A Novel Mindful-Compassion Art-Based Therapy for Reducing Burnout and Promoting Resilience Among Healthcare Workers: Findings From a Waitlist Randomized Control Trial

Andy Hau Yan Ho, Geraldine Tan-Ho, Thuy Anh Ngo, Grace Ong, Poh Heng Chong, Dennis Dignadice, Jordan Potash, Andy Hau Yan Ho, Geraldine Tan-Ho, Thuy Anh Ngo, Grace Ong, Poh Heng Chong, Dennis Dignadice, Jordan Potash

Abstract

Protecting the mental health of healthcare workers is an urgent global public health priority. Healthcare workers, especially those immersed in palliative care, are prone to burnout due to the intense emotions associated with end-of-life caregiving. This study examines the efficacy of a novel, multimodal, and group-based Mindful-Compassion Art-based Therapy (MCAT) that integrates reflective self-awareness with creative emotional expression for protecting healthcare workers' mental health. A dual-arm open-label waitlist randomized controlled trial was conducted. A total of 56 healthcare workers were recruited from the largest homecare hospice in Singapore and randomized to the immediate-treatment condition of a standardized 6-week, 18-hours MCAT intervention (n=29), or the waitlist-control condition (n=27). Self-administered outcome measures on burnout, resilience, emotional regulation, self-compassion, death attitudes, and quality of life were collected at baseline, post-intervention/second-baseline at 6weeks, and follow-up/post-intervention at 12weeks. Results from mixed model ANOVAs reveal that treatment group participants experienced significant reduction in mental exhaustion, as well as significant improvements in overall emotional regulation, nonreactivity to intrusive thoughts, approach acceptance of death, and afterlife belief as compared to waitlist-control immediately after MCAT completion. Effect sizes of these impacts ranged from medium to large (η 2=0.65 to 0.170). Results from one-way ANOVAs further reveal that the treatment gains of reduced mental exhaustion and increased emotional regulation were maintained among treatment group participants at 12-weeks follow-up compared to baseline, with new benefits identified. These include increased ability to observe and describe one's experiences, elevated overall self-compassion, greater mindful awareness, enhanced common humanity, and better quality of life. Effect sizes of these impacts were large (η 2=0.128 to 0.298). These findings reflect the robust effectiveness and positive residual effects of MCAT for reducing burnout, building resilience, nurturing compassion, fostering collegial support, and promoting mental wellness among healthcare workers. The clinical model and applicability of MCAT in larger and more diverse caregiving contexts, such as family dementia care, are discussed. Clinical Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov # NCT03440606, #NCT04548089.

Keywords: art-based therapy; burnout; mindful compassion; multimodal intervention; palliative end-of-life care; randomized control trial; resilience.

Conflict of interest statement

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Copyright © 2021 Ho, Tan-Ho, Ngo, Ong, Chong, Dignadice and Potash.

Figures

Figure 1
Figure 1
Study Flow Diagram.
Figure 2
Figure 2
(A) Mandala of self-care (Pastel on paper). (B) Transformative stress (Airdry clay). (C) Symbols of limitation (Pencil on paper). (D) Small group mural of meaning (Acrylic on canvas).
Figure 3
Figure 3
Large group mural – ‘Seasons of Life’ (Acrylic on canvas).

References

    1. Ablett J. R., Jones R. S. P. (2007). Resilience and well-being in palliative care staff: a qualitative study of hospice nurses’ experience of work. Psycho-Oncology 16, 733–740. doi: 10.1002/pon.1130, PMID:
    1. Baer R. A., Smith G. T., Lykins E., Button D., Krietemeyer J., Sauer S., et al. . (2008). Construct validity of the five facet mindfulness questionnaire in meditating and nonmeditating samples. Assessment 15, 329–342. doi: 10.1177/1073191107313003, PMID:
    1. Bishop S. R., Lau M., Shaprio S., Carlson L., Anderson N. D., Carmody J., et al. . (2008). Mindfulness: a proposed operational definition. Clin. Psychol. Sci. Pract. 11, 230–241. doi: 10.1093/clipsy.bph077
    1. Boccia M., Piccardi L., Guariglia P. (2015). The Meditative Mind: A Comprehensive Meta-Analysis of MRI Studies. Biomed. Res. Int. 2015:419808. doi: 10.1155/2015/419808
    1. Braun V., Clarke V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual. Res. Psychol. 3, 77–101. doi: 10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
    1. Brown N. W. (2018). Psychoeducational Groups Process and Practice. New York: Routledge.
    1. Campbell J., Prochazka A. V., Yamashita T., Gopal R. (2010). Predictors of persistent burnout in internal medicine residents: a prospective cohort study. Acad. Med. 85, 1630–1634. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181f0c4e7, PMID:
    1. Chan W. C. H., Tin A. F. (2012). Beyond knowledge and skills: self-competence in working with death, dying, and bereavement. Death Stud. 36, 899–913. doi: 10.1080/07481187.2011.604465, PMID:
    1. da Rocha N. S., Power M. J., Bushnell D. M., Fleck M. P. (2012). The EUROHIS-QOL 8-item index: comparative psychometric properties to its parent WHOQOL-BREF. Value Health 15, 449–57. doi: 10.1016/j.jval.2011.11.035
    1. Dewa C. S., Loong D., Bonato S., Trojanowski L. (2017). The relationship between physician burnout and quality of healthcare in terms of safety and acceptability: a systematic review. BMJ Open 7:e015141. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-015141, PMID:
    1. Dill J. S., Cagle J. (2010). Caregiving in a patient’s place of residence: turnover of direct care workers in home care and hospice agencies. J. Aging Health 22, 713–733. doi: 10.1177/0898264310373390, PMID:
    1. Farkas D., Orosz G. (2015). Ego-resiliency reloaded: a three-component model of general resiliency. PLoS One 10:e0120883. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0120883, PMID:
    1. Germer C. K., Neff K. D. (2013). Self-compassion in clinical practice. J. Clin. Psychol. 69, 1–12. doi: 10.1002/jclp.22021
    1. Gilbert P., Choden. (2014). Mindful Compassion: How the Science of Compassion Can Help You Understand Your Emotions, Live in the Present, and Connect Deeply with Others. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger Publications.
    1. Han S., Shanafelt T. D., Sinsky C. A., Awad K. M., Dyrbye L. N., Fiscus L. C., et al. . (2019). Estimating the attributable cost of physician burnout in the United States. Ann. Intern. Med. 170, 784–790. doi: 10.7326/M18-1422
    1. Hass-Cohen N., Findlay J. C. (2015). Art Therapy and the Neuroscience of Relationships, Creativity, & Resiliency. New York, NY: W. W. Norton & Company.
    1. Ho A. H. Y. (2021). “Challenges and coping strategies of non-palliative care professionals caring for dying patients.” Paper Presented at the 32nd International Congress of Psychology [Virtual], The Czech and Moravian Psychological Society; July 19–24; Prague, Czech Republic.
    1. Ho A. H. Y., Chan C. L. W., Chow A. Y. M., Pon A. K. L., Ng S.-M. (2010). Psychometric properties of the Chinese version (C-DAP-R) of the death attitude profile-revised. Illn. Crisis Loss 18, 95–110. doi: 10.2190/IL.18.2.b
    1. Ho A. H. Y., Tan-Ho G., Ngo T. A., Ong G., Chong P. H., Dignadice D., et al. . (2019). A novel mindful-compassion art therapy (MCAT) for reducing burnout and promoting resilience for end-of-life care professionals: a waitlist RCT protocol. Trials 20:406. doi: 10.1186/s13063-019-3533-y, PMID:
    1. Huang Y.-L., Yates P., Prior D. (2009). Factors influencing oncology nurses’ approaches to accommodating cultural needs in palliative care. J. Clin. Nurs. 18, 3421–3429. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2702.2009.02938.x, PMID:
    1. Huet V. (2017). Case study of an art therapy-based group for work-related stress with hospice staff. Int.J. Art Therapy 22, 22–34. doi: 10.1080/17454832.2016.1260039
    1. Huet V., Holttum S. (2016). Art therapy-based groups for work-related stress with staff in health and social care: an exploratory study. J. Art Therapy 50, 46–57. doi: 10.1016/j.aip.2016.06.003
    1. Kaimal G., Mensinger J. L., Carroll-Haskins K. (2020). Outcomes of collage art-based and narrative self-expression among home hospice caregivers. Int. J. Art Therapy 25, 52–63. doi: 10.1080/17454832.2020.1752756
    1. Kalmanowitz D., Potash J. S. (2010). Ethical considerations in the global teaching and promotion of art therapy to non-art therapists. Arts Psychother. 37, 20–26. doi: 10.1016/j.aip.2009.11.002
    1. Khoury B., Lecomte T., Fortin G., Masse M., Therien P., Bouchard V., et al. . (2013). “Mindfulness-based therapy: a comprehensive meta-analysis,” in Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects (DARE): Quality-assessed Reviews [Internet]. York, UK: Centre for Reviews and Dissemination.
    1. Koh M. Y. H., Chong P. H., Neo P. S. H., Ong Y. J., Yong W. C., Ong W. Y., et al. . (2015). Burnout, psychological morbidity and use of coping mechanisms among palliative care practitioners: a multi-Centre cross-sectional study. Palliat. Med. 29, 633–642. doi: 10.1177/0269216315575850, PMID:
    1. Koh M. Y. H., Hum A. Y. M., Khoo H. S., Ho A. H. Y., Chong P. H., Ong W. Y., et al. . (2020). Burnout and resilience After a decade in palliative care: what survivors have to teach us. A qualitative study of palliative care clinicians With more Than 10 years of experience. J. Pain Symptom Manag. 59, 105–115. doi: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2019.08.008, PMID:
    1. Kubler-Ross E. (1970). On Death and Dying. New York, NY: Tavistock Publications.
    1. Lambert M. J., Ogles B. M. (2004). “The efficacy and effectiveness of psychotherapy,” in Bergin and Garfield’s Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change 5th Edn. eds. Lambert M. J. (New York, NY: Wiley; ), 139–193.
    1. Lee P. T., Loh J., Sng G., Tung J., Yeo K. K. (2018). Empathy and burnout: a study on residents from a Singapore institution. Singap. Med. J. 59, 50–54. doi: 10.11622/smedj.2017096, PMID:
    1. Lepore S. J., Revenson T. A. (2006). “Resilience and posttraumatic growth: recovery, resistance, and reconfiguration,” in Handbook of Posttraumatic Growth: Research & Practice. eds. Calhoun L. G., Tedeschi R. G. (Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers; ), 24–46.
    1. Maslach C., Jackson S. E., Leiter M. (1996). “The maslach burnout inventory manual,” in Evaluating Stress: A Book of Resources. Vol. 3. eds. Zalaquett C. P., Wood R. J. (Palo Alto: Consulting Psychologists Press; ), 191–218.
    1. Mateen F. J., Dorji C. (2009). Health-care worker burnout and the mental health imperative. Lancet 374, 595–597. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(09)61483-5
    1. McAdams D. P. (2011). “Narrative identity,” in Handbook of Identity Theory and Research. eds. Schwartz S., Luyckx K., Vignoles V. (New York, NY: Springer; ), 99–115.
    1. McNiff S. (2007). Art as Medicine: Creating a Therapy of the Imagination. London: Shambhala Publications.
    1. Melamed S., Shirom A., Toker S., Berliner S., Shapira I. (2006). Burnout and risk of cardiovascular disease: evidence, possible causal paths, and promising research directions. Psychol. Bull. 132, 327–353. doi: 10.1037/0033-2909.132.3.327, PMID:
    1. Melvin C. S. (2015). Historical review in understanding burnout, professional compassion fatigue, and secondary traumatic stress disorder from a hospice and palliative nursing perspective. J. Hosp. Palliat. Nurs. 17, 66–72. doi: 10.1097/NJH.0000000000000126
    1. Nainis N. A. (2005). Art therapy with an oncology care team. Art Ther. 22, 150–154. doi: 10.1080/07421656.2005.10129491
    1. Neff K. (2003). Self-compassion: an alternative conceptualization of a healthy attitude toward oneself. J. Int. Soc. Self Identity 2, 85–101. doi: 10.1080/15298860309032
    1. Pals J. L. (2006). Narrative identity processing of difficult life experiences: pathways of personality development and positive self-transformation in adulthood. J. Pers. 74, 1079–1109. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-6494.2006.00403.x, PMID:
    1. Pope C., Ziebland S., Mays N. (2000). Qualitative research in health care: analysing qualitative data. BMJ 320:114. doi: 10.1136/bmj.320.7227.114, PMID:
    1. Potash J. S., Bardot H., Wang X. L., Chan F., Ho A. H. Y., Cheng C. (2014). Mandalas as indicators of burnout among end-of-life care workers. J. Appl. Arts Health 4, 363–377. doi: 10.1386/jaah.4.3.363_1
    1. Potash J. S., Chan F., Ho A. H. Y., Wang X. L., Cheng C. (2015). A model for art therapy-based supervision for end-of-life care workers in Hong Kong. Death Stud. 39, 44–51. doi: 10.1080/07481187.2013.859187, PMID:
    1. Potash J. S., Ho R. T. H., Ho A. H. Y. (2018). Citizenship, compassion, the arts: people living with mental illness need a caring community. Soc. Change 48, 238–259. doi: 10.1177/0049085718768911
    1. Raes F., Pommier E., Neff K. D., Van Gucht D. (2011). Construction and factorial validation of a short form of the self-compassion scale. Clin. Psychol. Psychotherapy 18, 250–255. doi: 10.1002/cpp.702
    1. Rappaport L. (2013). Mindfulness and Arts Therapies: Theory and Practice. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
    1. Ripp J., Babyatsky M., Fallar R., Bazari H., Bellini L., Kapadia C., et al. . (2011). The incidence and predictors of job burnout in first-year internal medicine residents: a five-institution study. Acad. Med. 86, 1304–1310. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e31822c1236
    1. Rushton C. H., Kaszniak A. W., Halifax J. S. (2013). A framework for understanding moral distress among palliative care clinicians. J. Palliat. Med. 16, 1074–1079. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2012.0490, PMID:
    1. Salvagioni D. A. J., Melanda F. N., Mesas A. E., González A. D., Gabani F. L., Andrade S. M.. (2017). Physical, psychological and occupational consequences of job burnout: a systematic review of prospective studies. PLoS One 12:e0185781. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0185781, PMID:
    1. Schön D. (1983). The Reflective Practitioner. New York: Basic Book.
    1. See K. C., Lim T. K., Kua E. H., Phua J., Chua G. S., Ho K. Y. (2016). Stress and burnout among physicians: prevalence and risk factors in a Singaporean internal medicine programme. Ann. Acad. Med. Singap. 45, 471–474. PMID:
    1. Shanafelt T. D., Balch C. M., Bechamps G., Russell T., Dyrbye L., Satele D., et al. . (2010). Burnout and medical errors among American surgeons. Ann. Surg. 251, 995–1000. doi: 10.1097/SLA.0b013e3181bfdab3, PMID:
    1. Søvold L. E., Naslund J. A., Kousoulis A. A., Saxena S., Qoronfleh M. W., Grobler C., et al. . (2021). Prioritizing the Mental Health and Well-Being of Healthcare Workers: An Urgent Global Public Health Priority. Front. Public Health 9:679397 doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2021.679397, PMID:
    1. Stebnicki M. A. (2008). Empathy Fatigue: Healing the Mind, Body and Spirit of Professional Counselors. New York: Springer Publishing Company.
    1. Storlie F. J. (1979). Burnout: the elaboration of a concept. Am. J. Nurs. 79, 2108–2111. PMID:
    1. Tawfik D. S., Profit J., Morgenthaler T. I., Satele D. V., Sinsky C. A., Dyrbye L. N., et al. . (2018). Physician burnout, well-being, and work unit safety grades in relationship to reported medical errors. Mayo Clin. Proc. 93, 1571–1580. doi: 10.1016/j.mayocp.2018.05.014, PMID:
    1. Thompson S., Thompson N. (2008). The Critically Reflective Practitioner. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.
    1. Tjasink M., Soosaipillai G. (2019). Art therapy to reduce burnout in oncology and palliative care doctors: a pilot study. Int. J. Art Therapy 24, 12–20. doi: 10.1080/17454832.2018.1490327
    1. Urbaniak G. C., Plous S. (2019). Research randomizer. Available at: (Accessed September 01, 2021).
    1. Vachon M. L. (1995). Staff stress in hospice/palliative care: a review. Palliat. Med. 9, 91–122. doi: 10.1177/026921639500900202, PMID:
    1. Van Lith T. (2016). Art therapy in mental health: a systematic review of approaches and practices. Arts Psychother. 47, 9–22. doi: 10.1016/j.aip.2015.09.003
    1. Victorson D., Kentor M., Maletich C., Lawton R. C., Kaufman V. H., Borrero M., et al. . (2015). Mindfulness meditation to promote wellness and manage chronic disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis of mindfulness-based randomized controlled trials relevant to lifestyle medicine. Am. J. Lifestyle Med. 9, 185–211. doi: 10.1177/1559827614537789
    1. Wilkinson H., Whittington R., Perry L., Eames C. (2017). Examining the relationship between burnout and empathy in healthcare professionals: a systematic review. Burn. Res. 6, 18–29. doi: 10.1016/j.burn.2017.06.003, PMID:
    1. Wong P. T., Reker G. T., Gesser G. (1994). “Death attitude profile—revised: A multidimensional measure of attitudes toward death,” in Death Anxiety Handbook: Research, Instrumentation, and Application. (ed.) Neimeyer R. A. (Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis; ), 121–148.
    1. World Health Organization . (2016). Working for Health and Growth: Investing in the Health Workforce - Report of the High-Level Commission on Health Employment and Economic Growth. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization.

Source: PubMed

Спонсоры и соавторы

Заболевания

Медикаментозные вмешательства

Подписаться