Mapping global trends in vaccine confidence and investigating barriers to vaccine uptake: a large-scale retrospective temporal modelling study
Alexandre de Figueiredo, Clarissa Simas, Emilie Karafillakis, Pauline Paterson, Heidi J Larson, Alexandre de Figueiredo, Clarissa Simas, Emilie Karafillakis, Pauline Paterson, Heidi J Larson
Abstract
Background: There is growing evidence of vaccine delays or refusals due to a lack of trust in the importance, safety, or effectiveness of vaccines, alongside persisting access issues. Although immunisation coverage is reported administratively across the world, no similarly robust monitoring system exists for vaccine confidence. In this study, vaccine confidence was mapped across 149 countries between 2015 and 2019.
Methods: In this large-scale retrospective data-driven analysis, we examined global trends in vaccine confidence using data from 290 surveys done between September, 2015, and December, 2019, across 149 countries, and including 284 381 individuals. We used a Bayesian multinomial logit Gaussian process model to produce estimates of public perceptions towards the safety, importance, and effectiveness of vaccines. Associations between vaccine uptake and a large range of putative drivers of uptake, including vaccine confidence, socioeconomic status, and sources of trust, were determined using univariate Bayesian logistic regressions. Gibbs sampling was used for Bayesian model inference, with 95% Bayesian highest posterior density intervals used to capture uncertainty.
Findings: Between November, 2015, and December, 2019, we estimate that confidence in the importance, safety, and effectiveness of vaccines fell in Afghanistan, Indonesia, Pakistan, the Philippines, and South Korea. We found significant increases in respondents strongly disagreeing that vaccines are safe between 2015 and 2019 in six countries: Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Indonesia, Nigeria, Pakistan, and Serbia. We find signs that confidence has improved between 2018 and 2019 in some EU member states, including Finland, France, Ireland, and Italy, with recent losses detected in Poland. Confidence in the importance of vaccines (rather than in their safety or effectiveness) had the strongest univariate association with vaccine uptake compared with other determinants considered. When a link was found between individuals' religious beliefs and uptake, findings indicated that minority religious groups tended to have lower probabilities of uptake.
Interpretation: To our knowledge, this is the largest study of global vaccine confidence to date, allowing for cross-country comparisons and changes over time. Our findings highlight the importance of regular monitoring to detect emerging trends to prompt interventions to build and sustain vaccine confidence.
Funding: European Commission, Wellcome, and Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council.
Copyright © 2020 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an Open Access article under the CC BY 4.0 license. Published by Elsevier Ltd.. All rights reserved.
Figures
References
- Omer SB, Salmon DA, Orenstein WA, Halsey N. Vaccine refusal, mandatory immunization, and the risks of vaccine-preventable diseases. N Engl J Med. 2009;360:1981–1988.
- Phadke VK, Bednarczyk RA, Salmon DA, Omer SB. Association between vaccine refusal and vaccine-preventable diseases in the United States: a review of measles and pertussis. JAMA. 2016;315:1149–1158.
- Cooper LZ, Larson HJ, Katz SL. Protecting public trust in immunization. Pediatrics. 2008;122:149–153.
- Larson HJ, Jarrett C, Eckersberger E, Smith DMD, Paterson P. Understanding vaccine hesitancy around vaccines and vaccination from a global perspective: a systematic review of published literature, 2007–2012. Vaccine. 2014;32:2150–2159.
- Principi N, Esposito S. Early vaccination: a provisional measure to prevent measles in infants. Lancet Infect Dis. 2019;19:1157–1158.
- Patel MK, Orenstein WA. Classification of global measles cases in 2013–17 as due to policy or vaccination failure: a retrospective review of global surveillance data. Lancet Glob Health. 2019;7:e313–e320.
- WHO Ten threats to global health in 2019. Jan 18, 2019.
- Larson HJ, Cooper LZ, Eskola J, Katz SL, Ratzan S. Addressing the vaccine confidence gap. Lancet. 2011;378:526–535.
- Larson HJ, Clarke RM, Jarrett C. Measuring trust in vaccination: a systematic review. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2018;14:1599–1609.
- Jarrett C, Wilson R, O'Leary M, Eckersberger E, Larson HJ. Strategies for addressing vaccine hesitancy—a systematic review. Vaccine. 2015;33:4180–4190.
- Larson HJ, Jarrett C, Eckersberger E, Smith DM, Paterson P. Understanding vaccine hesitancy around vaccines and vaccination from a global perspective: a systematic review of published literature, 2007–2012. Vaccine. 2014;32:2150–2159.
- Larson HJ, Jarrett C, Schulz WS. Measuring vaccine hesitancy: the development of a survey tool. Vaccine. 2015;33:4165–4175.
- Larson HJ, Wilson R, Hanley S, Parys A, Paterson P. Tracking the global spread of vaccine sentiments: The global response to Japan's suspension of its HPV vaccine recommendation. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2014;10:2543–2550.
- Larson HJ, de Figueiredo A, Xiahong Z. The state of vaccine confidence 2016: global insights through a 67-country survey. EBioMedicine. 2016;12:295–301.
- Larson H, de Figueiredo A, Karafillakis E, Rawal M. Publications Office of the European Union; Luxembourg: 2018. State of vaccine confidence in the EU 2018.
- Wilson RJ, Paterson P, Jarrett C, Larson HJ. Understanding factors influencing vaccination acceptance during pregnancy globally: a literature review. Vaccine. 2015;33:6420–6429.
- SAGE Working Group on Vaccine Hesitancy Report of the SAGE working group on vaccine hesitancy. Oct 1, 2014.
- Larson HJ, Schulz WS, Tucker JD, Smith DMD. Measuring vaccine confidence: introducing a global Vaccine Confidence Index. PLoS Curr. 2015;7:1–28.
- Opel DJ, Taylor JA, Zhou C, Catz S, Myaing M, Mangione-Smith R. The relationship between parent attitudes about childhood vaccines survey scores and future child immunization status: a validation study. JAMA Pediatr. 2013;167:1065–1071.
- Gilkey MB, Magnus BE, Reiter PL, McRee A-L, Dempsey AF, Brewer NT. The Vaccination Confidence Scale: a brief measure of parents' vaccination beliefs. Vaccine. 2014;32:6259–6265.
- Betsch C, Schmid P, Heinemeier D, Korn L, Holtmann C, Böhm R. Beyond confidence: development of a measure assessing the 5C psychological antecedents of vaccination. PLoS One. 2018;13
- Shapiro GK, Tatar O, Dube E. The vaccine hesitancy scale: psychometric properties and validation. Vaccine. 2018;36:660–667.
- Domek GJ, O'Leary ST, Bull S. Measuring vaccine hesitancy: field testing the WHO SAGE Working Group on Vaccine Hesitancy survey tool in Guatemala. Vaccine. 2018;36:5273–5281.
- Masters NB, Tefera YA, Wagner AL, Boulton ML. Vaccine hesitancy among caregivers and association with childhood vaccination timeliness in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2018;14:2340–2347.
- Ren J, Wagner AL, Zheng A. The demographics of vaccine hesitancy in Shanghai, China. PLoS One. 2018;13
- Wagner AL, Masters NB, Domek GJ. Comparisons of vaccine hesitancy across five low- and middle-income countries. Vaccines. 2019;7:155.
- Larson HJ, Hartigan-Go K, de Figueiredo A. Vaccine confidence plummets in the Philippines following dengue vaccine scare: why it matters to pandemic preparedness. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2019;15:625–627.
- Wellcome Wellcome Global Monitor: how does the world feel about science and health? June 19, 2019.
- Williams CKI, Barber D. Bayesian classification with Gaussian processes. IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Mach Intell. 1998;20:1342–1351.
- Gelman A, Carlin JB, Stern HS, Dunson DB, Vehtari A RD. 3rd edn. Chapman and Hall/CRC; Boca Raton, FL: 2013. Bayesian data analysis; p. 465.
- Plummer M. Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop on Distributed Statistical Computing. Technische Universit at Wien; Vienna: 2003. JAGS: just another Gibbs sampler. JAGS: a program for analysis of Bayesian graphical models using Gibbs sampling.
- Fatima K, Syed NI. Dengvaxia controversy: impact on vaccine hesitancy. J Glob Health. 2018;8
- Aguiar M, Stollenwerk N, Halstead SB. The risks behind Dengvaxia recommendation. Lancet Infect Dis. 2016;16:882–883.
- Żuk P, Lisiewicz-Jakubaszko J. The anti-vaccine movement in Poland: the socio-cultural conditions of the opposition to vaccination and threats to public health. Vaccine. 2019;37:1491–1494.
- Simms KT, Hanley SJB, Smith MA, Keane A, Canfell K. Impact of HPV vaccine hesitancy on cervical cancer in Japan: a modelling study. Lancet Public Health. 2020;5:e223–e234.
- Hanley SJB, Yoshioka E, Ito Y, Kishi R. HPV vaccination crisis in Japan. Lancet. 2015;385
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Rubella in Japan. Travelers' health. Travel notices.
- Ujiie M. Rubella Resurgence in Japan 2018–2019. J Travel Med. 2019;26
- Gilmour S, Kanda M, Kusumi E, Tanimoto T, Kami M, Shibuya K. HPV vaccination programme in Japan. Lancet. 2013;382:768.
- Rochmyaningsih D. Indonesian ‘vaccine fatwa’ sends measles immunization rates plummeting. Nov 7, 2018.
- Yufika A, Wagner AL, Nawawi Y. Parents' hesitancy towards vaccination in Indonesia: a cross-sectional study in Indonesia. Vaccine. 2020;38:2592–2599.
- Wong LP, Wong PF, AbuBakar S. Vaccine hesitancy and the resurgence of vaccine preventable diseases: the way forward for Malaysia, a Southeast Asian country. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2020 doi: 10.1080/21645515.2019.1706935. published online Jan 24.
- Chang K, Lee SY. Why do some Korean parents hesitate to vaccinate their children? Epidemiol Health. 2019;41
- Mohd Azizi FS, Kew Y, Moy FM. Vaccine hesitancy among parents in a multi-ethnic country, Malaysia. Vaccine. 2017;35:2955–2961.
- Park H, Park B, Choi EJ. Factors influencing vaccination in Korea: findings from focus group interviews. J Prev Med Public Health. 2018;51:173–180.
- Khetsuriani N, Imnadze P, Baidoshvili L. Impact of unfounded vaccine safety concerns on the nationwide measles–rubella immunization campaign, Georgia, 2008. Vaccine. 2010;28:6455–6462.
- Frew PM, Kriss JL, Chamberlain AT. A randomized trial of maternal influenza immunization decision-making: a test of persuasive messaging models. Hum Vaccines Immunother. 2016;12:1989–1996.
- Broniatowski DA, Jamison AM, Qi S. Weaponized health communication: Twitter bots and Russian trolls amplify the vaccine debate. Am J Public Health. 2018;108:1378–1384.
- Lasco G, Curato N. Medical populism. Soc Sci Med. 2019;221:1–8.
- Usman S, Bologna L, Stamidis KV. The CORE Group Partners Project in North East Nigeria: community engagement strategies to combat skepticism and build trust for vaccine acceptance. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2019;101(suppl 4):68–73.
- Ali M, Ahmad N, Khan H, Ali S, Akbar F, Hussain Z. Polio vaccination controversy in Pakistan. Lancet. 2019;394:915–916.
- WHO Poliovirus reported cases. July 15, 2020.
Source: PubMed