Blue care: a systematic review of blue space interventions for health and wellbeing

Easkey Britton, Gesche Kindermann, Christine Domegan, Caitriona Carlin, Easkey Britton, Gesche Kindermann, Christine Domegan, Caitriona Carlin

Abstract

There is increasing interest in the potential use of outdoor water environments, or blue space, in the promotion of human health and wellbeing. However, therapeutic nature-based practices are currently outpacing policy and the evidence base for health or wellbeing benefits of therapeutic interventions within blue space has not been systematically assessed. This systematic review aims to address the gap in understanding the impacts of blue space within existing interventions for targeted individuals. A systematic review was carried out, searching Google Scholar, SCOPUS, PubMed, etc. through to August 2017. Only blue space interventions were included that were specifically designed and structured with a therapeutic purpose for individuals with a defined need and did not include nature-based promotion projects or casual recreation in the outdoors. Thirty-three studies met the inclusion criteria and were assessed. Overall, the studies suggest that blue care can have direct benefit for health, especially mental health and psycho-social wellbeing. The majority of papers found a positive or weak association between blue care and health and wellbeing indicators. There was also some evidence for greater social connectedness during and after interventions, but results were inconsistent and mixed across studies with very few findings for physical health. This is the first systematic review of the literature on blue care. In summary, it has been shown that mental health, especially psycho-social wellbeing, can be improved with investment in blue spaces. Key areas for future research include improving understanding of the mechanisms through which blue care can improve public health promotion.

Keywords: blue health; blue space; intervention; nature-based therapy; systematic review.

© The Author(s) 2018. Published by Oxford University Press.

Figures

Fig. 1:
Fig. 1:
Summarized overview of the literature search and selection process.
Fig. 2:
Fig. 2:
Results (numbers of studies) from analysis showing the recruitment procedures used in the studies (a), health characteristics of study population (b), type of blue space setting where interventions took place (c) and physical activities in blue care (d).

References

    1. Armitano C. N., Clapham E. D., Lamont L. S., Audette J. G. (2015) Benefits of surfing for children with disabilities: a pilot study. Palaestra, 29, 31–34.
    1. Bell S. L., Phoenix C., Lovell R., Wheeler B. W. (2015) Seeking everyday wellbeing: the coast as a therapeutic landscape. Social Science & Medicine, 142, 56–67.
    1. Bell S. L., Westley M., Lovell R., Wheeler B. W. (2018) Everyday green space and experienced well-being: the significance of wildlife encounters. Landscape Research, 43, 8–19.
    1. Bennett J. L., Van Puymbroeck M., Piatt J. A., Rydell R. J. (2014) Veterans' perceptions of benefits and important program components of a therapeutic fly-fishing program. Therapeutic Recreation Journal, 48, 169.
    1. Berger R., Tiry M. (2012) The enchanting forest and the healing sand—nature therapy with people coping with psychiatric difficulties. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 39, 412–416.
    1. Bragg R., Atkins G. (2016) A Review of Nature-Based Interventions for Mental Health Care. Natural England Commissioned Reports, Number 204.
    1. Bryant C. A., McCormack Brown K., McDermott R. J., Debate R. D., Alfonso M. A., Baldwin J. L.. et al. (2009) Community-based prevention marketing: a new planning framework for designing and tailoring health promotion interventions In: DiClemente R., Crosby R.A., Kegler M.C. (eds), Emerging Theories in Health Promotion Practice and Research: Strategies for Improving Public Health, 2nd edition, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA, pp. 331–356.
    1. Bryson J. M. (2004) What to do when stakeholders matter: stakeholder identification and analysis techniques. Public Management Review, 6, 21–53.
    1. Caddick N., Smith B., Phoenix C. (2015) The effects of surfing and the natural environment on the well-being of combat veterans. Qualitative Health Research, 25, 76–86.
    1. Campbell M., Fitzpatrick R., Haines A., Kinmonth A. L., Sandercock P., Spiegelhalter D.. et al. (2000) Framework for design and evaluation of complex interventions to improve health. British Medical Journal, 321, 694–696.
    1. Capurso M., Borsci S. (2013) Effects of a tall ship sail training experience on adolescents’ self-concept. International Journal of Educational Research, 58, 15–24.
    1. Carin-Levy G., Jones D. (2007) Psychosocial aspects of scuba diving for people with physical disabilities: an occupational science perspective. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 74, 6–14.
    1. Carlin C., Cormican M., Gormally M. (2017) Health Benefits from Biodiversity and Green Infrastructure Synthesis Report (2014-HW-DS-1). Prepared for the Environmental Protection Agency. , last accessed 9 September 2018.
    1. Casey N., O'Broin D., Collins B. (2009) The meaning of the experience of kayaking for persons with spinal cord injury. Irish Journal of Occupational Therapy, 37, 29–36.
    1. Cavanaugh L. K., Rademacher S. B. (2014) How a SURFing social skills curriculum can impact children with autism spectrum disorders. Journal of the International Association of Special Education, 15, 27–35.
    1. Clapham E. D., Armitano C. N., Lamont L. S., Audette J. G. (2014) The ocean as a unique therapeutic environment: developing a surfing program. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation and Dance, 85, 8–14.
    1. Cochrane (2017) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions
    1. Colpus S., Taylor J. (2014) Ride every challenge: the impact of surfing on 100 young people facing personal and emotional challenges. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 48, 1581.
    1. Collier N., Massey H. C., Lomax M., Harper M., Tipton M. J. (2015) Cold water swimming and upper respiratory tract infections. Extreme Physiology & Medicine, 4, A36.
    1. Coombes E., Jones A. P., Hillsdon M. (2010) The relationship of physical activity and overweight to objectively measured green space accessibility and use. Social Science & Medicine, 70, 816–822.
    1. Cracknell D., White M. P., Pahl S., Depledge M. H. (2017) A preliminary investigation into the restorative potential of public aquaria exhibits: a UK student-based study. Landscape Research, 42, 18–32.
    1. Depledge M. H., Harvey A. J., Brownlee C., Frost M., Moore M. N., Fleming L. E. (2013) Changing views of the interconnections between the Oceans and Human Health in Europe. Microbial Ecology, 65, 852–859.
    1. Depledge M. H., Bird W. J. (2009) The Blue Gym: health and wellbeing from our coasts. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 58, 947–948.
    1. Domegan C., McHugh P., Devaney M., Duane S., Hogan M., Broome B. J.. et al. (2016) Systems-thinking social marketing: conceptual extensions and empirical investigations. Journal of Marketing Management, 32, 1123–1144.
    1. Domegan C., Domegan C., McHugh P., McHugh P., Biroscak B. J., Biroscak B. J.. et al. (2017) Non-linear causal modelling in social marketing for wicked problems. Journal of Social Marketing, 7, 305–329.
    1. Duane S., Domegan C., McHugh P., Devaney M. (2016) From restricted to complex exchange and beyond: social marketing's change agenda. Journal of Marketing Management, 32, 856–876.
    1. Dustin D., Bricker N., Arave J., Wall W., West G. (2011) The promise of river running as a therapeutic medium for veterans coping with post-traumatic stress disorder. Therapeutic Recreation Journal, 45, 326.
    1. EC (2016) Supporting the Implementation of Green Infrastructure European Commission, Directorate-General for the Environment ENV.B.2/SER/2014/0012. , last accessed 9 September 2018.
    1. Fleischmann D., Michalewicz B., Stedje-Larsen E., Neff J., Murphy J., Browning K.,. et al.(2011) Surf medicine: Surfing as a means of therapy for combat-related polytrauma. Journal of Prosthetics and Orthotics, 23, 27–29.
    1. Foley R. (2015) Swimming in Ireland: immersions in therapeutic blue space. Health & Place, 35, 218–225.
    1. Foley R., Kistemann T. (2015) Blue space geographies: enabling health in place. Health & Place, 35, 157–165.
    1. Gascon M., Zijlema W., Vert C., White M. P., Nieuwenhuijsen M. J. (2017) Outdoor blue spaces, human health and well-being: a systematic review of quantitative studies. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 220, 1207–1221.
    1. Godfrey C., Devine-Wright H., Taylor J. (2015) The positive impact of structured surfing courses on the wellbeing of vulnerable young people. Community Practitioner, 88, 26.
    1. Graham H., White P. C. L. (2016) Social determinants and lifestyles: integrating environmental and public health perspectives. Public Health, 141, 270–278.
    1. Grellier J., White M. P., Albin M., Bell S., Elliott L. R., Gascón M.. et al. (2017) BlueHealth: a study programme protocol for mapping and quantifying the potential benefits to public health and well-being from Europe’s blue spaces. BMJ Open, 7, e016188.
    1. Grocott A. C., Hunter J. A. (2009) Increases in global and domain specific self-esteem following a 10 day developmental voyage. Social Psychology of Education, 12, 443–459.
    1. Haase D., Kabisch S., Haase A., Andersson E., Banzhaf E., Baró F.. et al. (2017) Greening cities—to be socially inclusive? About the alleged paradox of society and ecology in cities. Habitat International, 64, 41–48.
    1. Haeffner M., Jackson-Smith D., Buchert M., Risley J. (2017) Accessing blue spaces: social and geographic factors structuring familiarity with, use of, and appreciation of urban waterways. Landscape and Urban Planning, 167, 136–146.
    1. Hartig T., Mitchell R., De Vries S., Frumkin H. (2014) Nature and health. Annual Review of Public Health, 35, 207–228.
    1. Hayhurst J., Hunter J. A., Kafka S., Boyes M. (2015) Enhancing resilience in youth through a 10-day developmental voyage. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 15, 40–52.
    1. Hignett A., White M. P., Pahl S., Jenkin R., Froy M. L. (2017) Evaluation of a surfing programme designed to increase personal well-being and connectedness to the natural environment among at risk young people. Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, 18, 53–69.
    1. Hisschemöller M., Gupta J. (1999) Problem-solving through international environmental agreements: the issue of regime effectiveness. International Political Science Review, 20, 151–174.
    1. Jonassen D. H. (2003) Learning to Solve Problems: An Instructional Design Guide. Pfeiffer, San Francisco, CA.
    1. Kaplan R. S., Porter M. E. (2011) How to solve the cost crisis in health care. Harvard Business Review, 89, 46–52.
    1. Kickbusch L. (2015) The imperative of public health: opportunity or trap? Health Promotion International, 30, 197–200.
    1. Kim J. Y., Farmer P., Porter M. E. (2013) Redefining global health-care delivery. The Lancet, 382, 1060–1069.
    1. Kirwan D., Bharucha T., Verity A., Traianou A., Dunlop C., Mabey D. (2017) Crisis in the national health service: a call to action. The Lancet, 390, 225–226.
    1. Kite-Powell H. L., Fleming L. E., Backer L. C., Faustman E. M., Hoagland P., Tsuchiya A.,. et al. (2008) Linking the oceans to public health: current efforts and future directions. Environmental Health, 7, S6.
    1. Komro K. A., Flay B. R., Biglan A., Wagenaar A. C. (2016) Research design issues for evaluating complex multicomponent interventions in neighborhoods and communities. Translational Behavioral Medicine, 6, 153–159.
    1. Korpela K. M., Ylén M., Tyrväinen L., Silvennoinen H. (2010) Favorite green, waterside and urban environments, restorative experiences and perceived health in Finland. Health Promotion International, 25, 200–209.
    1. Kwasnicka D., Dombrowski S. U., White M., Sniehotta F. (2016) Theoretical explanations for maintenance of behaviour change: a systematic review of behaviour theories. Health Psychology Review, 10, 277–296.
    1. Lefebvre C. R., Flora J. A. (1988) Social marketing and public health intervention. Health Education Quarterly, 15, 299–315.
    1. Levin P. S., Poe M. R. (2017) Conservation for the Anthropocene Ocean: Interdisciplinary Science in Support of Nature and People. Academic Press.
    1. Linton M.-J., Dieppe P., Medina-Lara A. (2016) Review of 99 self-report measures for assessing well-being in adults: exploring dimensions of well-being and developments over time. BMJ Open, 6, e010641.
    1. Lopes J. T. (2015) Adapted surfing as a tool to promote inclusion and rising disability awareness in Portugal. Journal of Sport for Development, 3, 4–10.
    1. Lovell R., Wheeler B. W., Higgins S. L., Irvine K. N., Depledge M. H. (2014) A systematic review of the health and well-being benefits of biodiverse environments. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, Part B, 17, 1–20.
    1. Maller C., Townsend M., Pryor A., Brown P., St Leger L. (2006) Healthy nature healthy people: ‘contact with nature’ as an upstream health promotion intervention for populations. Health Promotion International, 21, 45–54.
    1. Mansfield L., Kay T., Meads C., Grigsby-Duffy L., Lane J., John A.. et al., (2018) Sport and dance interventions for healthy young people (15–24 years) to promote subjective well-being: a systematic review. BMJ Open, 8, e020959.
    1. Marselle M. R., Irvine K. N., Warber S. L. (2013) Walking for well-being: are group walks in certain types of natural environments better for well-being than group walks in urban environments? International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 10, 5603–5628.
    1. Matos M. G., Santos A., Fauvelet C., Marta F., Evangelista E. S. (2017) Surfing for social integration: mental health and well-being promotion through surf therapy among institutionalized young people. Community Med Public Health Care, 4, 026.
    1. McCulloch K., McLaughlin P., Allison P., Edwards V., Tett L. (2010) Sail training as education: more than mere adventure. Oxford Review of Education, 36, 661–676.
    1. McDonough M. H., Sabiston C. M., Crocker P. R. (2008) An interpretative phenomenological examination of psychosocial changes among breast cancer survivors in their first season of dragon boating. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 20, 425–440.
    1. McHugh P., Domegan C., Duane S. (2018) Protocols for stakeholder participation in social marketing systems. Social Marketing Quarterly, 24, 164–193.
    1. MEA (Millennium Ecosystem Assessment) (2005) Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Wetlands and Water. World Resources Institute, Washington, DC, p. 5.
    1. Meadows D. H. (2008) Thinking in Systems: A Primer. Chelsea Green Publishing, White River Junction.
    1. Mental Health Taskforce (2016) A Five Year Forward View for Mental Health A report from the independent Mental Health Taskforce to the NHS in England. , last accessed 9 September 2018.
    1. Meyer J. H. F., Land R. (2003) Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge 1—linkages to ways of thinking and practising In Rust C. (ed.) Improving Student Learning—Ten Years On. OCSLD, Oxford, pp. 412–424.
    1. Mitchell T. L., Yakiwchuk C. V., Griffin K. L., Gray R. E., Fitch M. I. (2007) Survivor dragon boating: a vehicle to reclaim and enhance life after treatment for breast cancer. Health Care for Women International, 28, 122–140.
    1. Mowatt R. A., Bennett J. (2011) War narratives: veteran stories, PTSD effects, and therapeutic fly-fishing. Therapeutic Recreation Journal, 45, 286.
    1. Nielsen E., Mitchell T. (2002) Living life to the limits: dragon boaters and breast cancer. Canadian Woman Studies, 21, 50.
    1. Neumann B., Vafeidis A. T., Zimmermann J., Nicholls R. J. (2015) Future coastal population growth and exposure to sea-level rise and coastal flooding—a global assessment. PLoS One, 10, e0118571.
    1. Nutbeam D. (1998) Evaluating health promotion—progress, problems and solutions. Health Promotion International, 13, 27–44.
    1. Oakley A., Strange V., Bonell C., Allen E., Stephenson J. (2006) Process evaluation in randomised controlled trials of complex interventions. British Medical Journal, 332, 413–416.
    1. Parry D. C. (2008) The contribution of dragon boat racing to women's health and breast cancer survivorship. Qualitative Health Research, 18, 222–233.
    1. Parry D. C. (2007) “There is life after breast cancer”: nine vignettes exploring dragon boat racing for breast cancer survivors. Leisure Sciences, 29, 53–69.
    1. Pearce J., Shortt N., Rind E., Mitchell R. (2016) Lifecourse, green space and health: incorporating place into life course epidemiology. Environmental Research and Public Health, 13, 331–342.
    1. Pitt H. (2018) Muddying the waters: what urban waterways reveal about bluespaces and wellbeing. Geoforum, 92, 161–170.
    1. Poland B., Krupa G., McCall D. (2009) Settings for health promotion: an analytic framework to guide intervention design and implementation. Health Promotion Practice, 10, 505–516.
    1. Rogers C. M., Mallinson T., Peppers D. (2014) High-intensity sports for post traumatic stress disorder and depression: feasibility study of Ocean Therapy with veterans of Operation Enduring Freedom and Operation Iraqi Freedom. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 68, 395–404.
    1. Raymond C. M., Frantzeskaki N., Kabisch N., Berry P., Breil M., Nita M. R.. et al. (2017) A framework for assessing and implementing the co-benefits of nature-based solutions in urban areas. Environmental Science & Policy, 77, 15–24.
    1. Ritchie S. D., Wabano M. J., Corbiere R. G., Restoule B. M., Russell K. C., Young N. L. (2015) Connecting to the Good Life through outdoor adventure leadership experiences designed for Indigenous youth. Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, 15, 350–370.
    1. Ritchie S. D., Wabano M. J., Russell K., Enosse L., Young N. L. (2014) Promoting resilience and wellbeing through an outdoor intervention designed for Aboriginal adolescents. Rural Remote Health, 14, 2523.
    1. Rütten A., Frahsa A., Abel T., Bergmann M. D., Leeuw E., Hunter D.. et al. (2019) Co-producing active lifestyles as whole-system-approach: theory, intervention and knowledge-to-action implications. Health Promotion International, 34, 47–59.
    1. Sabiston C. M., McDonough M. H., Crocker P. R. (2007) Psychosocial experiences of breast cancer survivors involved in a dragon boat program: exploring links to positive psychological growth. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 29, 419–438.
    1. Sandifer P. A., Sutton-Grier A. E., Ward B. P. (2015) Exploring connections among nature, biodiversity, ecosystem services, and human health and well-being: opportunities to enhance health and biodiversity conservation. Ecosystem Services, 12, 1–15.
    1. de Savigny D., Adam T. (eds) (2009) Systems Thinking for Health Systems Strengthening. Alliance for Health Policy and Systems Research, World Health Organisation; , last accessed 9 September 2018.
    1. Schultz P. W. (2002) Inclusion with nature: the psychology of human-nature relations In Schmuck P., Schultz P. W. (eds), Psychology of Sustainable Development. Springer US, Boston, MA, pp. 61–78.
    1. Sempik J., Bragg R. (2016). Green care: nature-based interventions for vulnerable people In Barton J., Bragg R., Wood C., Pretty J. (eds), Green Exercise: Linking Nature, Health and Well-Being. Routledge, Abingdon, Oxon.
    1. Smolander J., Mikkelsson M., Oksa J., Westerlund T., Leppäluoto J., Huttunen P. (2004) Thermal sensation and comfort in women exposed repeatedly to whole-body cryotherapy and winter swimming in ice-cold water. Physiology & Behavior, 82, 691–695.
    1. Sniehotta F. F., Araújo-Soares V., Brown J., Kelly M. P., Michie S., West R. (2017) Complex systems and individual-level approaches to population health: a false dichotomy? The Lancet Public Health, 2, e396–e397.
    1. South J. (2015) A Guide to Community-centred Approaches for Health and Wellbeing. Public Health England; (Briefing), London, UK.
    1. Tardona D. R. (2011) Opportunities to explore nature and wellbeing through kayaking for inner-city youth. European Journal of Ecopsychology, 2, 77–85.
    1. Unruh A. M., Elvin N. (2004) In the eye of the dragon: women's experience of breast cancer and the occupation of dragon boat racing. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 71, 138–149.
    1. Vella E. J., Milligan B., Bennett J. L. (2013) Participation in outdoor recreation program predicts improved psychosocial well-being among veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder: a pilot study. Military Medicine, 178, 254–260.
    1. Völker S., Kistemann T. (2011) The impact of blue space on human health and well-being–Salutogenetic health effects of inland surface waters: a review. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 214, 449–460.
    1. Wheaton B. (2017) Surfing through the life-course: silver surfers’ negotiation of ageing. Annals of Leisure Research, 20, 96–116.
    1. Wheeler B. W., Lovell R., Higgins S. L., White M. P., Alcock I., Osborne N. J.. et al. (2015) Beyond greenspace: an ecological study of population general health and indicators of natural environment type and quality. International Journal of Health Geographics, 14, 17.
    1. White M. P., Weeks A., Hooper T., Bleakley L., Cracknell D., Lovell R.. et al. (2017) Marine wildlife as an important component of coastal visits: the role of perceived biodiversity and species behaviour. Marine Policy, 78, 80–89.
    1. White R., Abraham C., Smith J. R., White M., Staiger P. K. (2016) Recovery under sail: rehabilitation clients' experience of a sail training voyage. Addiction Research & Theory, 24, 355–365.
    1. Whitmee S., Haines A., Beyrer C., Boltz F., Capon A. G., de Souza Dias B. F.. et al. (2015) Safeguarding human health in the Anthropocene epoch: report of The Rockefeller Foundation–Lancet Commission on planetary health. The Lancet, 386, 1973–2028.
    1. WHO (2016) Prevention and Control of Noncommunicable Diseases in the European Region: A Progress Report World Health Organisation. , last accessed 9 September 2018.
    1. WHO (2017) Water, health and Ecosystems. World Health Organisation; , last accessed 9 September 2018.
    1. Wilson T. D., Gilbert D. T. (2005) Affective forecasting: knowing what to want. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 14, 131–134.
    1. Wong K. C., Wong F. K. Y., Yeung W. F., Chang K. (2017) The effect of complex interventions on supporting self-care among community-dwelling older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Age and Ageing, 1, 9.
    1. Wyles K. J., Pahl S., Thomas K., Thompson R. C. (2016) Factors that can undermine the psychological benefits of coastal environments: exploring the effect of tidal state, presence, and type of litter. Environment and Behavior, 48, 1095–1126.
    1. Wyles K. J., Pahl S., Holland M., Thompson R. C. (2017a) Can beach cleans do more than clean-up litter? Comparing beach cleans to other coastal activities. Environment and Behavior, 49, 509–535.
    1. Wyles K. J., White M. P., Hattam C., Pahl S., King H., Austen M. (2017b) Are some natural environments more psychologically beneficial than others? The importance of type and quality on connectedness to nature and psychological restoration. Environment and Behavior, doi:10.1177/0013916517738312.
    1. Yach D., Hawkes C., Gould C. L., Hofman K. J. (2004) The global burden of chronic diseases: overcoming impediments to prevention and control. Journal of the American Medical Association, 291, 2616–2622.
    1. Yerrell P. (2008) National Evaluation of BTCV's Green Gym. School of Health and Social Care, Oxford Brookes University, Oxford.

Source: PubMed

Sponsorzy i współpracownicy

Warunki medyczne

Interwencje lekowe

3
Subskrybuj