The effect of high-heeled shoes on lumbar lordosis: a narrative review and discussion of the disconnect between Internet content and peer-reviewed literature
Brent S Russell, Brent S Russell
Abstract
Objectives: Some women complain of low back pain that they believe is due to wearing high-heeled shoes, and some clinicians seem to think the reason is that high-heeled shoes cause increased lumbar lordosis. This article examines Internet information aimed at the general public and presents a literature review of available research in this area.
Methods: The keywords high heels and high-heeled shoes, combined with the words lumbar, lordosis, and pelvic tilt, were used in an Internet search of Ask.com; in published literature searches of PubMed, MANTIS, CINAHL, Scopus, and ProceedingsFirst; and in searches for theses and dissertations of PapersFirst through June 2010.
Results: There are many Internet sites that support the belief that high-heeled shoes cause increased lordosis. However, published research for this topic mostly does not support this belief; but some mixed results, small subject groups, and questionable methods have left the issue unclear.
Conclusions: It appears that some health care providers are offering advice about the effect of high-heeled shoes on lumbar lordosis that conflicts with most published research. However, the prevalence of such advice is unknown; and the published research is equivocal. Considering that both low back pain and the wearing of high heeled-shoes are common, clinicians could use some clearer guidance; this is an area that deserves further investigation.
Copyright © 2010. Published by Elsevier Inc.
Figures
References
- Franklin M.E., Chenier T.C., Brauninger L., Cook H., Harris S. Effect of positive heel inclination on posture. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1995;21(2):94–99.
- Opila K.A., Wagner S.S., Schiowitz S., Chen J. Postural alignment in barefoot and high-heeled stance. Spine. 1988;13(5):542–547.
- de Lateur B.J., Giaconi R.M., Questad K., Ko M., Lehmann J.F. Footwear and posture: compensatory strategies for heel height. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 1991;70(5):246–254.
- Buehler V.L. University of Oregon; Eugene, Oregon: 1932. The effect of various heights of heels upon erect body posture and an investigation of the possible reasons [thesis]
- MailOnline [homepage on the Internet]. Associated Newspapers, Ltd; c2010 [updated 2008 August 26; cited 2010 June 4]. Apprentice star Claire Young: my killer heels wrecked my spine and left me in agony. Available from: .
- American Chiropractic Association [homepage on the Internet]. Arlington, Virginia: American Chiropractic Association; c2009 [cited 2010 June 4]. Today's fashion can be tomorrow's pain. Available from: .
- American Physical Therapy Association [homepage on the Internet]. Alexandria, Virginia: American Physical Therapy Association; c2009 [updated 2000 August 20; cited 2009 May 18]. Physical therapists say tottering on high heels puts women at risk for foot and back problems. Available from: .
- Sutton A.L., editor. Back and neck sourcebook. 2nd ed. Omnigraphics; Detroit: 2004. p. 116.
- Physical Rehabilitation/Robert Egert, M.D. [homepage on the Internet]. Chico, CA: Robert Egert, MD. [cited 2010 June 4]. Low back pain; posture and lifting advice. Available from: .
- McKinley Health Center [homepage on the Internet]. The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; c2007 [updated 2007 February 23; cited 2010 June 4]. Back and neck care guide, section 5, Footwear. Available from: .
- [homepage on the Internet] Merritt, British Columbia, Canada: Nicola Valley Chiropractic; c2001 [cited 2010 June 4]. The downside of the high heels. Available from: .
- Apex Chiropractic Los Angeles [homepage on the Internet]. Santa Monica, California: Apex Chiropractic; c2008 [cited 2010 June 4]. Women's health—high heels. Available from: .
- Posture & Flexibility [homepage on the Internet]. Canberra, Australia: Posture & Flexibility; [cited 2010 June 4]. The downside of the high heel. Available from: .
- [home page on the Internet]. Silver Spring, Maryland: Discovery Communications, LLC; c1998-2009 [cited 2010 June 4]. How to prevent back pain—wear the right shoes. Available from: .
- [homepage on the Internet]. Alpharetta, Georgia, USA: BodyZone, LLC; [cited 2010 June 4]. Spinal care do's and don'ts, standing. Available from: .
- [homepage on the Internet]. Coventry, West Midlands, England: The Pain Clinic; c2009 [cited 2010 June 4]. Spinal pain, low back pain, posture and lifting. Available from: .
- [home page on the Internet]. New York, New York: The New York Times Company; c2009 [updated 2008 June 6; cited 2010 June 4]. High-heeled shoes—bad for the body, fashion at a high price. Available from: .
- Bendix T., Sorenson S.S., Klaussen K. Lumbar curve, trunk muscles, and the line of gravity with different heel heights. Spine. 1984;9(2):223–227.
- Snow R.E., Williams K.R. High-heeled shoes: their effect on center of mass position, posture, three-dimensional kinematics, rearfoot motion, and ground reaction forces. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1994;75(5):568–576.
- Opila-Correia K.A. Kinematics of high-heeled gait with consideration for age and experience of wearers. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1990;71(11):905–909.
- Cowley E.E., Chevalier T.L., Chockalingam N. The effect of heel height on gait and posture: a review of the literature. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. 2009;99(6):512–518.
- Lee C.M., Jeong E.H., Freivalds A. Biomechanical effects of wearing high-heeled shoes. Int J Ind Ergon. 2001;28(6):321–326.
- Iunes D.H., Monte-Raso W., Santos C.B.A., Castro F.A., Salgado H.S. Postural influence of high heels among adult women: analysis by computerized photogrammetry. Rev Bras Fisioter. 2008;12(6):454–459.
- Ebrahimian M., Ghaffarinejad F. The survey of the effect of heeled shoes on lumbar lordosis and pelvic tilt angles in females 20-30 years old [abstract] In: Vleeming A., Mooney V., Hodges P., Lee D., McGill S., Ostgaard H.C., editors. Proceedings of the 5th Interdisciplinary World Congress on Low back and pelvic pain; Nov. 7-10; Melbourne, Australia. 2004. p. 361.
- Yoo J. Hanyang University; Seoul, Korea: 1997. Assessment of lumbar lordosis by skin markers during gait [thesis]
- Fedorak C., Ashworth N., Marshal J., Paull H. Reliability of the visual assessment of cervical and lumbar lordosis: how good are we? Spine. 2003;28(16):1857–1859.
- Mosner E.A., Bryan J.M., Stull M.A., Shippee R. A comparison of actual and apparent lumbar lordosis in black and white adult females. Spine. 1989;14(3):310–314.
- Bryan J.M., Mosner E., Shippee R., Stull M.A. Investigation of the validity of postural evaluation skills in assessing lumbar lordosis using photographs of clothed subjects. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1990;12(1):24–29.
- Walsh M., Breen A.C. Reliability and validity of the Metrecom Skeletal Analysis System in the assessment of sagittal plane lumbar angles. Clin Biomech. 1995;10(4):222–223.
- Tuzun C., Yorulmaz I., Cindas A., Vatan S. Low back pain and posture. Clin Rheumatol. 1999;18(4):308–312.
- Liebig E.M., Kothe R., Mannion A.F., Grob D. The clinical significance of the lumbar lordosis: relationship between lumbar spinal curvature and low back pain [conference abstract] Eur Spine J. 2000;9(4):286.
Source: PubMed