Are all placebo effects equal? Placebo pills, sham acupuncture, cue conditioning and their association

Jian Kong, Rosa Spaeth, Amanda Cook, Irving Kirsch, Brian Claggett, Mark Vangel, Randy L Gollub, Jordan W Smoller, Ted J Kaptchuk, Jian Kong, Rosa Spaeth, Amanda Cook, Irving Kirsch, Brian Claggett, Mark Vangel, Randy L Gollub, Jordan W Smoller, Ted J Kaptchuk

Abstract

Placebo treatments and healing rituals have been used to treat pain throughout history. The present within-subject crossover study examines the variability in individual responses to placebo treatment with verbal suggestion and visual cue conditioning by investigating whether responses to different types of placebo treatment, as well as conditioning responses, correlate with one another. Secondarily, this study also examines whether responses to sham acupuncture correlate with responses to genuine acupuncture. Healthy subjects were recruited to participate in two sequential experiments. Experiment one is a five-session crossover study. In each session, subjects received one of four treatments: placebo pills (described as Tylenol), sham acupuncture, genuine acupuncture, or no treatment rest control condition. Before and after each treatment, paired with a verbal suggestion of positive effect, each subject's pain threshold, pain tolerance, and pain ratings to calibrated heat pain were measured. At least 14 days after completing experiment one, all subjects were invited to participate in experiment two, during which their analgesic responses to conditioned visual cues were tested. Forty-eight healthy subjects completed experiment one, and 45 completed experiment two. The results showed significantly different effects of genuine acupuncture, placebo pill and rest control on pain threshold. There was no significant association between placebo pills, sham acupuncture and cue conditioning effects, indicating that individuals may respond to unique healing rituals in different ways. This outcome suggests that placebo response may be a complex behavioral phenomenon that has properties that comprise a state, rather than a trait characteristic. This could explain the difficulty of detecting a signature for "placebo responders." However, a significant association was found between the genuine and sham acupuncture treatments, implying that the non-specific effects of acupuncture may contribute to the analgesic effect observed in genuine acupuncture analgesia.

Conflict of interest statement

Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Figures

Figure 1. Experimental design.
Figure 1. Experimental design.
Figure 2. Summary of pain measurement difference…
Figure 2. Summary of pain measurement difference (post- minus pre-treatment, mean ± SE) on pain threshold, pain tolerance, and pain rating across different groups.
EA, electroacupuncture group; PA, placebo acupuncture group; PT, placebo Tylenol group; RS, resting control group.

References

    1. Shapiro AK, Shapiro E (1997) The Powerful Placebo: From Ancient Priest to Modern Physician. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
    1. Kaptchuk TJ (2011) Placebo studies and ritual theory: a comparative analysis of Navajo, acupuncture and biomedical healing. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 366: 1849–1858.
    1. Brody H, Miller FG (2011) Lessons from recent research about the placebo effect – from art to science. Jama 306: 2612–2613.
    1. Finniss DG, Kaptchuk TJ, Miller F, Benedetti F (2010) Biological, clinical, and ethical advances of placebo effects. Lancet 375: 686–695.
    1. Kaptchuk TJ, Stason WB, Davis RB, Legedza AR, Schnyer RN, et al. (2006) Sham device v inert pill: randomised controlled trial of two placebo treatments. Bmj 332: 391–397.
    1. Colloca L, Tinazzi M, Recchia S, Le Pera D, Fiaschi A, et al. (2008) Learning potentiates neurophysiological and behavioral placebo analgesic responses. Pain 139: 306–314.
    1. Kaptchuk TJ (2002) Acupuncture: theory, efficacy, and practice. Ann Intern Med 136: 374–383.
    1. Linde K, Niemann K, Schneider A, Meissner K (2010) How large are the nonspecific effects of acupuncture? A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. BMC Med 8: 75.
    1. Kaptchuk TJ, Goldman P, Stone DA, Stason WB (2000) Do medical devices have enhanced placebo effects? J Clin Epidemiol 53: 786–792.
    1. Linde K, Niemann K, Meissner K (2010) Are sham acupuncture interventions more effective than (other) placebos? A re-analysis of data from the Cochrane review on placebo effects. Forsch Komplementmed 17: 259–264.
    1. Vickers AJ, Cronin AM, Maschino AC, Lewith G, Macpherson H, et al... (2012) Acupuncture for Chronic Pain: Individual Patient Data Meta-analysis. Arch Intern Med: 1–10.
    1. Kong J, Fufa DT, Gerber AJ, Rosman IS, Vangel MG, et al. (2005) Psychophysical outcomes from a randomized pilot study of manual, electro, and sham acupuncture treatment on experimentally induced thermal pain. J Pain 6: 55–64.
    1. Gracely RH, McGrath PA, Dubner R (1978) Ratio scales of sensory and affective verbal pain descriptors. Pain 5: 5–18.
    1. Gracely RH, McGrath PA, Dubner R (1978) Validity and sensitivity of ratio scales of sensory and affective verbal pain descriptors: manipulation of affect by diazepam. Pain 5: 19–29.
    1. Kong J, Gollub RL, Rosman IS, Webb JM, Vangel MG, et al. (2006) Brain activity associated with expectancy-enhanced placebo analgesia as measured by functional magnetic resonance imaging. J Neurosci 26: 381–388.
    1. Kong J, Kaptachuk TJ, Polich G, Kirsch IV, Angel M, et al... (2009) Expectancy and treatment interactions: A dissociation between acupuncture analgesia and expectancy evoked placebo analgesia. Neuroimage 45: 940–949 PMID: 19159691
    1. Kong J, Kaptchuk TJ, Polich G, Kirsch I, Vangel M, et al... (2009) An fMRI study on the interaction and dissociation between expectation of pain relief and acupuncture treatment. Neuroimage 47: 1066–1076 PMID: 19501656.
    1. Geers AL, Helfer SG, Kosbab K, Weiland PE, Landry SJ (2005) Reconsidering the role of personality in placebo effects: dispositional optimism, situational expectations, and the placebo response. J Psychosom Res 58: 121–127.
    1. Geers AL, Wellman JA, Fowler SL, Helfer SG, France CR (2010) Dispositional optimism predicts placebo analgesia. J Pain 11: 1165–1171.
    1. Morton DL, Watson A, El-Deredy W, Jones AK (2009) Reproducibility of placebo analgesia: Effect of dispositional optimism. Pain 146: 194–198.
    1. Voudouris NJ, Peck CL, Coleman G (1990) The role of conditioning and verbal expectancy in the placebo response. Pain 43: 121–128.
    1. Montgomery GH, Kirsch I (1997) Classical conditioning and the placebo effect. Pain 72: 107–113.
    1. Price DD, Milling LS, Kirsch I, Duff A, Montgomery GH, et al. (1999) An analysis of factors that contribute to the magnitude of placebo analgesia in an experimental paradigm. Pain 83: 147–156.
    1. De Pascalis V, Chiaradia C, Carotenuto E (2002) The contribution of suggestibility and expectation to placebo analgesia phenomenon in an experimental setting. Pain 96: 393–402.
    1. Wager TD, Rilling JK, Smith EE, Sokolik A, Casey KL, et al. (2004) Placebo-induced changes in FMRI in the anticipation and experience of pain. Science 303: 1162–1167.
    1. Kong J, Gollub RL, Polich G, Kirsch I, Laviolette P, et al... (2008) A functional magnetic resonance imaging study on the neural mechanisms of hyperalgesic nocebo effect. J Neurosci 28: 13354–13362 PMCID: PMC2649754.
    1. Bingel U, Lorenz J, Schoell E, Weiller C, Buchel C (2006) Mechanisms of placebo analgesia: rACC recruitment of a subcortical antinociceptive network. Pain 120: 8–15.
    1. Bingel U, Wanigasekera V, Wiech K, Mhuircheartaigh RN, Lee MC, et al. (2011) The effect of treatment expectation on drug efficacy: Imaging the analgesic benefit of the opioid remifentanil. Sci Transl Med 3: 70ra14.
    1. Kleinhenz J, Streitberger K, Windeler J, Gussbacher A, Mavridis G, et al. (1999) Randomised clinical trial comparing the effects of acupuncture and a newly designed placebo needle in rotator cuff tendinitis. Pain 83: 235–241.
    1. Streitberger K, Kleinhenz J (1998) Introducing a placebo needle into acupuncture research. Lancet 352: 364–365.
    1. White P, Lewith G, Hopwood V, Prescott P (2003) The placebo needle, is it a valid and convincing placebo for use in acupuncture trials? A randomised, single-blind, cross-over pilot trial. Pain 106: 401–409.
    1. Wasan AD, Kong J, Pham LD, Kaptchuk TJ, Edwards R, et al. (2010) The Impact of Placebo, Psychopathology, and Expectations on the Response to Acupuncture Needling in Patients With Chronic Low Back Pain. J Pain 11: 555–563.
    1. Cheng XN (1987) Chinese acupuncture and moxibustion. Beijing: Foreign Language Press. 513–523 p.
    1. Stux G (1997) Channels, Organs, and Points. In: Stux G, Pomeranz B, editors. Basics of Acupuncture. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. 110.
    1. Kong J, Gollub R, Huang T, Polich G, Napadow V, et al. (2007) Acupuncture de qi, from qualitative history to quantitative measurement. J Altern Complement Med 13: 1059–1070.
    1. Kong J, Jensen K, Loiotile R, Cheetham A, Wey HY, et al. (2013) Functional connectivity of frontoparietal network predicts cognitive modulation of pain. Pain 154: 459–467.
    1. Conover WJ, Iman RL (1982) Analysis of covariance using the rank transformation. Biometrics 38: 715–724.
    1. Huber P (1973) Robust Regression: Asymptotics, Conjectures and Monte Carlo. Ann Statist 1: 799–821.
    1. Passarelli EW, Traut EF (1956) Study in the controlled therapy of degenerative arthritis. AMA Arch Intern Med 98: 181–186.
    1. Traut EF, Passarelli EW (1957) Placebos in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis and other rheumatic conditions. Ann Rheum Dis 16: 18–22.
    1. Grenfell RF, Briggs AH, Holland WC (1961) A double-blind study of the treatment of hypertension. Jama 176: 124–128.
    1. Goldman AR, Witton K, Scherer JM (1965) The Drug-Giving Ritual, Verbal Instructions and Schizophrenics Ward Activity Levels. J Nerv Ment Dis 140: 272–279.
    1. de Craen AJ, Tijssen JG, de Gans J, Kleijnen J (2000) Placebo effect in the acute treatment of migraine: subcutaneous placebos are better than oral placebos. J Neurol 247: 183–188.
    1. Hrobjartsson A, Gotzsche PC (2010) Placebo interventions for all clinical conditions. Cochrane Database Syst Rev: CD003974.
    1. Whalley B, Hyland ME, Kirsch I (2008) Consistency of the placebo effect. J Psychosom Res 64: 537–541.
    1. Roberts AH, Kewman DG, Mercier L, Hovell M (1993) The power of nonspecific effects in healing implication for psychosocial and bioligical treatments. Clin psycho rev 13: 375–391.
    1. Charron J, Rainville P, Marchand S (2006) Direct comparison of placebo effects on clinical and experimental pain. Clin J Pain 22: 204–211.
    1. Gracely RH (1994) Studies of pain in normal man. In: Wall PD, Melzack R, editors. Textbook of Pain. 3rd ed. Edinbourgh: Churchill Livingstone. 315–336.
    1. Gelfand S (1964) The Relationship of Experimental Pain Tolerance to Pain Threshold. Can J Psychol 18: 36–42.
    1. Hrobjartsson A, Gotzsche PC (2001) Is the placebo powerless? An analysis of clinical trials comparing placebo with no treatment. N Engl J Med 344: 1594–1602.
    1. Kaptchuk TJ, Kelley JM, Deykin A, Wayne PM, Lasagna LC, et al. (2008) Do “placebo responders” exist? Contemp Clin Trials 29: 587–595.

Source: PubMed

Sponsorzy i współpracownicy

Warunki medyczne

Interwencje lekowe

3
Subskrybuj