Efficacy of Interventions Based on Applied Behavior Analysis for Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Meta-Analysis

Qian Yu, Enyao Li, Liguo Li, Weiyi Liang, Qian Yu, Enyao Li, Liguo Li, Weiyi Liang

Abstract

Objective: To systematically evaluate evidence for the use of interventions based on appied behavior analysis (ABA) to manage various symptoms of children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD).

Methods: Sensitivity analyses were conducted by removing any outlying studies and subgroup analyses were performed to compare the effectiveness of ABA and early start denver model (ESDM), picture exchange communication systems (PECS) and discrete trial training (DTT).

Results: 14 randomized control trials of 555 participants were included in this meta-analysis. The overall standardized mean difference was d=-0.36 (95% CI -1.31, 0.58; Z=0.75, p=0.45) for autism general symptoms, d=0.11 (95% CI -0.31, 0.54; Z=0.52, p=0.60) for socialization, d=0.30 (95% CI -0.02, 0.61; Z=1.84, p=0.07) for communication and d=-3.52 (95% CI -6.31, -0.72; Z=2.47, p=0.01) for expressive language, d=-0.04 (95% CI -0.44, 0.36; Z=0.20, p=0.84) for receptive language. Those results suggested outcomes of socialization, communication and expressive language may be promising targets for ABA-based interventions involving children with ASD. However, significant effects for the outcomes of autism general symptoms, receptive language, adaptive behavior, daily living skills, IQ, verbal IQ, nenverbal IQ, restricted and repetitive behavior, motor and cognition were not observed.

Conclusion: The small number of studies included in the present study limited the ability to make inferences when comparing ABA, ESDM, PECS and DTT interventions for children with ASD.

Keywords: Applied behavior analysis; Autism; Children; Meta-analysis.

Conflict of interest statement

The authors have no potential conflicts of interest to disclose.

Figures

Figure 1.
Figure 1.
PRISMA flow diagram of study selection.
Figure 2.
Figure 2.
Risk of bias within studies.
Figure 3.
Figure 3.
Forest plots.

References

    1. American Psychiatric Association . Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 5th ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Publishing; 2013.
    1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Prevalence of autism spectrum disorder among children aged 8 years – Autism and developmental disabilities monitoring network, 11 sites, United States, 2014. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report Surveillance Summaries, April 27th, 2018.
    1. Simonoff E, Pickles A, Charman T, Chandler S, Loucas T, Baird G. Psychiatric disorders in children with autism spectrum disorders: prevalence, comorbidity, and associated factors in a population-derived sample. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2008;47:921–929.
    1. Maskey M, Warnell F, Parr JR, Le Couteur A, McConachie H. Emotional and behavioural problems in children with autism spectrum disorder. J Autism Dev Disord. 2012;43:851–859.
    1. Pearson DA, Loveland KA, Lachar D, Lane DM, Reddoch SL, Mansour R, et al. A comparison of behavioral and emotional functioning in children and adolescents with autistic disorder and PDD-NOS. Child Neuropsychol. 2006;12:321–333.
    1. Green VA, Pituch KA, Itchon J, Choi A, O’Reilly M, Sigafoos J. Internet survey of treatments used by parents of children with autism. Res Dev Disabil. 2006;27:70–84.
    1. Hess KL, Morrier MJ, Heflin LJ, Ivey ML. Autism treatment survey: services received by children with autism spectrum disorders in public school classrooms. J Autism Dev Disord. 2008;38:961–971.
    1. Foxx RM. Applied behavior analysis treatment of autism: the state of art. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am. 2008;17:821–834.
    1. Howlin P. Interventions for people with autism: recent advances. Adv Psychiatr Treat. 1997;3:94–102.
    1. Schechtman MA. Scientifically unsupported therapies in the treatment of young children with Autism Spectrum Disorders. Pediatr Ann. 2007;36:497–505.
    1. Smith T. Outcome of early intervention for children with autism. Clin Psychol Sci Pract. 1999;6:33–49.
    1. Baer DM, Wolf MM. Some still-current dimensions of applied behavior analysis. J Appl Behav Anal. 1987;20:313–327.
    1. Baer DM, Wolf MM, Risley TR. Some current dimensions of applied behavior analysis. J Appl Behav Anal. 1968;1:91–97.
    1. Cooper JO, Heron TE, Heward WL. Definition and Characteristics of Applied Behavior Analysis. In: Cooper JO, Heron TE, Heward WL, editors. Applied Behavior Analysis. 2nd Edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson; 2007. pp. 2–23.
    1. Shook GL. An examination of the integrity and future of the Behavior Analyst Certification Board credentials. Behav Modif. 2005;29:562–574.
    1. Fenske EC, Zalenski S, Krantz PJ, McClannahan LE. Age at intervention and treatment outcome for autistic children in a comprehensive intervention program. Res Dev Disabil. 1985:549–558.
    1. Lovaas OI. Behavioral treatment and normal educational and intellectual functioning in young autistic children. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1987;55:3–9.
    1. Remington B, Hastings RP, Kovshoff H, degli Espinosa F, Jahr E, Brown T, et al. Early intensive behavioral intervention: outcomes for children with autism and their parents after two years. Am J Ment Retard. 2007;112:418–438.
    1. Smith M, Rogers S, Dawson G. The Early Start Denver Model: A Comprehensive Early Intervention Approach for Toddlers with Autism. In: Handleman JS, Harris SL, editors. Preschool Education Programs for Children with Autism. 3. Austin, TX: Pro-Ed Corporation Inc; 2008. pp. 65–101.
    1. Angermeier K, Schlosser RW, Luiselli JK, Harrington C, Carter B. Effects of iconicity on requesting with the Picture Exchange Communication System in children with autism spectrum disorder. Res Autism Spectrum Disord. 2008;2:430–446.
    1. Smith T. Discrete trial training in the treatment of autism. Focus Autism Dev Disabil. 2001;16:86–92.
    1. Mohammadzaheri FM, Koegel LK, Rezaee M, Rafiee SM. A randomized clinical trial comparison between Pivotal Response Treatment (PRT) and structured Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) intervention for children with autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 2014;44:2769–2777.
    1. Schiavo JH. PROSPERO: an international register of systematic review protocols. Med Ref Serv Q. 2019;38:171–180.
    1. Moher D, Shamseer L, Clarke M, Ghersi D, Liberati A, Petticrew M, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMAP) 2015 statement. Syst Rev. 2015;4:1.
    1. Higgins JP, Green S. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Chichester: Wiley Online Library; 2008.
    1. Liberati A, Altman DG, Tetzlaff J, Mulrow C, Gotzsche PC, Ioannidis JPA, et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. PLos Med. 2009;6:e1000100.
    1. Higgins JPT, Green S. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0. Available at: . Accessed March 20, 2011.
    1. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ. 2003;327:557–560.
    1. DerSimonian R, Laird N. Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials. 1986;7:177–188.
    1. Cohen J. Statistical Power Analysis in the Behavioral Sciences. 2nd Edition. Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc; 1988.
    1. Macaskill P, Walter SD, Irwig L. A comparison of methods to detect publication bias in meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2001;20:641–654.
    1. Dawson G, Jones EJ, Merkle K, Venema K, Lowy R, Faja S, et al. Early behavioral intervention is associated with normalized brain activity in young children with autism. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2012;51:1150–1159.
    1. Dawson G, Rogers S, Munson J, Smith M, Winter J, Greenson J, et al. Randomized, controlled trial of an intervention for toddlers with autism: the Early Start Denver Model. Pediatrics. 2009;125:e17–e23.
    1. Estes A, Munson J, Rogers SJ, Greenson J, Winter J, Dawson G. Long-term outcomes of early intervention in 6-year-old children with autism spectrum disorder. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2015;54:580–587.
    1. Gordon K, Pasco G, McElduff F, Wade A, Howlin P, Charman T. A communication-based intervention for nonverbal children with autism: what changes? Who benefits? J Consult Clin Psychol. 2011;79:447–457.
    1. Grindle CF, Hastings RP, Saville M, Hughes JC, Huxley K, Kovshoff H, et al. Outcomes of a behavioral education model for children with autism in a mainstream school setting. Behav Modif. 2012;36:298–319.
    1. Hamdan MA. Developing a proposed training program based on discrete trial training (DTT) to improve the non-verbal communication skills in children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) Int J Spec Educ. 2018;33:579–591.
    1. Leaf JB, Milne C, Taubman M, Oppenheim-Leaf M, Torres N, et al. An evaluation of a behaviorally based social skills group for individuals diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder. J Autism Dev Disord. 2017;47:243–259.
    1. Li HH, Li CL, Gao D, Pan XY, DU L, Jia FY. Preliminary application of early start denver model in children with autism spectrum disorder. Chin J Contemp Pediatr. 2018;20:793–798.
    1. Sallows GO, Graupner TD. Intensive behavioral treatment for children with autism: four-year outcome and predictors. Am J Ment Retard. 2005;110:417–438.
    1. Smith T, Groen AD, Wynn JW. Randomized trial of intensive early intervention for children with Pervasive Developmental Disorder. Am J Ment Retard. 2000;105:269–285.
    1. Yan HH. The effect of behavioral analysis therapy on children with autism and its influence on social function. Chin J Convalescent Med. 2018;27:580–582.
    1. Xu Y, Yao J, Yang J. Application of early start denver model for early intervention on autistic children. Chin J Clin Psychol. 2017;25:188–191.
    1. Kong XY, Song FX, Li H, Xu HW, Wang YN, Li Y, et al. Effect of picture exchange communication system on children with autism. Chin J Rehabil Theory Pract. 2014;11:1086–1088.
    1. Liu XL. The application value of picture exchange communication system in the rehabilitation and nursing of children with autism. Mod J Integr Tradit Chin West Med. 2016;25:3634–3636.
    1. Tachibana Y, Miyazaki C, Ota E, Mori R, Hwang Y, Kobayashi E, et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis of comprehensive interventions for pre-school children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) PLoS One. 2017;12:e0186502.
    1. Smith T, Groen AD, Wynn JW. Randomized trial of intensive early intervention for children with pervasive developmental disorder. Am J Ment Retard. 2000;105:269–285.
    1. Reitzel J, Summers J, Lorv B, Szatmari P, Zwaigenbaum L, Georgiades S, et al. Pilot randomized controlled trial of a Functional Behavior Skills Training program for young children with autism spectrum disorder who have significant early learning skill impairments and their families. Res Autism Spectr Disord. 2013;7:1418–1432.
    1. Makrygianni MK, Gena A, Galanis P, Katoudi S. The effectiveness of applied behavior analytic interventions for children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: a meta-analytic study. Res Autism Spectr Disord. 2018;51:18–31.
    1. Hedges LV, Olkin I. Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1985.
    1. Lipsey MW, Wilson DB. Practical Meta-Analysis. Los Angeles: Sage Publications; 2001.
    1. O’Mara AJ, Marsh HW, Craven RG. Meta-Analytic methods in educational research: issues and their solutions. Australia: Paper presented at Australian Association for research in education annual conference; 2005.
    1. Kelley K, Preacher KJ. On effect size. Psychol Methods. 2002;17:137–152.
    1. Hedges LV. Distribution theory for Glass’s estimator of effect size and related estimators. J Educ Behav Stat. 1981;6:107–128.
    1. Spreckley M, Boyd R. Efficacy of applied behavioral intervention in preschool children with autism for improving cognitive, language, and adaptive behavior: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Pediatr. 2009;154:338–344.
    1. Eikeseth S, Smith T, Jahr E, Eldevik S. Intensive behavioral treatment at school for 4- to 7- year-old children with autism: a one-year comparison controlled study. Behav Modif. 2002;26:49–68.
    1. Eikeseth S, Smith T, Jahr E, Eldevik S. Outcome for children with autism who began intensive behavioral treatment between ages 4 and 7: a comparison controlled study. Behav Modif. 2007;31:264–278.
    1. Virués-Ortega J. Applied behavior analytic intervention for autism in early childhood: meta-analysis, meta-regression and dose–response meta-analysis of multiple outcomes. Clin Psychol Rev. 2010;30:387–399.
    1. Roth ME, Gillis JM, DiGennaro Reed FD. DiGennaro Reed. A meta-analysis of behavioral interventions for adolescents and adults with autism spectrum disorders. J Behav Educ. 2014;23:258–286.
    1. Aldred C, Green J, Emsley R, McConachie H. Brief report: Mediation of treatment effect in a communication intervention for pre-school children with autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 2012;42:447–454.
    1. Aldred C, Green J, Adams C. A new social communication intervention for children with autism: pilot randomised controlled treatment study suggesting effectiveness. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2004;45:1420–1430.
    1. Green J, Charman T, McConachie H, Aldred C, Slonims V, Howlin P, et al. Parent-mediated communication-focused treatment in children with autism (PACT): a randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2010;375:2152–2160.
    1. Casenhiser DM, Shanker SG, Stieben J. Learning through interaction in children with autism: preliminary data from asocial-communication-based intervention. Autism. 2013;17:220–241.
    1. Ichikawa K, Takahashi Y, Ando M, Anme T, Ishizaki T, Yamaguchi H, et al. TEACCH-based group social skills training for children with high-functioning autism: a pilot randomized controlled trial. Biopsychosoc Med. 2013;7:14.
    1. Kaale A, Smith L, Sponheim E. A randomized controlled trial of preschool-based joint attention intervention for children with autism. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2012;53:97–105.
    1. Kasari C, Gulsrud AC, Wong C, Kwon S, Locke J. Randomized controlled caregiver mediated joint engagement intervention for toddlers with autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 2010;40:1045–1056.
    1. Lawton K, Kasari C. Brief report: longitudinal improvements in the quality of joint attention in preschool children with autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 2012;42:307–312.

Source: PubMed

Sponsors and Collaborators

Medical Conditions

Drug Interventions

3
Subscribe