The $5 man: the underground economic response to a large cigarette tax increase in New York City
Donna Shelley, M Jennifer Cantrell, Joyce Moon-Howard, Destiny Q Ramjohn, Nancy VanDevanter, Donna Shelley, M Jennifer Cantrell, Joyce Moon-Howard, Destiny Q Ramjohn, Nancy VanDevanter
Abstract
Objectives: We examined the mechanisms by which living in a disadvantaged minority community influences smoking and illegal cigarette sale and purchasing behaviors after a large cigarette tax increase.
Methods: Data were collected from 14 focus groups (n=104) that were conducted during the spring of 2003 among Blacks aged 18 years and older living in New York City.
Results: A large tax increase led to what focus group participants described as a pervasive illegal cigarette market in a low-income minority community. Perceived pro-smoking community norms, a stressful social and economic environment, and the availability of illegal cigarettes worked together to reinforce smoking and undermine cessation.
Conclusions: Although interest in quitting was high, bootleggers created an environment in which reduced-price cigarettes were easier to access than cessation services. This activity continues to undermine the public health goals of the tax increase.
References
- Chaloupka FJ, Warner KE The Economics of Smoking. Cambridge, Mass: National Bureau of Economic Research, 1999.
- Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids. Top combined state-local cigarette tax rates. Available at: . Accessed on February 15, 2006.
- Frieden TR, Mostashari F, Kerker BD, Miller N, Hajat A, Frankel M. Adult tobacco use levels after intensive tobacco control measures: New York City, 2002–2003. Am J Public Health. 2005;95: 1016–1023.
- Guart A. Burning issues steam the apple—butt-leggers sell illicit cigs under cops’ noses. New York Post. August 18, 2002;9.
- Denny L. Where Corner Tobacconists sell from the sidewalk. New York Times. September 21, 2003;sect 14:5.
- Cigarette smoking among adults–United States, 2002. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2004;53: 427–431.
- Cigarette smoking among adults–United States, 2004. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2005;54: 1121–1124.
- Bang KM, Kim JH. Prevalence of cigarette smoking by occupation and industry in the United States. Am J Ind Med. 2001;40:233–239.
- Barbeau EM, Krieger N, Soobader MJ. Working class matters: socioeconomic disadvantage, race/ethnicity, gender, and smoking in NHIS 2000. Am J Public Health. 2004;94:269–278.
- Giovino GA. Epidemiology of tobacco use in the United States. Oncogene. 2002;21:7326–7340.
- Winkleby MA, Cubbin C. Racial/ethnic disparities in health behaviors: a challenge to current assumptions. In: Anderson NA, Bulatao RA, Cohen B, eds. Critical Perspectives on Racial and Ethnic Differences in Health in Later Life. Washington, DC: National Academies Press; 2004:450–483.
- Tobacco Use Among Racial/Ethnic Minority Groups–African-Americans, American Indians and Alaska Natives, Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders, and Hispanics: A Report of the Surgeon General. Atlanta, Ga: US Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 1998.
- Graham H. Promoting health against inequality: using research to identify targets for intervention—a case study of women and smoking. Health Educ J. 1998;57:292–302.
- Stead M, MacAskill S, MacKintosh AM, Reece J, Eadie D. “It’s as if you’re locked in”: qualitative explanations for area effects on smoking in disadvantaged communities. Health Place. 2001;7:333–343.
- Wetter DW, Cofta-Gunn L, Fouladi RT, et al. Understanding the associations among education, employment characteristics, and smoking. Addict Behav. 2005; 30:905–914.
- Laws MB, Whitman J, Bowser DM, Krech L. Tobacco availability and point of sale marketing in demographically contrasting districts of Massachusetts. Tob Control. 2002. Jun;11 Suppl 2:ii71–3.
- Barbeau EM, Wolin KY, Naumova EN, Balbach E. Tobacco advertising in communities: associations with race and class. Prev Med. 2005. Jan;40(1):16–22.
- Diez Roux AV, Merkin SS, Hannan P, Jacobs DR, Kiefe CI. Area characteristics, individual-level socioeconomic indicators, and smoking in young adults: the coronary artery disease risk development in young adults study. Am J Epidemiol. 2003;157:315–326.
- Duncan C, Jones K, Moon G. Smoking and deprivation: are there neighbourhood effects? Soc Sci Med. 1999;48:497–505.
- Reijneveld SA. Neighbourhood socioeconomic context and self reported health and smoking: a secondary analysis of data on seven cities. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2002;56:935–942.
- Cockerham WC. Health lifestyle theory and the convergence of agency and structure. J Health Soc Behav. 2005;46:51–67.
- Wiltshire S, Bancroft A, Amos A, Parry O. “They’re doing people a service”—qualitative study of smoking, smuggling, and social deprivation. BMJ. 2001;323:203–207.
- First Annual Independent Evaluation of New York’s Tobacco Control Program: Final Report. Research Triangle Park, NC: Research Triangle Institute; 2004.
- Second Annual Independent Evaluation of New York’s Tobacco Control Program, 2005. Research Triangle Park, NC: Research Triangle Institute; 2005.
- Hyland A, Bauer JE, Li Q, et al. Higher cigarette prices influence cigarette purchase patterns. Tob Control. 2005;14:86–92.
- Hyland A, Higbee C, Bauer JE, Giovino GA, Cummings KM. Cigarette purchasing behaviors when prices are high. J Public Health Manag Pract. 2004;10: 497–500.
- King G, Mallett RK, Kozlowski LT, Bendel RB. African Americans’ attitudes toward cigarette excise taxes. Am J Public Health. 2003;93:828–834.
- Fagan P, King G, Lawrence D, et al. Eliminating tobacco-related health disparities: directions for future research. Am J Public Health. 2004;94:211–217.
- Israel BA, Schulz AJ, Parker EA, Becker AB. Review of community-based research: assessing partnership approaches to improve public health. Annu Rev Public Health. 1998;19:173–202.
- Diez-Roux AV, Northridge ME, Morabia A, Bassett MT, Shea S. Prevalence and social correlates of cardiovascular disease risk factors in Harlem. Am J Public Health. 1999;89:302–307.
- Fullilove RE, Fullilove MT, Northridge ME, et al. Risk factors for excess mortality in Harlem. Findings from the Harlem Household Survey. Am J Prev Med. 1999;16(suppl 3):22–28.
- Northridge ME, Morabia A, Ganz ML, et al. Contribution of smoking to excess mortality in Harlem. Am J Epidemiol. 1998;147:250–258.
- Morgan DL. Focus Groups as Qualitative Research. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, Calif: Sage Publications; 1997.
- Lincoln YS, Guba EG. Naturalistic Inquiry. Beverly Hills, Calif: Sage Publications; 1985.
- Muhr T. Atlas.ti Short User’s Guide. Berlin, Germany: Scientific Software; 1997.
- Strauss AL, Corbin JM. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, Calif: Sage Publications; 1998.
- Warner KE. The economics of tobacco: myths and realities. Tob Control. 2000;9:78–89.
- Wilson N, Thomson G, Tobias M, Blakely T. How much downside? Quantifying the relative harm from tobacco taxation. J Epidemiol Community HealthI. 2004; 58:451–454.
- Wilson N, Thomson G. Tobacco taxation and public health: ethical problems, policy responses. Soc Sci Med. 2005;61:649–659.
- Remler DK. Poor smokers, poor quitters, and cigarette tax regressivity. Am J Public Health. 2004;94: 225–229.
- Emery S, White MM, Gilpin EA, Pierce JP. Was there significant tax evasion after the 1999 50 cent per pack cigarette tax increase in California? Tob Control. 2002;11:130–134.
- White VM, Gilpin EA, White MM, Pierce JP. How do smokers control their cigarette expenditures? Nicotine Tob Res. 2005;7:625–635.
- Curry SJ, Wagner EH, Cheadle A, et al. Assessment of community-level influences on individuals’ attitudes about cigarette smoking, alcohol use, and consumption of dietary fat. Am J Prev Med. 1993;9: 78–84.
- Sorensen G, Barbeau E, Hunt MK, Emmons K. Reducing social disparities in tobacco use: a social-contextual model for reducing tobacco use among blue-collar workers. Am J Public Health. 2004; 94:230–239.
- Hennessey Lavery S, Smith ML, Esparza AA, Hrushow A, Moore M, Reed DF. The community action model: a community-driven model designed to address disparities in health. Am J Public Health. 2005; 95:611–616.
- Lew R. APPEAL: fighting for social justice in tobacco control among Native Hawaiians and Pacific Islanders through leadership and capacity building. Pac Health Dialog. 2004;11:239–242.
- Pobutsky AM, Pordell P, Yamashita B, et al. Community based participatory approaches to address health disparities in Hawai’i: recent applications in cancer prevention, detection and treatment programs. Pac Health Dialog. 2004;11:183–190.
- Schulz AJ, Zenk S, Odoms-Young A, et al. Healthy eating and exercising to reduce diabetes: exploring the potential of social determinants of health frameworks within the context of community-based participatory diabetes prevention. Am J Public Health. 2005;95: 645–651.
Source: PubMed