The Agreement between Auscultation and Lung Ultrasound in Hemodialysis Patients: The LUST Study

Abstract

Background and objectives: Accumulation of fluid in the lung is the most concerning sequela of volume expansion in patients with ESRD. Lung auscultation is recommended to detect and monitor pulmonary congestion, but its reliability in ESRD is unknown.

Design, setting, participants, & measurements: In a subproject of the ongoing Lung Water by Ultra-Sound Guided Treatment to Prevent Death and Cardiovascular Complications in High Risk ESRD Patients with Cardiomyopathy Trial, we compared a lung ultrasound-guided ultrafiltration prescription policy versus standard care in high-risk patients on hemodialysis. The reliability of peripheral edema was tested as well. This study was on the basis of 1106 pre- and postdialysis lung ultrasound studies (in 79 patients) simultaneous with standardized lung auscultation (crackles at the lung bases) and quantification of peripheral edema.

Results: Lung congestion by crackles, edema, or a combination thereof poorly reflected the severity of congestion as detected by ultrasound B lines in various analyses, including standard regression analysis weighting for repeated measures in individual patients (shared variance of 12% and 4% for crackles and edema, respectively) and κ-statistics (κ ranging from 0.00 to 0.16). In general, auscultation had very low discriminatory power for the diagnosis of mild (area under the receiver operating curve =0.61), moderate (area under the receiver operating curve =0.65), and severe (area under the receiver operating curve =0.68) lung congestion, and the same was true for peripheral edema (receiver operating curve =0.56 or lower) and the combination of the two physical signs.

Conclusions: Lung crackles, either alone or combined with peripheral edema, very poorly reflect interstitial lung edema in patients with ESRD. These findings reinforce the rationale underlying the Lung Water by Ultra-Sound Guided Treatment to Prevent Death and Cardiovascular Complications in High Risk ESRD Patients with Cardiomyopathy Trial, a trial adopting ultrasound B lines as an instrument to guide interventions aimed at mitigating lung congestion in high-risk patients on hemodialysis.

Keywords: Auscultation; Cardiomyopathies; Edema; Humans; Kidney Failure, Chronic; Pulmonary Edema; Regression Analysis; Reproducibility of Results; Respiratory Sounds; Sound; Water; chronic kidney disease; clinical epidemiology; end-stage renal disease; hemodialysis; renal dialysis; ultrafiltration.

Copyright © 2016 by the American Society of Nephrology.

Figures

Figure 1.

Poor correlation between ultrasound (US) B lines and clinical signs of lung congestion. Correlation between the severity of lung congestion as detected by US-B lines with (A) pulmonary crackles and (B) peripheral edema.