Differences in program implementation between nurses and paraprofessionals providing home visits during pregnancy and infancy: a randomized trial
J Korfmacher, R O'Brien, S Hiatt, D Olds, J Korfmacher, R O'Brien, S Hiatt, D Olds
Abstract
Objectives: This study examined differences between nurses and paraprofessionals in implementation of a home visiting program for low-income, first-time parents during pregnancy and the first 2 years of the child's life.
Methods: Mothers were randomly assigned to either a nurse-visited (n = 236) or a paraprofessional-visited (n = 244) condition. Nurse- and paraprofessional-visited families were compared on number and length of visits, topics covered, number of program dropouts, and relationship with home visitor.
Results: On average, nurses completed more visits than paraprofessionals (28 vs 23; P < .001) and spent a greater proportion of time on physical health issues during pregnancy (38% vs 27%; P < .001) and on parenting issues during infancy (46% vs 32%; P < .001). Paraprofessionals conducted visits that lasted longer and spent a greater proportion of time on environmental health and safety issues (15% vs 7% pregnancy; 15% vs 8% infancy; P < .001). While home visitors were viewed equally positively by mothers, nurses had fewer dropouts than did paraprofessionals (38% vs 48%; P = .04). More paraprofessional-visited families than nurse-visited families experienced staff turnover.
Conclusions: Nurses and paraprofessionals, even when using the same model, provide home visiting services in different ways.
References
- Psychol Bull. 1979 Jan;86(1):80-92
- Psychol Bull. 1984 May;95(3):534-41
- Pediatrics. 1986 Jan;77(1):16-28
- JAMA. 1997 Aug 27;278(8):644-52
- Am J Public Health. 1988 Nov;78(11):1436-45
- Pediatrics. 1989 Jul;84(1):157-64
- Pediatrics. 1986 Jul;78(1):65-78
Source: PubMed