Perceived racial discrimination and hypertension: a comprehensive systematic review

Abstract

Objective: Discrimination is posited to underlie racial disparities in hypertension. Extant literature suggests a possible association between racial discrimination and blood pressure, although inconsistent findings have been reported. The aim of this comprehensive systematic review was to quantitatively evaluate the association between perceived racial discrimination with hypertensive status and systolic, diastolic, and ambulatory blood pressure.

Method: Electronic database search of PubMed and PsycINFO (keywords: blood pressure/hypertension/diastolic/systolic, racism/discrimination/prejudice/unfair treatment) was combined with descendancy and ascendancy approaches. Forty-four articles (N = 32,651) met inclusion criteria. Articles were coded for demographics, hypertensive diagnosis, blood pressure measurement, discrimination measure and constructs, study quality, and effect sizes.

Results: Random effects meta-analytic models were tested based on Fisher's Z, the derived common effect size metric. Overall, perceived racial discrimination was associated with hypertensive status, Zhypertension = 0.048, 95% CI [.013, .087], but not with resting blood pressure, Zsystolic = 0.011, 95% CI [-.006, .031], Zdiastolic = .016, 95% CI [-.006, .034]. Moderators that strengthened the relation included sex (male), race (Black), age (older), education (lower), and hypertensive status. Perceived discrimination was most strongly associated with nighttime ambulatory blood pressure, especially among Blacks.

Conclusions: Despite methodological limitations in the existing literature, there was a small, significant association between perceived discrimination and hypertension. Future studies should consider ambulatory nighttime blood pressure, which may more accurately capture daily variation attributable to experienced racial discrimination. Perceived discrimination may partly explain racial health disparities.

2014 APA, all rights reserved

Figures

Figure 1

Flow chart for article identification and inclusion.

Figure 2

Forest Plot of Effect Sizes for Perceived Racial Discrimination and Hypertension (Hypertensive Status, Resting Systolic Blood Pressure, Nighttime Systolic Blood Pressure, Resting Diastolic Blood Pressure, Nighttime Diastolic Blood Pressure).

Figure 2

Forest Plot of Effect Sizes for Perceived Racial Discrimination and Hypertension (Hypertensive Status, Resting Systolic Blood Pressure, Nighttime Systolic Blood Pressure, Resting Diastolic Blood Pressure, Nighttime Diastolic Blood Pressure).