Is the intention to vaccinate enough? Systematic variation in the value of timely vaccinations and preferences for monetary vs non-monetary incentives among pregnant women in southern Tanzania
Jan Ostermann, Nicole L Hair, Sara Moses, Esther Ngadaya, Sayoki Godfrey Mfinanga, Derek S Brown, Joy Noel Baumgartner, Lavanya Vasudevan, Jan Ostermann, Nicole L Hair, Sara Moses, Esther Ngadaya, Sayoki Godfrey Mfinanga, Derek S Brown, Joy Noel Baumgartner, Lavanya Vasudevan
Abstract
Background: Globally, approximately 19.7 million children remain under-vaccinated; many more receive delayed vaccinations. Sustained progress towards global vaccination targets requires overcoming, or compensating for, incrementally greater barriers to vaccinating hard-to-reach and hard-to-vaccinate children. We prospectively assessed pregnant women's valuations of routine childhood vaccinations and preferences for alternative incentives to inform interventions aiming to increase vaccination coverage and timeliness in southern Tanzania.
Methods: Between August and December 2017, 406 women in their last trimester of pregnancy were enrolled from health facilities and communities in the Mtwara region of Tanzania and asked contingent valuation questions about their willingness to vaccinate their child if they were (a) given an incentive, or (b) facing a cost for each vaccination. Interval censored regressions assessed correlates of women's willingness to pay (WTP) for timely vaccinations. Participants were asked to rank monetary and non-monetary incentive options for the timely vaccination of their children.
Findings: All women expected to get their children vaccinated according to the recommended schedule, even without incentives. Nearly all women (393; 96.8 %) were willing to pay for vaccinations. The average WTP was Tanzania Shilling (Tsh) 3,066 (95 % confidence interval Tsh 2,523-3,610; 1 USD ∼ Tsh 2,200) for each vaccination. Women's valuations of timely vaccinations varied significantly with vaccine-related knowledge and attitudes, economic status, and rural vs urban residence. Women tended to prefer non-monetary over monetary incentives for the timely vaccination of their children.
Interpretation: Women placed a high value on timely childhood vaccinations, suggesting that unexpected system-level barriers rather than individual-level demand factors are likely to be the primary drivers of missed vaccinations. Systematic variation in the value of vaccinations across women reflects variation in perceived benefits and opportunity costs. In this setting, nonmonetary incentives and other interventions to increase demand and compensate for system-level barriers hold significant potential for improving vaccination coverage and timeliness.
Clinicaltrialsgov protocol: NCT03252288.
Keywords: Childhood vaccinations; Contingent valuation; Incentives; Tanzania; Vaccination timeliness; Willingness to pay.
Conflict of interest statement
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
© 2023 The Authors.
Figures
References
- Sim S.Y., Watts E., Constenla D., Brenzel L., Patenaude B.N. Return On Investment From Immunization Against 10 Pathogens In 94 Low- And Middle-Income Countries, 2011–30. Health Aff (Millwood) 2020;39(8):1343–1353.
- MacDonald N., Mohsni E., Al-Mazrou Y., Kim Andrus J., Arora N., Elden S., et al. Global vaccine action plan lessons learned I: Recommendations for the next decade. Vaccine. 2020;38(33):5364–5371.
- Vasudevan L., Baumgartner J.N., Moses S., Ngadaya E., Mfinanga S.G., Ostermann J. Parental concerns and uptake of childhood vaccines in rural Tanzania - a mixed methods study. BMC Public Health. 2020;20(1):1573.
- Deogaonkar R., Hutubessy R., van der Putten I., Evers S., Jit M. Systematic review of studies evaluating the broader economic impact of vaccination in low and middle income countries. BMC Public Health. 2012;12:878.
- Peck M., Gacic-Dobo M., Diallo M.S., Nedelec Y., Sodha S.V., Wallace A.S. Global Routine Vaccination Coverage, 2018. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2019;68(42):937–942.
- Bowles S., Polania-Reyes S. Economic incentives and social preferences: substitutes or complements? J Econ Lit. 2012;50(2):368–425.
- Ozawa S., Yemeke T.T., Evans D.R., Pallas S.E., Wallace A.S., Lee B.Y. Defining hard-to-reach populations for vaccination. Vaccine. 2019;37(37):5525–5534.
- Barnighausen T., Bloom D.E., Cafiero-Fonseca E.T., O'Brien J.C. Valuing vaccination. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2014;111(34):12313–12319.
- Ozawa S., Clark S., Portnoy A., Grewal S., Brenzel L., Walker D.G. Return On Investment From Childhood Immunization In Low- And Middle-Income Countries, 2011–20. Health Aff (Millwood) 2016;35(2):199–207.
- Prosser L.A., Payne K., Rusinak D., Shi P., Uyeki T., Messonnier M. Valuing health across the lifespan: health state preferences for seasonal influenza illnesses in patients of different ages. Value Health. 2011;14(1):135–143.
- Jacobs R.J., Moleski R.J., Meyerhoff A.S. Valuation of symptomatic hepatitis a in adults: estimates based on time trade-off and willingness-to-pay measurement. Pharmacoeconomics. 2002;20(11):739–747.
- Poulos C., Yang J.C., Levin C., Van Minh H., Giang K.B., Nguyen D. Mothers' preferences and willingness to pay for HPV vaccines in Vinh Long Province. Vietnam, Soc Sci Med. 2011;73(2):226–234.
- Brown D.S., Johnson F.R., Poulos C., Messonnier M.L. Mothers' preferences and willingness to pay for vaccinating daughters against human papillomavirus. Vaccine. 2010;28(7):1702–1708.
- Lin Y., Lin Z., He F., Chen H., Lin X., Zimet G.D., et al. HPV vaccination intent and willingness to pay for 2-,4-, and 9-valent HPV vaccines: A study of adult women aged 27–45 years in China. Vaccine. 2020;38(14):3021–3030.
- Ossai E.N., Fatiregun A.A. Clients' Willingness to Pay for Immunization Services in the Urban and Rural Primary Health Centers of Enugu State, Nigeria. J Public Health Afr. 2015;6(1):480.
- Semali I.A., Tanner M., de Savigny D. Decentralizing EPI services and prospects for increasing coverage: the case of Tanzania. Int J Health Plann Manage. 2005;20(1):21–39.
- Kamenica E. Behavioral Economics and Psychology of Incentives. Annual Review of Economics. 2012;4(1):427–452.
- Gopalan S.S., Mutasa R., Friedman J., Das A. Health sector demand-side financial incentives in low- and middle-income countries: a systematic review on demand- and supply-side effects. Soc Sci Med. 2014;100:72–83.
- Lagarde M., Haines A., Palmer N. The impact of conditional cash transfers on health outcomes and use of health services in low and middle income countries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;4:CD008137.
- Ranganathan M., Lagarde M. Promoting healthy behaviours and improving health outcomes in low and middle income countries: a review of the impact of conditional cash transfer programmes. Prev Med. 2012;55(Suppl):S95–S105.
- Bassani D.G., Arora P., Wazny K., Gaffey M.F., Lenters L., Bhutta Z.A. Financial incentives and coverage of child health interventions: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Public Health. 2013;13(Suppl 3):S30.
- Chandir S., Khan A.J., Hussain H., Usman H.R., Khowaja S., Halsey N.A., et al. Effect of food coupon incentives on timely completion of DTP immunization series in children from a low-income area in Karachi, Pakistan: a longitudinal intervention study. Vaccine. 2010;28(19):3473–3478.
- Robertson L., Mushati P., Eaton J.W., Dumba L., Mavise G., Makoni J., et al. Effects of unconditional and conditional cash transfers on child health and development in Zimbabwe: a cluster-randomised trial. Lancet. 2013;381(9874):1283–1292.
- Wakadha H., Chandir S., Were E.V., Rubin A., Obor D., Levine O.S., et al. The feasibility of using mobile-phone based SMS reminders and conditional cash transfers to improve timely immunization in rural Kenya. Vaccine. 2013;31(6):987–993.
- Finkelstein E.A., Bilger M., Baid D. Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of incentives as a tool for prevention of non-communicable diseases: A systematic review. Soc Sci Med. 2019;232:340–350.
- Adams J., McNaughton R.J., Wigham S., Flynn D., Ternent L., Shucksmith J. Acceptability of Parental Financial Incentives and Quasi-Mandatory Interventions for Preschool Vaccinations: Triangulation of Findings from Three Linked Studies. PLoS One. 2016;11(6):e0156843.
- Carson R.T., Hanemann W.M. Handbook of Environmental Economics. Elsevier; 2006. pp. 821–936.
- Ostermann J., Vasudevan L., Baumgartner J.N., Ngadaya E., Mfinanga S.G. Do mobile phone-based reminders and conditional financial transfers improve the timeliness of childhood vaccinations in Tanzania? Study protocol for a quasi-randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2019;20(1):397.
- Yelverton V., Hair N., Vasudevan L., Baumgartner J.N., Ngadaya E., Mfinanga S.G., Ostermann J. Beyond coverage: Rural-urban disparities in the timeliness of childhood vaccinations in Tanzania. Vaccine. 2022 Sep 2;40(37):5483–5493. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.07.020. Epub 2022 Aug 10.
- Duan N. Smearing Estimate: A Nonparametric Retransformation Method. J Am Stat Assoc. 1983;78(383):605–610.
- Hall J., Kenny P., King M., Louviere J., Viney R., Yeoh A. Using stated preference discrete choice modelling to evaluate the introduction of varicella vaccination. Health Econ. 2002;11(5):457–465.
- Sansom S.L., Barker L., Corso P.S., Brown C., Deuson R. Rotavirus vaccine and intussusception: how much risk will parents in the United States accept to obtain vaccine benefits? Am J Epidemiol. 2001;154(11):1077–1085.
- Rezaei S., Woldemichael A., Mirzaei M., Mohammadi S., Karami Matin B. Mothers' willingness to accept and pay for vaccines to their children in western Iran: a contingent valuation study. BMC Pediatr. 2020;20(1):307.
- Lucas M.E., Jeuland M., Deen J., Lazaro N., MacMahon M., Nyamete A., et al. Private demand for cholera vaccines in Beira. Mozambique, Vaccine. 2007;25(14):2599–2609.
- Umeh I.B., Nduka S.O., Ekwunife O.I. Mothers' willingness to pay for HPV vaccines in Anambra state, Nigeria: a cross sectional contingent valuation study. Cost Eff Resour Alloc. 2016;14:8.
- Cropper M.L. The Demand for a Malaria Vaccine: Evidence from Ethiopia. J Dev Econ. 2004;75(1):303–318.
- Ughasoro M.D., Esangbedo D.O., Tagbo B.N., Mejeha I.C. Acceptability and Willingness-to-Pay for a Hypothetical Ebola Virus Vaccine in Nigeria. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2015;9(6):e0003838.
- Bishai D., Pariyo G., Ainsworth M., Hill K. Determinants of personal demand for an AIDS vaccine in Uganda: contingent valuation survey. Bull World Health Organ. 2004;82(9):652–660.
- Do G.C., Whittington D., Le T.K., Utomo N., Nguyen T.H., Poulos C., et al. Household demand for typhoid fever vaccines in Hue. Vietnam, Health Policy Plan. 2006;21(3):241–255.
- Guh S., Xingbao C., Poulos C., Qi Z., Jianwen C., von Seidlein L., et al. Comparison of cost-of-illness with willingness-to-pay estimates to avoid shigellosis: evidence from China. Health Policy Plan. 2008;23(2):125–136.
- Heinzen R.R., Bridges J.F. Comparison of four contingent valuation methods to estimate the economic value of a pneumococcal vaccine in Bangladesh. Int J Technol Assess Health Care. 2008;24(4):481–487.
- Islam Z., Maskery B., Nyamete A., Horowitz M.S., Yunus M., Whittington D. Private demand for cholera vaccines in rural Matlab. Bangladesh, Health Policy. 2008;85(2):184–195.
- Kim D., Canh D.G., Poulos C., Thoa L.T., Cook J., Hoa N.T., et al. Private demand for cholera vaccines in Hue. Vietnam, Value Health. 2008;11(1):119–128.
- Lieu T.A., Finkelstein J.A., Adams M.M., Miroshnik I.L., Lett S.M., Palfrey S., et al. Pediatricians' views on financial barriers and values for pneumococcal vaccine for children. Ambul Pediatr. 2002;2(5):358–366.
- Baumgartner J.N., Morroni C., Mlobeli R.D., Otterness C., Myer L., Janowitz B., et al. Timeliness of contraceptive reinjections in South Africa and its relation to unintentional discontinuation. Int Fam Plan Perspect. 2007;33(2):66–74.
- Carson R., Flores N., Martin K.M., Wright J.L. Contingent Valuation and Revealed Preference Methodologies: Comparing the Estimates for Quasi-Public Goods. Land Econ. 1996;72(1):80–99.
- Dow W.H., White J.S. Incentivizing use of health care. United Nations Population Division Publications. 2013
- Cook J. Using Private Demand Studies to Calculate Socially Optimal Vaccine Subsidies in Developing Countries. J Policy Anal Manage. 2009;28(1):6–28.
- Kessing S.G., Nuscheler R. Monopoly Pricing with Negative Network Effects: The Case of Vaccines. Eur Econ Rev. 2006;50(4):1061–1069.
- Deci E.L., Koestner R., Ryan R.M. A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation. Psychol Bull. 1999;125(6):627–628. discussion 692–700.
- Uri Gneezy B., Rustichini A. A Fine Is a Price. J Leg Stud. 2000;29(1):1–17.
Source: PubMed