Efficacy and acceptability of psychosocial interventions in asylum seekers and refugees: systematic review and meta-analysis

G Turrini, M Purgato, C Acarturk, M Anttila, T Au, F Ballette, M Bird, K Carswell, R Churchill, P Cuijpers, J Hall, L J Hansen, M Kösters, T Lantta, M Nosè, G Ostuzzi, M Sijbrandij, F Tedeschi, M Valimaki, J Wancata, R White, M van Ommeren, C Barbui, G Turrini, M Purgato, C Acarturk, M Anttila, T Au, F Ballette, M Bird, K Carswell, R Churchill, P Cuijpers, J Hall, L J Hansen, M Kösters, T Lantta, M Nosè, G Ostuzzi, M Sijbrandij, F Tedeschi, M Valimaki, J Wancata, R White, M van Ommeren, C Barbui

Abstract

AimsIn the past few years, there has been an unprecedented increase in the number of forcibly displaced migrants worldwide, of which a substantial proportion is refugees and asylum seekers. Refugees and asylum seekers may experience high levels of psychological distress, and show high rates of mental health conditions. It is therefore timely and particularly relevant to assess whether current evidence supports the provision of psychosocial interventions for this population. We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) assessing the efficacy and acceptability of psychosocial interventions compared with control conditions (treatment as usual/no treatment, waiting list, psychological placebo) aimed at reducing mental health problems in distressed refugees and asylum seekers.

Methods: We used Cochrane procedures for conducting a systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTs. We searched for published and unpublished RCTs assessing the efficacy and acceptability of psychosocial interventions in adults and children asylum seekers and refugees with psychological distress. Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depressive and anxiety symptoms at post-intervention were the primary outcomes. Secondary outcomes include: PTSD, depressive and anxiety symptoms at follow-up, functioning, quality of life and dropouts due to any reason.

Results: We included 26 studies with 1959 participants. Meta-analysis of RCTs revealed that psychosocial interventions have a clinically significant beneficial effect on PTSD (standardised mean difference [SMD] = -0.71; 95% confidence interval [CI] -1.01 to -0.41; I2 = 83%; 95% CI 78-88; 20 studies, 1370 participants; moderate quality evidence), depression (SMD = -1.02; 95% CI -1.52 to -0.51; I2 = 89%; 95% CI 82-93; 12 studies, 844 participants; moderate quality evidence) and anxiety outcomes (SMD = -1.05; 95% CI -1.55 to -0.56; I2 = 87%; 95% CI 79-92; 11 studies, 815 participants; moderate quality evidence). This beneficial effect was maintained at 1 month or longer follow-up, which is extremely important for populations exposed to ongoing post-migration stressors. For the other secondary outcomes, we identified a non-significant trend in favour of psychosocial interventions. Most evidence supported interventions based on cognitive behavioural therapies with a trauma-focused component. Limitations of this review include the limited number of studies collected, with a relatively low total number of participants, and the limited available data for positive outcomes like functioning and quality of life.

Conclusions: Considering the epidemiological relevance of psychological distress and mental health conditions in refugees and asylum seekers, and in view of the existing data on the effectiveness of psychosocial interventions, these interventions should be routinely made available as part of the health care of distressed refugees and asylum seekers. Evidence-based guidelines and implementation packages should be developed accordingly.

Keywords: Asylum seekers; mental health; psychosocial interventions; refugees.

Figures

Fig. 1.
Fig. 1.
PRISMA flow-chart diagram.
Fig. 2.
Fig. 2.
Efficacy of psychosocial interventions in refugees and asylum seekers: PTSD symptoms post intervention.
Fig. 3.
Fig. 3.
Efficacy of psychosocial interventions in refugees and asylum seekers: depressive symptoms post intervention.
Fig. 4.
Fig. 4.
Efficacy of psychosocial interventions in refugees and asylum seekers: anxiety symptoms post intervention.

References

    1. Acarturk C, Konuk E, Cetinkaya M, Senay I, Sijbrandij M, Cuijpers P and Aker T (2015) EMDR for Syrian refugees with posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms: results of a pilot randomized controlled trial. European Journal of Psychotraumatology 6, 1–9.
    1. Acarturk C, Konuk E, Cetinkaya M, Senay I, Sijbrandij M, Gulen B and Cuijpers P (2016) The efficacy of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing for post-traumatic stress disorder and depression among Syrian refugees: results of a randomized controlled trial. Psychological Medicine 46, 2583–2593.
    1. Adenauer H, Catani C, Gola H, Keil J, Ruf M, Schauer M and Neuner F (2011) Narrative exposure therapy for PTSD increases top-down processing of aversive stimuli-evidence from a randomized controlled treatment trial. BMC Neuroscience 12, 127.
    1. Altman DG and Bland JM (1996) Detecting skewness from summary information. BMJ 313, 1200.
    1. Altman DG and Bland JM (2011) How to obtain the confidence interval from a p value. BMJ 343, d2090–d2090.
    1. Baker F and Jones C (2006) The effect of music therapy services on classroom behaviours of newly arrived refugee students in Australia – a pilot study. Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties 11, 249–260.
    1. Barbui C (2016) Sharing all types of clinical data and harmonizing journal standards. BMC Medicine 14, 63.
    1. Barbui C, Dua T, van Ommeren M, Yasamy MT, Fleischmann A, Clark N, Thornicroft G, Hill S and Saxena S (2010) Challenges in developing evidence-based recommendations using the GRADE approach: the case of mental, neurological, and substance use disorders. PLoS Medicine 7, 1–8.
    1. Barbui C, Dua T, Harper M, Tablante EC, Thornicroft G and Saxena S (2015) Using GRADE to update WHO recommendations for MNS. The Lancet Psychiatry 2, 1054–1056.
    1. Barbui C, Gureje O, Puschner B, Patten S and Thornicroft G (2016) Implementing a data sharing culture. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences 25, 289–290.
    1. Barbui C, Purgato M, Churchill R, Adams C, Amato L, Macdonald G, McCleery J, Minozzi S and Sheriff RS (2017) Cochrane for global mental health. The Lancet Psychiatry 4, 1–2.
    1. Bass JK, Bolton PA and Murray LK (2007) Do not forget culture when studying mental health. The Lancet 370, 918–919.
    1. Beck AT, Steer RA and Brown GK (1996) BDI-II, Beck Depression Inventory: Manual. Boston: Harcourt Brace.
    1. Blake DD, Weathers FW, Nagy LM, Kaloupek DG, Gusman FD, Charney DS and Keane TM (1995) The development of a clinician-administered PTSD scale. Journal of Traumatic Stress 8, 75–90.
    1. Bogic M, Ajdukpvic D, Bremner S, Franciskovic T, Galeazzi GM, Kucukalic A, Lecic-Tosevski D, Morina N, Popovski M, Schutzwohl M, Wang D and Priebe S (2012) Factors associated with mental disorders in long-settled war refugees: refugees from the former Yugoslavia in Germany, Italy and the UK. The British Journal of Psychiatry: the Journal of Mental Science 200, 216–223.
    1. Bolton P, Lee C, Haroz EE, Murray L, Dorsey S, Robinson C, Ugueto AM and Bass J (2014) A transdiagnostic community-based mental health treatment for comorbid disorders: development and outcomes of a randomized controlled trial among Burmese refugees in Thailand. PLoS Medicine 11, 1–16.
    1. Borenstein M, Hedges LV, Higgins JPT and Rothstein HR (2009) Introduction to Meta-Analysis. Chichester: Wiley.
    1. Buhmann CB, Nordentoft M, Ekstroem M, Carlsson J and Mortensen EL (2016) The effect of flexible cognitive-behavioural therapy and medical treatment, including antidepressants on post-traumatic stress disorder and depression in traumatised refugees: pragmatic randomised controlled clinical trial. The British Journal of Psychiatry: the Journal of Mental Science 208, 252–259.
    1. Close C, Kouvonen A, Bosqui T, Patel K, O'Reilly D and Donnelly M (2016) The mental health and wellbeing of first generation migrants: a systematic-narrative review of reviews. Globalization and Health 12, 47.
    1. Dapunt J, Kluge U and Heinz A (2017) Risk of psychosis in refugees: a literature review. Translational Psychiatry 7, e1149.
    1. Fazel M (2018) Psychological and psychosocial interventions for refugee children resettled in high-income countries. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences 27, 117–123.
    1. Furukawa TA, Barbui C, Cipriani A, Brambilla P and Watanabe N (2006) Imputing missing standard deviations in meta-analyses can provide accurate results. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 59, 7–10.
    1. Giacco D and Priebe S (2018) Mental health care for adult refugees in high-income countries. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences 27, 109–116.
    1. Guyatt G, Oxman AD, Akl EA, Kunz R, Vist G, Brozek J, Norris S, Falck-Ytter Y, Glasziou P, DeBeer H, Jaeschke R, Rind D, Meerpohl J, Dahm P and Schunemann HJ (2011) GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction-GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 64, 383–394.
    1. Hamilton M (1959) The assessment of anxiety states by rating. The British Journal of Medical Psychology 32, 50–55.
    1. Hamilton M (1960) A rating scale for depression. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry 23, 56–62.
    1. Haroz EE, Ritchey M, Bass JK, Kohrt BA, Augustinavicius J, Michalopoulos L, Burkey MD and Bolton P (2017) How is depression experienced around the world? A systematic review of qualitative literature. Social Science & Medicine 183, 151–162.
    1. Harper Shehadeh M, Heim E, Chowdhary N, Maercker A and Albanese E (2016) Cultural adaptation of minimally guided interventions for common mental disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JMIR Mental Health 3, 1–21.
    1. Higgins J and Green S (2011) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0. Chichester: Wiley; Available at .
    1. Hijazi AM, Lumley MA, Ziadni MS, Haddad L, Rapport LJ and Arnetz BB (2014) Brief narrative exposure therapy for posttraumatic stress in Iraqi refugees: a preliminary randomized clinical trial. Journal of Traumatic Stress 27, 314–322.
    1. Hinton DE, Pham T, Tran M, Safren SA, Otto MW and Pollack MH (2004) CBT for Vietnamese refugees with treatment-resistant PTSD and panic attacks: a pilot study. Journal of Traumatic Stress 17, 429–433.
    1. Hinton DE, Chhean D, Pich V, Safren SA, Hofmann SG and Pollack MH (2005) A randomized controlled trial of cognitive-behavior therapy for Cambodian refugees with treatment-resistant PTSD and panic attacks: a cross-over design. Journal of Traumatic Stress 18, 617–629.
    1. Hinton DE, Hofmann SG, Pollack MH and Otto MW (2009) Mechanisms of efficacy of CBT for Cambodian refugees with PTSD: improvement in emotion regulation and orthostatic blood pressure response. CNS Neuroscience & Therapeutics 15, 255–263.
    1. IOM International Organization for Migration (2011) Glossary on Migration, International Migration Law Series No. 25 Available at (Accessed 16 July 2018).
    1. Kaiser BN, Haroz EE, Kohrt BA, Bolton PA, Bass JK and Hinton DE (2015) ‘Thinking too much’: a systematic review of a common idiom of distress. Social Science & Medicine 147, 170–183.
    1. Kalantari M, Yule W, Dyregrov A, Neshatdoost H and Ahmadi SJ (2012) Efficacy of writing for recovery on traumatic grief symptoms of Afghani refugee bereaved adolescents: a randomized control trial. Omega 65, 139–150.
    1. Kirmayer LJ, Narasiah L, Munoz M, Rashid M, Ryder AG, Guzder J, Hassan G, Rousseau C and Pottie K and Canadian Collaboration for Immigrant and Refugee Health (CCIRH) (2011) Common mental health problems in immigrants and refugees: general approach in primary care. Canadian Medical Association Journal 183, E959–E967.
    1. Koesters M, Barbui C and Purgato M (2018) Recent approaches to provision of mental healthcare in refugee populations. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 31, 368–372.
    1. Kraemer HC and Kupfer DJ (2006) Size of treatment effects and their importance to clinical research and practice. Biological Psychiatry 59, 990–996.
    1. Liedl A, Muller J, Morina N, Karl A, Denke C and Knaevelsrud C (2011) Physical activity within a CBT intervention improves coping with pain in traumatized refugees: results of a randomized controlled design. Pain Medicine Malden Mass 12, 234–245.
    1. Lund C, Stansfeld S and De Silva M (2014) Social determinants of mental health In Patel V, Minas H, Cohen A and Prince MJ (eds), Global Mental Health: Principles and Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 1–498.
    1. Lund C, Brooke-Sumner C, Baingana F, Baron EC, Breuer E, Chandra P, Haushofer J, Herrman H, Jordans M, Kieling C, Medina-Mora ME, Morgan E, Omigbodun O, Tol W, Patel V and Saxena S (2018) Social determinants of mental disorders and the sustainable development goals: a systematic review of reviews. The Lancet Psychiatry 5, 357–369.
    1. Meffert SM, Abdo AO, Alla OAA, Elmakki YOM, Omer AAI, Yousif S, Metzler TJ and Marmar CR (2014) A pilot randomized controlled trial of interpersonal psychotherapy for Sudanese refugees in Cairo, Egypt. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy 6, 240–249.
    1. Miller KE and Rasmussen A (2010) War exposure, daily stressors, and mental health in conflict and post-conflict settings: bridging the divide between trauma-focused and psychosocial frameworks. Social Science & Medicine 70, 7–16.
    1. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J and Altman DG and PRISMA Group (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 62, 1006–1012.
    1. Mollica RF, Caspi-Yavin Y, Bollini P, Truong T, Tor S and Lavelle J (1992) The Harvard trauma questionnaire: validating a cross-cultural instrument for measuring torture, trauma, and posttraumatic stress disorder in Indochinese refugees. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 180, 111–116.
    1. Morath J, Gola H, Sommershof A, Hamuni G, Kolassa S, Catani C, Adenauer H, Ruf-Leuschner M, Schauer M, Elbert T, Groettrup M and Kolassa IT (2014) The effect of trauma-focused therapy on the altered T cell distribution in individuals with PTSD: evidence from a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Psychiatric Research 54, 1–10.
    1. Neuner F, Schauer M, Klaschik C and Elbert T (2004) A comparison of narrative exposure therapy, supportive counseling, and psychoeducation for treating posttraumatic stress disorder in an African refugee settlement. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 72, 579–587.
    1. Neuner F, Onyut PL, Ertl V, Odenwald M, Schauer E and Elbert T (2008) Treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder by trained lay counselors in an African refugee settlement: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 76, 686–694.
    1. Neuner F, Kurreck S, Ruf M, Odenwald M, Elbert T and Schauer M (2010) Can asylum-seekers with posttraumatic stress disorder be successfully treated? A randomized controlled pilot study. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy 39, 81–91.
    1. Nosè M, Ballette F, Bighelli I, Turrini G, Purgato M, Tol W, Priebe S and Barbui C (2017) Psychosocial interventions for post-traumatic stress disorder in refugees and asylum seekers resettled in high-income countries: systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 12, 1–16.
    1. Ooi CS, Rooney RM, Roberts C, Kane RT, Wright B and Chatzisarantis N (2016) The efficacy of a group cognitive behavioral therapy for war-affected young migrants living in Australia: a cluster randomized controlled trial. Frontiers in Psychology 7, 1–14.
    1. Orsini N, Bottai M, Higgins J and Buchan I (2006) HETEROGI: Stata Module to Quantify Heterogeneity in a Meta-Analysis. Boston: Statistical Software Components S449201, Boston College Department of Economics; Available at: .
    1. Otto MW, Hinton D, Korbly NB, Chea A, Ba P, Gershuny BS and Pollack MH (2003) Treatment of pharmacotherapy-refractory posttraumatic stress disorder among Cambodian refugees: a pilot study of combination treatment with cognitive-behavior therapy v. sertraline alone. Behaviour Research and Therapy 41, 1271–1276.
    1. Priebe S and Giacco D and El-Nagib R (2016) Public Health Aspects of Mental Health among Migrants and Refugees: A Review of the Evidence on Mental Health Care for Refugees, Asylum Seekers and Irregular Migrants in the WHO European Region. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office; Available at (Accessed 7 May 2018).
    1. Purgato M, Gastaldon C, Papola D, van Ommeren M, Barbui C and Tol WA (2015) Psychological therapies for the treatment of mental disorders in low- and middle-income countries affected by humanitarian crises. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 7, 1–258.
    1. Purgato M, Gross AL, Betancourt T, Bolton P, Bonetto C, Gastaldon C, Gordon J, O'Callaghan P, Papola D, Peltronen K, Punamaki RL, Richards J, Staples JK, Unterhitzenberger J, van Ommeren M, de Jong J, Jordans MJD, Tol WA and Barbui C (2018) Focused psychosocial interventions for children in low-resource humanitarian settings: a systematic review and individual participant data meta-analysis. The Lancet Global Health 6, e390–e400.
    1. Rahman A, Riaz N, Dawson KS, Usman Hamdani S, Chiumento A, Sijbrandij M, Minhas F, Bryant RA, Saeed K, van Ommeren M and Farooq S (2016) Problem management plus (PM+): pilot trial of a WHO transdiagnostic psychological intervention in conflict-affected Pakistan. World Psychiatry 15, 182–183.
    1. Renner W, Huber EB and Peltzer K (2011) Culture-Sensitive and Resource Oriented Peer (CROP) – groups as a community based intervention for trauma survivors: a randomized controlled pilot study with refugees and asylum seekers from Chechnya. Australasian Journal of Disaster and Trauma Studies 1, 1–13.
    1. RevMan; version 5.3.5; Review Manager (RevMan) [Computer program]. Version 5.3 (2014) Copenhagen: The Nordic Cochrane Centre: The Cochrane Collaboration.
    1. Ruf M, Schauer M, Neuner F, Catani C, Schauer E and Elbert T (2010) Narrative exposure therapy for 7- to 16-year-olds: a randomized controlled trial with traumatized refugee children. Journal of Traumatic Stress 23, 437–445.
    1. Sijbrandij M (2018) Expanding the evidence: key priorities for research on mental health interventions for refugees in high-income countries. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences 27, 105–108.
    1. StataCorp (2017) Stata Statistical Software: Release 15. (n.d.) (2017) College Station, TX: StataCorp LLC Available at: .
    1. Stenmark H, Catani C, Neuner F, Elbert T and Holen A (2013) Treating PTSD in refugees and asylum seekers within the general health care system. A randomized controlled multicenter study. Behaviour Research and Therapy 51, 641–647.
    1. Ter Heide FJJ, Mooren GTM, Kleijn W, de Jongh A and Kleber RJ (2011) EMDR versus stabilisation in traumatised asylum seekers and refugees: results of a pilot study. European Journal of Psychotraumatology 2, 1–12.
    1. Ter Heide FJJ, Mooren GTM, Van de Schoot R, de Jongh A and Kleber RJ (2016) Eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing therapy v. stabilisation as usual for refugees: randomised controlled trial. The British Journal of Psychiatry 209, 311–318.
    1. Thompson CT, Vidgen A and Roberts NP (2018) Psychological interventions for post-traumatic stress disorder in refugees and asylum seekers: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review 63, 66–79.
    1. Tol WA, Barbui C and van Ommeren M (2013) Management of acute stress, PTSD, and bereavement: WHO recommendations. JAMA 310, 477–478.
    1. Tol WA, Barbui C, Bisson J, Cohen J, Hijazi Z, Jones L, de Jong JT, Magrini N, Omigbodun O, Seedat S, Silove D, Souza R, Sumathipala A, Vijayakumar L, Weissbecker I, Zatzick D and van Ommeren M (2014) World Health Organization Guidelines for management of acute stress, PTSD, and bereavement: key challenges on the road ahead. PLoS Medicine 11, 1–5.
    1. Tribe RH, Sendt KV and Tracy DK (2017) A systematic review of psychosocial interventions for adult refugees and asylum seekers. Journal of Mental Health 12, 1–15.
    1. Turrini G, Purgato M, Ballette F, Nosè M, Ostuzzi G and Barbui C (2017) Common mental disorders in asylum seekers and refugees: umbrella review of prevalence and intervention studies. International Journal of Mental Health Systems 11, 51.
    1. United Nations General Assembly (1951) Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees. Geneva: United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees; Available at (Accessed 3 April 2018).
    1. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (2006) The State of the World's Refugees 2006: Human Displacement in the new Millennium. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
    1. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (2017) Global Trends: Forced Displacement in 2016 Available at (Accessed 18 April 2018).
    1. Van't Hof E, Dawson KS, Schafer A, Chiumento A, Harper Shehadeh M, Sijbrandij M, Bryant RA, Anjuri D, Koyiet P, Ndogoni L, Ulate J and van Ommeren M (2018) A qualitative evaluation of a brief multicomponent intervention provided by lay health workers for women affected by adversity in urban Kenya. Global Mental Health 5, 1–12.
    1. Wampold BE (2015) How important are the common factors in psychotherapy? An update. World Psychiatry 14, 270–277.
    1. Weine S, Kulauzovic Y, Klebic A, Besic S, Mujagic A, Muzurovic J, Spahovic D, Sclove S, Pavkovic I, Feetham S and Rolland J (2008) Evaluating a multiple-family group access intervention for refugees with PTSD. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy 34, 149–164.
    1. Weinstein N, Khabbaz F and Legate N (2016) Enhancing need satisfaction to reduce psychological distress in Syrian refugees. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 84, 645–650.
    1. World Bank (2018) World Bank Country and Lending Groups Available at (Accessed 22 March 2018).

Source: PubMed

Sponsors and Collaborators

Medical Conditions

Drug Interventions

3
Subscribe