Sensory stimulation for brain injured individuals in coma or vegetative state

F Lombardi, M Taricco, A De Tanti, E Telaro, A Liberati, F Lombardi, M Taricco, A De Tanti, E Telaro, A Liberati

Abstract

Background: Coma and vegetative state follow traumatic brain injury in about one out of eight patients, and in patients with non traumatic injury the prognosis is worse. The use of sensory stimulation for coma and vegetative state has gained popularity during the 1980's but beliefs and opinions about its effectiveness vary substantially among health professionals.

Objectives: To assess the effectiveness of sensory stimulation programmes in patients in coma or vegetative state.

Search strategy: We searched the Injuries Group specialised register, the Cochrane Controlled trials register, EMBASE, MEDLINE, CINAHL and PSYCHLIT from 1966 to January 2002, without language restriction. Reference lists of articles were scanned and we contacted experts in the area to find other relevant studies.

Selection criteria: Randomised or controlled trials that compared sensory stimulation programmes with standard rehabilitation in patients in coma or vegetative state.

Data collection and analysis: Abstracts and papers found were screened by one reviewer. Three reviewers independently identified relevant studies, extracted data and assessed study quality resolving disagreement by consensus.

Main results: Three studies were identified with 68 patients in total. The overall methodological quality was poor and studies differed widely in terms of outcomes measures, study design and conduct. We therefore did not carry out any quantitative synthesis but reviewed results of available studies qualitatively.

Reviewer's conclusions: This systematic review indicates that there is no reliable evidence to support, or rule out, the effectiveness of multisensory programmes in patients in coma or vegetative state.

Conflict of interest statement

None known.

References

References to studies included in this review Johnson 1993 {published data only}

    1. Johnson DA, Roething‐Johnston K, Richards D. Biochemical and physiological parameters of recovery in acute severe head injury. Brain Injury 1993;7(6):491‐9.
Kater 1989 {published data only}
    1. Kater KM. Response of head‐injured patients to sensory stimulation. Western Journal of Nursing Research 1989;11(1):20‐33.
Mitchell 1990 {published data only}
    1. Mitchell S, Bradley VA, Welch JL, Britton PG. Coma arousal procedure: a therapeutic intervention in the treatment of head injury. Brain Injury 1990;4(3):273‐9.
References to studies excluded from this review Boyle 1983 {published data only}
    1. Boyle MEM, Greer RD. Operant procedures and the comatose patient. Journal of Applied Behaviour Analysis 1983;16:3‐12.
Cooper 1999 {published data only}
    1. Cooper JB, Jane JA, Alves WM, Cooper EB. Right median nerve electrical stimulation to hasten awakening from coma. Brain‐Injury 1999;13(4):261‐7.
De Young 1987 {published data only}
    1. Young S, Grass RB. Coma recovery program. Rehabilitation Nursing 1987;12(3):121‐4.
Doman 1993 {published data only}
    1. Doman G, Wilkinson R, Dimancescu MD, Pelligra R. The effect of intense multisensory stimulation on coma arousal and recovery. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation 1993;3(2):203‐12.
Guina 1997 {published data only}
    1. Guina FD, Cosic T, Kracun L, Dimic Z. Sensorimotor stimulation of comatose patients. Acta Medica Croatica 1997;51:101‐3.
Hall 1992 {published data only}
    1. Hall MEM, MacDonald S, Young GC. The effectiveness of directed multisensory stimulation versus non‐directed stimulation in comatose CHI patients: pilot study of a single subject design. Brain Injury 1992;6(5):435‐45.
Johnson 1989 {published data only}
    1. Johnson MJ, Omery A, Nikas D. Effects of conversation on intracranial pressure in comatose patients. Heart Lung 1989;18:56‐63.
Jones 1994 {published data only}
    1. Jones R, Hux K, Morton‐Anderson A, Knepper L. Auditory stimulation effect on a comatose survivor of traumatic brain injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1994;75:164‐71.
Le Winn 1978 {published data only}
    1. Winn EB, Dimancescu MD. Environmental deprivation and enrichment in coma. Lancet 1978;2(8081):156‐7.
Mackay 1992 {published data only}
    1. Mackay LE, Bernstein BA, Chapman PE, Morgan AS, Milazzo LS. Early intervantion in severe head injury: long‐term benefits of a formalized program. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1992;73:635‐41.
Pierce 1990 {published data only}
    1. Pierce JP, Lyle DM, Quine S, Evans NJ, Morris J, Fearnside MR. The effectiveness of coma arousal intervention. Brain Injury 1990;4(2):191‐7.
Rader 1989 {published data only}
    1. Rader MA, Alston JB, Ellis DW. Sensory stimulation of severely brain‐injured patients. Brain Injury 1989;3(2):141‐7.
Rosadini 1982 {published data only}
    1. Rosadini G, Sannita WG. Inter‐ and intra‐hemispheric topographic analyses of quantitative EEG in patients in coma. Research Communications in Psychology, Psychiatry and Behaviour 1982;7(1):97‐107.
Schinner 1995 {published data only}
    1. Schinner KM, Chisolm AH, Grap MJ, Siva P, Hallinan M, LaVoice‐Hawkins AM. Effects of auditory stimuli on intracranial pressure and cerebral perfusion pressure in traumatic brain injury. Journal of Neuroscience Nursing 1995;27(6):348‐54.
Sisson 1990 {published data only}
    1. Sisson R. Effects of auditory stimuli on comatose patients with head injury. Heart Lung 1990;19:373‐8.
Weber 1984 {published data only}
    1. Weber PL. Sensorimotor therapy: its effect on electroencephalograms of acute comatose patients. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 1984;65:457‐62.
Wilson 1991 {published data only}
    1. Wilson SL, Powell GE, Elliot K, Thwaites H. Sensory stimulation in prolonged coma: four single case studies. Brain Injury 1991;5(4):393‐400.
Wilson 1993 {published data only}
    1. Wilson SL, Powell GE, Elliot K, Thwaites H. Evaluation of sensory stimulation as a treatment for prolonged coma ‐ seven single experiemental case studies. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation 1993;3(2):191‐201.
Wilson 1996 A {published data only}
    1. Wilson SL, Powell GE, Thwaites H, Elliot K. Constructing arousal profiles for vegetative state patients ‐ a preliminary report. Brain Injury 1996;10(2):105‐13.
Wilson 1996 B {published data only}
    1. Wilson SL, Powell GE, Rock D, Thwaites H. Behavioural differnces between patients who emerged from vegetative state and those who did not. Brain Injury 1996;10(7):509‐16.
Wood 1992 {published data only}
    1. Wood R, Winkowski TB, Miller JL, Tierney L, Goldman L. Evaluating sensory regulation as a method to improve awareness in patients with altered states of consciousness: a pilot study. Brain Injury 1992;6(5):411‐8.
Wood 1993 {published data only}
    1. Wood RL, Winkowski T, Miller J. Sensory regulation as a method to promote recovery in patients with altered states of consciousness. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation 1993;3(2):177‐90.
Additional references ACRM 1995
    1. American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine. Recommendations for use of uniform nomenclature pertinent to patients with severe alterations in consciousness. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1995;76:205‐9.
Andrews 1996
    1. Andrews K. International working party on the management of the vegetative state: summary report. Brain Injury 1996;11:797‐806.
Giacino 1997
    1. Giacino JT, Zasler ND, Katz DI, Kelly JP, Rosenburg JH, Filley CM. Development of practice guidelines for assessment and management of the vegetative and minimally conscious states. J Head Trauma Rehab 1997;12:79‐89.
Grosswasser 1990
    1. Grosswasser Z, Sazbon L. Outcome in 134 patients with prolonged post‐traumatic unawareness. J Neurosurg 1990;72:81‐4.
Hagen 1979
    1. Downey. Levels of Cognitive Functioning. In: Hagen C, Malkmus D, Durham P editor(s). Rehabilitation of the head injured adult. Comprehensive physical management. Professional Staff Association of Rancho Los Amigos Hospital, Inc. 1979.
Jennett 1975
    1. Jennett B, Bond M. Assessment of outcome after severe brain damage. Lancet 1975;1:480‐4.
Jennett 1982
    1. Jennet B, Bond M. Disability Rating Scale for severe head trauma: coma to community. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 1982;63(3):118‐123.
Le Winn 1978
    1. Winn EB, Dimancescu MD. Environmental deprivation and enrichment in coma. Lancet 1978;2(8081):156‐7.
Levin 1991
    1. Levin HS, Saydjari C, Eisenberg HM, Foulkes M, et al. Vegetative State after closed head injury: A traumatic coma data bank report. Archives of Neurology 1991;48:580‐5.
Moher 1995
    1. Moher D, Jadad AR, Nichol G, Penman M, Tugwell P, Walsh S. Assessing the quality of randomized controlled trials: an annotated bibliography of scales and checklists. Controlled Clinical Trials 1995;16:62‐73.
Rappaport 1982
    1. Rappaport M, Hall KM, Hopkins HK, Belleza T, Cope DN. Disability rating scale for severe head trauma: coma to community. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 1982;63(3):118‐23.
Sazbon 1993
    1. Sazbon L, Zagreba F, Ronen J, Solzi P, Costeff H. Course and outcome of patients in vegetative state of nontraumatic aetiology. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 1993;56:407‐9.
Schulz 1995
    1. Schulz KF, Chalmers I, Hayes RJ, Altman DG. Empirical evidence of bias: dimensions of methodological quality associated with estimates of treatment effects in controlled trials. JAMA 1995;273:408‐12.
Task Force on PVS
    1. The Multi‐society Task Force on PVS. Medical aspects of the Persistent Vegetative State (second of two parts). N Engl J Med 1994;330:1572‐9.
Teasdale 1974
    1. Teasdale G, Jennet B. Assessment of coma and impaired consciuosness: A practical scale. The Lancet 1974;2:81‐4.
Whyte 1994
    1. Whyte J. Toward a methodology for rehabilitation research. Am J Phys Med Rehabil 1994;6:428‐35.
Wood 1991
    1. Wood RL. Critical analysis of the concept of sensory stimulation for patients in vegetative states. Brain Injury 1991;4:401‐10.
Wood 1992
    1. Wood R, Winkowski TB, Miller JL, Tierney L, Goldman L. Evaluating sensory regulation as a method to improve awareness in patients with altered states of consciousness: a pilot study. Brain Injury 1992;6:411‐8.
Zasler 1991
    1. Zasler ND, Kreutzer JS, Taylor D. Coma stimulation and coma recovery: a critical review. NeuroRehabilitation 1991;1:33‐4.

Source: PubMed

Sponsorer och medarbetare

Medicinska tillstånd

Läkemedelsinterventioner

3
Prenumerera