Insecurity, distress and mental health: experimental and randomized controlled trials of a psychosocial intervention for youth affected by the Syrian crisis

Catherine Panter-Brick, Rana Dajani, Mark Eggerman, Sabrina Hermosilla, Amelia Sancilio, Alastair Ager, Catherine Panter-Brick, Rana Dajani, Mark Eggerman, Sabrina Hermosilla, Amelia Sancilio, Alastair Ager

Abstract

Background: Strengthening the evidence base for humanitarian interventions that provide psychosocial support to war-affected youth is a key priority. We tested the impacts of an 8-week programme of structured activities informed by a profound stress attunement (PSA) framework (Advancing Adolescents), delivered in group-format to 12-18 year-olds in communities heavily affected by the Syrian crisis. We included both Syrian refugee and Jordanian youth.

Methods: We followed an experimental design, comparing treatment youth and wait-list controls over two programme implementation cycles, randomizing to study arm in cycle 2 (ClinicalTrials.gov ID: NCT03012451). We measured insecurity, distress, mental health difficulties, prosocial behaviour and post-traumatic stress symptoms at three time-points: baseline (n = 817 youth; 55% Syrian, 43% female), postintervention (n = 463; 54% Syrian, 47% female), and follow-up (n = 212, 58% Syrian, 43% female). Regression models assessed: prospective intervention impacts, adjusting for baseline scores, trauma exposure, age, and gender; differential impacts across levels of trauma exposure and activity-based modality; and sustained recovery 1 year later. We analysed cycle-specific and cycle-pooled data for youth exclusively engaged in Advancing Adolescents and for the intent-to-treat sample.

Results: We found medium to small effect sizes for all psychosocial outcomes, namely Human Insecurity (β = -7.04 (95% CI: -10.90, -3.17), Cohen's d = -0.4), Human Distress (β = -5.78 (-9.02, -2.54), d = -0.3), and Perceived Stress (β = -1.92 (-3.05, -0.79), d = -0.3); and two secondary mental health outcomes (AYMH: β = -3.35 (-4.68, -2.02), d = -0.4; SDQ: β = -1.46 (-2.42, -0.50), d = -0.2). We found no programme impacts for prosocial behaviour or post-traumatic stress reactions. Beneficial impacts were stronger for youth with exposure to four trauma events or more. While symptoms alleviated for both intervention and control groups over time, there were sustained effects of the intervention on Human Insecurity.

Conclusions: Findings strengthen the evidence base for mental health and psychosocial programming for a generation affected by conflict and forced displacement. We discuss implications for programme implementation and evaluation research.

Keywords: Mental health and psychosocial support; evaluation; forced displacement; implementation science; refugees; war.

© 2017 The Authors. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.

Figures

Figure 1
Figure 1
Study design and sample frame [Colour figure can be viewed at http://wileyonlinelibrary.com]
Figure 2
Figure 2
Primary health outcomes, pre/postintervention symptom scores (n = 463). Significance levels are for differences across time, within treatment and within control groups [Colour figure can be viewed at http://wileyonlinelibrary.com]

References

    1. Ager, A. , Ager, W. , Stavrou, V. , & Boothby, N. (2011). Inter‐agency guide for the evaluation of psychosocial programming in humanitarian crises. New York: UNICEF.
    1. Ager, A. , Burnham, G. , Checchi, F. , Gayer, M. , Grais, R. , Henkens, M. , … & Spiegel, P. (2014). Strengthening the evidence base for health programming in humanitarian crises. Science, 345, 1290–1292.
    1. Ager, A. , & Metzler, J. (2017). Where there is no intervention: Insights into processes of resilience supporting war‐affected children. Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology, 23, 67–75.
    1. Ager, A. , Metzler, J. , Vojta, M. , & Savage, K. (2013). Child friendly spaces: A systematic review of the current evidence‐base on outcomes and impact. Intervention, 11, 133–147.
    1. Almadi, T. , Cathers, I. , Mansour, A. , & Chow, C. (2012). An Arabic version of the perceived stress scale: Translation and validation study. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 49, 84–89.
    1. Almaqrami, M.H. , & Shuwail, A.Y. (2004). Validity of the self‐report version of the strengths and difficulties questionnaire in Yemen. Saudi Medical Journal, 25, 592–601.
    1. Alyahri, A. , & Goodman, R. (2006). Validation of the Arabic strengths and difficulties questionnaire and the development and well‐being assessment. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal, 12(Suppl. 2), S138–S146.
    1. Annan, J. , Sim, A. , Puffer, E. , Salhi, C. , & Betancourt, T. (2016). Improving mental health outcomes of Burmese migrant and displaced children in Thailand: A community‐based randomized controlled trial of a parenting and family skills intervention. Prevention Science, 18, 793–803.
    1. Bangpan, M. , Dickson, K. , Felix, L. , & Chiumento, A. (2017). The impact of mental health and psychosocial support interventions on people affected by humanitarian emergencies: A systematic review humanitarian evidence programme. Oxford: Oxfam GB.
    1. Barber, B. , McNeely, C. , Allen, C. , Giacaman, R. , Arafat, C. , Daher, M. , … & Belli, R. (2016). Whither the “children of the stone”? An entire life under occupation. Journal of Palestine Studies, 45, 77–108.
    1. Betancourt, T. , & Khan, K. (2008). The mental health of children affected by armed conflict: Protective processes and pathways to resilience. International Review of Psychiatry, 20, 317–328.
    1. Betancourt, T. , McBain, R. , Newnham, E. , Akinsulure‐Smith, A. , Brennan, R. , Weisz, J. , & Hansen, N. (2014). A behavioral intervention for war‐affected youth in Sierra Leone: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 53, 1288–1297.
    1. Betancourt, T.S. , McBain, R. , Newnham, E. , & Brennan, R. (2013a). Trajectories of internalizing problems in war‐affected Sierra Leonean youth: Examining conflict and post‐conflict factors. Child Development, 84, 455–470.
    1. Betancourt, T.S. , Meyers‐Ohki, S.E. , Charrow, A.P. , & Tol, W.A. (2013b). Interventions for children affected by war: An ecological perspective on psychosocial support and mental health care. Harvard Review of Psychiatry, 21, 70–91.
    1. Blanchet, K. , Sistenich, V. , Ramesh, A. , Frison, S. , Warren, E. , Smith, J. , … & Roberts, B. (2015). An evidence review of research on health interventions in humanitarian crises. London: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, Harvard School of Public Health & Overseas Development Institute.
    1. Bolton, P. , Bass, J. , Betancourt, T. , Speelman, L. , Onuango, G. , Clougherty, K. , … & Verdeli, H. (2007). Interventions for depression symptoms among adolescent survivors of war and displacement in northern Uganda: A randomized controlled trial. JAMA, 298, 519–527.
    1. Brown, F. , de Graaff, A. , Annan, J. , & Betancourt, T. (2017). Annual Research Review: Breaking cycles of violence – a systematic review and common practice elements analysis of psychosocial interventions for children and youth affected by armed conflict. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 58, 507–524.
    1. Dajani, R. , Hadfield, K. , van Uum, S. , Greff, M. , & Panter‐Brick, C. (under review). Scalp hair cortisol in adolescents affected by the Syrian crisis: Trauma, insecurity, and humanitarian intervention impacts over time. Psychoneuroendocrinology.
    1. Das, J. , Salam, R. , Lassi, Z. , Khan, M. , Mahmood, W. , Patel, V. , & Bhutta, Z. (2016). Interventions for adolescent mental health: An overview of systematic reviews. Journal of Adolescent Health, 59, S49–S60.
    1. Dua, T. , Barbui, C. , Clark, N. , Fleischmann, A. , Poznyak, V. , van Ommeren, M. , … & Saxena, S. (2011). Evidence‐based guidelines for mental, neurological, and substance use disorders in low‐ and middle‐income countries: Summary of WHO recommendations. PLOS Medicine, 8, e1001122.
    1. Durlak, J. (2008). Implementation matters: A review of research on the influence of implemetation on program outcomes and the factors affecting implementation. American Journal of Community Psychology, 41, 327–350.
    1. Ehntholt, K. , & Yule, W. (2006). Practitioner review: Assessment and treatment of refugee children and adolescents who have experienced war‐related trauma. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 47, 1197–1210.
    1. Fazel, M. , Reed, R. , Panter‐Brick, C. , & Stein, A. (2011). Mental health of displaced and refugee children resettled in high‐income countries: Risk and protective factors. Lancet, 379, 266–282.
    1. Felliti, V. (2002). The relation between adverse childhood experiences and adult health: Turning gold into lead. Permanente Journal, 6, 44–47.
    1. Garner, A.S. , & Shonkoff, J.P. (2012). Early childhood adversity, toxic stress, and the role of the pediatrician: Translating developmental science into lifelong health. Pediatrics, 129, e224–e231.
    1. Garrido, M.M. , Kelley, A.S. , Paris, J. , Roza, K. , Meier, D.E. , Morrison, R.S. , & Aldridge, M.D. (2014). Methods for constructing and assessing propensity scores. Health Services Research, 49, 1701–1720.
    1. Giordano, F. , Boerchi, D. , Hurtubia, V. , Maragel, M. , Koteir, W. , Yazbek, L. , & Castelli, C. (2014). Risk and protection in mental health among Syrian children displaced in Lebanon. Paper presented at the Second World Congress on Resilience: From Person to Society. Timişoara, Romania.
    1. Goodman, A. , & Goodman, R. (2009). Strengths and difficulties questionnaire as a dimensional measure of child mental health. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 48, 400–403.
    1. Hamayel, L. , Ghandour, R. , Abu Rmeileh, N. , & Giacaman, R. (2014). Assessment of the psychosocial health status of adolescents 12–18 years old in the occupied Palestinian Territory: A cross sectional baseline survey. Birzeit, West Bank, Palestine: Institute of Community and Public Health, Birzeit University.
    1. Hassan, G. , Ventevogel, P. , Jefee‐Bahloul, H. , Barkil‐Oteo, A. , & Kirmayer, L. (2016). Mental health and psychosocial wellbeing of Syrians affected by armed conflict. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences, 25, 129–141.
    1. Hundeide, K. (2013). An introduction to the ICDP Programme. Available from: [last accessed 15 May 2017].
    1. Imbens, G. , & Lemieux, T. (2008). Regression discontinuity designs: A guide to practice. Journal of Econometrics, 142, 615–635.
    1. Jordans, M. , Komproe, I. , Tol, W. , Kohrt, B. , Luitel, N. , Macy, R. , & de Jong, J. (2010). Evaluation of a classroom‐based psychosocial intervention in conflict‐affected Nepal: A cluster randomized controlled trial. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 51, 818–826.
    1. Jordans, M. , Tol, W. , Komproe, I. , & de Jong, J. (2009). Systematic review of evidence and treatment approaches: Psychosocial and mental health care for children in war. Child and Adolescent Mental Health, 14, 2–14.
    1. Kessler, R. , McLaughlin, K. , Green, J. , Gruber, M. , Sampson, N. , Zaslavsky, A. , … & Williams, D. (2010). Childhood adversities and adult psychopathology in the WHO World Mental Health Surveys. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 197, 378–385.
    1. Kurtz, J. (2016). Advancing adolescents: Evidence on the impact of psychosocial support for Syrian refugee and Jordanian adolescents. Portland, OR: Mercy Corps.
    1. Leckman, J. , Panter‐Brick, C. , & Saleh, R. (2014). Human biological development and peace – Genes, brains, safety, and justice In Strüngmann Forum Report (Ed.), Pathways to peace: The transformative power of children and families (pp. 95–128). Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
    1. Macphail, J. , Niconchuk, M. , & El‐wer, N. (2017). Conflict, the brain, and community: A neurobiology‐informed approach to resilience and community development In Phillips R., Kenny S., & McGrath B. (Eds.), The Routledge handbook of community development perspectives from around the globe (pp. 340–357). London: Taylor & Francis Ltd.
    1. Mahfoud, Z. , Abdulrahim, S. , Taha, M. , Harpham, T. , El Hajj, T. , Makhoul, J. , … & Afifi, R. (2011). Validation of the Arab Youth Mental Health scale as a screening tool for depression/anxiety for Lebanese children. Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Mental Health, 5, 9
    1. Mercy Corps . (2014a). Advancing adolescents approach: resilience to keep adolescents safe, learning and valued – Lebanon, Jordan & Syria. Unpublished.
    1. Mercy Corps . (2014b). Advancing Adolescents: Getting Syrian refugee and host‐community adolescents back on track. Portland, Oregon.
    1. Mercy Corps . (2016). NUBADER advancing the next generation: Final evaluation report. Unpublished.
    1. Metzler, J. , & Ager, A. (2015). Evaluation of child friendly spaces: Ethiopia field study summary report.
    1. Metzler, J. , Savage, K. , Yamano, M. , & Ager, A. (2015). Evaluation of child friendly spaces: An inter‐agency series of impact evaluations in humanitarian emergencies. New York and Geneva: Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health and World Vision International.
    1. Muris, P. , Meesters, C. , & van den Berg, F. (2003). The Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ)—further evidence for its reliability and validity in a community sample of Dutch children and adolescents. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 12, 1–8.
    1. Murphy, K.M. , Rodrigues, K. , Costigan, J. , & Annan, J. (2017). Raising children in conflict: An integrative model of parenting in war. Peace and Conflict, 23, 46–57.
    1. Murray, L. , Tol, W. , Jordans, M. , Sabir, G. , Amin, A.M. , Bolton, P. , & Thornicroft, G. (2014). Dissemination and implementation of evidence based, mental health interventions in post conflict, low resource settings. Intervention, 12, 94–112.
    1. Newnham, E.A. , McBain, R.K. , Hann, K. , Akinsulure‐Smith, A.M. , Weisz, J. , Lilienthal, G.M. , … Betancourt, T.S. (2015). The youth readiness intervention for war‐affected youth. Journal of Adolescent Health, 56, 606–611.
    1. No Lost Generation . (2016). No Lost Generation January–December 2016. Available from: : [last accessed 22 September 2017].
    1. Panter‐Brick, C. , Eggerman, M. , Gonzalez, V. , & Safdar, S. (2009). Violence, suffering, and mental health in Afghanistan: A school‐based survey. Lancet, 374, 807–886.
    1. Panter‐Brick, C. , Grimon, M.‐P. , & Eggerman, M. (2014). Caregiver‐child mental health: A prospective study in conflict and refugee settings. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 55, 313–327.
    1. Panter‐Brick, C. , Hadfield, K. , Dajani, R. , Eggerman, M. , Ager, A. , & Ungar, M. (2017). Resilience in context: A brief and culturally‐grounded measure in Syrian refugees and Jordanian host‐community adolescents. Child Development. Advanced online publication.
    1. Patel, V. (2014). Rethinking mental health care: Bridging the credibility gap. Intervention, 12, 15–20.
    1. Punamäki, R.L. , Palosaari, E. , Diab, M. , Peltonen, K. , & Qouta, S.R. (2015). Trajectories of posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) after major war among Palestinian children: Trauma, family‐and child‐related predictors. Journal of Affective Disorders, 172, 133–140.
    1. Quosh, C. , Eloul, L. , & Ajlani, R. (2013). Mental health of refugees and displaced persons in Syria and surrounding countries: A systematic review. Intervention, 11, 276–294.
    1. Rahman, A. , Hamdani, S. , Awan, N. , Bryant, R. , Dawson, K. , Khan, M. , … & van Ommeren, M. (2016). Effect of a multicomponent behavioral intervention in adults impaired by psychological distress in a conflict‐affected area of Pakistan: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA, 316, 2609–2617.
    1. Reed, R. , Fazel, M. , Jones, L. , Panter‐Brick, C. , & Stein, A. (2011). Mental health of displaced and refugee children resettled in low and middle‐income countries: Risk and protective factors. Lancet, 379, 250–265.
    1. Resnick, M. , Catalano, R. , Sawyer, S. , Viner, R. , & Patton, G. (2012). Seizing the opportunities of adolescent health. Lancet, 379, 1564–1567.
    1. Sami, S. , Williams, H. , Krause, S. , Onyango, M. , Burton, A. , & Tomczyk, B. (2014). Responding to the Syrian crisis: The needs of women and girls. Lancet, 383, 1179–1181.
    1. Save The Children (2017). Invisible Wounds. Available from: . [last accessed 22 September 2017].
    1. Shonkoff, J.P. , Garner, A.S. , Siegel, B.S. , Dobbins, M.I. , Earls, M.F. , McGuinn, L. , … & Wood, D. (2012). The lifelong effects of early childhood adversity and toxic stress. Pediatrics, 129, e232–e246.
    1. Terwee, C.B. , Bot, S. , de Boer, M. , van der Windt, D. , Knol, D. , Dekker, J. , … & de Vet, H. (2007). Quality criteria were proposed for measurement properties of health status questionnaires. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 60, 34–42.
    1. Thabet, A.A. , Stretch, D. , & Vostanis, P. (2000). Child mental health problems in Arab children: Application of the strengths and difficulties questionnaire. International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 46, 266–280.
    1. Tol, W. , Barbui, C. , Galappatti, A. , Silove, D. , Betancourt, T. , Souza, R. , … & van Ommeren, M. (2011). Mental health and psychosocial support in humanitarian settings: Linking practice and research. Lancet, 378, 1581–1591.
    1. Tol, W.A. , Song, S. , & Jordans, M.J.D. (2013). Annual Research Review: Resilience in children and adolescents living in areas of armed conflict: A systematic review of findings in low‐ and middle‐income countries. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 54, 445–460.
    1. UNHCR . (2017). Syrian regional refugee response in Jordan. Available from: [last accessed 22 September 2017].
    1. UNHCR Jordan . (2015). Jordan refugee response: Vulnerability assessment framework baseline survey. Jordan: UNHCR; Available from: [last accessed 22 September 2017].
    1. Veronese, G. , & Pepe, A. (2013). Psychometric properties of IES‐R, short Arabic version in contexts of military violence. Research on Social Work Practice, 23, 710–718.
    1. Viner, R. , Ozer, E. , Denny, S. , Marmot, M. , Resnick, M. , Fatusi, A. , & Currie, C. (2012). Adolescence and the social determinants of health. Lancet, 379, 1641–1652.
    1. Ziadni, M. , Hammoudeh, W. , Abu Rmeileh, N. , Hogan, D. , Shannon, H. , & Giacaman, R. (2011). Sources of human insecurity in post‐war situations: The case of Gaza. Journal of Human Security, 7, 23–36.

Source: PubMed

Patrocinadores y Colaboradores

Condiciones médicas

Intervenciones de drogas

3
Suscribir