Adjuvant chemotherapy in older women with early-stage breast cancer
Hyman B Muss, Donald A Berry, Constance T Cirrincione, Maria Theodoulou, Ann M Mauer, Alice B Kornblith, Ann H Partridge, Lynn G Dressler, Harvey J Cohen, Heather P Becker, Patricia A Kartcheske, Judith D Wheeler, Edith A Perez, Antonio C Wolff, Julie R Gralow, Harold J Burstein, Ahmad A Mahmood, Gustav Magrinat, Barbara A Parker, Ronald D Hart, Debjani Grenier, Larry Norton, Clifford A Hudis, Eric P Winer, CALGB Investigators, R L Comis, L H Baker, J Buckner, N Wolmark, E Eisenhauer, W J Curran Jr, H Ozer, S Grubbs, E P Winer, M S Ernstoff, J Crawford, D L Grinblatt, M Lange, J K Giguere, L J Kirshner, J W Kugler, K R Rai, C A Hudis, A P Lyss, G S Soori, R C Lilenbaum, L R Silverman, J A Ellerton, D J Weckstein, R Ansari, E Levine, F P Smith, J N Atkins, S L Graziano, C D Bloomfield, B A Parker, G Fleming, L E Feldman, D A Vaena, M Edelman, W V Walsh, B A Peterson, M C Perry, H B Muss, D D Hurd, T Reid, N Bartlett, J Leonard, R K Shadduck, Hyman B Muss, Donald A Berry, Constance T Cirrincione, Maria Theodoulou, Ann M Mauer, Alice B Kornblith, Ann H Partridge, Lynn G Dressler, Harvey J Cohen, Heather P Becker, Patricia A Kartcheske, Judith D Wheeler, Edith A Perez, Antonio C Wolff, Julie R Gralow, Harold J Burstein, Ahmad A Mahmood, Gustav Magrinat, Barbara A Parker, Ronald D Hart, Debjani Grenier, Larry Norton, Clifford A Hudis, Eric P Winer, CALGB Investigators, R L Comis, L H Baker, J Buckner, N Wolmark, E Eisenhauer, W J Curran Jr, H Ozer, S Grubbs, E P Winer, M S Ernstoff, J Crawford, D L Grinblatt, M Lange, J K Giguere, L J Kirshner, J W Kugler, K R Rai, C A Hudis, A P Lyss, G S Soori, R C Lilenbaum, L R Silverman, J A Ellerton, D J Weckstein, R Ansari, E Levine, F P Smith, J N Atkins, S L Graziano, C D Bloomfield, B A Parker, G Fleming, L E Feldman, D A Vaena, M Edelman, W V Walsh, B A Peterson, M C Perry, H B Muss, D D Hurd, T Reid, N Bartlett, J Leonard, R K Shadduck
Abstract
Background: Older women with breast cancer are underrepresented in clinical trials, and data on the effects of adjuvant chemotherapy in such patients are scant. We tested for the noninferiority of capecitabine as compared with standard chemotherapy in women with breast cancer who were 65 years of age or older.
Methods: We randomly assigned patients with stage I, II, IIIA, or IIIB breast cancer to standard chemotherapy (either cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, and fluorouracil or cyclophosphamide plus doxorubicin) or capecitabine. Endocrine therapy was recommended after chemotherapy in patients with hormone-receptor-positive tumors. A Bayesian statistical design was used with a range in sample size from 600 to 1800 patients. The primary end point was relapse-free survival.
Results: When the 600th patient was enrolled, the probability that, with longer follow-up, capecitabine therapy was highly likely to be inferior to standard chemotherapy met a prescribed level, and enrollment was discontinued. After an additional year of follow-up, the hazard ratio for disease recurrence or death in the capecitabine group was 2.09 (95% confidence interval, 1.38 to 3.17; P<0.001). Patients who were randomly assigned to capecitabine were twice as likely to have a relapse and almost twice as likely to die as patients who were randomly assigned to standard chemotherapy (P=0.02). At 3 years, the rate of relapse-free survival was 68% in the capecitabine group versus 85% in the standard-chemotherapy group, and the overall survival rate was 86% versus 91%. Two patients in the capecitabine group died of treatment-related complications; as compared with patients receiving capecitabine, twice as many patients receiving standard chemotherapy had moderate-to-severe toxic effects (64% vs. 33%).
Conclusions: Standard adjuvant chemotherapy is superior to capecitabine in patients with early-stage breast cancer who are 65 years of age or older. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00024102.)
Conflict of interest statement
Drs. Muss, Berry, Norton, and Hudis report receiving consulting fees from Hoffmann-La Roche; and Drs. Gralow, Hudis, Wolff, and Perez, research support from Hoffman-La Roche. No other potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
2009 Massachusetts Medical Society
Figures
Source: PubMed