Antenatal consent in the SUPPORT trial: challenges, costs, and representative enrollment
Wade D Rich, Kathy J Auten, Marie G Gantz, Ellen C Hale, Angelita M Hensman, Nancy S Newman, Neil N Finer, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Neonatal Research Network, Alan H Jobe, Michael S Caplan, Michele C Walsh, Avroy A Fanaroff, Nancy S Newman, Bonnie S Siner, Kurt Schibler, Edward F Donovan, Vivek Narendran, Kate Bridges, Barbara Alexander, Cathy Grisby, Marcia Worley Mersmann, Holly L Mincey, Jody Hessling, Ronald N Goldberg, C Michael Cotten, Kathy J Auten, Kimberly A Fischer, Katherine A Foy, Gloria Siaw, Barbara J Stoll, Susie Buchter, Anthony Piazza, David P Carlton, Ellen C Hale, Rosemary D Higgins, Stephanie Wilson Archer, Brenda B Poindexter, James A Lemons, Diana D Appel, Faithe Hamer, Dianne E Herron, Lucy C Miller, Leslie D Wilson, Abhik Das, W Kenneth Poole, Marie Gantz, Margaret Cunningham, Betty K Hastings, Amanda R Irene, Jeanette O'Donnell Auman, Carolyn Petrie Huitema, James W Pickett 2nd, Kristin M Zaterka-Baxter, Krisa P Van Meurs, David K Stevenson, M Bethany Ball, Melinda S Proud, Ivan D Frantz 3rd, John M Fiascone, Anne Furey, Brenda L MacKinnon, Ellen Nylen, Waldemar A Carlo, Namasivayam Ambalavanan, Monica V Collins, Shirley S Cosby, Vivien A Phillips, Neil N Finer, Maynard R Rasmussen, Paul R Wozniak, Kathy Arnell, Clarence Demetrio, Wade Rich, Edward F Bell, John A Widness, Jonathan M Klein, Karen J Johnson, Shahnaz Duara, Ruth Everett-Thomas, Kristi L Watterberg, Robin K Ohls, Julie Rohr, Nirupama Laroira, Dale L Phelps, Linda J Reubens, Erica Burnell, Pablo J Sánchez, Charles R Rosenfeld, Walid A Salhab, Alicia Guzman, Gaynelle Hensley, Melissa H Lepps, Nancy A Miller, Kathleen A Kennedy, Jon E Tyson, Brenda H Morris, Beverly Foley Harris, Anna E Lis, Sarah Martin, Georgia E McDavid, Patti Pierce Tate, Sharon L Wright, Roger G Faix, Bradley A Yoder, Jill Burnett, Jennifer J Jensen, Karen A Osborne, Cynthia Spencer, Kimberlee Weaver-Lewis, T Michael O'Shea, Nancy J Peters, Seetha Shankaran, Beena Sood, Rebecca Bara, Elizabeth Billian, Abbot R Laptook, William Oh, Angelita M Hensman, Dan Gingras, Kim Francis, Dawn Andrews, Kristen Angela, Richard A Ehrenkranz, Vineet Bhandari, Harris C Jacobs, Pat Cervone, Patricia Gettner, Monica Konstantino, JoAnn Poulsen, Janet Taft, Wade D Rich, Kathy J Auten, Marie G Gantz, Ellen C Hale, Angelita M Hensman, Nancy S Newman, Neil N Finer, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Neonatal Research Network, Alan H Jobe, Michael S Caplan, Michele C Walsh, Avroy A Fanaroff, Nancy S Newman, Bonnie S Siner, Kurt Schibler, Edward F Donovan, Vivek Narendran, Kate Bridges, Barbara Alexander, Cathy Grisby, Marcia Worley Mersmann, Holly L Mincey, Jody Hessling, Ronald N Goldberg, C Michael Cotten, Kathy J Auten, Kimberly A Fischer, Katherine A Foy, Gloria Siaw, Barbara J Stoll, Susie Buchter, Anthony Piazza, David P Carlton, Ellen C Hale, Rosemary D Higgins, Stephanie Wilson Archer, Brenda B Poindexter, James A Lemons, Diana D Appel, Faithe Hamer, Dianne E Herron, Lucy C Miller, Leslie D Wilson, Abhik Das, W Kenneth Poole, Marie Gantz, Margaret Cunningham, Betty K Hastings, Amanda R Irene, Jeanette O'Donnell Auman, Carolyn Petrie Huitema, James W Pickett 2nd, Kristin M Zaterka-Baxter, Krisa P Van Meurs, David K Stevenson, M Bethany Ball, Melinda S Proud, Ivan D Frantz 3rd, John M Fiascone, Anne Furey, Brenda L MacKinnon, Ellen Nylen, Waldemar A Carlo, Namasivayam Ambalavanan, Monica V Collins, Shirley S Cosby, Vivien A Phillips, Neil N Finer, Maynard R Rasmussen, Paul R Wozniak, Kathy Arnell, Clarence Demetrio, Wade Rich, Edward F Bell, John A Widness, Jonathan M Klein, Karen J Johnson, Shahnaz Duara, Ruth Everett-Thomas, Kristi L Watterberg, Robin K Ohls, Julie Rohr, Nirupama Laroira, Dale L Phelps, Linda J Reubens, Erica Burnell, Pablo J Sánchez, Charles R Rosenfeld, Walid A Salhab, Alicia Guzman, Gaynelle Hensley, Melissa H Lepps, Nancy A Miller, Kathleen A Kennedy, Jon E Tyson, Brenda H Morris, Beverly Foley Harris, Anna E Lis, Sarah Martin, Georgia E McDavid, Patti Pierce Tate, Sharon L Wright, Roger G Faix, Bradley A Yoder, Jill Burnett, Jennifer J Jensen, Karen A Osborne, Cynthia Spencer, Kimberlee Weaver-Lewis, T Michael O'Shea, Nancy J Peters, Seetha Shankaran, Beena Sood, Rebecca Bara, Elizabeth Billian, Abbot R Laptook, William Oh, Angelita M Hensman, Dan Gingras, Kim Francis, Dawn Andrews, Kristen Angela, Richard A Ehrenkranz, Vineet Bhandari, Harris C Jacobs, Pat Cervone, Patricia Gettner, Monica Konstantino, JoAnn Poulsen, Janet Taft
Abstract
Objectives: The purposes of this study were to quantify the time and effort involved in obtaining prenatal consent for the Neonatal Research Network Surfactant Positive Airway Pressure and Pulse Oximetry Randomized Trial (SUPPORT) and to determine whether the enrolled infants were representative of the eligible population.
Methods: Eligible subjects were likely to deliver in the SUPPORT gestational age window (24-27(6/7)] weeks). Data included who approached the subjects for consent, how often they approached, the duration of each contact, whether consent was obtained, and whether subjects were enrolled in the trial. Eligible, nonenrolled infants entered into the Neonatal Research Network Generic Database throughout the period of SUPPORT enrollment were compared with enrolled infants.
Results: A total of 2826 women were identified at 18 sites, 2228 were approached for consent, and 1219 (54.7%) agreed. For 76.9% of those approached, <3 visits (mean: 2.0 +/- 1.2 visits) were required to complete the consent process. Of the 659 infants with consent who were delivered within the study window, 611 were enrolled. Mothers who received a neonatal consultation were more likely to give consent (P < .001). The proportion of infants not exposed to steroids was significantly greater in the nonapproached group than in the approached group (20.0% vs 3.4%; P < .0001).
Conclusion: In a trial that involved preterm infants and required prenatal consent, >5 women were identified as being likely to deliver in the SUPPORT gestational age window for each 1 who delivered an enrolled infant.
Figures
Source: PubMed