Health effects related to wind turbine noise exposure: a systematic review

Jesper Hvass Schmidt, Mads Klokker, Jesper Hvass Schmidt, Mads Klokker

Abstract

Background: Wind turbine noise exposure and suspected health-related effects thereof have attracted substantial attention. Various symptoms such as sleep-related problems, headache, tinnitus and vertigo have been described by subjects suspected of having been exposed to wind turbine noise.

Objective: This review was conducted systematically with the purpose of identifying any reported associations between wind turbine noise exposure and suspected health-related effects.

Data sources: A search of the scientific literature concerning the health-related effects of wind turbine noise was conducted on PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar and various other Internet sources.

Study eligibility criteria: All studies investigating suspected health-related outcomes associated with wind turbine noise exposure were included.

Results: Wind turbines emit noise, including low-frequency noise, which decreases incrementally with increases in distance from the wind turbines. Likewise, evidence of a dose-response relationship between wind turbine noise linked to noise annoyance, sleep disturbance and possibly even psychological distress was present in the literature. Currently, there is no further existing statistically-significant evidence indicating any association between wind turbine noise exposure and tinnitus, hearing loss, vertigo or headache.

Limitations: Selection bias and information bias of differing magnitudes were found to be present in all current studies investigating wind turbine noise exposure and adverse health effects. Only articles published in English, German or Scandinavian languages were reviewed.

Conclusions: Exposure to wind turbines does seem to increase the risk of annoyance and self-reported sleep disturbance in a dose-response relationship. There appears, though, to be a tolerable level of around LAeq of 35 dB. Of the many other claimed health effects of wind turbine noise exposure reported in the literature, however, no conclusive evidence could be found. Future studies should focus on investigations aimed at objectively demonstrating whether or not measureable health-related outcomes can be proven to fluctuate depending on exposure to wind turbines.

Conflict of interest statement

Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Figures

Figure 1. Search strategy for relevant publications.
Figure 1. Search strategy for relevant publications.

References

    1. Pierpont N (2009) Wind turbine syndrome: A report on a natural experiment: K-Selected Books Santa Fe, NM, USA.
    1. Ambrose S, Rand R, Krogh C (2012) Wind Turbine Acoustic Investigation: Infrasound and Low-Frequency Noise-A Case Study. Bull Sci Tech Soc 32:128–141.
    1. Jeffery RD, Krogh C, Horner B (2013) Adverse health effects of industrial wind turbines. Can Fam Physician 59:473–475.
    1. Enbom H, Enbom IM (2013) [Infrasound from wind turbines–an overlooked health hazard]. Lakartidningen 110:1388–1389.
    1. Seltenrich N (2014) Wind turbines: a different breed of noise? Environ Health Perspect 122:A20–25.
    1. Phillips CV (2011) Properly interpreting the epidemiologic evidence about the health effects of industrial wind turbines on nearby residents. Bull Sci Tech Soc 31:303–315.
    1. Punch J, James R, Parbst D (2010) Wind-turbine noise: What audiologist should know. Audiology today 20–31.
    1. Knopper LD, Ollson CA (2011) Health effects and wind turbines: a review of the literature. Environ Health 10.1186/1476-069X-10-78: Available: .
    1. Hanning CD, Evans A (2012) Wind turbine noise. BMJ 344:e1527.
    1. Farboud A, Crunkhorn R, Trinidade A (2013) ‘Wind turbine syndrome’: fact or fiction? J Laryngol Otol 127:222–226.
    1. Roberts JD, Roberts MA (2013) Wind turbines: is there a human health risk? J Environ Health 75: 8–13, 16–17.
    1. Rubin GJ, Burns M, Wessely S (2014) Possible psychological mechanisms for “wind turbine syndrome”. On the windmills of your mind. 16:116–122.
    1. Chapman S (2012) WIND TURBINE NOISE Editorial ignored 17 reviews on wind turbines and health. BMJ 344:e3366.
    1. Barnard M (2013) Issues of wind turbine noise. Noise Health 15:150–152.
    1. Oerlemans S, Sijtsma P, Lopez BM (2007) Location and quantification of noise sources on a wind turbine. J Sound Vibr 299:869–883.
    1. Doolan CJ, Moreau DJ, Brooks LA (2012) Wind turbine noise mechanisms and some concepts for its control. Acoustics Australia 40:7–13.
    1. Tonin R (2012) Sources of wind turbine noise and sound propagation. Acoustics Australia 40:20–27.
    1. van den Berg GP (2004) Effects of the wind profile at night on wind turbine sound. J Sound Vibr 277:955–970.
    1. Larsson C, Ohlund O (2014) Amplitude modulation of sound from wind turbines under various meteorological conditions. J Acoust Soc Am 135:67–73.
    1. Bjorkman M (2004) Long time measurements of noise from wind turbines. J Sound Vibr 277:567–572.
    1. Cook A, Evans T, Brown R (2012) Effect of a 35 dB(A) minimum Criterion on a Wind Farm Development. Acoustics Australia 40:144–146.
    1. Fukushima A, Yamamoto K, Uchida H, Sueoka S, Kobayashi T, et al. (2013) Study on the amplitude modulation of wind turbine noise: Part 1–Physical investigation. INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 42nd International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2013 (INTERNOISE 2013), Insbruck, Austria, 15–18 September 2013:pp. 3117–3125.
    1. Lenchine VV (2009) Amplitude modulation in wind turbine noise. Acoustics 2009: Research to Consulting. Proceedings of the annual conference of the Australian Acoustical Society, Adelaide, Australia, 23–25th November 2009:pp. 1–4.
    1. Yokoyama S, Sakamoto S, Tachibana H (2013) Study on the amplitude modulation of wind turbine noise: part 2-Auditory experiments. INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 42nd International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2013 (INTERNOISE 2013), Insbruck, Austria, 15–18 September 2013:pp. 3136–3145.
    1. van den Berg F (2008) Criteria for wind farm noise: Lmax and Lden. Proceedings of the 7th European Conference on Noise Control, EURO-NOISE, Acoustics 08, Paris, France, 29 June -4 July Paris, France pp. 4043–4048.
    1. Miljøministeriet (2011) BEK nr 1284 af 15/12/2011 Bekendtgørelse om støj fra vindmøller. Available: . Accessed 2014 Jun 30.
    1. Di Napoli C (2011) Wind turbine noise assessment in a small and quiet community in Finland. Noise Control Eng J 59:30–37.
    1. Meir R, Legerton M, Anderson M, Berry B, Bullmore A, et al. (1996) The Assesment and Rating of Noise from Wind Farms. The Working Group on Noise from Wind Turbines. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 30. ETSU-R-97. 10 p.
    1. Jakobsen J (2012) Danish Regulation of Low Frequency Noise from Wind Turbines. J Low Freq Noise V A 31:239–246.
    1. Evans T, Cooper J (2012) Comparison of Predicted and Measured Wind Farm Noise Levels and Implications for assesments of new Wind Farms. Acoustics Australia 40:28–36.
    1. Moller H, Pedersen CS (2004) Hearing at low and infrasonic frequencies. Noise Health 6:37–57.
    1. Moller H, Pedersen CS (2011) Low-frequency noise from large wind turbines. J Acoust Soc Am 129:3727–3744.
    1. Janssen SA, Vos H, Eisses AR, Pedersen E (2011) A comparison between exposure-response relationships for wind turbine annoyance and annoyance due to other noise sources. J Acoust Soc Am 130:3746–3753.
    1. Pedersen E, Larsman P (2008) The impact of visual factors on noise annoyance among people living in the vicinity of wind turbines. J Environ Psychol 28:379–389.
    1. Pedersen E (2011) Health aspects associated with wind turbine noise-Results from three field studies. Noise Control Eng J 59:47–53.
    1. Bakker RH, Pedersen E, van den Berg GP, Stewart RE, Lok W, et al. (2012) Impact of wind turbine sound on annoyance, self-reported sleep disturbance and psychological distress. Sci Total Environ 425:42–51.
    1. Nissenbaum MA, Aramini JJ, Hanning CD (2012) Effects of industrial wind turbine noise on sleep and health. Noise Health 14:237–243.
    1. Pedersen E, Waye KP (2004) Perception and annoyance due to wind turbine noise–a dose-response relationship. J Acoust Soc Am 116:3460–3470.
    1. Pedersen E, Persson Waye K (2007) Wind turbine noise, annoyance and self-reported health and well-being in different living environments. Occup Environ Med 64:480–486.
    1. Pedersen E, van den Berg F, Bakker R, Bouma J (2009) Response to noise from modern wind farms in The Netherlands. J Acoust Soc Am 126:634–643.
    1. Pedersen E (2009) Effects of wind turbine noise on humans. Proceedings of the Third International Meeting on Wind Turbine Noise, Aalborg, Denmark, 17–19 June 2009:pp. 11.
    1. Shepherd D, McBride D, Welch D, Dirks KN, Hill EM (2011) Evaluating the impact of wind turbine noise on health-related quality of life. Noise Health 13:333–339.
    1. Kuwano S, Yano T, Kageyama T, Sueoka S, Tachibana H (2013) Social survey on community response to wind turbine noise. INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 42nd International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2013 (INTERNOISE 2013), Insbruck, Austria, 15–18 September 2013:pp. 3362–3371.
    1. Yano T, Kuwano S, Kageyama T, Sueoka S, Tachibana H (2013) Dose-response relationships for wind turbine noise in Japan. INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 42nd International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2013 (INTERNOISE 2013), Insbruck, Austria, 15–18 September 2013:pp. 2715–2722.
    1. Paller C (2014) Exploring the Association between Proximity to Industrial Wind Turbines and Self-Reported Health Outcomes in Ontario, Canada [Master of Science in Health Studies and Gerontology]. University of Waterloo, Canada Available: . Accessed 2014 Jun 9. 102 p.
    1. Pawlaczyk-Luszczynska M, Dudarewicz A, Zaborowski K, Zamojska-Daniszewska M, Waszkowska M (2014) Evaluation of annoyance from the wind turbine noise - A pilot study. Int J Occup Med Environ Health
    1. Pedersen E (2007) Human response to wind turbine noise-perception, annoyance and moderating factors [Ph.D.]. Inst of Medicine. Dept of Public Health and Community Medicine. University of Göteborg Available: . Accessed 2014 Jun 9. 86 p.
    1. McBride D, Shepherd D, Welch D, Dirks KN (2013) A longtitudinal study of the impact of wind turbine proximity on health related quality of life. INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 42nd International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2013 (INTERNOISE 2013), Insbruck, Austria, 15–18 September 2013. Institute of Noise Control Engineering pp. 2529–2533.
    1. Krogh CM, Gillis L, Kouwen N, Aramini J (2011) WindVOiCe, a self-reporting survey: adverse health effects, industrial wind turbines, and the need for vigilance monitoring. Bull Sci Tech Soc 31:334–345.
    1. Morris M (2013) Waterloo case series preliminary report. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Morris M (2012) Waterloo Wind Farm Survey April 2012. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Thorne B (2012) Wind Farm Generated Noise and Adverse Health Effects. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Phipps R (2007) Evidence of Dr Robyn Phipps, In the Matter of Moturimu Wind Farm Application. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 21.
    1. Schafer A (2013) Macarthur wind energy facility preliminary survey. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Schneider P (2012) Cullerin Range Wind Farm Survey. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Schneider P (2013) Cullerin range wind farm survey Follow-up survey. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Lane J (2013) Association Between Industrial Wind Turbine Noise and Sleep Quality in a Comparison Sample of Rural Ontarians [Master of Science in Health Studies and Gerontology]. University of Waterloo, Canada Available: . Accessed 2014 Jun 8.
    1. Nissenbaum M, Aramini J, Hanning C (2011) Adverse health effects of industrial wind turbines: a preliminary report. Proceedings of 10th International Congress on Noise as a Public Health Problem (ICBEN) 2011, London, UK, 24–28 July 2011:pp. 1–6.
    1. Janssen SA, Vos H, Eisses AR, Pedersen E (2009) Exposure-response relationships for annoyance by wind turbine noise: a comparison with other stationary sources. Proceedings of the Institute of Acoustics: 8th European Conference on Noise Control 2009 (EURONOISE 2009), Edinbourgh, Scotland, 26–28 October 2009:pp. 1472–1478.
    1. Janssen S, Vos H, Eisses AR, Pedersen E (2010) Predicting annoyance by wind turbine noise. INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 39th International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2010 (INTERNOISE 2010), Lisbon, Portugal, 13–16 June 2010:pp. 4476–4480.
    1. Pedersen E, Bouma J, Bakker R, Van Den Berg F (2008) Response to wind turbine noise in the Netherlands. Proceedings of the 7th European Conference on Noise Control, EURO-NOISE, Acoustics 08, Paris, France, 29 June -4 July pp. 4049–4054.
    1. Pedersen E, Waye KP (2006) Exploring perception and annoyance due to wind turbine noise in dissimilar living environments. Proceedings of the 6th European Conference on Noise Control, EURO-NOISE, Acoustics 06, Tampere, Finland, 30 May -1 June
    1. Pawlaczyk-Luszczynska M, Dudarewicz A, Zaborowski K, Zamojska M, Waszkowska M (2013) Assessment of annoyance due to wind turbine noise. Proceedings of Meetings on Acoustics. Acoustical Society of America. ICA 2013. Montreal, Canada, 2–7 June 2013:pp. 040078.
    1. Ontariro WC (2009) A self-reporting survey: adverse health effects with industrial wind turbines and the need for vigilance. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Iser DJ (2004) Results - Local wind farm survey. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Harry A (2007) Wind Turbines, Noise and Health. Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Aslund MLW, Ollson CA, Knopper LD (2013) Projected contributions of future wind farm development to community noise and annoyance levels in Ontario, Canada. Energ Policy 62:44–50.
    1. Botha P (2013) Ground Vibration, Infrasound and Low Frequency Noise Measurements from a Modern Wind Turbine. Acta Acust United Ac 99:537–544.
    1. Turnbull C, Turner J, Walsh D (2012) Measurement and level of infrasound from wind farms and other sources. Acoustics Australia 40:45–50.
    1. Jakobsen J (2005) Infrasound emission from wind turbines. J Low Freq Noise V A 24:145–155.
    1. Kelley ND, Hemphill RR, McKenna HE (1982) A methodology for assessment of wind turbine noise generation. J Sol Energ-T Asme 104:104–120.
    1. O'Neal RD, Hellweg RD, Lampeter RM (2011) Low frequency noise and infrasound from wind turbines. Noise Control Eng J 59:135–157.
    1. Jung SS, Cheung WS, Cheong C, Shin SH (2008) Experimental Identification of Acoustic Emission Characteristics of Large Wind Turbines with Emphasis on Infrasound and Low-Frequency Noise. J Korean Phys Soc 53:1897–1905.
    1. Tickell C (2012) Low frequency, infrasound and amplitude modulation noise from wind farms - some recent findings. Acoustics Australia 40:64–66.
    1. Swinbanks M (2011) The audibility of low frequency wind turbine noise. Proceedings of the Fourth International Meeting on Wind Turbine Noise, Rome, Italy, 12–14 April 2011
    1. Schiff MT, Magari SR, Smith CE, Rohr AC (2013) Field evaluation of wind turbine-related noise in western New York State. Noise Control Eng J 61:509–519.
    1. van den Berg GP (2005) The beat is getting stronger: The effect of atmospheric stability on low frequency modulated sound of wind turbines. J Low Freq Noise V A 24:1–23.
    1. Leventhall G (2007) What is infrasound? Prog Biophys Mol Biol 93:130–137.
    1. Lichtenhan J, Salt A (2013) Amplitude modulation of audible sounds by non-audible sounds: Understanding the effects of wind turbine noise. Proceedings of Meetings on Acoustics. Acoustical Society of America. ICA 2013. Montreal, Canada, 2–7 June 2013. Acoustical Society of America pp. 040064.
    1. Salt AN, Lichtenhan JT, Gill RM, Hartsock JJ (2013) Large endolymphatic potentials from low-frequency and infrasonic tones in the guinea pig. J Acoust Soc Am 133:1561–1571.
    1. Dommes E, Bauknecht HC, Scholz G, Rothemund Y, Hensel J, et al. (2009) Auditory cortex stimulation by low-frequency tones-an fMRI study. Brain Res 1304:129–137.
    1. Hensel J, Scholz G, Hurttig U, Mrowinski D, Janssen T (2007) Impact of infrasound on the human cochlea. Hear Res 233:67–76.
    1. Thomsen J, Sass K, Odkvist L, Arlinger S (2005) Local overpressure treatment reduces vestibular symptoms in patients with Meniere's disease: a clinical, randomized, multicenter, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Otol Neurotol 26:68–73.
    1. Salt AN, Hullar TE (2010) Responses of the ear to low frequency sounds, infrasound and wind turbines. Hear Res 268:12–21.
    1. Crichton F, Dodd G, Schmid G, Gamble G, Petrie KJ (2014) Can Expectations Produce Symptoms From Infrasound Associated With Wind Turbines? Health Psychol 33:360–364.
    1. Crichton F, Dodd G, Schmid G, Gamble G, Cundy T, et al. (2013) The Power of Positive and Negative Expectations to Influence Reported Symptoms and Mood During Exposure to Wind Farm Sound. Health Psychol. Epub ahead of printing DOI:.
    1. Wolsink M (2000) Wind power and the NIMBY-myth: institutional capacity and the limited significance of public support. Renew Energ 21:49–64.
    1. Krohn S, Damborg S (1999) On public attitudes towards wind power. Renew Energ 16:954–960.
    1. Verheijen E, Jabben J, Schreurs E, Smith KB (2011) Impact of wind turbine noise in the Netherlands. Noise Health 13:459–463.
    1. Shepherd KP, Grosveld FW, Stephens DG (1983) Evaluation of human exposure to the noise from large wind turbine generators. Noise Control Eng J 21:30–37.
    1. Chapman S, St George A (2013) How the factoid of wind turbines causing ‘vibroacoustic disease’ came to be ‘irrefutably demonstrated’. Aust N Z J Public Health 37:244–249.
    1. Alves-Pereira M, Castelo Branco NA (2007) Vibroacoustic disease: biological effects of infrasound and low-frequency noise explained by mechanotransduction cellular signalling. Prog Biophys Mol Biol 93:256–279.
    1. Branco NA, Alves-Pereira M (2004) Vibroacoustic disease. Noise Health 6:3–20.
    1. Pedersen E, Hallberg L-M, Waye KP (2007) Living in the vicinity of wind turbines–a grounded theory study. Qualitative Research in Psychology 4:49–63.
    1. Hessler DM, Hessler GF (2011) Recommended noise level design goals and limits at residential receptors for wind turbine developments in the United States. Noise Control Eng J 59:94–104.
    1. Van Renterghem T, Bockstael A, De Weirt V, Botteldooren D (2013) Annoyance, detection and recognition of wind turbine noise. Sci Total Environ 456:333–345.
    1. Pedersen E, van den Berg F (2010) Why is wind turbine noise poorly masked by road traffic noise? INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 39th International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2010 (INTERNOISE 2010), Lisbon, Portugal, 13–16 June 2010:pp. 2291–2300.
    1. Pedersen E, van den Berg F, Bakker R, Bouma J (2010) Can road traffic mask sound from wind turbines? Response to wind turbine sound at different levels of road traffic sound. Energ Policy 38:2520–2527.
    1. Bolin K, Nilsson ME, Khan S (2010) The Potential of Natural Sounds to Mask Wind Turbine Noise. Acta Acust United Ac 96:131–137.
    1. Bolin K, Kedhammar A, Nilsson ME (2012) The Influence of Background Sounds on Loudness and Annoyance of Wind Turbine Noise. Acta Acust United Ac 98:741–748.
    1. Hume KI, Brink M, Basner M (2012) Effects of environmental noise on sleep. Noise Health 14:297–302.
    1. Salt AN, Lichtenhan JT (2012) Perception-based protection from low-frequency sounds may not be enough. INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 41st International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2012 (INTERNOISE 2012), New York City, New Your, USA, 19–22 August 2012:pp. 3999–4010.
    1. Minor LB (2000) Superior canal dehiscence syndrome. Am J Otol 21:9–19.
    1. Harding G, Harding P, Wilkins A (2008) Wind turbines, flicker, and photosensitive epilepsy: Characterizing the flashing that may precipitate seizures and optimizing guidelines to prevent them. Epilepsia 49:1095–1098.
    1. Smedley AR, Webb AR, Wilkins AJ (2010) Potential of wind turbines to elicit seizures under various meteorological conditions. Epilepsia 51:1146–1151.
    1. Pedersen E, PerssonWaye K (2008) Wind turbines - low level noise sources interfering with restoration? Environ Res Lett DOI:
    1. Seong Y, Lee S, Gwak DY, Cho Y, Hong J, et al.. (2013) An experimental study on rating scale for annoyance due to wind turbine noise. INTER-NOISE and NOISE-CON Congress and Conference Proceedings, 42nd International Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering 2013 (INTERNOISE 2013), Insbruck, Austria, 15–18 September 2013. Institute of Noise Control Engineering pp. 2699–2704.
    1. Kelley ND (1987) A proposed metric for assessing the potential of community annoyance from wind turbine low-frequency noise emissions. Solar Energy Research Inst., Golden, CO (USA). Availiable: . Accessed 2014 Jun 8.
    1. Lee S, Kim K, Choi W, Lee S (2011) Annoyance caused by amplitude modulation of wind turbine noise. Noise Control Eng J 59:38–46.
    1. King EA, Pilla F, Mahon J (2012) Assessing noise from wind farm developments in Ireland: A consideration of critical wind speeds and turbine choice. Energ Policy 41:548–560.
    1. Sorensen M, Andersen ZJ, Nordsborg RB, Becker T, Tjonneland A, et al. (2013) Long-term exposure to road traffic noise and incident diabetes: a cohort study. Environ Health Perspect 121:217–222.
    1. Sorensen M, Hvidberg M, Andersen ZJ, Nordsborg RB, Lillelund KG, et al. (2011) Road traffic noise and stroke: a prospective cohort study. Eur Heart J 32:737–744.
    1. Henningsen P, Zipfel S, Herzog W (2007) Management of functional somatic syndromes. Lancet 369:946–955.
    1. Jones TF, Craig AS, Hoy D, Gunter EW, Ashley DL, et al. (2000) Mass psychogenic illness attributed to toxic exposure at a high school. N Engl J Med 342:96–100.
    1. Chapman S, St George A, Waller K, Cakic V (2013) The Pattern of Complaints about Australian Wind Farms Does Not Match the Establishment and Distribution of Turbines: Support for the Psychogenic, 'Communicated Disease' Hypothesis. PLoS One 8:e76584.
    1. Deignan B, Harvey E, Hoffman-Goetz L (2013) Fright factors about wind turbines and health in Ontario newspapers before and after the Green Energy Act. Health Risk & Society 15:234–250.

Source: PubMed

Sponsorit ja yhteistyökumppanit

Sairaudet

Huumeiden interventiot

3
Tilaa