The Effectiveness of Interventions for Developmental Dyslexia: Rhythmic Reading Training Compared With Hemisphere-Specific Stimulation and Action Video Games

Alice Cancer, Silvia Bonacina, Alessandro Antonietti, Antonio Salandi, Massimo Molteni, Maria Luisa Lorusso, Alice Cancer, Silvia Bonacina, Alessandro Antonietti, Antonio Salandi, Massimo Molteni, Maria Luisa Lorusso

Abstract

Developmental dyslexia is a very common learning disorder causing an impairment in reading ability. Although the core deficit underlying dyslexia is still under debate, significant agreement is reached in the literature that dyslexia is related to a specific deficit in the phonological representation of speech sounds. Many studies also reported an association between reading skills and music. These findings suggest that interventions aimed at enhancing basic auditory skills of children with DD may impact reading abilities. However, music education alone failed to produce improvements in reading skills comparable to those resulting from traditional intervention methods for DD. Therefore, a computer-assisted intervention method, called Rhythmic Reading Training (RRT), which combines sublexical reading exercises with rhythm processing, was implemented. The purpose of the present study was to compare the effectiveness of RRT and that of an intervention resulting from the combination of two yet validated treatments for dyslexia, namely, Bakker's Visual Hemisphere-Specific Stimulation (VHSS) and the Action Video Game Training (AVG). Both interventions, administered for 13 h over 9 days, significantly improved reading speed and accuracy of a group of Italian students with dyslexia aged 8-14. However, each intervention program produced improvements that were more evident in specific reading parameters: RRT was more effective for improvement of pseudoword reading speed, whereas VHSS + AVG was more effective in increasing general reading accuracy. Such different effects were found to be associated with different cognitive mechanisms, namely, phonological awareness for RRT and rapid automatized naming for VHSS + AVG, thus explaining the specific contribution of each training approach. Clinical Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02791841.

Keywords: action video games; developmental dyslexia; hemisphere-specific stimulation; music; reading; rhythm.

Copyright © 2020 Cancer, Bonacina, Antonietti, Salandi, Molteni and Lorusso.

Figures

FIGURE 1
FIGURE 1
D-scores (differences between pre- and post-training scores) for global Reading Accuracy, global Reading Speed (A) and global Phonological Awareness (B) in the two groups. *p < 0.017; **p < 0.01.
FIGURE 2
FIGURE 2
Comparison of mean D-scores between long pseudo-word accuracy and speed scores in the WPRT test. **p < 0.01.
FIGURE 3
FIGURE 3
Mean D-scores of reading subtests (text reading and DDE word and pseudoword reading test) and phonological awareness tests in the two groups. *p < 0.017; **p < 0.01.
FIGURE 4
FIGURE 4
Scatterplot illustrating the correlation between improvement in Sound Length discrimination and improvement in reading accuracy, in the RRT group.
FIGURE 5
FIGURE 5
Scatterplot illustrating the correlation between improvement in Rhythm Reproduction scores (Stambak test) and improvement in RAN speed scores, in the RRT group.

References

    1. Bakker D. J., Licht R. (1986). “Learning to read: changing horses in midstream,” in Dyslexia: Neuropsychology and Treatment, eds Pavlidis G. T., Fisher D. F. (London: Wiley; ), 87–95.
    1. Bakker D. J., Vinke J. (1985). Effects of hemisphere-specific stimulation on brain activity and reading in dyslexics. J. Clin. Exp. Neuropsychol. 7 505–525. 10.1080/01688638508401282
    1. Bhide A., Power A., Goswami U. (2013). A rhythmic musical intervention for poor readers: a comparison of efficacy with a letter-based intervention. Mind Brain Educ. 7 113–123. 10.1111/mbe.12016
    1. Bonacina S., Cancer A., Lanzi P. L., Lorusso M. L., Antonietti A. (2015). Improving reading skills in students with dyslexia: the efficacy of a sublexical training with rhythmic background. Front. Psychol. 6:1510. 10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01510
    1. Cancer A., Antonietti A. (2017). Remedial interventions for developmental dyslexia: how neuropsychological evidence can inspire and support a rehabilitation training. Neuropsychol. Trends 4 73–95. 10.7358/neur-2017-022-canc
    1. Cancer A., Antonietti A. (2018). tDCS modulatory effect on reading processes: a review of studies on typical readers and individuals with dyslexia. Front. Behav. Neurosci. 12:162. 10.3389/fnbeh.2018.00162
    1. Cancer A., Bonacina S., Lorusso M. L., Lanzi P. L., Antonietti A. (2016). “Rhythmic reading training (Rrt): a computer-assisted intervention program for dyslexia,” in Pervasive Computing Paradigms for Mental Health Communications in Computer and Information Science, eds Serino S., Matic A., Giakoumis D., Lopez G., Cipresso P. (Cham: Springer International Publishing; ), 249–258. 10.1007/978-3-319-32270-4_25
    1. Cancer A., Stievano G., Pace G., Colombo A., Antonietti A. (2019). Cognitive processes underlying reading improvement during a rhythm-based intervention. a small-scale investigation of italian children with dyslexia. Children 6:91. 10.3390/children6080091
    1. Castles A., Friedmann N. (2014). Developmental dyslexia and the phonological deficit hypothesis. Mind Lang. 29 270–285. 10.1111/mila.12050
    1. Cogo-Moreira H., Brandão de Ávila C. R., Ploubidis G. B., Mari J. D. J. (2013). Effectiveness of music education for the improvement of reading skills and academic achievement in young poor readers: a pragmatic cluster-randomized, controlled clinical trial. PLoS One 8:e59984. 10.1371/journal.pone.0059984
    1. Cornoldi C., Colpo G. (1995). Nuove Prove di lettura MT Per La Scuola Media Inferiore: Manuale [New Mt Reading Test For Junior High School: Manual]. Florence, IT: Giunti O.S.
    1. Cossu G., Shankweiler D., Liberman I. Y., Katz L., Tola G. (1988). Awareness of phonological segments and reading ability in Italian children. Appl. Psycholing. 9 1–16. 10.1017/S0142716400000424
    1. De Beni R., Zamperlin C., Friso G., Molin A., Poli S., Vocetti C. (2006). Q1 VATA. Batteria per La Valutazione Delle Abilità Trasversali All’apprendimento [Battery for the Assessment Of General Learning-Related Abilities]. Firenze: Giunti O.S.
    1. De Luca M., Di Filippo G., Judica A., Spinelli D., Zoccolotti P. (2005). Test di Denominazione Rapida E Ricerca Visiva Di Colori, Figure E Numeri. [Rapid Naming Test And Visual Search Of Colours, Figures, And Numbers]. Rome: IRCCS Fondazione Santa Lucia.
    1. Di Filippo G., Brizzolara D., Chilosi A., Luca M. D., Judica A., Pecini C., et al. (2005). Rapid naming, not cancellation speed or articulation rate, predicts reading in an orthographically regular language (Italian). Child Neuropsychol. 11 349–361. 10.1080/09297040490916947
    1. Facoetti A., Luisa Lorusso M., Paganoni P., Umiltà C., Gastone Mascetti G. (2003). The role of visuospatial attention in developmental dyslexia: evidence from a rehabilitation study. Cogn. Brain Res. 15 154–164. 10.1016/S0926-6410(02)00148-149
    1. Flaugnacco E., Lopez L., Terribili C., Montico M., Zoia S., Schön D. (2015). Music training increases phonological awareness and reading skills in developmental dyslexia: a randomized control trial. PLoS One 10:e0138715. 10.1371/journal.pone.0138715
    1. Franceschini S., Bertoni S., Ronconi L., Molteni M., Gori S., Facoetti A. (2015). “Shall we play a game?”: improving reading through action video games in developmental Dyslexia. Curr. Dev. Disord. Rep. 2 318–329. 10.1007/s40474-015-0064-64
    1. Franceschini S., Gori S., Ruffino M., Pedrolli K., Facoetti A. (2012). A causal link between visual spatial attention and reading acquisition. Curr. Biol. 22 814–819. 10.1016/j.cub.2012.03.013
    1. Franceschini S., Gori S., Ruffino M., Viola S., Molteni M., Facoetti A. (2013). Action video games make dyslexic children read better. Curr. Biol. 23 462–466. 10.1016/j.cub.2013.01.044
    1. Franceschini S., Trevisan P., Ronconi L., Bertoni S., Colmar S., Double K., et al. (2017). Action video games improve reading abilities and visual-to-auditory attentional shifting in English-speaking children with dyslexia. Sci. Rep. 7:5863 10.1038/s41598-017-05826-5828
    1. Frey A., François C., Chobert J., Velay J.-L., Habib M., Besson M. (2019). Music training positively influences the preattentive perception of voice onset time in children with dyslexia: a longitudinal study. Brain Sci. 9:91. 10.3390/brainsci9040091
    1. Georgiou G. K., Parrila R., Kirby J. R. (2009). RAN components and reading development from grade 3 to grade 5: what underlies their relationship? Sci. Stud. Read. 13 508–534. 10.1080/10888430903034796
    1. Gordon R. L., Fehd H. M., McCandliss B. D. (2015). Does music training enhance literacy skills? A meta-analysis. Front. Psychol. 6:1777. 10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01777
    1. Gori S., Seitz A. R., Ronconi L., Franceschini S., Facoetti A. (2016). Multiple causal links between magnocellular-dorsal pathway deficit and developmental dyslexia. Cereb. Cortex 26 4356–4369. 10.1093/cercor/bhv206
    1. Goswami U. (2011). A temporal sampling framework for developmental dyslexia. Trends Cogn. Sci. 15 3–10. 10.1016/j.tics.2010.10.001
    1. Goswami U., Power A. J., Lallier M., Facoetti A. (2014). Oscillatory “temporal sampling” and developmental dyslexia: toward an over-arching theoretical framework. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 8:904. 10.3389/fnhum.2014.00904
    1. Goswami U., Thomson J., Richardson U., Stainthorp R., Hughes D., Rosen S., et al. (2002). Amplitude envelope onsets and developmental dyslexia: a new hypothesis. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 99 10911–10916. 10.1073/pnas.122368599
    1. Habib M., Lardy C., Desiles T., Commeiras C., Chobert J., Besson M. (2016). Music and dyslexia: a new musical training method to improve reading and related disorders. Front. Psychol. 7:26. 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00026
    1. Harm M. W., Seidenberg M. S. (1999). Phonology, reading acquisition, and dyslexia: insights from connectionist models. Psychol. Rev. 106 491–528. 10.1037/0033-295X.106.3.491
    1. Heim S., Grande M. (2012). Fingerprints of developmental dyslexia. Trends Neurosci. Educ. 1 10–14. 10.1016/j.tine.2012.09.001
    1. Huss M., Verney J. P., Fosker T., Mead N., Goswami U. (2011). Music, rhythm, rise time perception and developmental dyslexia: perception of musical meter predicts reading and phonology. Cortex 47 674–689. 10.1016/j.cortex.2010.07.010
    1. Korkman M., Kirk U., Kemp S. (2007). NEPSY-II. London: Pearson.
    1. Kraus N., Chandrasekaran B. (2010). Music training for the development of auditory skills. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 11 599–605. 10.1038/nrn2882
    1. Kraus N., Slater J., Thompson E. C., Hornickel J., Strait D. L., Nicol T., et al. (2014a). Auditory learning through active engagement with sound: biological impact of community music lessons in at-risk children. Front. Neurosci. 8:351. 10.3389/fnins.2014.00351
    1. Kraus N., Slater J., Thompson E. C., Hornickel J., Strait D. L., Nicol T., et al. (2014b). Music enrichment programs improve the neural encoding of speech in at-risk children. J. Neurosci. 34 11913–11918. 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1881-14.2014
    1. Lorusso M. L., Facoetti A., Bakker D. J. (2011). Neuropsychological treatment of Dyslexia: does type of treatment matter? J. Learn. Disabil. 44 136–149. 10.1177/0022219410391186
    1. Lorusso M. L., Facoetti A., Molteni M. (2004). Hemispheric, attentional, and processing speed factors in the treatment of developmental dyslexia. Brain Cogn. 55 341–348. 10.1016/j.bandc.2004.02.040
    1. Lorusso M. L., Facoetti A., Paganoni P., Pezzani M., Molteni M. (2006). Effects of visual hemisphere-specific stimulation versus reading-focused training in dyslexic children. Neuropsychol. Rehabil. 16 194–212. 10.1080/09602010500145620
    1. Łuniewska M., Chyl K., Dębska A., Kacprzak A., Plewko J., Szczerbiński M., et al. (2018). Neither action nor phonological video games make dyslexic children read better. Sci. Rep. 8:549 10.1038/s41598-017-18878-18877
    1. Lyon G. R., Shaywitz S. E., Shaywitz B. A. (2003). A definition of dyslexia. Ann. Dyslexia 53 1–14. 10.1007/s11881-003-0001-9
    1. Norton E. S., Beach S. D., Gabrieli J. D. (2015). Neurobiology of dyslexia. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 30 73–78. 10.1016/j.conb.2014.09.007
    1. Overy K. (2003). Dyslexia and music. From timing deficits to musical intervention. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 999 497–505.
    1. Pecini C., Spoglianti S., Bonetti S., Di Lieto M. C., Guaran F., Martinelli A., et al. (2019). Training RAN or reading? A telerehabilitation study on developmental dyslexia. Dyslexia 25:dys1619. 10.1002/dys.1619
    1. Pennington B. F. (2006). From single to multiple deficit models of developmental disorders. Cognition 101 385–413. 10.1016/j.cognition.2006.04.008
    1. Peters J. L., De Losa L., Bavin E. L., Crewther S. G. (2019). Efficacy of dynamic visuo-attentional interventions for reading in dyslexic and neurotypical children: a systematic review. Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev. 100 58–76. 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.02.015
    1. Ramus F. (2004). Neurobiology of dyslexia: a reinterpretation of the data. Trends Neurosci. 27 720–726. 10.1016/j.tins.2004.10.004
    1. Ramus F., Marshall C. R., Rosen S., Lely H. K. J. (2013). Phonological deficits in specific language impairment and developmental dyslexia: towards a multidimensional model. Brain 136 630–645. 10.1093/brain/aws356
    1. Richardson U., Thomson J. M., Scott S. K., Goswami U. (2004). Auditory processing skills and phonological representation in Dyslexic children. Dyslexia 10 215–233. 10.1002/dys.276
    1. Sartori G., Job R. (2007). DDE-2: Batteria per La Valutazione Della Dislessia E Della Disortografia Evolutiva-2 [Assessment Battery for Developmental Reading and Spelling Disorders]. Florence, IT: Giunti O.S.
    1. Shapiro L. R., Carroll J. M., Solity J. E. (2013). Separating the influences of prereading skills on early word and nonword reading. J. Exp. Child Psychol. 116 278–295. 10.1016/j.jecp.2013.05.011
    1. Stambak M. (1951). Le problème du rythme dans le développement de l’enfant et dans les dyslexies d’évolution. Enfance 4 480–502. 10.3406/enfan.1951.1202
    1. Thomson J. M., Leong V., Goswami U. (2012). Auditory processing interventions and developmental dyslexia: a comparison of phonemic and rhythmic approaches. Read. Writ. 26 139–161. 10.1007/s11145-012-9359-9356
    1. Tressoldi P. E., Stella G., Faggella M. (2001). The development of reading speed in italians with dyslexia: a longitudinal study. J. Learn. Disabilit. 34 414–417. 10.1177/002221940103400503
    1. Tressoldi P. E., Vio C., Lorusso M. L., Facoetti A., Iozzino R. (2003). Confronto di efficacia ed efficienza tra trattamenti per il miglioramento della lettura in soggetti dislessici. [Efficiency and effectiveness comparison between treatment for reading improvement in dyslexic individuals]. Science 2003 481–494. 10.1449/11529
    1. World Health Organization (1992). The ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders: Clinical Descriptions and Diagnostic Guidelines. Geneva: World Health Organization.
    1. Zoccolotti P., De Luca M., Di Filippo G., Judica A., Spinelli D. (2005). Prova di Lettura Di Parole E Non Parole. [Word and Pseudo-Word Reading Test - WPRT]. Rome: IRCCS Fondazione Santa Lucia.

Source: PubMed

Sponsorer og samarbeidspartnere

Medisinsk tilstand

Legemiddelintervensjoner

3
Abonnere