Shadow-Mode Evaluation of an AI Assistant for Multidisciplinary Tumor Boards (OnkoBot)
OnkoBot: Prospective Shadow-Mode Evaluation of a Locally Operated, Source-Grounded Large Language Model System for Drafting Multidisciplinary Tumor Board Recommendations
This study tests whether an artificial intelligence (AI) system that drafts tumor board recommendations performs as well on new cases as it did on archived cases. The system runs in shadow mode at three multidisciplinary tumor boards of TUM University Hospital rechts der Isar. For each case it drafts a recommendation before the board meets. The board does not see the draft, and the draft has no influence on patient care. After the meeting, each draft is compared with the board decision. The agreement rate is then compared with the rate measured on archived decisions of the same boards.
Přehled studie
Postavení
Postavení
Podmínky
Podmínky
Intervence / Léčba
Intervence / Léčba
Detailní popis
The system is a locally operated large language model (LLM) pipeline with retrieval-augmented generation. Its input is the case as presented to the board, with diagnosis, course, question and all patient documents dated before the board date. It retrieves guideline recommendations (Onkopedia and AWMF S3 guidelines in the version in force on the board date), laboratory values, precedent cases from the board archive and PubMed abstracts published before the board date. It then drafts a recommendation with justification. Each statement of the draft is linked to a verbatim quote from its source. All models run on local GPU servers of the hospital with no data retention beyond the immediate analysis, and no patient data are sent to external providers.
The study includes the hematology board, the orthopedics and sarcoma board and the head and neck board. For each case registered for a session, the system drafts a recommendation after the pre-board documents are pulled and before the session starts. Board members do not see the drafts. The decision pipeline (generator Gemma-4-31B at temperature 0) is frozen and versioned for the study period. The study uses routine clinical data only. Patients are not contacted, and no study-specific procedures are performed.
The draft is compared with the consensus decision in the board report. An LLM judge (GLM-5.3-Flash, majority of three votes) assigns both texts to one of seven decision categories: systemic therapy, surgery, radiotherapy, watch and wait, further diagnostics, best supportive care and referral to the molecular tumor board. It also scores agreement in substance from 0 to 3 and records the direction of any disagreement. The judge was validated against clinician ratings on a sealed test set. The same prompt version is used to score the prospective cases and the retrospective reference sample, separately from any output that clinicians see.
The retrospective reference is the evaluation sample of archived decisions of the same three boards (about 2,000 cases, one per patient, drawn with a fixed seed and stratified by time). Patients who also appear in the prospective cohort are removed from the reference. The primary analysis tests non-inferiority of the prospective category match rate against the retrospective rate, pooled over the three boards, with a margin of 7.5 percentage points and a one-sided alpha of 0.025. The variance is cluster-robust for board sessions. A case without a draft counts as not concordant. Per-board results are reported descriptively with 95% confidence intervals. An exploratory component evaluates a trial-matching engine that proposes recruiting clinical trials per case.
In a subset of 30 to 50 cases per board, physicians rate the system draft against the board decision. This subset tests whether the agreement between judge and clinicians, measured retrospectively, also holds prospectively.
Typ studie
Typ studie
Zápis (Odhadovaný)
Zápis
Kontakty a umístění
Studijní kontakt
Studijní kontakt
- Jméno: Lisa Adams, MD
- Telefonní číslo: +49 89 4150 1084
- E-mail: lisa.adams@tum.de
Studijní záloha kontaktů
- Jméno: Keno Bressem, MD
- E-mail: keno.bressem@tum.de
Studijní místa
-
-
Bavaria
-
Munich, Bavaria, Německo, 81675
- Zatím nenabíráme
- TUM University Hospital rechts der Isar
-
Munich, Bavaria, Německo
- Nábor
- TUM Klinikum rechts der Isar
-
Kontakt:
- Lisa Adams, Prof.
- Telefonní číslo: +49 89 4140-1084
- E-mail: lisa.adams@tum.de
-
-
Kritéria účasti
Kritéria způsobilosti
Kritéria způsobilosti
Věk způsobilý ke studiu
- Dítě
- Dospělý
- Starší dospělý
Přijímá zdravé dobrovolníky
Pohlaví způsobilá ke studiu
Metoda odběru vzorků
Studijní populace
All cases registered for the hematology, orthopedics and sarcoma, and head and neck tumor boards of TUM University Hospital rechts der Isar during the study period. One case is one patient presentation on one board date.
Popis
Inclusion Criteria:
- Case registered for a session of a participating tumor board (hematology, orthopedics and sarcoma, head and neck) of TUM University Hospital rechts der Isar during the study period
- Board registration and pre-board patient documents available before the session starts
Exclusion Criteria:
- Case not discussed at the session, defined as no board report with a consensus decision for that date (deferred or withdrawn registrations)
- Session without a shadow run of the system
Excluded cases are counted and reported by reason.
Studijní plán
Jak je studie koncipována?
Detaily designu
- Observační modely: COHORT
- Časové perspektivy: PROSPECTIVE
Počet skupin / kohort
Kohorty a intervence
Skupina / kohortaSkupina / kohorta |
Intervence / LéčbaIntervence / Léčba |
|---|---|
|
Hematology board
Consecutive cases presented at the hematology tumor board of TUM University Hospital rechts der Isar. |
A locally operated, source-grounded large language model system drafts a tumor board recommendation with justification and verified citations for each case before the board meeting. The draft is not shown to the board and does not influence patient care. |
|
Orthopedics and sarcoma board
Consecutive cases presented at the orthopedics and sarcoma tumor board of TUM University Hospital rechts der Isar. |
A locally operated, source-grounded large language model system drafts a tumor board recommendation with justification and verified citations for each case before the board meeting. The draft is not shown to the board and does not influence patient care. |
|
Head and neck board
Consecutive cases presented at the head and neck tumor board of TUM University Hospital rechts der Isar. |
A locally operated, source-grounded large language model system drafts a tumor board recommendation with justification and verified citations for each case before the board meeting. The draft is not shown to the board and does not influence patient care. |
Co je měření studie?
Primární výstupní opatření
Primární výstupní opatření
Měření výsledku |
Popis opatření |
Časové okno |
|---|---|---|
|
Proportion of Cases With Category Match Between System Draft and Board Decision
Časové okno: Each case is assessed once, after the board report of its session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
Proportion of discussed cases in which the system draft and the board consensus decision fall into the same of seven decision categories (systemic therapy, surgery, radiotherapy, watch and wait, further diagnostics, best supportive care, referral to the molecular tumor board). Overlap counts where either side carries a second category. Assessed by a pre-specified LLM judge (GLM-5.3-Flash, prompt V3, majority of three votes), pooled over the three boards. Tested for non-inferiority against the rate of the same system and judge on the retrospective reference sample of the same boards, margin 7.5 percentage points, one-sided alpha 0.025. |
Each case is assessed once, after the board report of its session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
Sekundární výstupní opatření
Sekundární výstupní opatření
Měření výsledku |
Popis opatření |
Časové okno |
|---|---|---|
|
Proportion of Cases Rated Concordant or Partially Concordant
Časové okno: After the board report of each session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
Category match with a substance score of at least 1 of 3 (concordant requires at least 2 of 3 on a primary-category match, 3 of 3 where only second categories overlap). Non-inferiority versus retrospective reference, margin 7.5 percentage points, tested after the primary outcome (hierarchical testing). |
After the board report of each session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
|
Proportion of Cases Rated Concordant, Partially Concordant and Not Concordant
Časové okno: After the board report of each session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
Proportion of cases rated concordant, partially concordant and not concordant by the LLM judge. |
After the board report of each session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
|
Proportion of Cases With Category Match per Board
Časové okno: After the board report of each session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
Category match and concordant or partially concordant per board, with 95% confidence intervals, descriptive. |
After the board report of each session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
|
Proportion of Discordant Cases by Direction of Disagreement
Časové okno: After the board report of each session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
Among cases without category match, proportion in which the draft is more conservative, more aggressive or a different modality than the board decision. |
After the board report of each session is available; analysis after accrual is complete (anticipated January 2027)
|
|
Proportion of Cases With Category Match as Rated by Clinicians
Časové okno: Within 3 months after the board session
|
In 30 to 50 cases per board, agreement between draft and board decision as rated by physicians who did not attend the session, and agreement between judge and clinicians on category match (percentage agreement, Cohen's kappa). |
Within 3 months after the board session
|
|
Proportion of Citations Verified Word for Word Against Their Source
Časové okno: At draft generation, before the board session
|
Proportion of citations per case that verify word for word against their source, and proportion of cases in which every citation verifies. |
At draft generation, before the board session
|
|
Proportion of Cases With a Draft Completed Before the Board Session
Časové okno: At draft generation, before the board session
|
Proportion of cases with a draft completed before the session starts, and generation time per case in minutes. |
At draft generation, before the board session
|
Další výstupní opatření
Další výstupní opatření
Měření výsledku |
Popis opatření |
Časové okno |
|---|---|---|
|
Number of Clinical Trials Shortlisted per Case by the Trial-Matching Engine
Časové okno: At draft generation, before the board session
|
Number of trials shortlisted per case, proportion recruiting on the board date, rule-based error rate (wrong disease, line of therapy, setting or status) and clinician screening verdicts where given. |
At draft generation, before the board session
|
Spolupracovníci a vyšetřovatelé
Sponzor
Sponzor
Vyšetřovatelé
Vyšetřovatelé
- Vrchní vyšetřovatel: Lisa Adams, MD, Technical University of Munich
- Vrchní vyšetřovatel: Krischan Braitsch, MD, Technical University of Munich
Termíny studijních záznamů
Hlavní termíny studia
Začátek studia (Odhadovaný)
Začátek studia
Primární dokončení (Odhadovaný)
Primární dokončení
Dokončení studie (Odhadovaný)
Dokončení studie
Termíny zápisu do studia
První předloženo
První předloženo
První předloženo, které splnilo kritéria kontroly kvality
První předloženo, které splnilo kritéria kontroly kvality
První zveřejněno (Aktuální)
První zveřejněno
Aktualizace studijních záznamů
Poslední zveřejněná aktualizace (Aktuální)
Poslední zveřejněná aktualizace
Odeslaná poslední aktualizace, která splnila kritéria kontroly kvality
Odeslaná poslední aktualizace, která splnila kritéria kontroly kvality
Naposledy ověřeno
Naposledy ověřeno
Více informací
Termíny související s touto studií
Klíčová slova
Další relevantní podmínky MeSH
Další identifikační čísla studie
Další identifikační čísla studie
- ONKOBOT-SHADOW-01
- KK6050201BM5 (Jiné číslo grantu/financování: Central Innovation Programme for SMEs (ZIM), German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs)
Plán pro data jednotlivých účastníků (IPD)
Plánujete sdílet data jednotlivých účastníků (IPD)?
Popis plánu IPD
Individual participant data are routine clinical records that may not leave the hospital under the ethics approval and data protection concept. Aggregate results and the analysis code will be published.
Informace o lécích a zařízeních, studijní dokumenty
Studuje lékový produkt regulovaný americkým FDA
Studuje produkt zařízení regulovaný americkým úřadem FDA
Tyto informace byly beze změn načteny přímo z webu clinicaltrials.gov. Máte-li jakékoli požadavky na změnu, odstranění nebo aktualizaci podrobností studie, kontaktujte prosím register@clinicaltrials.gov. Jakmile bude změna implementována na clinicaltrials.gov, bude automaticky aktualizována i na našem webu .