada; (2005). Available from:
    1. Sciacca JP. Student peer health education: a powerful yet inexpensive helping strategy. Peer Facil Q (1987) 5(2):4–6.
    1. Milburn K. A critical review of peer education with young people with special reference to sexual health. Health Educ Res (1995) 10(4):407–20.10.1093/her/10.4.407
    1. UNAIDS. Peer Education and HIV/AIDS: Concepts, Uses and Challenges. Geneva: UNAIDS; (1999). Available from:
    1. Harden A, Oakley A, Weston R. A Review of the Effectiveness and Appropriateness of Peer-Delivered Health Promotion for Young People. Institute of Education, University of London; (1999). Available from:
    1. Sun WH, Miu HYH, Wong CKH, Tucker JD, Wong WCW. Assessing participation and effectiveness of the peer-led approach in youth sexual health education: systematic review and meta-analysis in more developed countries. J Sex Res (2016) 55(1):31–44.10.1080/00224499.2016.1247779
    1. Hunt S, Kay-Lambkin F, Simmons M, Thornton L, Slade T, Killackey E, et al. Evidence for the Effectiveness of Peer-Led Education for at Risk Youth: An Evidence Check Rapid Review Brokered by the Sax Institute. Sydney: Sax Institute; (2006).
    1. Wang S, Moss J, Hiller J. Applicability and transferability of interventions in evidence-based public health. Health Prom Int (2006) 21(1):76–83.10.1093/heapro/dai025
    1. Harvey D, Tsey K, Cadet-James Y, Minniecon D, Ivers R, Minniecon D, et al. An evaluation of tobacco brief intervention training in three indigenous health care settings in north Queensland. Aust N Z J Public Health (2001) 26(5):426–31.10.1111/j.1467-842X.2002.tb00342.x
    1. South Australian Health and Medical Research Institute. The Remote STI and BBV Project. South Australian Health and Medical Research Institute; (2017). Available from:
    1. Kim CR, Free C. Recent evaluations of the peer-led approach in adolescent sexual health education: a systematic review. Perspect Sex Reprod Health (2008) 40(3):144–51.10.1363/4014408
    1. Medley A, Kennedy C, O’Reilly K, Sweat M. Effectiveness of peer education interventions for HIV prevention in developing countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis. AIDS Educ Prev (2009) 21(3):181–206.10.1521/aeap.2009.21.3.181
    1. Biggs K, Walsh J, Ooi C. Deadly liver mob: opening the door-improving sexual health pathways for Aboriginal people in Western Sydney. Sex Health (2016) 13(5):457–64.10.1071/SH15176
    1. Fagan P, Cannon F, Crouch A. The young person check: screening for sexually transmitted infections and chronic disease risk in remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander youth. Aust N Z J Public Health (2013) 37(4):316–21.10.1111/1753-6405.12078
    1. McEwan A, Crouch A, Robertson H, Fagan P. The Torres Indigenous Hip Hop project: evaluating the use of performing arts as a medium for sexual health promotion. Health Promot J Austr (2013) 24(2):132–6.10.1071/HE12924
    1. Crouch A, Robertson H, Fagan P. Hip hopping the gap – performing arts approaches to sexual health disadvantage in young people in remote settings. Aust Psychiatry (2011) 19(1):SS34–7.10.3109/10398562.2011.583046
    1. Hayward C, Monteiro H, McAullay D. Evaluation of Indigenous Hip Hop Projects. Melbourne: Beyondblue; (2009).
    1. Bentley M. Evaluation of the Peer Education Component of the Young Nungas Yarning Together Program. Adelaide: South Australian Community Research Unit; (2008).
    1. Tighe J, McKay K. Alive and kicking goals! Preliminary findings from a Kimberley suicide prevention program. Adv Ment Health (2012) 10(3):240–5.10.5172/jamh.2012.10.3.240
    1. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. Demonstration Projects for Improving Sexual Health in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Youth: Evaluation Report. Canberra: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; (2013).
    1. Mikhailovich K, Arabena K. Evaluating an indigenous sexual health peer education project. Health Promot J Austr (2005) 16(3):189–93.10.1071/HE05189
    1. McCallum GB, Chang AB, Wilson CA, Petsky HL, Saunders J, Pizzutto SJ, et al. Feasibility of a peer-led asthma and smoking prevention project in Australian schools with high indigenous youth. Front Pediatr (2017) 5:33.10.3389/fped.2017.00033
    1. Flicker S, Danforth J, Konsmo E, Wilson C, Oliver V, Jackson R, et al. “Because we are natives and we stand strong to our pride”: decolonizing HIV prevention with aboriginal youth in Canada using the arts. Can J Aborig Commun Based HIVAIDS Res (2013) 5:4–24.
    1. Wilson C, Oliver V, Flicker S. “Culture” as HIV prevention. Gatew Int J Commun Res Engagem (2016) 9(1):74–88.10.5130/ijcre.v9i1.4802
    1. Flicker S, Yee J, Larkin J, Jackson R, Prentice T, Restoule JP, et al. Taking Action! Art and Aboriginal Youth Leadership for HIV Prevention. Toronto, ON: (2012).
    1. Huynh E, Rand D, McNeill C, Brown S, Senechal M, Wicklow B, et al. Beating diabetes together: a mixed-methods analysis of a feasibility study of intensive lifestyle intervention for youth with type 2 diabetes. Can J Diabetes (2015) 39(6):484–90.10.1016/j.jcjd.2015.09.093
    1. Majumdar BB, Chambers TL, Roberts J. Community-based, culturally sensitive HIV/AIDS education for Aboriginal adolescents: implications for nursing practice. J Transcult Nurs (2004) 15(1):69–73.10.1177/1043659603260015
    1. Crooks C, Exner-Cortens D, Burn S, Lapointe A, Chiodo D. Two-years of relationship-focused mentoring for First Nations, Metis, and Inuit adolescents: promoting positive mental health. J Prim Prev (2017) 38:87–104.10.1007/s10935-016-0457-0
    1. Smith MU, Rushing SC, The Native STAND Curriculum Development Group Native STAND (students together against negative decisions): evaluating a school-based sexual risk reduction intervention in Indian boarding schools. Health Educ Monogr (2011) 28(2):67–74.
    1. Rushing SNC, Hildebrandt NL, Grimes CJ, Rowsell AJ, Christensen BC, Lambert WE. Healthy & empowered youth: a positive youth development program for native youth. Am J Prev Med (2017) 52(3):S263–7.10.1016/j.amepre.2016.10.024
    1. Montgomery M, Manuelito B, Nass C, Chock T, Buchwald D. The native comic book project: native youth making comics and healthy decisions. J Cancer Educ (2012) 27(1):41–6.10.1007/s13187-012-0311-x
    1. Parker L. The missing component in substance abuse prevention efforts: a Native American example. Contemp Drug Probs (1990) 17:251.
    1. Aguilera S, Plasencia AV. Culturally appropriate HIV/AIDS and substance abuse prevention programs for urban native youth. J Psychoactive Drugs (2005) 37(3):299–304.10.1080/02791072.2005.10400523
    1. Marlow E, D’Eramo Melkus G, Bosma AM. STOP diabetes! An educational model for Native American adolescents in the prevention of diabetes. Diabetes Educ (1998) 24(4):441–50.10.1177/014572179802400403
    1. Carpenter RA, Lyons CA, Miller WR. Peer-managed self-control program for prevention of alcohol abuse in American Indian high school students: a pilot evaluation study. Int J Addict (1985) 20(2):299–310.10.3109/10826088509044912
    1. Mitschke D, Loebl K, Tatafu E, Matsunaga D, Cassel K. Using drama to prevent teen smoking: development, implementation, and evaluation of crossroads in Hawai’i. Health Promot Pract (2010) 11(2):244–8.10.1177/1524839907309869
    1. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, The PRISMA Group Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med (2009) 6(7):e1000097.10.1371/journal.pmed1000097
    1. Jepson R, Harris F, Platt S, Tannahill C. The effectiveness of interventions to change six health behaviours: a review of reviews. BMC Public Health (2010) 10:538.10.1186/1471-2458-10-538
    1. Harden A, Oakley A, Oliver S. Peer-delivered health promotion for young people: a systematic review of different study designs. Health Educ J (2001) 60(4):339–53.10.1177/001789690106000406
    1. Morrow V, Richards M. The ethics of social research with children: an overview. Child Soc (1996) 10:90–105.10.1111/j.1099-0860.1996.tb00461.x
    1. Ethics and Social Research Council. Research with Children and Young People. Ethics and Social Research Council; (2017). Available from:
    1. Bauman L, Sclafane J, LoIacono M, Wilson K, Macklin R. Ethical issues in HIV/STD prevention research with high risk youth: providing help, preserving validity. Ethics Behav (2008) 18(2/3):247–65.10.1080/10508420802066833
    1. Cochran P, Marshall C, Garcia-Downing C, Kendall E, Cook D, McCubbin L, et al. Indigenous ways of knowing: implications for participatory research and community. Health Policy Ethics (2008) 98:22–7.10.2105/AJPH.2006.093641
    1. Tuhiwai Smith L. Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples. New York: Zed Books; (1999).
    1. Humphery K. Dirty questions: indigenous health and ‘western research’. Aust N Z J Public Health (2001) 25:197–202.10.1111/j.1467-842X.2001.tb00563.x
    1. Australian Bureau of Statistics. Estimates of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians. Australian Bureau of Statistics; (2011). Available from:
    1. Statistics NZ. Census Ethnic Group Profiles: Maori. StatsNZ; (2013). Available from:
    1. Statistics Canada. Aboriginal Peoples in Canada: First Nations People, Metis and Inuit. Statistics Canada; (2011). Available from:
    1. National Congress of American Indians. Demographics. National Congress of American Indians; (Accessed 2017). Available from:
    1. Cobb-Clark D. The Case for Making Public Policy Evaluations Public. Melbourne: Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research; (2013).
    1. Snijder M, Shakeshaft A, Wagemakers A, Stephens A, Calabria B. A systematic review of studies evaluating Australian indigenous community development projects: the extent of community participation, their methodological quality and their outcomes. BMC Public Health (2015) 15:1154.10.1186/s12889-015-2514-7
    1. Merzel C, D’Afflitti J. Reconsidering community-based health promotion: promise, performance, and potential. Am J Public Health (2003) 93(4):557–74.10.2105/AJPH.93.4.557
    1. Ronsley R, Lee AS, Kuzeljevic B, Panagiotopoulos C. Healthy Buddies™ reduces body mass index Z-score and waist circumference in Aboriginal children living in remote coastal communities. J Sch Health (2013) 83(9):605–13.10.1111/josh.12072
    1. Santos RG, Durksen A, Rabbani R, Chanoine J-P, Miln AL, Mayer T, et al. Effectiveness of peer-based healthy living lesson plans on anthropometric measures and physical activity in elementary school students: a cluster randomized trial. JAMA Pediatr (2014) 168(4):330–7.10.1001/jamapediatrics.2013.3688
    1. Eskicioglu P, Halas J, Sénéchal M, Wood L, McKay E, Villeneuve S, et al. Peer mentoring for type 2 diabetes prevention in first nations children. Pediatrics (2014) 133(6):e1624–31.10.1542/peds.2013-2621
    1. Lobo R, McManus A, Brown G, Hildebrand J, Maycock B. Evaluating peer-based youth programs: barriers and enablers. Eval J Aust (2010) 10(1):36–43.10.1177/1035719X1001000106

Source: PubMed

Sponsorer og samarbejdspartnere

Medicinske tilstande

Narkotikainterventioner

3
Abonner