A randomized effectiveness study comparing trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy with therapy as usual for youth

Tine K Jensen, Tonje Holt, Silje M Ormhaug, Karina Egeland, Lene Granly, Live C Hoaas, Silje S Hukkelberg, Tore Indregard, Shirley D Stormyren, Tore Wentzel-Larsen, Tine K Jensen, Tonje Holt, Silje M Ormhaug, Karina Egeland, Lene Granly, Live C Hoaas, Silje S Hukkelberg, Tore Indregard, Shirley D Stormyren, Tore Wentzel-Larsen

Abstract

The efficacy of trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy (TF-CBT) has been shown in several randomized controlled trials. However, few trials have been conducted in community clinics, few have used therapy as usual (TAU) as a comparison group, and none have been conducted outside of the United States. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of TF-CBT in regular community settings compared with TAU. One hundred fifty-six traumatized youth (M age = 15.1 years, range = 10-18; 79.5% girls) were randomly assigned to TF-CBT or TAU. Intent-to-treat analysis using mixed effects models showed that youth receiving TF-CBT reported significantly lower levels of posttraumatic stress symptoms (est. = 5.78, d = 0.51), 95% CI [2.32, 9.23]; depression (est. = 7.00, d = 0.54), 95% CI [2.04, 11.96]; and general mental health symptoms (est. = 2.54, d = 0.45), 95% CI [0.50, 4.58], compared with youth in the TAU group. Youth assigned to TF-CBT showed significantly greater improvements in functional impairment (est. = -1.05, d = -0.55), 95% CI [-1.67, -0.42]. Although the same trend was found for anxiety reduction, this difference was not statistically significant (est. = 4.34, d = 0.30), 95% CI [-1.50, 10.19]. Significantly fewer youths in the TF-CBT condition were diagnosed with posttraumatic stress disorder compared to youths in the TAU condition, χ(2)(1, N = 116) = 4.61, p = .031, Phi = .20). Findings indicate that TF-CBT is effective in treating traumatized youth in community mental health clinics and that the program may also be successfully implemented in countries outside the United States.

Figures

FIGURE 1
FIGURE 1
Flow chart: Participants.

References

    1. Ackerman P. T., Newton J. E. O., McPherson W. B., Jones J. G., Dykman R. A. Prevalence of post traumatic stress disorder and other psychiatric diagnoses in three groups of abused children (sexual, physical, and both) Child Abuse & Neglect. 1998;22:759–774. doi: 10.1016/s0145-2134(98)00062-3.
    1. Aickin M., Gensler H. Adjusting for multiple testing when reporting research results: The Bonferroni vs Holm methods. American Journal of Public Health. 1996;86:726–728.
    1. Ajdukovic M. Displaced adolescents in Croatia: Sources of stress and posttraumatic stress reaction. Adolescence. 1998;33:209–217.
    1. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 4th ed. Washington, DC: Author; 1994.
    1. Angold A., Costello E. J., Messer S. C., Pickles A. Development of a short questionnaire for use in epidemiological studies of depression in children and adolescents. International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research. 1995;5:237–249.
    1. Berliner L. The results of randomized clinical trials move the field forward. Child Abuse & Neglect. 2005;29:103–105.
    1. Birmaher B., Brent D. A., Chiappetta L., Bridge J., Monga S., Baugher M. Psychometric properties of the screen for child anxiety related emotional disorders (SCARED): A replication study. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 1999;38:1230–1236.
    1. Cohen J. A., Deblinger E., Mannarino A. P., Steer R. A. A multisite, randomized controlled trial for children with sexual abuse-related PTSD symptoms. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2004;43:393–402.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P. A treatment outcome study for sexually abused preschool children: Initial findings. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 1996;35:42–50.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P. A treatment study for sexually abused preschool children: Outcome during a one-year follow-up. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 1997;36:1228–1235.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P. Interventions for sexually abused children: Initial treatment outcome findings. Child Maltreatment. 1998;3:17–26.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P. Trauma-focused cognitive behavioural therapy for children and parents. Child and Adolescent Mental Health. 2008;13:158–162.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P., Deblinger E. Treating trauma and traumatic grief in children and adolescents. New York, NY: Guilford; 2006.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P., Iyengar S. Community treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder for children exposed to intimate partner violence: A randomized controlled trial. Archives of Pediatrics Adolescent Medicine. 2011;165:16–21.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P., Knudsen K. Treating childhood traumatic grief: A pilot study. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2004;43:1225–1233.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P., Knudsen K. Treating sexually abused children: 1 year follow-up of a randomized controlled trial. Child Abuse & Neglect. 2005;29:135–145.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P., Perel J. M., Staron V. A Pilot randomized controlled trial of combined trauma-focused CBT and sertraline for childhood PTSD symptoms. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2007;46:811–819. doi: 10.1097/chi.0b013e3180547105.
    1. Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P., Staron V. R. A Pilot study of modified cognitive-behavioral therapy for childhood traumatic grief (CBT-CTG) Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2006;45:1465–1473.
    1. Connolly D., McClowry S., Hayman L., Mahony L., Artman M. Posttraumatic stress disorder in children after cardiac surgery. The Journal of Pediatrics. 2004;144:480–484.
    1. Copeland W. E., Keeler G., Angold A., Costello E. J. Traumatic events and posttraumatic stress in childhood. Archives of General Psychiatry. 2007;64:577–584.
    1. Deblinger E., Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P., Murray L. A., Epstein C. TF-CBT Fidelity Checklist (Unpublished instrument) Stratford, NJ: UMDNJ-SOM CARES Institute; 2008.
    1. Deblinger E., Lippman J., Steer R. Sexually abused children suffering posttramatic stress symptoms: Initial treatment outcome findings. Child Maltreatment. 1996;1:310–321. doi: 10.1177/1077559596001004003..
    1. Deblinger E., Mannarino A., Cohen J. A., Runyon M. K., Steer R. A. Trauma-focused cognitive behavior therapy for children: Impact of the traumanarrative and treatment length. Depression and Anxiety. 2011;28:67–75. doi: 10.1002/da.20744.
    1. Deblinger E., Mannarino A. P., Cohen J. A., Steer R. A. A follow-up study of a multisite, randomized, controlled trial for children with sexual abuse-related PTSD symptoms. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2006;45:1474–1484.
    1. Deblinger E., Stauffer L., Steer R. Comparative efficacies of supportive and cognitive behavioral group therapies for young children who have been sexually abused and their nonoffending mothers. Child Maltreatment. 2001;6:332–343.
    1. Deblinger E., Steer R. A., Lippmann J. Two-year follow- up study of CBT for sexually abused children suffering posttraumatic stress symptoms. Child Abuse & Neglect. 1999;23:1371–1378.
    1. Dube S. R., Felitti V. J., Dong M., Giles W. H., Anda R. F. The impact of adverse childhood experiences in health problems: Evidence from four birth cohorts dating back to 1900. Preventive Medicine. 2003;37:268–277.
    1. Ehrenreich-May J., Southham-Gerow M. A., Hourigan S. E., Wright L. R., Pincus D. B., Weisz J. R. Characteristics of anxious and depressed youth seen in two different clinical contexts. Administration and Policy in Mental Health. 2011;38:398–411. doi: 10.1007/S10488-010-0328-6.
    1. Famularo R., Fenton T., Kinscherff R., Augustyn M. Psychiatric comorbidity in childhood posttraumatic stress disorder. Child Abuse & Neglect. 1996;20:953–961.
    1. Finkelhor D. The international epidemiology of child sexual abuse. Child Abuse and Neglect. 1994;18:409–117.
    1. Finkelhor D., Ormrod R. K., Turner H. A. Lifetime assessment of poly-victimization in a national sample of children and youth. Child Abuse & Neglect. 2009;33:403–411.
    1. Foa E. B., Johnson K. M., Feeny N. C., Treadwell K. R. The Child PTSD Symptom Scale: A preliminary examination of its psychometric properties. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology. 2001;30(3):376–384.
    1. Ford J. D., Elhai J. D., Connor D. F., Frueh B. C. Poly-victimization and risk of posttraumatic, depressive, and substance use disorders and involvement in delinquency in a national sample of adolescents. The Journal of Adolescent Health. 2010;46:545–552. doi: 10.1016/j.jadohealth.2009.11.212.
    1. Goodman R. Psychometric properties of the strengths and difficulties questionnaire. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2001;40:1337–1345. doi: 10.1097/00004583-200111000-00015.
    1. Hoagwood K. E., Radigan M., Rodriguez J., Levitt J. M. D. F., Foster J. Final report on the Child and Adolescent Trauma Treatment Consortium (CATS) Project for the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. Washington, DC: Department of Health and Human Services; 2006.
    1. Hornik K. The R FAQ. 2012. Retrieved from .
    1. Jaycox L. H., Cohen J. A., Mannarino A. P., Walker D. W., Langley A. K., Gegenheimer K. L., Schonlau M. Children's mental health care following Hurricane Katrina: A field trial of trauma-focused psychotherapies. Journal of Traumatic Stress. 2010;23:223–231.
    1. Jensen T. K., Dyb G., Nygaard E. A longitudinal study of posttraumatic stress reactions in Norwegian children and adolescents exposed to the 2004 tsunami. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine. 2009;163:856–861. doi: 10.1001/archpediatrics.2009.151.
    1. Kazdin A. E. The state of child and adolescent psychotherapy research. Child and Adolescent Mental Health. 2002;7:53–59.
    1. Kerfoot M., Harrington R., Harrington V., Rogers J., Verduyn C. A step too far? Randomized trial of cognitive-behaviour therapy delivered by social workers to depressed adolescents. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2004;13:92–99. doi: 10.1007/s00787-004-0362-6.
    1. Kilpatrick D. G., Ruggiero K. J., Acierno R., Saunders B. E., Resnick H. S., Best C. L. Violence and risk of PTSD, major depression, substance abuse/dependence, and comorbidity: Results from the National Survey of Adolescents. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 2003;71:692–700. doi: 10.1037/0022-006X.71.4.692.
    1. King N. J., Tonge B. J., Mullen P., Myerson N., Heyne D., Rollings S., Ollendick T. H. Treating sexually abused children with posttraumatic stress symptoms: A randomized clinical trial. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2000;39:1347–1355.
    1. La Greca A. M., Silverman W. K., Vernberg E. M., Prinstein M. J. Symptoms of posttraumatic stress in children after Hurricane Andrew: A prospective study. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 1996;64:712–723.
    1. Leykin Y., DeRubeis R. J. Allegiance in psychotherapy outcome research: Separating association from bias. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice. 2009;16:54–65. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2850.2009.01143.x.
    1. Meiser-Stedman R., Smith P., Glucksman E., Yule W., Dalgleish T. The posttraumatic stress disorder diagnosis in preschool- and elementary school-age children exposed to motor vehicle accidents. American Journal of Psychiatry. 2008;165:1326–1337.
    1. Murray L. K., Skavenski S. A. International settings. In: Cohen J. A., Mannarin A. P., Deblinger E., editors. Trauma- focused CBT for children and adolescents. New York, NY: Guilford; 2012. pp. 225–252.
    1. Nader K., Kriegler J. A., Blake D. D., Pynoos R. S., Newman E., Weathers F. Clinician Administered PTSD Scale, Child and Adolescent version (CAPS-C) White River Junction, VT: National Center for PTSD; 1996.
    1. Nader K., Newman E., Weathers F., Kaloupek D. G., Kriegler J., Blake D. Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale for Children and Adolescents (CAPS-CA) Los Angeles, CA: Western Psychological Press; 2004.
    1. Norris F. H., Friedman M. J., Watson P. J. 60,000 disaster victims speak: Part II. Summary and implications of the disaster mental health research. Psychiatry. 2002;65:240–260.
    1. Pinheiro J., Bates D. Mixed effects models in S and S-Plus. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag; 2000.
    1. Ribbe D. Psychometric review of Traumatic Event Screening Instrument for Children (TESI-C) In: Stamm B. H., editor. Measurement of stress, trauma, and adaptation. Lutherville, MD: Sidran Press; 1996. pp. 386–387.
    1. Rønning J., Handegaard B., Sourander A., Mørch W.-T. The Strengths and Difficulties Self-Report Questionnaire as a screening instrument in Norwegian community samples. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 2004;13:73–82. doi: 10.1007/s00787-004-0356-4.
    1. Saigh P. A., Yasyk A. E., Oberfield R. A., Halamandaris P. V., McHugh M. An analysis of the internalizing and externalizing behaviors of traumatized urban youth with and without PTSD. Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 2002;111:462–170.
    1. Saunders B. E., Hanson R. F. Innovative methods for implementing evidence supported interventions for mental health treatment of child and adolescent victims of violence. In: Reece R. M., Hanson R. F., Sargent J., editors. Treatment of child abuse: Common ground for mental health, medical and legal practitioners. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press;
    1. Saxe G. N., Stodard F., Hall E., Chawly N., Lopez C., Sheridan R., Yehuda R. Pathways to PTSD, Part I: Children with burns. American Journal of Psychiatry. 2005;162:1299–1304.
    1. Scheeringa M. S., Weems C. F., Cohen J. A., Amaya-Jackson L., Guthrie D. Trauma-focused cognitive-behavioral therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder in three through six year-old children: A randomized clinical trial. The Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. 2011;52:853–860.
    1. Schoenwald S. K., Hoagwood K. Effectiveness, transportability, and dissemination of interventions: What matters when? Psychiatric Services. 2001;52:1190–1197.
    1. Shirk S. R., Karver M. S., Brown R. The alliance in child and adolescent psychotherapy. Psychotherapy. 2011;48:17–24. doi: 10.1037/a0022181.
    1. Silverman W. K., Ortiz C. D., Viswesvaran C., Burns B. J., Kolko D., Putnam F. W., Amaya-Jackson L. Evidence-based psychosocial treatments for children and adolescents exposed to traumatic events. Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology. 2008;37:156–183.
    1. Southam-Gerow M. A., Rodríguez A., Chorpita B. F., Daleiden E. L. Dissemination and implementation of evidence based treatments for youth: Challenges and recommendations. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice. 2012;43:527–534.
    1. Southham-Gerow M. A., Weisz J. R., Kendall P. C. Youth with anxiety disorders in research and service clinics: Examining client differences and similarities. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology. 2003;32:375–385.
    1. Wampold B. E., Mondin G. W., Moody M., Stich F., Benson K., Ahn H. A metaanalysis of outcome studies comparing bona fida psychotherapies: Empirically, “all must have prizes. Psychological Bulletin. 1997;122:203–215.
    1. Weathers F. W., Ruscio A. M., Keane T. M. Psychometric properties of nine scoring rules for the Clinician-Administered Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Scale. Psychological Assessment. 1999;11:124–133.
    1. Weisz J. R., Addis M. E. The research-practice tango and other choreographic challenges: Using and testing evidence-based psychotherapies in clinical care settings. In: Goodheart C. D., Kazdin A. E., Sternberg R. J., editors. Evidence-based psychotherapy: Where practice and research meet. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association; 2006. pp. 179–206.
    1. Weisz J. R., Gray J. S. Evidence-based psychotherapy for children and adolescents: Data from the present and a model for the future. Child and Adolescent Mental Health. 2008;13:54–65. doi: 10.1111/j.l475-3588.2007.00475.x.
    1. Weisz J. R., Southam-Gerow M. A., Cordis E. B., Connor-Smith J. K., Chu B. C, Langer D. A., Weiss B. Cognitive-behavioral therapy versus usual clinical care for youth depression: An initial test of transportability to community clinics and clinicians. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 2009;77:383–396. doi: 10.1037/a0013877.
    1. Wise E. A. Methods for analyzing psychotherapy outcomes: A review of clinical significance, reliable change, and recommendations for future directions. Journal of Personality Assessment. 2004;82:50–59. doi: 10.1207/sl5327752jpa8201_10.

Source: PubMed

Sponsoren und Mitarbeiter

Krankheiten

Drogeninterventionen

3
Abonnieren