Preventing caries in preschoolers: successful initiation of an innovative community-based clinical trial in Navajo Nation Head Start

Abstract

Navajo Nation children have the greatest prevalence of early childhood caries in the United States. This protocol describes an innovative combination of community-based participatory research and clinical trial methods to rigorously test a lay native Community Oral Health Specialists-delivered oral health intervention, with the goal of reducing the progression of disease and improving family knowledge and behaviors.

Methods/design: This cluster-randomized trial designed by researchers at the Center for Native Oral Health Research at the University of Colorado in conjunction with members of the Navajo Nation community compares outcomes between the manualized 2-year oral health fluoride varnish-oral health promotion intervention and usual care in the community (child-caregiver dyads from 26 Head Start classrooms in each study arm; total of 1016 dyads). Outcome assessment includes annual dental screening and an annual caregiver survey of knowledge, attitudes and behaviors; collection of cost data will support cost-benefit analyses.

Discussion: The study protocol meets all standards required of randomized clinical trials. Aligned with principles of community-based participatory research, extended interaction between members of the Navajo community and researchers preceded study initiation, and collaboration between project staff and a wide variety of community members informed the study design and implementation. We believe that the benefits of adding CBPR methods to those of randomized clinical studies outweigh the barriers and constraints, especially in studies of health disparities and in challenging settings. When done well, this innovative mix of methods will increase the likelihood of valid results that communities can use.

Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01116739.

Keywords: Clinical trial; Community-based research; Disparities; Indigenous populations; Native American; Oral health.

Conflict of interest statement

Competing Interests: The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

Copyright © 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

Figures

Fig. 1

Conceptual Framework

Fig. 2

Schematic of Study Design