Evidence-based treatment recommendations for neck and low back pain across Europe: A systematic review of guidelines

Nadia Corp, Gemma Mansell, Siobhán Stynes, Gwenllian Wynne-Jones, Lars Morsø, Jonathan C Hill, Danielle A van der Windt, Nadia Corp, Gemma Mansell, Siobhán Stynes, Gwenllian Wynne-Jones, Lars Morsø, Jonathan C Hill, Danielle A van der Windt

Abstract

Background and objective: This systematic review synthesized evidence from European neck and low back pain (NLBP) clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) to identify recommended treatment options for use across Europe.

Databases and data treatment: Comprehensive searches of thirteen databases were conducted, from 1st January 2013 to 4th May 2020 to identify up-to-date evidence-based European CPGs for primary care management of NLBP, issued by professional bodies/organizations. Data extracted included; aim and target population, methods for development and implementation and treatment recommendations. The AGREE II checklist was used to critically appraise guidelines. Criteria were devised to summarize and synthesize the direction and strength of recommendations across guidelines.

Results: Seventeen CPGs (11 low back; 5 neck; 1 both) from eight European countries were identified, of which seven were high quality. For neck pain, there were consistent weak or moderate strength recommendations for: reassurance, advice and education, manual therapy, referral for exercise therapy/programme, oral analgesics and topical medications, plus psychological therapies or multidisciplinary treatment for specific subgroups. Notable recommendation differences between back and neck pain included, i) analgesics for neck pain (not for back pain); ii) options for back pain-specific subgroups-work-based interventions, return to work advice/programmes and surgical interventions (but not for neck pain) and iii) a greater strength of recommendations (generally moderate or strong) for back pain than those for neck pain.

Conclusions: This review of European CPGs identified a range of mainly non-pharmacological recommended treatment options for NLBP that have broad consensus for use across Europe.

Significance: Consensus regarding evidence-based treatment recommendations for patients with neck and low back pain (NLBP) from recent European clinical practice guidelines identifies a wide range of predominantly non-pharmacological treatment options. This includes options potentially applicable to all patients with NLBP and those applicable to only specific patient subgroups. Future work within our Back-UP research team will transfer these evidence-based treatment options to an accessible clinician decision support tool for first contact clinicians.

Conflict of interest statement

The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.

© 2020 The Authors. European Journal of Pain published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of European Pain Federation - EFIC ®.

Figures

Figure 1
Figure 1
PRISMA Flow Diagram

References

    1. AGREE Next Steps Consortium (2017). The AGREE II Instrument [Electronic version]. Retrieved from
    1. Babatunde, O. O. , Jordan, J. L. , Van der Windt, D. A. , Hill, J. C. , Foster, N. E. , & Protheroe, J. (2017). Effective treatment options for musculoskeletal pain in primary care: A systematic overview of current evidence. PLoS One, 12, e0178621 10.1371/journal.pone.0178621
    1. Bier, J. D. , Scholten‐Peeters, G. G. M. , Staal, J. B. , Pool, J. , Van Tulder, M. , Beekman, E. , Meerhoff, G. M. , Knoop, J. , & Verhagen, A. P. (2016). KNGF‐richtlijn Nekpijn: Praktijkrichtlijn [KNGF clinical practice guideline for physical therapy in patients with neck pain], Amersfoort, Netherlands: Koninklijk Nederlands Genootschap voor Fysiotherapie (KNGF).
    1. Bons, S. C. S. , Borg, M. A. J. P. , van den Donk, M. , Koes, B. W. , Kuijpers, T. , Ostelo, R. W. J. G. , Schaafstra, A. , Spinnewijn, W. E. M. , Verburg‐Oorthuizen, A. F. E. , & Verweij, H. A. (2017). NHG Standaard Aspecifieke lagerugpijn (tweede herziening) [NHG Standard Non‐specific lower back pain (2nd Revision)]. Huisarts En Wetenschap, 60, 2–31.
    1. Bot, S. D. , van der Waal, J. M. , Terwee, C. B. , van der Windt, D. A. , Schellevis, F. G. , Bouter, L. M. , & Dekker, J. (2005). Incidence and prevalence of complaints of the neck and upper extremity in general practice. Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases, 64, 118–123. 10.1136/ard.2003.019349
    1. Bouwmeester, W. , van Enst, A. , & van Tulder, M. (2009). Quality of low back pain guidelines improved. Spine, 34, 2562–2567. 10.1097/BRS.0b013e3181b4d50d
    1. Brouwers, M. C. , Kho, M. E. , Browman, G. P. , Burgers, J. S. , Cluzeau, F. , Feder, G. , Fervers, B. , Graham, I. D. , Grimshaw, J. , Hanna, S. E. , Littlejohns, P. , Makarski, J. , & Zitzelsberger, L. ; Agree Next Steps Consortium (2010a). AGREE II: Advancing guideline development, reporting and evaluation in health care. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 182, E839–842. 10.1503/cmaj.090449
    1. Brouwers, M. C. , Kho, M. E. , Browman, G. P. , Burgers, J. S. , Cluzeau, F. , Feder, G. , Fervers, B. , Graham, I. D. , Hanna, S. E. , & Makarski, J. ; Agree Next Steps Consortium (2010b). Development of the AGREE II, part 1: Performance, usefulness and areas for improvement. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 182, 1045–1052. 10.1503/cmaj.091714
    1. Brouwers, M. C. , Kho, M. E. , Browman, G. P. , Burgers, J. S. , Cluzeau, F. , Feder, G. , Fervers, B. , Graham, I. D. , Hanna, S. E. , & Makarski, J. ; Agree Next Steps Consortium (2010c). Development of the AGREE II, part 2: Assessment of validity of items and tools to support application. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 182, E472–478. 10.1503/cmaj.091716
    1. Bundesärztekammer (BÄK) , Kassenärztliche Bundesvereinigung (KBV) , & Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Wissenschaftlichen Medizinischen Fachgesellschaften (AWMF) . (2017). Nationale VersorgungsLeitlinie Nicht‐spezifischer Kreuzschmerz – Langfassung, 2. Auflage. Version 1. [National Guideline: Non‐specific low back pain. Long version: 2nd edition, version 1].
    1. Chou, R. , Deyo, R. , Friedly, J. , Skelly, A. , Hashimoto, R. , Weimer, M. , Fu, R. , Dana, T. , Kraegel, P. , Griffin, J. , Grusing, S. , & Brodt, E. (2016). Noninvasive Treatments for Low Back Pain In: AHRQ Comparative Effectiveness Reviews, No 169 Rockville (MD): Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (US).
    1. Chou, R. , Deyo, R. , Friedly, J. , Skelly, A. , Hashimoto, R. , Weimer, M. , Fu, R. , Dana, T. , Kraegel, P. , Griffin, J. , Grusing, S. , & Brodt, E. D. (2017a). Nonpharmacologic therapies for low back pain: A systematic review for an American college of physicians clinical practice guideline. Annals of Internal Medicine, 166, 493–505. 10.7326/M16-2459
    1. Chou, R. , Deyo, R. , Friedly, J. , Skelly, A. , Weimer, M. , Fu, R. , Dana, T. , Kraegel, P. , Griffin, J. , & Grusing, S. (2017b). Systemic pharmacologic therapies for low back pain: A systematic review for an american college of physicians clinical practice guideline. Annals of Internal Medicine, 166, 480–492. 10.7326/M16-2458
    1. Darlow, B. , Dean, S. , Perry, M. , Mathieson, F. , Baxter, G. D. , & Dowell, A. (2014). Acute low back pain management in general practice: Uncertainty and conflicting certainties. Family Practice, 31, 723–732. 10.1093/fampra/cmu051
    1. Dunn, K. M. , Campbell, P. , Lewis, M. , Hill, J. C. , van der Windt, D. , Afolabi, E. , Protheroe, J. , Wathall, S. , Jowett, S. , Oppong, R. , Mallen, C. D. , Hay, E. , & Foster, N. E. (submitted). Refinement and validation of the Keele STarT MSK Tool for stratifying patients with musculoskeletal pain. PLoS Med.
    1. Foster, N. E. , Anema, J. R. , Cherkin, D. , Chou, R. , Cohen, S. P. , Gross, D. P. , Ferreira, P. H. , Fritz, J. M. , Koes, B. W. , Peul, W. , Turner, J. A. , & Maher, C. G. ; Lancet Low Back Pain Series Working Group (2018). Prevention and treatment of low back pain: Evidence, challenges, and promising directions. Lancet, 391, 2368–2383. 10.1016/S0140-6736(18)30489-6
    1. Foster, N. E. , Hartvigsen, J. , & Croft, P. R. (2012). Taking responsibility for the early assessment and treatment of patients with musculoskeletal pain: A review and critical analysis. Arthritis Research and Therapy, 14, 205 10.1186/ar3743
    1. GBD 2017 Disease and Injury Incidence and Prevalence Collaborators (2018). Disease and Injury Incidence and Prevalence Collaborators. (2018). Global, regional, and national incidence, prevalence, and years lived with disability for 354 diseases and injuries for 195 countries and territories, 1990–2017: A systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. Lancet, 392, 1789–1858. 10.1016/S0140-6736(18)32279-7
    1. Glocker, F. et al (2018). Lumbale Radikulopathie, S2k‐Leitlinie 2018; In: Deutsche Gesellschaft für Neurologie (Hrsg.), Leitlinien für Diagnostik und Therapie in der Neurologie [Lumbar radiculopathy, S2k Guideline 2018; In: German Society of Neurology (Ed), Guidelines for Diagnostics and Therapy in Neurology].
    1. Hill J. C., Garvin S., Chen Y., Cooper V., Wathall S., Saunders B., Lewis M., Protheroe J., Chudyk A., Dunn K. M., Hay E., van der Windt D., Mallen C., Foster N. E. (2020). Stratified primary care versus non‐stratified care for musculoskeletal pain: findings from the STarT MSK feasibility and pilot cluster randomized controlled trial. BMC Family Practice, 21, (1), 10.1186/s12875-019-1074-9.
    1. Jonckheer, P. , Desomer, A. , Depreitere, B. , Berquin, A. , Bruneau, M. , Christiaens, W. , Coeckelberghs, E. , Demoulin, C. , Duquenne, P. , Forget, P. , Fraselle, V. , Godderis, L. , Hans, G. , Hoste, D. , Kohn, L. , Mairiaux, P. , Munting, E. , Nielens, H. , Orban, T. , Parlevliet, T. , Pirotte, B. , van Boxem, K. , van Lerbeirghe, J. , van Schaeybroeck, P. , van Wambeke, P. , van Zundert, J. , Vanderstraeten, J. , Vanhaecht, K. , & Verhulst, D. (2017). Low back pain and radicular pain: development of a clinical pathway, Health Services Research (HSR), Brussels: . : Belgian Health Care Knowledge Centre (KCE).
    1. Jordan, K. P. , Kadam, U. T. , Hayward, R. , Porcheret, M. , Young, C. , & Croft, P. (2010). Annual consultation prevalence of regional musculoskeletal problems in primary care: An observational study. BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders, 11, 144 10.1186/1471-2474-11-144
    1. Kassolik, K. , Rajkowska‐Labon, E. , Tomasik, T. , Pisula‐Lewadowska, A. , Gieremek, K. , Andrzejewski, W. , Dobrzycka, A. , & Kurpas, D. (2017). Recommendations of the Polish Society of Physiotherapy, the Polish Society of Family Medicine and the College of Family Physicians in Poland in the field of physiotherapy of back pain syndromes in primary health care. Family Medicine and Primary Care Review, 19, 323–334. 10.5114/fmpcr.2017.69299
    1. Koes, B. W. , van Tulder, M. , Lin, C. W. C. , Macedo, L. G. , McAuley, J. , & Maher, C. (2010). An updated overview of clinical guidelines for the management of non‐specific low back pain in primary care. European Spine Journal, 19, 2075–2094. 10.1007/s00586-010-1502-y
    1. Lin, I. , Wiles, L. , Waller, R. , Goucke, R. , Nagree, Y. , Gibberd, M. , Straker, L. , Maher, C. G. , & O’Sullivan, P. P. B. (2020). What does best practice care for musculoskeletal pain look like? Eleven consistent recommendations from high‐quality clinical practice guidelines: Systematic review. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 54, 79–86. 10.1136/bjsports-2018-099878
    1. Maher, C. , Underwood, M. , & Buchbinder, R. (2017). Non‐specific low back pain. Lancet, 389, 736–747. 10.1016/S0140-6736(16)30970-9
    1. Maserejian, N. N. , Fischer, M. A. , Trachtenberg, F. L. , Yu, J. , Marceau, L. D. , McKinlay, J. B. , & Katz, J. N. (2014). Variations Among Primary Care Physicians in Exercise Advice, Imaging, and Analgesics for Musculoskeletal Pain: Results From a Factorial Experiment. Arthritis Care & Research, 66, 147–156. 10.1002/acr.22143
    1. Moher, D. , Liberati, A. , Tetzlaff, J. , & Altman, D. G. ; PRISMA Group (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta‐analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Medicine, 6, e1000097 10.1136/bmj.b2535
    1. Monticone, M. , Iovine, R. , de Sena, G. , Rovere, G. , Uliano, D. , Arioli, G. , Bonaiuti, D. , Brugnoni, G. , Ceravolo, G. , Cerri, C. , Dalla Toffola, E. , Fiore, P. , & Foti, C. (2013). The Italian Society of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine (SIMFER) recommendations for neck pain. Giornale Italiano Di Medicina Del Lavoro Ed Ergonomia, 35, 36–50.
    1. Murphy, M. E. , Fahey, T. , & Smith, S. M. (2014). Computer‐based clinical decision support for general practitioners. Family Practice, 31, 497–498. 10.1093/fampra/cmu045
    1. National Institute for Health Care Excellence (NICE) (2016). Low back pain and sciatica in over 16s: Assessment and management (NG59), London: . National Institute for Health Care Excellence.
    1. Oliveira, C. B. , Maher, C. G. , Pinto, R. Z. , Traeger, A. C. , Lin, C. C. , Chenot, J. F. , van Tulder, M. , & Koes, B. W. (2018). Clinical practice guidelines for the management of non‐specific low back pain in primary care: An updated overview. European Spine Journal, 27, 2791–2803. 10.1007/s00586-018-5673-2
    1. Pohl, M. , Back, T. , Leimert, M. , Seifert, J. , Stoffel, M. , Amelung, R. I. , Dodd, N. , Gibson, B. , Linn, J. , Locher, H. , Mokrusch, T. , Schulte, T. L. , Tholen, R. , & van de Weyer, T. (2018). Zervikale Radikulopathie [Cervical Radiculopathy]. Aktuelle Neurologie, 45, 349–369. 10.1055/a-0575-7066
    1. Protheroe, J. , Saunders, B. , Bartlam, B. , Dunn, K. M. , Cooper, V. , Campbell, P. , Hill, J. C. , Tooth, S. , Mallen, C. D. , Hay, E. M. , & Foster, N. E. (2019). Matching treatment options for risk sub‐groups in musculoskeletal pain: A consensus groups study. BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders, 20, 271 10.1186/s12891-019-2587-z
    1. Roshanov, P. S. , Fernandes, N. , Wilczynski, J. M. , Hemens, B. J. , You, J. J. , Handler, S. M. , Nieuwlaat, R. , Souza, N. M. , Beyene, J. , Van Spall, H. G. , Garg, A. X. , & Haynes, R. B. (2013). Features of effective computerised clinical decision support systems: Meta‐regression of 162 randomised trials. BMJ, 346, f657 10.1136/bmj.f657
    1. Schaafstra, A. , Spinnewijn, W. , Bons, S. , Borg, M. , Koes, B. , Osteol, R. , Spijker‐Huiges, A. , Burgers, J. , Bouma, M. , & Verburg, A. (2015). NHG‐Standaard Lumbosacraal radiculair syndroom (tweede herziening) [NHG Standard Lumbar radicular syndrome (2nd Revision)]. Huisarts En Wetenschap, 58, 308–320.
    1. Siering, U. , Eikermann, M. , Hausner, E. , Hoffmann‐Esser, W. , & Neugebauer, E. A. (2013). Appraisal tools for clinical practice guidelines: A systematic review. PLoS One, 8, e82915 10.1371/journal.pone.0082915
    1. Société Française de Médecine du Travail (SFMT) [French National Health Authority] (2013). Recommandations de Bonne Pratique sur la surveillance médico‐professionnelle du risque lombaire pour les travailleurs exposés à des manipulations de charges [Clinical practice guidelines for medical and occupational surveillance of the low back risk in workers exposed to manual handling of loads], Paris, France: Société Française de Médecine du Travail et Haute Autorité de Santé.
    1. Somerville, S. , Hay, E. , Lewis, M. , Barber, J. , van der Windt, D. , Hill, J. , & Sowden, G. (2008). Content and outcome of usual primary care for back pain: A systematic review. British Journal of General Practice, 58, 790–797. 10.3399/bjgp08X319909
    1. Staal, J. B. , Hendriks, E. J. M. , Heijmans, M. , Kiers, H. , Lutgers‐Boomsma, A. M. , Rutten, G. , van Tulder, M. W. , den Boer, J. , Ostelo, R. , & Custers, J. W. H. (2017). KNGF‐richtlijn Lage rugpijn: Praktijkrichtlijn [KNGF clinical practice guideline for physical therapy in patients with low back pain], Amersfoort, Netherlands: Koninklijk Nederlands Genootschap voor Fysiotherapie (KNGF).
    1. Sundhedsstyrelsen (SST) [Danish Health Authority] (2015). National Klinisk Retningslinje for ikke‐kirurgisk behandling af nyopstået rodpåvirkning i nakken med udstrålende symptomer til armen (cervikal radikulopati) [National clinical guideline for the non‐surgical treatment of recent onset nerve root compromise in the neck with symptoms radiating to the arm (cervical radiculopathy)], Copenhagen, Denmark: . Sundhedsstyrelsen.
    1. Sundhedsstyrelsen (SST) [Danish Health Authority] (2016a). National klinisk retningslinje for behandling af nyopståede lænderygsmerter [National clinical guideline for the treatment of recent onset low back pain], Copenhagen, Denmark: Sundhedsstyrelsen.
    1. Sundhedsstyrelsen (SST) [Danish Health Authority] (2016b). National klinisk retningslinje for ikke‐kirurgisk behandling af nylig opstået lumbal nerverodspåvirkning [National clinical guideline for the non‐surgical treatment of recent onset lumbar nerve root compression (lumbar radiculopathy)], Copenhagen, Denmark: Sundhedsstyrelsen.
    1. Sundhedsstyrelsen (SST) [Danish Health Authority] (2016c). National klinisk retningslinje for ikke‐kirurgisk behandling af nyopståede uspecifikke nakkesmerter [National clinical guideline for the non‐surgical treatment of recent onset non‐specific neck pain], Copenhagen, Denmark: Sundhedsstyrelsen.
    1. Regione T. (2015). Mal Di Schiena: Linee Guida Diagnostico Terapeutiche E Raccomandazioni Per La Costruzione Di Percorsi Assistenziali [Back pain: therapeutic and diagnostic guidelines and recommendations for treatment plans]. Documento Regionale Di Indirizzo Linea Guida: Consiglio Sanitario RegionaleRegione Toscana: Sistema Nazionale Linee Guida (SNLG) Regioni 1.,
    1. van Wambeke, P. , Desomer, A. , Ailliet, L. , Berquin, A. , Demoulin, C. , Depreitere, B. , Dewachter, J. , Dolphens, M. , Forget, P. , Fraselle, V. , Hans, G. , Hoste, D. , Mahieu, G. , Michielsen, J. , Nielens, H. , Orban, T. , Parlevliet, T. , Simons, E. , Tobbackx, Y. , & van Schaeybroeck, P. , van Zundert, J. , vanderstraeten, J. , Vlaeyen, J. , & Jonckheer, P. (2017). Low back pain and radicular pain: Assessment and management. Good Clinical Practice (GCP), Brussels: Belgian Health Care Knowledge Centre (KCE).
    1. Wong, J. J. , Cote, P. , Sutton, D. A. , Randhawa, K. , Yu, H. , Varatharajan, S. , Goldgrub, R. , Nordin, M. , Gross, D. P. , Shearer, H. M. , Carroll, L. J. , Stern, P. J. , Ameis, A. , Southerst, D. , Mior, S. , Stupar, M. , Varatharajan, T. , & Taylor‐Vaisey, A. (2017). Clinical practice guidelines for the noninvasive management of low back pain: A systematic review by the Ontario Protocol for Traffic Injury Management (OPTIMa) Collaboration. European Journal of Pain, 21, 201–216. 10.1002/ejp.931

Source: PubMed

Sponsor e collaboratori

Condizioni mediche

Interventi farmacologici

3
Sottoscrivi