The effect of financial compensation on health outcomes following musculoskeletal injury: systematic review

Darnel F Murgatroyd, Petrina P Casey, Ian D Cameron, Ian A Harris, Darnel F Murgatroyd, Petrina P Casey, Ian D Cameron, Ian A Harris

Abstract

The effect of financial compensation on health outcomes following musculoskeletal injury requires further exploration because results to date are varied and controversial. This systematic review identifies compensation related factors associated with poorer health outcomes following musculoskeletal injury. Searches were conducted using electronic medical journal databases (Medline, CINAHL, Embase, Informit, Web of Science) for prospective studies published up to October 2012. Selection criteria included: prognostic factors associated with validated health outcomes; six or more months follow up; and multivariate statistical analysis. Studies solely measuring return to work outcomes were excluded. Twenty nine articles were synthesised and then assessed using GRADE (Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation) methodology to determine evidence levels. The results were mixed. There was strong evidence of an association between compensation status and poorer psychological function; and legal representation and poorer physical function. There was moderate evidence of an association between compensation status and poorer physical function; and legal representation and poorer psychological function. There was limited evidence of an association between compensation status and increased pain. In seven studies the association depended on the outcome measured. No studies reported an association between compensation related factors and improved health outcomes. Further research is needed to find plausible reasons why compensation related factors are associated with poorer health following musculoskeletal injury.

Conflict of interest statement

Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Figures

Fig 1. Retrieval of studies for the…
Fig 1. Retrieval of studies for the systematic review.

References

    1. Global health risks: mortality and burden of disease attributable to selected major risks. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2009. World Health Organization website. Available: . Accessed 2014 March 5.
    1. Murray CJ, Vos T, Lozano R, Naghavi M, Flaxman AD, et al. Disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) for 291 diseases and injuries in 21 regions, 1990–2010: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010. Lancet. 2013 Feb 23;381(9867):628. AlMazroa, Mohammad A [added]; Memish, Ziad A [added].
    1. Mock C, Mackenzie E, Jurkovich G, Burgess A, Cushing B, et al. (2000) Determinants of disability after lower extremity fracture. J Trauma 49: 1002–1011.
    1. Harris IA, Young JM, Dalaludin BB, Solomon MJ (2008) The effect of compensation on general health in patients sustaining fractures in motor vehicle trauma. J Orthop Trauma 22: 216–220. 10.1097/BOT.0b013e31815c11dc
    1. Bhandari M, Busse J, Hanson B, Leece P, Ayeni O, et al. (2008) Psychological distress and quality of life after orthopaedic trauma: an observational study. Can J Surg 51: 15–22.
    1. Cameron ID, Rebbeck T, Sindhusake D, Rubin G, Feyer A-M, et al. (2008) Legislative change is associated with improved health status in people with whiplash. Spine 33: 250–254. 10.1097/BRS.0b013e31816244ed
    1. Cassidy D, Carroll L, Cote P, Lemstra M, Bergland A (2000) Effect of eliminating compensation for pain and suffering on the outcome of insurance claims for whiplash injury. N Engl J Med 342: 1179–1186.
    1. Gabbe B, Cameron P, Williamson O, Edwards E, Graves S, et al. (2007) The relationship between compensable status and long-term patient outcomes following orthopaedic trauma. Med J Aust 187: 14–17.
    1. Littleton SM, Cameron ID, Poustie SJ, Hughes DC, Robinson BJ, et al. (2011) The association of compensation on longer term health status for people with musculoskeletal injuries following road traffic crashes: emergency department inception cohort study. Injury 42: 927–933.
    1. Australian and New Zealand Consensus Statement on the Use of Research Evidence in Compensation Policy and Practice. Institute for Safety, Compensation and Recovery Research, 2012. Institute for Safety, Compensation and Recovery Research website. Available: . Accessed 2014 May 1.
    1. Clay FJ, Newstead SV, McClure RJ (2010) A systematic review of early prognostic factors for return to work following acute orthopaedic trauma. Injury 41: 787–803. 10.1016/j.injury.2010.04.005
    1. Scholten-Peeters GGM, Verhagen AP, Bekkering GE, van der Windt DAWM, Barnsley L, et al. (2003) Prognostic factors of whiplash-associated disorders: a systematic review of prospective cohort studies. Pain 104: 303–322.
    1. Kamper SJ, Rebbeck TJ, Maher CG, McAuley JH, Sterling M (2008) Course and prognostic factors of whiplash: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Pain 138: 617–629. 10.1016/j.pain.2008.02.019
    1. Iles RA, Davidson M, Taylor NF (2008) Psychosocial predictors of failure to return to work in non-chronic non-specific low back pain: a systematic review. Occup Enviro Med 65: 507–517. 10.1136/oem.2007.036046
    1. Elbers NA, Hulst L, Cuijpers P, Akkermans AJ, Bruinvels DJ (2013) Do compensation processes impair mental health? A meta-analysis. Injury 44: 674–683. 10.1016/j.injury.2011.11.025
    1. Harris I, Mulford J, Solomon M, van Gelder J, Young J (2005) Association between compensation status and outcome after surgery, a meta-analysis. JAMA 293: 1644–1652.
    1. Binder L, Rohling M (1996) Money matters: A meta-analytic review of the effects of financial incentives on recovery after closed-head injury. Am J Psychiatry 153: 7–10.
    1. Spearing NM, Connelly LB, Gargett S, Sterling M (2012) Does injury compensation lead to worse health after whiplash? A systematic review. Pain 153: 1274–1282. 10.1016/j.pain.2012.03.007
    1. Spearing NM, Connelly LB (2011) Is compensation "bad for health"? A systematic meta-review. [Review]. Injury 42: 15–24. 10.1016/j.injury.2009.12.009
    1. Phillips B, Ball C, Sackett D, Badenoch D, Straus S, et al. (2009) Oxford Centre for Evidence-based Medicine—Levels of Evidence (March 2009). Oxford: Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine; Centre for Evidence Based Medicine website. Available: . Accessed 2014 Jun 15.
    1. Altman DG (2001) Systematic reviews of evaluations of prognostic variables. BMJ 323: 224–228.
    1. Hayden JA, Chou R, Hogg-Johnson S, Bombardier C (2009) Systematic reviews of low back pain prognosis had variable methods and results: guidance for future prognosis reviews. J Clin Epidemiol 62: 781–796. 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2008.09.004
    1. Hayden JA, Cote P, Bombardier C (2006) Evaluation of the quality of prognosis studies in systematic reviews. Ann Intern Med 144: 427–437.
    1. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, Group P (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ 339: b2535 10.1136/bmj.b2535
    1. Technical Report: Guidelines for the Management of Acute Whiplash Associated Disorders, 2nd Edition 2007, Motor Accidents Authority. Motor Accidents Authority, 2007. Motor Accidents Authority of NSW website. Available: . Accessed 2014 Jun 6.
    1. How to review the evidence: systematic identification and review of the scientific literature. Canberra: National Health and Medical Research Council, 2000. National Health and Medical Research Council website. Available: . Accessed 2014 Mar 3.
    1. NHMRC additional levels of evidence and grades for recommendations for developers of guidelines stage 2 consultation early 2008—end June 2009. Canberra: National Health and Medical Research Council, 2009. National Health and Medical Research Council website. Available: . Accessed 2014 Mar 7.
    1. Guyatt G, Oxman AD, Akl EA, Kunz R, Vist G, et al. (2011) GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction-GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. J Clin Epidemiol 64: 383–394. 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2010.04.026
    1. Guyatt GH, Oxman AD, Vist G, Kunz R, Brozek J, et al. (2011) GRADE guidelines: 4. Rating the quality of evidence-study limitations (risk of bias). J Clin Epidemiol 64: 407–415. 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2010.07.017
    1. Sanderson S, Tatt ID, Higgins JP (2007) Tools for assessing quality and susceptibility to bias in observational studies in epidemiology: a systematic review and annotated bibliography. Int J Epidemiol 36: 666–676.
    1. Greenland S, O'Rourke K (2001) On the bias produced by quality scores in meta-analysis, and a hierarchical view of proposed solutions. Biostatistics 2: 463–471.
    1. Juni P, Witschi A, Bloch R, Egger M (1999) The hazards of scoring the quality of clinical trials for meta-analysis. JAMA 282: 1054–1060.
    1. Lakke SE, Soer R, Takken T, Reneman MF (2009) Risk and prognostic factors for non-specific musculoskeletal pain: a synthesis of evidence from systematic reviews classified into ICF dimensions. Pain 147: 153–164. 10.1016/j.pain.2009.08.032
    1. Williamson OD, Epi GDC, Gabbe BJ, Physio B, Cameron PA, et al. (2009) Predictors of moderate or severe pain 6 months after orthopaedic injury: a prospective cohort study. J Orthop Trauma 23: 139–144. 10.1097/BOT.0b013e3181962e29
    1. Yang Z, Lowe AJ, de la Harpe DE, Richardson MD (2010) Factors that predict poor outcomes in patients with traumatic vertebral body fractures. Injury 41: 226–230. 10.1016/j.injury.2009.10.019
    1. Ehlers A, Mayou RA, Bryant B (1998) Psychological predictors of chronic posttraumatic stress disorder after motor vehicle accidents. J Abnorm Psychol 107: 508–519.
    1. Mayou R, Bryant B (2001) Outcome in consecutive emergency department attenders following a road traffic accident. Br J Psychiatry 179: 528–534.
    1. Mayou R, Bryant B (2002) Psychiatry of whiplash neck injury. Br J Psychiatry 180: 441–448.
    1. Harris IA, Young JM, Jalaludin BB, Solomon MJ (2011) Predictors of neck pain after motor vehicle collisions: a prospective survey. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong) 19: 317–321.
    1. Littleton SM, Hughes DC, Poustie SJ, Robinson BJ, Neeman T, et al. (2011) The influence of fault on health in the immediate post-crash period following road traffic crashes. Injury. 2011 Mar 29. [Epub ahead of print].
    1. Hadler NM, Carey TS, Garrett J (1995) The influence of indemnification by workers' compensation insurance on recovery from acute backache. North Carolina Back Pain Project. Spine 20: 2710–2715.
    1. Bendix AF, Bendix T, Haestrup C (2000) Can it be predicted which patients with chronic low back pain should be offered tertiary rehabilitation in a functional restoration program? A search for demographic, socioeconomic, and physical predictors. Spine 23: 1775–1783.
    1. Cassidy JD, Carroll L, Côté P, Berglund A, Nygren A (2003) Low back pain after traffic collisions: a population-based cohort study. Spine 28: 1002–1009.
    1. Sterling M, Hendrikz J, Kenardy J (2010) Compensation claim lodgement and health outcome developmental trajectories following whiplash injury: A prospective study. Pain 150: 22–28. 10.1016/j.pain.2010.02.013
    1. Sterling M, Jull G, Kenardy J (2006) Physical and psychological factors maintain long-term predictive capacity post-whiplash injury. Pain 122: 102–108.
    1. Atlas SJ, Keller RB, Wu YA, Deyo RA, Singer DE (2005) Long-term outcomes of surgical and nonsurgical management of sciatica secondary to a lumbar disc herniation: 10 year results from the maine lumbar spine study. Spine 30: 927–935.
    1. Atlas SJ, Tosteson TD, Blood EA, Skinner JS, Pransky GS, et al. (2010) The impact of workers' compensation on outcomes of surgical and nonoperative therapy for patients with a lumbar disc herniation: SPORT. Spine 35: 89–97. 10.1097/BRS.0b013e3181c68047
    1. Gun RT, Osti OL, O'Riordan A, Mpelasoka F, Eckerwall CGM, et al. (2005) Risk factors for prolonged disability after whiplash injury: a prospective study. Spine 30: 386–391.
    1. Rebbeck T, Sindhusake D, Cameron ID, Rubin G, Feyer A-M, et al. (2006) A prospective cohort study of health outcomes following whiplash associated disorders in an Australian population. Inj Prev 12: 93–98.
    1. Pobereskin LH (2005) Whiplash following rear end collisions: A prospective cohort study. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 76: 1146–1151.
    1. Bosse MJ, MacKenzie EJ, Kellam JF, Burgess AR, Webb LX, et al. (2002) An analysis of outcomes of reconstruction or amputation of leg-threatening injuries. N Engl J Med 347: 1924–1931.
    1. Hendriks EJ, Scholten-Peeters GG, van der Windt DA, Neeleman-van der Steen CW, Oostendorp RA, et al. (2005) Prognostic factors for poor recovery in acute whiplash patients. Pain 114: 408–416.
    1. Clay FJ, Newstead SV, Watson WL, Ozanne-Smith J, Guy J, et al. (2010) Bio-psychosocial determinants of persistent pain 6 months after non-life-threatening acute orthopaedic trauma. J Pain 11: 420–430. 10.1016/j.jpain.2009.12.002
    1. Sharma R, Haas M, Stano M, Spegman A, Gehring R (2009) Determinants of costs and pain improvement for medical and chiropractic care of low back pain. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 32: 252–261. 10.1016/j.jmpt.2009.03.010
    1. Anderson PA, Schwaegler PE, Cizek D, Leverson G (2006) Work status as a predictor of surgical outcome of discogenic low back pain. Spine 31: 2510–2515.
    1. Asch HL, Lewis PJ, Moreland DB, Egnatchik JG, Yu YJ, et al. (2002) Prospective multiple outcomes study of outpatient lumbar microdiscectomy: Should 75 to 80% success rates be the norm? J Neurosurg 96 (1 SUPPL.): 34–44.
    1. Rasmussen C, Leboeuf-Yde C, Hestbaek L, Manniche C (2008) Poor outcome in patients with spine-related leg or arm pain who are involved in compensation claims: a prospective study of patients in the secondary care sector. Scand J Rheumatol 37: 462–468. 10.1080/03009740802241709
    1. Buckley R, Tough S, McCormack R, Pate G, Leighton R, et al. (2002) Operative compared with nonoperative treatment of displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures: a prospective, randomized, controlled multicenter trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am 84A: 1733–1744.
    1. Kadzielski JJ, Bot AG, Ring D (2012) The influence of job satisfaction, burnout, pain, and worker's compensation status on disability after finger injuries. J Hand Surg Am 37: 1812–1819. 10.1016/j.jhsa.2012.05.023
    1. MacDermid JC, Donner A, Richards RS, Roth JH (2002) Patient versus injury factors as predictors of pain and disability six months after a distal radius fracture. J Clin Epidemiol 55: 849–854.
    1. Henschke N, Maher CG, Refshauge KM, Herbert RD, Cumming RG, et al. (2008) Prognosis in patients with recent onset low back pain in Australian primary care: Inception cohort study. BMJ 337: 154–157.
    1. Ameratunga S, Tin ST, Connor J, Norton R (2010) Chronic neck pain following car crashes: a population-based study from Auckland, New Zealand. Intern Med J 40: 704–709. 10.1111/j.1445-5994.2009.02101.x
    1. Jensen OK, Nielsen CV, Stengaard-Pedersen K (2010) One-year prognosis in sick-listed low back pain patients with and without radiculopathy. Prognostic factors influencing pain and disability. Spine J 10: 659–675. 10.1016/j.spinee.2010.03.026
    1. Berglund A, Bodin L, Jensen I, Wiklund A, Alfredsson L (2006) The influence of prognostic factors on neck pain intensity, disability, anxiety and depression over a 2-year period in subjects with acute whiplash injury. Pain 125: 244–256.
    1. Balyk R, Luciak-Corea C, Otto D, Baysal D, Beaupre L (2008) Do outcomes differ after rotator cuff repair for patients receiving workers' compensation? Clin Orthop Relat Res 466: 3025–3033. 10.1007/s11999-008-0475-1
    1. Guyatt GH, Oxman AD, Kunz R, Woodcock J, Brozek J, et al. (2011) GRADE guidelines: 7. Rating the quality of evidence—inconsistency. J Clinical Epidemiol 64: 1294–1302. 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2011.03.017
    1. Cote P, Cassidy JD, Carroll L, Frank JW, Bombardier C (2001) A systematic review of the prognosis of acute whiplash and a new conceptual framework to synthesize the literature. Spine 26: E445–458.
    1. Steenstra IA, Verbeek JH, Heymans MW, Bongers PM (2005) Prognostic factors for duration of sick leave in patients sick listed with acute low back pain: a systematic review of the literature. Occup Environ Med 62: 851–860.
    1. Carroll LJ, Holm LW, Hogg-Johnson S, Cote P, Cassidy JD, et al. (2008) Course and prognostic factors for neck pain in whiplash-associated disorders (WAD): results of the Bone and Joint Decade 2000–2010 Task Force on Neck Pain and Its Associated Disorders. Spine 33: S83–92. 10.1097/BRS.0b013e3181643eb8
    1. Harris IA, Young JM, Rae H, Jalaludin BB, Solomon MJ (2008) Predictors of general health after major trauma. J Trauma 64: 969–974. 10.1097/01.ta.0000245972.83948.1a
    1. Akkermans AJ (2009) Reforming personal injury claims settlement: paying more attention to emotional dimension promotes victim recovery. Social Science Research Network. Amsterdam: Amsterdam Interdisciplinary Centre for Law and Health; VU University Amsterdam—Faculty of Law. Social Science Research Network website. Available: . Accessed 2014 May 27.
    1. Lippel K (2007) Workers describe the effect of the workers' compensation process on their health: a Quebec study. Int J Law Psychiatry 30: 427–443.
    1. Murgatroyd DF, Cameron ID, Harris IA (2010) Understanding the effect of compensation on recovery from severe motor vehicle crash injuries: a qualitative study. Inj Prev 17: 222–7. 10.1136/ip.2010.029546
    1. Grant GM, O'Donnell ML, Spittal MJ, Creamer M, Studdert DM (2014) Relationship Between Stressfulness of Claiming for Injury Compensation and Long-term Recovery: A Prospective Cohort Study. JAMA Psychiatry 71: 446–53. 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2013.4023
    1. Clay F, Berecki-Gisolf J, Collie A (2014) How well do we report on compensation systems in studies of return to work: a systematic review. J Occup Rehabil 24: 111–124. 10.1007/s10926-013-9435-z
    1. Carroll LJ, Connelly LB, Spearing NM, Cote P, Buitenhuis J, et al. (2011) Complexities in understanding the role of compensation-related factors on recovery from whiplash-associated disorders: discussion paper 2. Spine 36: S316–321. 10.1097/BRS.0b013e3182388739
    1. Grant G, Studdert DM (2009) Poisoned Chalice? A Critical Analysis of the Evidence Linking Personal Injury Compensation Processes with Adverse Health Outcomes. Melbourne University Law Review 33: 865–885.
    1. Grimes DA, Schulz KF (2002) Bias and causal associations in observational research. Lancet 359: 248–252.
    1. Sullivan M, Adams H, Horan S, Maher D, Boland D, et al. (2008) The role of perceived injustice in the experience of chronic pain and disability: scale development and validation. J Occup Rehabil 18: 249–261. 10.1007/s10926-008-9140-5
    1. Sullivan MJL, Thibault P, Simmonds MJ, Milioto M, Cantin A-P, et al. (2009) Pain, perceived injustice and the persistence of post-traumatic stress symptoms during the course of rehabilitation for whiplash injuries. Pain 145: 325–331. 10.1016/j.pain.2009.06.031
    1. Harris IA, Murgatroyd DF, Cameron ID, Young JM, Solomon MJ (2009) The effect of compensation on health care utilisation in a trauma cohort. Med J Aust 190: 619–622

Source: PubMed

Sponsor e collaboratori

Condizioni mediche

Interventi farmacologici

3
Sottoscrivi