Implicit bias in healthcare professionals: a systematic review

Chloë FitzGerald, Samia Hurst, Chloë FitzGerald, Samia Hurst

Abstract

Background: Implicit biases involve associations outside conscious awareness that lead to a negative evaluation of a person on the basis of irrelevant characteristics such as race or gender. This review examines the evidence that healthcare professionals display implicit biases towards patients.

Methods: PubMed, PsychINFO, PsychARTICLE and CINAHL were searched for peer-reviewed articles published between 1st March 2003 and 31st March 2013. Two reviewers assessed the eligibility of the identified papers based on precise content and quality criteria. The references of eligible papers were examined to identify further eligible studies.

Results: Forty two articles were identified as eligible. Seventeen used an implicit measure (Implicit Association Test in fifteen and subliminal priming in two), to test the biases of healthcare professionals. Twenty five articles employed a between-subjects design, using vignettes to examine the influence of patient characteristics on healthcare professionals' attitudes, diagnoses, and treatment decisions. The second method was included although it does not isolate implicit attitudes because it is recognised by psychologists who specialise in implicit cognition as a way of detecting the possible presence of implicit bias. Twenty seven studies examined racial/ethnic biases; ten other biases were investigated, including gender, age and weight. Thirty five articles found evidence of implicit bias in healthcare professionals; all the studies that investigated correlations found a significant positive relationship between level of implicit bias and lower quality of care.

Discussion: The evidence indicates that healthcare professionals exhibit the same levels of implicit bias as the wider population. The interactions between multiple patient characteristics and between healthcare professional and patient characteristics reveal the complexity of the phenomenon of implicit bias and its influence on clinician-patient interaction. The most convincing studies from our review are those that combine the IAT and a method measuring the quality of treatment in the actual world. Correlational evidence indicates that biases are likely to influence diagnosis and treatment decisions and levels of care in some circumstances and need to be further investigated. Our review also indicates that there may sometimes be a gap between the norm of impartiality and the extent to which it is embraced by healthcare professionals for some of the tested characteristics.

Conclusions: Our findings highlight the need for the healthcare profession to address the role of implicit biases in disparities in healthcare. More research in actual care settings and a greater homogeneity in methods employed to test implicit biases in healthcare is needed.

Keywords: Attitudes of health personnel; Healthcare disparities; Implicit bias; Prejudice; Stereotyping.

References

    1. Holroyd J, Sweetman J. The Heterogeneity of Implicit Bias. In Brownstein, Michael, Saul, Jennifer, editors. Implicit Bias and Philosophy, Volume 1: Metaphysics and Epistemology 1. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2016. p. 80–103.
    1. Blair IV, Steiner JF, Havranek EP. Unconscious (implicit) bias and health disparities: where do we go from here? Perm J. 2011;15:71.
    1. Ambady N, Shih M, Kim A, Pittinsky TL. Stereotype susceptibility in children: effects of identity activation on quantitative performance. Psychol Sci. 2001;12:385–390. doi: 10.1111/1467-9280.00371.
    1. Louise A. Bias: Friend or Foe? Reflections on Saulish Skepticism. In Brownstein, Michael, Saul, Jennifer, editors. Implicit Bias and Philosophy, Volume 1: Metaphysics and Epistemology 1. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2016. p. 157–190.
    1. Nosek BA, et al. Pervasiveness and correlates of implicit attitudes and stereotypes. Eur Rev Soc Psychol. 2007;18:36–88. doi: 10.1080/10463280701489053.
    1. Nosek BA, Riskind RG. Policy implications of implicit social cognition. Soc Issues Policy Rev. 2012;6:113–147. doi: 10.1111/j.1751-2409.2011.01037.x.
    1. Jost JT, et al. The existence of implicit bias is beyond reasonable doubt: a refutation of ideological and methodological objections and executive summary of ten studies that no manager should ignore. Res Organ Behav. 2009;29:39–69. doi: 10.1016/j.riob.2009.10.001.
    1. Bertrand M, Mullainathan S. Are Emily and Greg more employable than lakisha and Jamal? a field experiment on labor market discrimination. Am Econ Rev. 2004;94:991–1013. doi: 10.1257/0002828042002561.
    1. Rooth D-O. Automatic associations and discrimination in hiring: real world evidence. Labour Econ. 2010;17:523–534. doi: 10.1016/j.labeco.2009.04.005.
    1. Dovidio JF, Gaertner SL. Aversive racism. Adv Exp Soc Psychol. 2004;36:1–52. doi: 10.1016/S0065-2601(04)36001-6.
    1. Martin AK, Tavaglione N, Hurst S. Resolving the conflict: Clarifying’ Vulnerability’ in health care ethics. Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 2014;24:51–72. doi: 10.1353/ken.2014.0005.
    1. De-Shalit A, Wolff J. Disadvantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2007.
    1. Burgess D, van Ryn M, Dovidio J, Saha S. Reducing racial bias among health care providers: lessons from social-cognitive psychology. J Gen Intern Med. 2007;22:882–887. doi: 10.1007/s11606-007-0160-1.
    1. Stone J, Moskowitz GB. Non-conscious bias in medical decision making: what can be done to reduce it? Med Educ. 2011;45:768–776. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2011.04026.x.
    1. Shavers VL, et al. The state of research on racial/ethnic discrimination in the receipt of health care. Am J Public Health. 2012;102:953–966. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2012.300773.
    1. Zestcott, C. A., Blair, I. V. & Stone, J. Examining the presence, consequences, and reduction of implicit bias in health care: A narrative review. Group Process Intergroup Relat. 2016. doi:10.1177/1368430216642029.
    1. Hall WJ, et al. Implicit racial/ethnic bias among health care professionals and its influence on health care outcomes: a systematic review. Am J Public Health. 2015;105:e60–e76. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2015.302903.
    1. Drewniak D, Krones T, Sauer C, Wild V. The influence of patients’ immigration background and residence permit status on treatment decisions in health care. Results of a factorial survey among general practitioners in Switzerland. Soc Sci Med. 2016;161:64–73. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.05.039.
    1. De Houwer J, Moors A. How to define and examine the implicitness of implicit measures. In Wittenbrink B, Schwartz N. (eds.). Implicit measures of attitudes: Procedures and controversies. New York: Guilford Press; 2007. pp. 179–194.
    1. Moskowitz GB, Stone J, Childs A. Implicit stereotyping and medical decisions: unconscious stereotype activation in practitioners’ thoughts about African americans. Am J Public Health. 2012;102:996–1001. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2011.300591.
    1. Stepanikova I. Racial-ethnic biases, time pressure, and medical decisions. J Health Soc Behav. 2012;53:329–343. doi: 10.1177/0022146512445807.
    1. Blair IV, et al. Assessment of biases against Latinos and African americans among primary care providers and community members. Am J Public Health. 2013;103:92–98. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2012.300812.
    1. Cooper LA, et al. The associations of clinicians’ implicit attitudes about race with medical visit communication and patient ratings of interpersonal care. Am J Public Health. 2012;102:979–987. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2011.300558.
    1. Penner LA, et al. Aversive racism and medical interactions with black patients: a field study. J Exp Soc Psychol. 2010;46:436–440. doi: 10.1016/j.jesp.2009.11.004.
    1. Protière C, Viens P, Rousseau F, Moatti JP. Prescribers’ attitudes toward elderly breast cancer patients. Discrimination or empathy? Crit Rev Oncol Hematol. 2010;75:138–150. doi: 10.1016/j.critrevonc.2009.09.007.
    1. Mackay N, Barrowclough C. Accident and emergency staff’s perceptions of deliberate self-harm: attributions, emotions and willingness to help. Br J Clin Psychol. 2005;44:255–267. doi: 10.1348/014466505X29620.
    1. Arber S, et al. Influence of patient characteristics on doctors’ questioning and lifestyle advice for coronary heart disease: a UK/US video experiment. Br J Gen Pract. 2004;54:673–678.
    1. McKinlay J, et al. How do doctors in different countries manage the same patient? results of a factorial experiment. Health Serv Res. 2006;41:2182–2200. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2006.00595.x.
    1. Lutfey KE, et al. Diagnostic certainty as a source of medical practice variation in coronary heart disease: results from a cross-national experiment of clinical decision making. Med Decis Making. 2009;29(5):606–18.
    1. McKinlay JB, et al. Sources of variation in physician adherence with clinical guidelines: results from a factorial experiment. J Gen Intern Med. 2007;22:289–296. doi: 10.1007/s11606-006-0075-2.
    1. Bönte M, et al. Women and men with coronary heart disease in three countries: are they treated differently? Womens Health Issues. 2008;18:191–198. doi: 10.1016/j.whi.2008.01.003.
    1. Arber S, et al. Patient characteristics and inequalities in doctors’ diagnostic and management strategies relating to CHD: a video-simulation experiment. Soc Sci Med. 2006;62:103–115. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2005.05.028.
    1. Lutfey KE, Eva KW, Gerstenberger E, Link CL, McKinlay JB. Physician cognitive processing as a source of diagnostic and treatment disparities in coronary heart disease results of a factorial priming experiment. J Health Soc Behav. 2010;51:16–29. doi: 10.1177/0022146509361193.
    1. Maserejian NN, Link CL, Lutfey KL, Marceau LD, McKinlay JB. Disparities in physicians’ interpretations of heart disease symptoms by patient gender: results of a video vignette factorial experiment. J Womens Health. 2009;18:1661–1667. doi: 10.1089/jwh.2008.1007.
    1. Lutfey KE, Link CL, Grant RW, Marceau LD, McKinlay JB. Is certainty more important than diagnosis for understanding race and gender disparities?: An experiment using coronary heart disease and depression case vignettes. Health Policy. 2009;89:279–287. doi: 10.1016/j.healthpol.2008.06.007.
    1. Maserejian NN, Lutfey KE, McKinlay JB. Do physicians attend to base rates? prevalence data and statistical discrimination in the diagnosis of coronary heart disease. Health Serv Res. 2009;44:1933–1949. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2009.01022.x.
    1. Kales HC, et al. Race, gender, and psychiatrists’ diagnosis and treatment of major depression among elderly patients. Psychiatr Serv. 2005;56:721–728. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.56.6.721.
    1. Kales HC, et al. Effect of race and Sex on primary care Physicians’ diagnosis and treatment of late-life depression. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2005;53:777–784. doi: 10.1111/j.1532-5415.2005.53255.x.
    1. Dehlendorf C, et al. Recommendations for intrauterine contraception: a randomized trial of the effects of patients’ race/ethnicity and socioeconomic status. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2010;203:319–e1. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2010.05.009.
    1. Tamayo-Sarver JH, et al. The effect of race/ethnicity and desirable social characteristics on physicians’ decisions to prescribe opioid analgesics. Acad Emerg Med. 2003;10:1239–1248. doi: 10.1111/j.1553-2712.2003.tb00608.x.
    1. Barnato AE, et al. A randomized trial of the effect of patient race on physician ICU and life-sustaining treatment decisions for an acutely unstable elder with end-stage cancer. Crit Care Med. 2011;39:1663. doi: 10.1097/CCM.0b013e3182186e98.
    1. Peris TS, Teachman BA, Nosek BA. Implicit and explicit stigma of mental illness: Links to clinical care. J Nerv Ment Dis. 2008;196:752–760. doi: 10.1097/NMD.0b013e3181879dfd.
    1. Burgess DJ, et al. Patient race and physicians’ decisions to prescribe opioids for chronic low back pain. Soc Sci Med. 2008;67:1852–1860. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2008.09.009.
    1. Blair IV, et al. Clinicians’ implicit ethnic/racial bias and perceptions of care among black and Latino patients. Ann Fam Med. 2013;11:43–52. doi: 10.1370/afm.1442.
    1. Sabin JA, Greenwald AG. The influence of implicit bias on treatment recommendations for four common pediatric conditions: pain, urinary tract infection, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and asthma. Am J Public Health. 2012;102:988–995. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2011.300621.
    1. Green AR, et al. Implicit bias among physicians and its prediction of thrombolysis decisions for black and white patients. J Gen Intern Med. 2007;22:1231–1238. doi: 10.1007/s11606-007-0258-5.
    1. Sabin JA, Rivara FP, Greenwald AG. Physician implicit attitudes and stereotypes about race and quality of medical care. Med Care. 2008;46:678–685. doi: 10.1097/MLR.0b013e3181653d58.
    1. von Hippel W, Brener L, von Hippel C. Implicit prejudice toward injecting drug users predicts intentions to change jobs among drug and alcohol nurses. Psychol Sci. 2008;19:7–11. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02037.x.
    1. Brener L, von Hippel W, Kippax S. Prejudice among health care workers toward injecting drug users with hepatitis C: does greater contact lead to less prejudice? Int J Drug Policy. 2007;18:381–387. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2007.01.006.
    1. Schwartz MB, Chambliss HO, Brownell KD, Blair SN, Billington C. Weight bias among health professionals specializing in obesity. Obes Res. 2003;11:1033–1039. doi: 10.1038/oby.2003.142.
    1. Haider AH, et al. Association of unconscious race and social class bias with vignette-based clinical assessments by medical students. JAMA. 2011;306:942–951.
    1. Oliver MN, Wells KM, Joy-Gaba JA, Hawkins CB, Nosek BA. Do physicians’ implicit views of African americans affect clinical decision making? J Am Board Fam Med. 2014;27:177–188. doi: 10.3122/jabfm.2014.02.120314.
    1. Blair IV, et al. An investigation of associations between clinicians’ ethnic or racial bias and hypertension treatment, medication adherence and blood pressure control. J Gen Intern Med. 2014;29:987–995. doi: 10.1007/s11606-014-2795-z.
    1. Hirsh AT, Hollingshead NA, Ashburn-Nardo L, Kroenke K. The interaction of patient race, provider bias, and clinical ambiguity on pain management decisions. J Pain. 2015;16:558–568. doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2015.03.003.
    1. Cole ER. Intersectionality and research in psychology. Am Psychol. 2009;64:170. doi: 10.1037/a0014564.
    1. Burgess DJ, Fu SS, Van Ryn M. Why do providers contribute to disparities and what can be done about it? J Gen Intern Med. 2004;19:1154–1159. doi: 10.1111/j.1525-1497.2004.30227.x.
    1. Dominicé Dao M. Vulnerability in the clinic: case study of a transcultural consultation. J Med Ethics. 2016. doi:10.1136/medethics-2015-103337.
    1. Linden MA, Redpath SJ. A comparative study of nursing attitudes towards young male survivors of brain injury: a questionnaire survey. Int J Nurs Stud. 2011;48:62–69. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2010.05.011.
    1. Redpath SJ, et al. Healthcare professionals’ attitudes towards traumatic brain injury (TBI): the influence of profession, experience, aetiology and blame on prejudice towards survivors of brain injury. Brain Inj. 2010;24:802–811. doi: 10.3109/02699051003709623.
    1. Sabin JA, Marini M, Nosek BA. Implicit and explicit anti-fat bias among a large sample of medical doctors by BMI, race/ethnicity and gender. PLoS One. 2012;7:e48448. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0048448.
    1. Li L, et al. Using case vignettes to measure HIV-related stigma among health professionals in China. Int J Epidemiol. 2007;36:178–184. doi: 10.1093/ije/dyl256.
    1. Aaberg VA. A path to greater inclusivity through understanding implicit attitudes toward disability. J Nurs Educ. 2012;51:505–510. doi: 10.3928/01484834-20120706-02.
    1. Abuful A, Gidron Y, Henkin Y. Physicians’ attitudes toward preventive therapy for coronary artery disease: is there a gender bias? Clin Cardiol. 2005;28:389–393. doi: 10.1002/clc.4960280809.
    1. Chow LY, Kam WK, Leung CM. Attitudes of healthcare professionals towards psychiatric patients in a general hospital in Hong Kong. J Psychiatry. 2007;17(1):3–9.
    1. Neauport A, et al. Effects of a psychiatric label on medical residents’ attitudes. Int J Soc Psychiatry. 2012;58:485–487. doi: 10.1177/0020764011408652.
    1. Barnhart JM, Wassertheil-Smoller S. The effect of race/ethnicity, sex, and social circumstances on coronary revascularization preferences: a vignette comparison. Cardiol Rev. 2006;14:215–222. doi: 10.1097/01.crd.0000214180.24372.d5.
    1. Sabin DJA, Nosek DBA, Greenwald DAG, Rivara DFP. Physicians’ implicit and explicit attitudes about race by MD race, ethnicity, and gender. J Health Care Poor Underserved. 2009;20:896. doi: 10.1353/hpu.0.0185.
    1. Michael Vallis T, Currie B, Lawlor D, Ransom T. Healthcare professional bias against the obese: how do we know if we have a problem? Can J Diabetes. 2007;31:365–370. doi: 10.1016/S1499-2671(07)14008-9.

Source: PubMed

Sponzoři a spolupracovníci

Zdravotní podmínky

Drogové intervence

3
Předplatit