Early Speech and Language Development in Children With Nonsyndromic Cleft Lip and/or Palate: A Meta-Analysis

Hope Sparks Lancaster, Kari M Lien, Jason C Chow, Jennifer R Frey, Nancy J Scherer, Ann P Kaiser, Hope Sparks Lancaster, Kari M Lien, Jason C Chow, Jennifer R Frey, Nancy J Scherer, Ann P Kaiser

Abstract

Objective The aim of the study was to conduct a meta-analysis of research examining the early speech and language functioning of young children, birth to age 8;11 (years;months), with nonsyndromic cleft lip and/or palate (NSCL/P) compared to their peers without NSCL/P. Method We conducted a random-effects metaregression using 241 effect sizes from 31 studies comparing 955 young children with NSCL/P to 938 typically developing peers on measures of speech and language functioning. Moderators were sample characteristics (i.e., age, cleft type, publication year, and study location) and measurement characteristics (i.e., speech sample material, language modality and domain, and assessment type). Results Young children with NSCL/P scored significantly lower on measures of speech and language compared to children without NSCL/P. Children with NSCL/P had smaller consonant inventories (standardized mean difference effect size [ESg] = -1.24), less accurate articulation (ESg = -1.13), and more speech errors (ESg = 0.93) than their peers. Additionally, children with NSCL/P had poorer expressive (ESg = -0.57) and receptive (ESg = -0.59) language skills than their peers. Age and assessment type moderated effect sizes for expressive language. As children with NSCL/P aged, their expressive language performance became more similar to their peers. Expressive language effect sizes from parent reports and observational language measures (estimated effect size = -0.74) were significantly lower than those from standardized norm-referenced tests (estimated effect size = -0.45). Conclusions These findings suggest that young children with NSCL/P experience delays relative to their peers across multiple speech and language constructs. Differences between children with NSCL/P and their typically developing peers appear to decrease with age. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.11356904.

Figures

Figure 1.
Figure 1.
Flow chart of study identification and inclusion.
Figure 2.
Figure 2.
Funnel plots for (A) consonant inventory, (B) speech accuracy, (C) speech error, (D) expressive language, and (E) receptive language effect sizes.

References

    1. Borenstein M., Hedges L. V., Higgins J. P. T., & Rothstein H. R. (2009). Introduction to meta-analysis. Chichester, England: : Wiley.
    1. Boyce J. O., Kilpatrick N., Reilly S., Da Costa A., & Morgan A. T. (2018). Receptive and expressive language characteristics of school-aged children with non-syndromic cleft lip and/or palate. International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders, 53(5), 959–968.
    1. Broen P. A., Devers M. C., Doyle S. S., Prouty J. M., & Moller K. T. (1998). Acquisition of linguistic and cognitive skills by children with cleft palate. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 41(3), 676–687.
    1. Cavalheiro M. G., Lamônica D. A. C., de Vasconsellos Hage S. R., & Maximino L. P. (2019). Child development skills and language in toddlers with cleft lip and palate. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 116, 18–21.
    1. Chapman K. L. (1993). Phonologic processes in children with cleft palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 30(1), 64–72.
    1. Chapman K. L. (2004). Is presurgery and early postsurgery performance related to speech and language outcomes at 3 years of age for children with cleft palate. Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics, 18(4–5), 235–257.
    1. Chapman K. L. (2011). The relationship between early reading skills and speech and language performance in young children with cleft lip and palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 48(3), 301–311.
    1. Chapman K. L., Dixon A., Wilson K., Dobbelsteyn C., Cordero K., Trost-Cardamone J., … Baylis A. (2017). No benchmarking speech outcomes of kindergarteners with cleft palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 54(3), e51.
    1. Chapman K. L., Graham K. T., Gooch J., & Visconti C. (1998). Conversational skills of preschool and school-age children with cleft lip and palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 35, 503–516.
    1. Chapman K. L., & Hardin M. A. (1992). Phonetic and phonologic skills of two-year-olds with cleft palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 29(5), 435–443.
    1. Choa R. M., Slator R., Jeremy A., Robinson S., Franklin D., Roberts A., … Clark V. (2014). Identifying the effect of cleft type, deprivation and ethnicity on speech and dental outcomes in UK cleft patients: A multi-centred study. Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery, 67(12), 1637–1643.
    1. Chapman K. L., Hardin-Jones M. A., & Halter K. A. (2003). The relationship between early speech and later speech and language performance for children with cleft lip and palate. Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics, 17(3), 173–197.
    1. Chow J. C. (2018). Prevalence of publication bias tests in speech, language, and hearing research. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 61, 3055–3063.
    1. Chow J. C., & Ekholm E. (2018). Do published studies yield larger effect sizes than unpublished studies in education and special education? A meta-review. Educational Psychology Review, 30, 727–744.
    1. Collett B. R., Leroux B., & Speltz M. L. (2010). Language and early reading among children with orofacial clefts. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 47, 284–292.
    1. Estrem T., & Broen P. A. (1989). Early speech production of children with cleft palate. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 32(1), 12–23.
    1. Fenson L., Marchman V. A., Thal D. J., Dale P. S., Reznick J. S., & Bates E. (2007). MacArthur-Bates Communicative Development Inventories: User's guide and technical manual (2nd ed.). Baltimore, MD: Brookes.
    1. Fleiss J. L. (1999). The design and analysis of clinical experiments. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley;
    1. Fox D., Lynch J., & Brookshire B. (1978). Selected developmental factors of cleft palate children between two and thirty-three months of age. The Cleft Palate Journal, 15(3), 239–245. Retrieved from
    1. Frey J. R., Kaiser A. P., & Scherer N. J. (2018). The influences of child intelligibility and rate on caregiver responses to toddlers with and without cleft palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 55(2), 276–286.
    1. Ha S., Koh K. S., Moon H., Jung S., & Oh T. S. (2015). Clinical outcomes of primary palatal surgery in children with nonsyndromic cleft palate with and without lip. BioMed Research International, 2015, 1–5.
    1. Hardin-Jones M. A., & Chapman K. L. (2014). Early lexical characteristics of toddlers with cleft lip and palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 51(6), 622–631.
    1. Hedges L. V., Tipton E., & Johnson M. C. (2010). Robust variance estimation in meta-regression with dependent effect size estimates. Research Synthesis Methods, 1(1), 39–65.
    1. Hentges F., Hill J., Bishop D. V. M., Goodacre T., Moss T., & Murray L. (2011). The effect of cleft lip on cognitive development in school-aged children: A paradigm for examining sensitive period effects. The Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 52(6), 704–712.
    1. Higgins J. P. T., Thompson S. G., Deeks J. J., & Altman D. G. (2003). Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ, 327(7414), 557–560.
    1. Hoff E. (2013). Interpreting the early language trajectories of children from low-SES and language minority homes: Implications for closing achievement gaps. Developmental Psychology, 49(1), 4–14.
    1. Jocelyn L. J., Penko M. A., & Rode H. L. (1996). Cognition, communication, and hearing in young children with cleft lip and palate and in control children: A longitudinal study. Pediatrics, 97(4), 529–534.
    1. Jones C. E., Chapman K. L., & Hardin-Jones M. A. (2003). Speech development of children with cleft palate before and after palatal surgery. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 40(1), 19–31.
    1. Klintö K., Salameh E.-K., & Lohmander A. (2015). Verbal competence in narrative retelling in 5-year-olds with unilateral cleft lip and palate. International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders, 50(1), 119–128.
    1. Klintö K., Salameh E.-K., & Lohmander A. (2016). Phonology in Swedish-speaking 5-year-olds born with unilateral cleft lip and palate and the relationship with consonant production at 3 years of age. International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 18(2), 147–156.
    1. Klintö K., Salameh E.-K., Olsson M., Flynn T., Svensson H., & Lohmander A. (2014). Phonology in Swedish-speaking 3-year-olds born with cleft lip and palate and the relationship with consonant production at 18 months. International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders, 49(2), 240–254.
    1. Klintö K., Salameh E.-K., Svensson H., & Lohmander A. (2011). The impact of speech material on speech judgement in children with and without cleft palate. International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders, 46(3), 348–360.
    1. Kummer A. W., Lee L., Stutz L. S., Maroney A., & Brandt J. W. (2007). The prevalence of apraxia characteristics in patients with velocardiofacial syndrome as compared with other cleft populations. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 44(2), 175–181.
    1. Lakens D. (2013). Calculating and reporting effect sizes to facilitate cumulative science: A practical primer for t-tests and ANOVAs. Frontiers in Psychology, 4, 863
    1. Landis J. R., & Koch G. G. (1977). The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics, 33(1), 159–174.
    1. Lee H.-C., Madison C. L., & Jackson R. (2009). Phonological competence in Mandarin Chinese-speaking children with cleft palate. Asia Pacific Journal of Speech, Language and Hearing, 12(1), 13–26.
    1. Lee K. S. M., Young S. E.-L., Liow S. J. R., & Purcell A. A. (2015). Spelling processes of children with nonsyndromic cleft lip and/or palate: A preliminary study. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 52(1), 70–81.
    1. Lohmander A., & Persson C. (2008). A longitudinal study of speech production in Swedish children with unilateral cleft lip and palate and two-stage palatal repair. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 45(1), 32–41.
    1. Lohmander-Agerskov A., Söderpalm E., Friede H., Persson E.-C., & Lilja J. (1994). Pre-speech in children with cleft lip and palate or cleft palate only: Phonetic analysis related to morphological and functional factors. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 31(4), 271–279.
    1. Long R. E., Hathaway R., Daskalogiannakis J., Mercado A., Russell K., Cohen M., … Shaw W. (2011). The Americleft study: An inter-center study of treatment outcomes for patients with unilateral cleft lip and palate part 1. Principles and study design. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 48(3), 239–243.
    1. Luyten A., Bettens K., D'haeseleer E., De Ley S., Hodges A., Galiwango G., … Van Lierde K. (2014a). The impact of palatal repair before and after 6 months of age on speech characteristics. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 78(5), 787–798.
    1. Luyten A., Bettens K., D'haeseleer E., De Ley S., Hodges A., Galiwango G., … Van Lierde K. (2014b). Impact of early synchronous lip and palatal repair on speech. Folia Phoniatrica et Logopaedica, 65(6), 303–311.
    1. Moher D., Liberati A., Tetzlaff J., Altman D. G., & . The PRISMA Group. (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA Statement. PLOS MEDICINE, 6(7), e1000097
    1. Morgan A. R., Bellucci C. C., Coppersmith J., Linde S. B., Curtis A., Albert M., … Kapp-Simon K. (2017). Language development in children with cleft palate with or without cleft lip adopted from non-English-speaking countries. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 26(2), 342–354.
    1. Morris H., & Ozanne A. (2003). Phonetic, phonological, and language skills of children with a cleft palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 40, 460–470.
    1. Nakajima T., Mitsudome A., & Yosikawa A. (2001). Postoperative speech development based on cleft types in children with cleft palate. Pediatrics International, 43, 666–672.
    1. Page M. J., Mckenzie J. E., & Higgins J. P. T. (2018). Tools for assessing risk of reporting biases in studies and syntheses of studies: A systematic review. BMJ Open, 8, e019703
    1. Pamplona M. C., Ysunza A., González M., Ramírez E., & Patiño C. (2000). Linguistic development in cleft palate patients with and without compensatory articulation disorder. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 54(2–3), 81–91.
    1. Philips B. J., & Harrison R. J. (1969). Language skills of preschool cleft palate children. The Cleft Palate Journal, 6(2), 108–119. Retrieved from
    1. Priester G. H., & Goorhuis-Brouwer S. M. (2008). Speech and language development in toddlers with and without cleft palate. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 72(6), 801–806.
    1. R Core Team. (2017). R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing; Retrieved from
    1. Richman L. C. (1980). Cognitive patterns and learning disabilities of cleft palate children with verbal deficits. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 23(2), 447–456.
    1. Roberts R. M., Mathias J. L., & Wheaton P. (2012). Cognitive functioning in children and adults with nonsyndromal cleft lip and/or palate: A meta-analysis. Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 37(7), 786–797.
    1. Sanderson S., Tatt I. D., & Higgins J. P. T. (2007). Tools for assessing quality and susceptibility to bias in observational studies in epidemiology: A systematic review and annotated bibliography. International Journal of Epidemiology, 36(3), 666–676.
    1. Scherer N. J., Boyce S., & Martin G. (2013). Pre-linguistic children with cleft palate: Growth of gesture, vocalization, and word use. International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 15(6), 586–592.
    1. Scherer N. J., & D'Antonio L. L. (1995). Parent questionnaire for screening early language development in children with cleft palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 32, 7–13.
    1. Scherer N. J., D'Antonio L. L., & McGahey H. (2008). Early intervention for speech impairment in children with cleft palate. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 45(1), 18–31.
    1. Scherer N. J., Oravkinova Z., & McBee M. T. (2013). Longitudinal comparison of early speech and language milestones in children with cleft palate: A comparison of U.S. and Slovak children. Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics, 27(6–7), 404–418.
    1. Scherer N. J., Williams A. L., & Proctor-Williams K. (2008). Early and later vocalization skills in children with and without cleft palate. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 72(6), 827–840.
    1. Scherer N. J., Williams L.,Stoel-Gammon C., &Kaiser A. P. (2012). Assessment of single-word production for children under three years of age: Comparison of children with and without cleft palate. International Journal of Otolaryngology, 2012, Article ID 724214.
    1. Schönweiler R., Lisson J. A., Schönweiler B., Eckardt A., Ptok M., Tränkmann J., & Hausamen J.-E. (1999). A retrospective study of hearing, speech and language function in children with clefts following palatoplasty and veloplasty procedures at 18–24 months of age. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 50(3), 205–217.
    1. Semel E., Wiig E. H., & Secord W. (2003). Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals–Third Edition. San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation.
    1. Snyder L. E., & Scherer N. J. (2004). The development of symbolic play and language in toddlers with cleft palate. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 13(1), 66–80.
    1. Speltz M. L., Endriga M. C., Hill S., Maris C. L., Jones K., & Omnell M. L. (2000). Brief report: Cognitive and psychomotor development of infants with orofacial clefts. Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 25(3), 185–190.
    1. Tanner-Smith E. E., & Tipton E. (2014). Robust variance estimation with dependent effect sizes: Practical considerations including a software tutorial in Stata and SPSS. Research Synthesis Methods, 5(1), 13–30.
    1. Tipton E. (2015). Small sample adjustments for robust variance estimation with meta-regression. Psychological Methods, 20(3), 375–393.
    1. Watkins, S. E., Meyer, R. E., Aylsworth, A. S., Marcus, J. R., Allori, A. C., Pimenta, L., … Strauss, R. P. (2018). Academic achievement among children with nonsyndromic orofacial clefts: A population-based study. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 55(1), 12–20.
    1. Willadsen E., & Enemark H. (2000). A comparative study of prespeech vocalizations in two groups of toddlers with cleft palate and a noncleft group. The Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, 37(2), 172–178. <0172:ACSOPV>;2
    1. Wilson D. B. (n.d.). Practical meta-analysis effect size calculator [Online calculator]. Retrieved from
    1. Young S. E., Purcell A. A., & Ballard K. J. (2010). Expressive language skills in Chinese Singaporean preschoolers with nonsyndromic cleft lip and/or palate. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 74(5), 456–464.
    1. Zimmerman I. L., Steiner V. G., & Pond R.. E. (2012). Preschool Language Scales–Fifth Edition. San Antonio, TX: Pearson.

Source: PubMed

Sponsorzy i współpracownicy

Warunki medyczne

Interwencje lekowe

3
Subskrybuj