Strengthening Delivery of Health Services Using Digital Devices

Maeghan Orton, Smisha Agarwal, Pierre Muhoza, Lavanya Vasudevan, Alexander Vu, Maeghan Orton, Smisha Agarwal, Pierre Muhoza, Lavanya Vasudevan, Alexander Vu

Abstract

Background: Delivery of high-quality efficient health services is a cornerstone of the global agenda to achieve universal health coverage. According to the World Health Organization, health service delivery is considered good when equitable access to a comprehensive range of high-quality health services is ensured within an integrated and person-centered continuum of care. However, good health service delivery can be challenging in low-resource settings. In this review, we summarize and discuss key advances in health service delivery, particularly in the context of using digital health strategies for mitigating human resource constraints.

Methods: The review updates the foundational systematic review conducted by Agarwal et al. in 2015. We used PubMed, EMBASE, and CINAHL to find relevant English-language peer-reviewed articles published 2018. Our search strategy for MEDLINE was based on MeSH (medical subject headings) terms and text words of key articles that we identified a priori. Our search identified 92 articles. After screening, we selected 24 articles for abstract review, of which only 6 met the eligibility criteria and were ultimately included in this review.

Results: Despite encouraging advances in the evidence base on digital strategies for health service delivery, the current body of evidence is still quite limited in 3 main areas: the effectiveness of interventions on health outcomes, improvement in health system efficiencies for service delivery, and the human capacity required to implement and support digital health strategies at scale. Two particular areas, digital health-enhanced referral coordination and mobile clinical decision support systems, demonstrate considerable potential to improve the quality and comprehensiveness of care received by patients, but they require a greater level of standardization and an expanded scope of health worker engagement across the health system in order to scale them up effectively.

Conclusions: Additional research is urgently needed to inform the effectiveness of interventions on health outcomes, improvement in health system efficiencies, and cost-effectiveness of service delivery. In particular, more documentation and research on ways to standardize and engage health workers in digital referral and clinical decision support systems can provide the foundation needed to scale these promising approaches in low- and middle-income settings.

© Orton et al.

Figures

FIGURE
FIGURE
Strategic Focus Areas of the Integrated Patient-Centered Health Services Framework

References

    1. World Health Organization (WHO). Monitoring the Building Blocks of Health Systems: A Handbook of Indicators and Their Measurement Strategies. Geneva: WHO; 2010. Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. Bogan M, Mushi C, Esch J, et al. Improving Standards of Care with Mobile Applications in Tanzania. Paper presented at: W3C Workshop on the Role of Mobile Technologies in Fostering Social and Economic Development in Africa; April 1, 2009; Maputo, Mozambique: Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. Campanella N, Morosini P, Sampaolo G, et al. . Medical teleconsultation to general practitioners reduces the medical error vulnerability of internal medicine patients. Eur J Intern Med. 2015;26(9):675–679.
    1. Interactive Research and Development (IRD), Stop TB Partnership. mHealth to Improve TB Care. Karachi, Pakistan: IRD; 2012. Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. International Telecommunication Union (ITU). ICT Facts Figures 2017. Geneva: ITU; 2017. Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. World Health Organization. Framework on integrated people-centred health services. Report by the Secretariat. 69th World Health Assembly provisional agenda item 16.1. A69/39. . Published April 15, 2016 Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. Agarwal S, Perry HB, Long LA, Labrique AB. Evidence on feasibility and effective use of mHealth strategies by frontline health workers in developing countries: systematic review. Trop Med Int Health. 2015;20(8):1003–1014. .
    1. Barrington J, Wereko-Brobby O, Ward P, Mwafongo W, Kungulwe S. SMS for Life: a pilot project to improve anti-malarial drug supply management in rural Tanzania using standard technology. Malar J. 2010;9:298. .
    1. Farrell MJ, Rose L. Use of mobile handheld computers in clinical nursing education. J Nurs Educ. 2008;47(1):13–19.
    1. Goldsworthy S, Lawrence N, Goodman W. The use of personal digital assistants at the point of care in an undergraduate nursing program. Comput Inform Nurs. 2006;24(3):138–143.
    1. Leung GM, Johnston JM, Tin KY, et al. . Randomised controlled trial of clinical decision support tools to improve learning of evidence based medicine in medical students. BMJ. 2003;327(7423):1090. .
    1. Lori JR, Munro ML, Boyd CJ, Andreatta P. Cell phones to collect pregnancy data from remote areas in Liberia. J Nursing Scholarsh. 2012;44(3):294–301. .
    1. Mcleod TG, McNaughton DA, Hanson GJ, Cha SS. Educational effectiveness of a personal digital assistant-based geriatric assessment tool. Med Teach. 2009;31(5):409–414.
    1. Strayer SM, Pelletier SL, Martindale JR, Rais S, Powell J, Schorling JB. A PDA-based counseling tool for improving medical student smoking cessation counseling. Fam Med. 2010;42(5):350–357. .
    1. Tempelhof MW, Garman KS, Langman MK, Adams MB. Leveraging time and learning style, iPod vs. realtime attendance at a series of medicine residents conferences: a randomised controlled trial. Inform Prim Care. 2009;17(2):87–94. 10.14236/jhi.v17i2.720.
    1. Berner ES, Houston TK, Ray MN, et al. . Improving ambulatory prescribing safety with a handheld decision support system: a randomized controlled trial. J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2006;13(2):171–179. .
    1. Blaivas M, Lyon M, Duggal S. Ultrasound image transmission via camera phones for overreading. Am J Emerg Med. 2005;23(4):433–438. 10.1016/j.ajem.2004.09.037.
    1. Bürkle T, Beisig A, Ganslmayer M, Prokosch HU. A randomized controlled trial to evaluate an electronic scoring tool in the ICU. In: Andersen SK, Klein GO, Schultz A, Aarts J, Mazzoleni MC, eds. Health Beyond the Horizon – Get IT There. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics Series. 2008;136:279–284. .
    1. Chaiyachati KH, Loveday M, Lorenz S, et al. . A pilot study of an mHealth application for healthcare workers: poor uptake despite high reported acceptability at a rural South African community-based MDR-TB treatment program. PLoS One. 2013;8(5):e64662. .
    1. Cole-Ceesay R, Cherian M, Sonko A, et al. . Strengthening the emergency healthcare system for mothers and children in The Gambia. Reprod Health. 2010;7:21. .
    1. Coopmans VC, Biddle C. CRNA performance using a handheld, computerized, decision-making aid during critical events in a simulated environment: a methodologic inquiry. AANA J. 2008;76(1):29–35.
    1. Greenfield S. Medication error reduction and the use of PDA technology. J Nurs Educ. 2007;46(3):127–131.
    1. Jayaraman C, Kennedy P, Dutu G, Lawrenson R. Use of mobile phone cameras for after-hours triage in primary care. J Telemed Telecare. 2008;14(5):271–274. 10.1258/jtt.2008.080303.
    1. Mitchell M, Hedt-Gauthier BL, Msellemu D, Nkaka M, Lesh N. Using electronic technology to improve clinical care – results from a before-after cluster trial to evaluate assessment and classification of sick children according to Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI) protocol in Tanzania. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak. 2013;13:95. 10.1186/1472-6947-13-95.
    1. Momtahan KL, Burns CM, Sherrard H, Mesana T, Labinaz M. Using personal digital assistants and patient care algorithms to improve access to cardiac care best practices. In: Kuhn KA, Warren JR, Leong T-Y, eds. MEDINFO 2007. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics Series. 2007;129(Pt 1):117–121. .
    1. Ngabo F, Nguimfack J, Nwaigwe F, et al. . Designing and implementing an innovative SMS-based alert system (RapidSMS-MCH) to monitor pregnancy and reduce maternal and child deaths in Rwanda. Pan Afr Med J. 2012;13:31. .
    1. Prytherch DR, Smith GB, Schmidt P, et al. . Calculating early warning scores—a classroom comparison of pen and paper and hand-held computer methods. Resuscitation. 2006;70(2):173–178. 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2005.12.002.
    1. Rudkin SE, Langdorf MI, Macias D, Oman JA, Kazzi AA. Personal digital assistants change management more often than paper texts and foster patient confidence. Eur J Emerg Med. 2006;13(2):92–96.
    1. Zurovac D, Sudoi RK, Akhwale WS, et al. . The effect of mobile phone text-message reminders on Kenyan health workers' adherence to malaria treatment guidelines: a cluster randomised trial. Lancet. 2011;378(9793):795–803. .
    1. Chandhanayingyong C, Tangtrakulwanich B, Kiriratnikom T. Teleconsultation for emergency orthopaedic patients using the multimedia messaging service via mobile phones. J Telemed Telecare. 2007;13(4):193–196. 10.1258/135763307780908049.
    1. Eze N, Lo S, Bray D, Toma AG. The use of camera mobile phone to assess emergency ENT radiological investigations. Clin Otolaryngol. 2005;30(3):230–233; discussion 233. 10.1111/j.1365-2273.2005.00982.x.
    1. Gandsas A, McIntire K, Montgomery K, Bumgardner C, Rice L. The personal digital assistant (PDA) as a tool for telementoring endoscopic procedures. In: Westwood JD, Haluck RS, Hoffman HM, et al., eds. Medicine Meets Virtual Reality 12. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics Series. 2004;98:99–103.
    1. Hsieh CH, Jeng SF, Chen CY, et al. . Teleconsultation with the mobile camera-phone in remote evaluation of replantation potential. J Trauma. 2005;58(6):1208–1212.
    1. Pettis KS, Savona MR, Leibrandt PN, et al. . Evaluation of the efficacy of hand-held computer screens for cardiologists' interpretations of 12-lead electrocardiograms. Am Heart J. 1999;138(4 Pt 1):765–770. 10.1016/S0002-8703(99)70194-8.
    1. Yaghmai V, Kuppuswami S, Berlin JW, Salehi SA. Evaluation of personal digital assistants as an interpretation medium for computed tomography of patients with intracranial injury. Emerg Radiol. 2003;10(2):87–89. .
    1. Bos A, Hoogstraten J, Prahl-Andersen B. Failed appointments in an orthodontic clinic. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2005;127(3):355–357. 10.1016/j.ajodo.2004.11.014.
    1. Chen ZW, Fang LZ, Chen LY, Dai HL. Comparison of an SMS text messaging and phone reminder to improve attendance at a health promotion center: a randomized controlled trial. J Zhejiang Univ Sci B. 2008;9(1):34–38.
    1. Fairhurst K, Sheikh A. Texting appointment reminders to repeated non-attenders in primary care: randomised controlled study. Qual Saf Health Care. 2008;17(5):373–376.
    1. Leong KC, Chen WS, Leong KW, et al. . The use of text messaging to improve attendance in primary care: a randomized controlled trial. Fam Pract. 2006;23(6):699–705.
    1. Milne RG, Horne M, Torsney B. SMS reminders in the UK national health service: an evaluation of its impact on “no-shows” at hospital out-patient clinics. Health Care Manage Rev. 2006;31(2):130–136.
    1. Lund S, Hemed M, Nielsen BB, et al. . Mobile phones as a health communication tool to improve skilled attendance at delivery in Zanzibar: a cluster-randomised controlled trial. BJOG. 2012;119(10):1256–1264.
    1. Macleod B, Phillips J, Stone AE, Walji A, Awoonor-Williams JK. The architecture of a software system for supporting community-based primary health care with mobile technology: the Mobile Technology for Community Health (MoTeCH) Initiative in Ghana. Online J Public Health Inform. 2012;4(1):ojphi.v4i1.3910.
    1. Kim CS, Park SY, Kang JG, et al. . Insulin dose titration system in diabetes patients using a short messaging service automatically produced by a knowledge matrix. Diabetes Technol Ther. 2010;12(8):663–669.
    1. Goodarzi M, Ebrahimzadeh I, Rabi A, Saedipoor B, Jafarabadi MA. Impact of distance education via mobile phone text messaging on knowledge, attitude, practice and self efficacy of patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus in Iran. J Diabetes Metab Disord. 2012;11(1):10. 10.1186/2251-6581-11-10.
    1. Tomlinson M, Solomon W, Singh Y, et al. . The use of mobile phones as a data collection tool: a report from a household survey in South Africa. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak. 2009;9:51. 10.1186/1472-6947-9-51.
    1. Lim S, Kang SM, Kim KM, et al. . Multifactorial intervention in diabetes care using real-time monitoring and tailored feedback in type 2 diabetes. Acta Diabetol. 2016;53(2):189–198.
    1. Agboola S, Jethwani K, Lopez L, Searl M, O'Keefe S, Kvedar J. Text to move: a randomized controlled trial of a text-messaging program to improve physical activity behaviors in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. J Med Internet Res. 2016;18(11):e307.
    1. Arora S, Peters AL, Burner E, Lam CN, Menchine M. Trial to examine text message-based mHealth in emergency department patients with diabetes (TExT-MED): a randomized controlled trial. Ann Emerg Med. 2014;63(6):745–54.e6.
    1. Capozza K, Woolsey S, Georgsson M, et al. . Going mobile with diabetes support: a randomized study of a text message-based personalized behavioral intervention for type 2 diabetes self-care. Diabetes Spectr. 2015;28(2):83–91.
    1. Daher J, Vijh R, Linthwaite B, et al. . Do digital innovations for HIV and sexually transmitted infections work? Results from a systematic review (1996–2017). BMJ Open. 2017;7(11):e017604.
    1. Free C, Phillips G, Watson L, et al. . The effectiveness of mobile-health technologies to improve health care service delivery processes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Med. 2013;10(1):e1001363. 10.1371/journal.pmed.1001363.
    1. Dobson R, Whittaker R, Pfaeffli Dale L, Maddison R. The effectiveness of text message-based self-management interventions for poorly-controlled diabetes: a systematic review. Digit Health. 2017;3:2055207617740315. 10.1177/2055207617740315.
    1. Shetty AS, Chamukuttan S, Nanditha A, Raj RK, Ramachandran A. Reinforcement of adherence to prescription recommendations in Asian Indian diabetes patients using short message service (SMS)—a pilot study. J Assoc Physicians India. 2011;59:711–714.
    1. Global Health Workforce Alliance, World Health Organization (WHO). A Universal Truth: No Health Without a Workforce. Geneva: WHO; 2014. Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. Kawamoto K, Houlihan CA, Balas EA, Lobach DF. Improving clinical practice using clinical decision support systems: a systematic review of trials to identify features critical to success. BMJ. 2005;330(7494):765.
    1. Divall P, Camosso-Stefinovic J, Baker R. The use of personal digital assistants in clinical decision making by health care professionals: a systematic review. Health Informatics J. 2013;19(1):16–28.
    1. Agarwal S, Lasway C, L'Engle K, et al. . Family planning counseling in your pocket: a mobile job aid for community health workers in Tanzania. Glob Health Sci Pract. 2016;4(2):300–310.
    1. Källander K, Tibenderana JK, Akpogheneta OJ, et al. . Mobile health (mHealth) approaches and lessons for increased performance and retention of community health workers in low- and middle-income countries: a review. J Med Internet Res. 2013;15(1):e17.
    1. Cervantes K, Salgado R, Choi M, Kalter H. Rapid Assessment of Referral Care Systems: A Guide for Program Managers. Arlington, VA: Basic Support for Institutionalizing Child Survival Project (BASICS II) project, John Snow, Inc; 2003. Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. World Health Organization (WHO). Referral systems – a summary of key processes to guide health services managers. Geneva: WHO; date unknown; Accessed September 8, 2018.
    1. Bossyns P, Van Lerberghe W. The weakest link: competence and prestige as constraints to referral by isolated nurses in rural Niger. Hum Resour Health. 2004;2(1):1. 10.1186/1478-4491-2-1.
    1. Kabakyenga J, Barigye C, Brenner J, et al. . A demonstration of mobile phone deployment to support the treatment of acutely ill children under five in Bushenyi district, Uganda. Afr Health Sci. 2016;16(1):89–96.
    1. Global Health Workforce Alliance, World Health Organization (WHO). Global Experience of Community Health Workers for Delivery of Health Related Millennium Development Goals: A Systematic Review, Country Case Studies, and Recommendations for Integration into National Health Systems. Geneva: WHO; 2010. Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. Mbuagbaw L, Thabane L, Ongolo-Zogo P, et al. . The Cameroon Mobile Phone SMS (CAMPS) trial: a randomized trial of text messaging versus usual care for adherence to antiretroviral therapy. PLoS One. 2012;7(12):e46909.
    1. Asiimwe C, Gelvin D, Lee E, et al. . Use of an innovative, affordable, and open-source short message service-based tool to monitor malaria in remote areas of Uganda. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2011;85(1):26–33.
    1. Lund S, Nielsen BB, Hemed M, et al. . Mobile phones improve antenatal care attendance in Zanzibar: a cluster randomized controlled trial. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2014;14:29.
    1. den Hollander D, Mars M. Smart phones make smart referrals: the use of mobile phone technology in burn care – a retrospective case series. Burns. 2017;43(1):190–194. 10.1016/j.burns.2016.07.015.
    1. Daviaud E, Besada D, Leon N, et al. . Costs of implementing integrated community case management (iCCM) in six African countries: implications for sustainability. J Glob Health. 2017;7(1):010403.
    1. International Telecommunication Union (ITU). ITU releases 2015 ICT figures: statistics confirm ICT revolution of the past 15 years [press release]. ITU website. . Published May 26, 2015 Accessed September 6, 2018.
    1. Mehl G, Labrique A. Prioritizing integrated mHealth strategies for universal health coverage. Science. 2014;345(6202):1284–1287.

Source: PubMed

Sponsors and Collaborators

Medical Conditions

Drug Interventions

3
Subscribe