Exploring the role of community engagement in improving the health of disadvantaged populations: a systematic review

Sheila Cyril, Ben J Smith, Alphia Possamai-Inesedy, Andre M N Renzaho, Sheila Cyril, Ben J Smith, Alphia Possamai-Inesedy, Andre M N Renzaho

Abstract

Background: Although community engagement (CE) is widely used in health promotion, components of CE models associated with improved health are poorly understood. This study aimed to examine the magnitude of the impact of CE on health and health inequalities among disadvantaged populations, which methodological approaches maximise the effectiveness of CE, and components of CE that are acceptable, feasible, and effective when used among disadvantaged populations.

Design: The systematic review followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. We carried out methodological assessments of the included studies using rating scales. The analysis focussed on model synthesis to identify the key CE components linked to positive study outcomes and comparative analysis between positive study outcomes, processes, and quality indicators of CE.

Results: Out of 24 studies that met our inclusion criteria, 21 (87.5%) had positively impacted health behaviours, public health planning, health service access, health literacy, and a range of health outcomes. More than half of the studies (58%) were of good quality, whereas 71% and 42% of studies showed good community involvement in research and achieved high levels of CE, respectively. Key CE components that affected health outcomes included real power-sharing, collaborative partnerships, bidirectional learning, incorporating the voice and agency of beneficiary communities in research protocol, and using bicultural health workers for intervention delivery.

Conclusions: The findings suggest that CE models can lead to improved health and health behaviours among disadvantaged populations if designed properly and implemented through effective community consultation and participation. We also found several gaps in the current measurement of CE in health intervention studies, which suggests the importance of developing innovative approaches to measure CE impact on health outcomes in a more rigorous way.

Keywords: community engagement; culturally and linguistically diverse; disadvantaged populations; ethnic minorities; health.

Figures

Fig. 1
Fig. 1
Flow chart of study selection.

References

    1. Butterfoss FD, Kegler MC. Toward a comprehensive understanding of community coalitions: moving from practice to theory. In: DiClemente R, Crosby R, Kegler MC, editors. Emerging theories in health promotion practice and research. 2nd ed. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass; 2002. pp. 157–93.
    1. NICE. Community engagement to improve health. London: NHS National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence; 2008.
    1. Balcázar HG, de Heer H, Rosenthal L, Aguirre M, Flores L, Puentes FA, et al. A promotores de salud intervention to reduce cardiovascular disease risk in a high-risk Hispanic border population. Prev Chronic Dis. 2010;7:A28.
    1. Wells KB, Jones L, Chung B, Dixon EL, Tang L, Gilmore J, et al. Community-partnered cluster-randomized comparative effectiveness trial of community engagement and planning or resources for services to address depression disparities. J Gen Intern Med. 2013;28:1268–78.
    1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Principles of community engagement. CDC/ATSDR Committee on Community Engagement. 1997. Available from: [cited 10 March 2015]
    1. CDC/ATSDR. Principles of community engagement CDC/ATSDR committee on community engagement. 2nd ed. 2013. Available from: [cited 6 July 2015]
    1. Wallerstein N, Duran B. The conceptual, historical, and practice roots of community-based participatory research and related participatory traditions. In: Minkler M, Wallerstein N, editors. Community-based participatory research for health. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass; 2003. pp. 27–52.
    1. Holkup PA, Tripp-Reimer T, Salois EM, Weinert C. Community-based participatory research: an approach to intervention research with a Native American community. ANS Adv Nurs Sci. 2004;27:162.
    1. Wallerstein N, Duran B. Community-based participatory research contributions to intervention research: the intersection of science and practice to improve health equity. Am J Public Health. 2010;1(100 Suppl 1):S40–6.
    1. Las Nueces D, Hacker K, DiGirolamo A, Hicks LS. A systematic review of community-based participatory research to enhance clinical trials in racial and ethnic minority groups. Health Serv Res. 2012;47(3 Pt 2):1363–86.
    1. Trotter RT, Needle RH, Goosby E, Bates C, Singer M. A methodological model for rapid assessment, response, and evaluation: the RARE program in public health. Field Methods. 2001;13:137–59.
    1. Staley K. Eastleigh, UK: INVOLVE; 2009. Exploring impact: public involvement in NHS, public health and social care research.
    1. Whitehead M, Dahlgren G. Copenhagen: WHO; 2006. Levelling up (part 1): a discussion paper on concepts and principles for tackling social inequities in health.
    1. Renzaho A, Polonsky M, Mellor D, Cyril S. Addressing migration-related social and health inequalities in Australia-call for research funding priorities to recognise the needs of migrant populations. Aust Health Rev. 2015 doi: . [Epub ahead of print].
    1. Balcazar H, Rosenthal L, De Heer H, Aguirre M, Flores L, Vasquez E, et al. Use of community-based participatory research to disseminate baseline results from a cardiovascular disease randomized community trial for Mexican Americans living in a US-Mexico border community. Educ Health. 2009;22:279.
    1. Burhansstipanov L. Cancer: a growing problem among American Indians and Alaska Natives. In: Dixon M, Roubideaux Y, editors. Promises to keep: public health policy for American Indians and Alaska Natives in the 21st century. Washington, DC: American Public Health Association; 2001. pp. 223–51.
    1. Riggs E, Davis E, Gibbs L, Block K, Szwarc J, Casey S, et al. Accessing maternal and child health services in Melbourne, Australia: reflections from refugee families and service providers. BMC Health Serv Res. 2012;12:117.
    1. English KC, Fairbanks J, Finster CE, Rafelito A, Luna J, Kennedy M. A socioecological approach to improving mammography rates in a tribal community. Health Educ Behav. 2006;35:396–409.
    1. National Center for Health Statistics. Hyattsville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services; 2010. Health, United States 2009: with specific feature on medical technology.
    1. Fawcett SB, Collie-Akers V, Schultz JA, Cupertino P. Community-based participatory research within the Latino health for all coalition. J Prev Interv Community. 2013;41:142–54.
    1. Garcia-Dominic O, Wray LA, Trevino RP, Hernandez AE, Yin Z, Ulbrecht JS. Identifying barriers that hinder onsite parental involvement in a school-based health promotion program. Health Promot Pract. 2010;11:703–13.
    1. Gibbs L, Waters E, Magarey A, Booth M, Gibbons K, Swinburn B. Fun ‘n’ healthy in Moreland! Final Report to Victorian Department of Human Services. Melbourne: DHS; 2011.
    1. Tovar A, Renzaho AMN, Guerrero AD, Mena N, Ayala GX. A systematic review of obesity prevention intervention studies among immigrant populations in the US. Curr Obes Rep. 2014;3:206–22.
    1. Charania NA, Tsuji LJ. A community-based participatory approach and engagement process creates culturally appropriate and community informed pandemic plans after the 2009 H1N1 influenza pandemic: remote and isolated First Nations communities of sub-arctic Ontario, Canada. BMC Public Health. 2012;12:268.
    1. Sheikh A. Why are ethnic minorities under-represented in US research studies? PLoS Med. 2006;3:e49.
    1. Cochran PA, Marshall CA, Garcia-Downing C, Kendall E, Cook D, McCubbin L, et al. Indigenous ways of knowing: implications for participatory research and community. Am J Public Health. 2008;98:22–7.
    1. Wallerstein N. What is the evidence on effectiveness of empowerment to improve health? Copenhagen: WHO Europe, Health Evidence Network; 2006.
    1. Renzaho A, Renzaho C, Polonsky M. Left out, left off, left over: why migrants from non-English speaking backgrounds are not adequately recognised in health promotion policy and programs. Health Promot J Aust. 2012;23:84–5.
    1. Waheed W, Husain N, Creed F. Psychiatric services for ethnic minority groups: a third way? Br J Psychiatry. 2003;183:562–3. author reply 563.
    1. Airhihenbuwa CO. Health and culture: beyond the western paradigm. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; 1995.
    1. Ahmed SM, Palermo AS. Community engagement in research: frameworks for education and peer review. Am J Public Health. 2010;100:1380–7.
    1. Baranowski T, Simons-Morton B, Hooks P, Henske J, Tiernan K, Dunn JK, et al. A center-based program for exercise change among black-American families. Health Educ Behav. 1990;17:179–96.
    1. Poston WS, 2nd, Haddock CK, Olvera NE, Suminski RR, Reeves RS, Dunn JK, et al. Evaluation of a culturally appropriate intervention to increase physical activity. Am J Health Behav. 2001;25:396–406.
    1. Dedobbeleer N, Desjardins S. Outcomes of an ecological and participatory approach to prevent alcohol and other drug abuse among multiethnic adolescents. Subst Use Misuse. 2001;36:1959.
    1. Conway TL, Woodruff SI, Edwards CC, Hovell MF, Klein J. Intervention to reduce environmental tobacco smoke exposure in Latino children: null effects on hair biomarkers and parent reports. Tob Control. 2004;13:90–2.
    1. Faridi Z, Shuval K, Njike VY, Katz JA, Jennings G, Williams M, et al. Partners reducing effects of diabetes (PREDICT): a diabetes prevention physical activity and dietary intervention through African-American churches. Health Educ Res. 2010;25:306–15.
    1. Daniel M, Green LW, Marion SA, Gamble D, Herbert CP, Hertzman C, et al. Effectiveness of community-directed diabetes prevention and control in a rural Aboriginal population in British Columbia, Canada. Soc Sci Med. 1999;48:815–32.
    1. Anand SS, Davis AD, Ahmed R, Jacobs R, Xie C, Hill A, et al. A family-based intervention to promote healthy lifestyles in an aboriginal community in Canada. Can J Public Health. 2007;98:447–52.
    1. Hayashi T, Farrell MA, Chaput LA, Rocha DA, Hernandez M. Lifestyle intervention, behavioral changes, and improvement in cardiovascular risk profiles in the California WISEWOMAN project. J Womens Health. 2010;19:1129–38.
    1. Hunter J, de Zapien JG, Papenfuss M, Fernandez ML, Meister J, Giuliano AR. The impact of a promotora on increasing routine chronic disease prevention among women aged 40 and older at the US–Mexico border. Health Educ Behav. 2004;31:18–28S.
    1. Avila P, Hovell MF. Physical activity training for weight loss in Latinas: a controlled trial. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 1994;18:476–82.
    1. Black MM, Hager ER, Le K, Anliker J, Arteaga SS, DiClemente C, et al. Challenge! Health promotion/obesity prevention mentorship model among urban, black adolescents. Pediatrics. 2010;126:280–8.
    1. Popay J, Attree P, Hornby D, Milton B, Whitehead M, French B, et al. Community engagement in initiatives addressing the wider social determinants of health: a rapid review of evidence on impact, experience and process. Lancaster: University of Lancaster; 2007.
    1. Laverack G, Ronald L. A planning framework for community empowerment goals within health promotion. Health Policy Plan. 2000;15:255–62.
    1. O'Mara-Eves A, Brunton G, McDaid D, Oliver S, Kavanagh J, Jamal F, et al. Community engagement to reduce inequalities in health: a systematic review, meta-analysis and economic analysis. Public Health Res. 2013;1:1–140.
    1. Attree P, French B, Milton B, Povall S, Whitehead M, Popay J. The experience of community engagement for individuals: a rapid review of evidence. Health Soc Care Community. 2011;19:250–60.
    1. Chau RCM. The involvement of Chinese older people in policy and practice: aspirations and expectations. York: University of Sheffield and the Joseph Rowntree Foundation; 2007.
    1. Swainston K, Summerbell C. The effectiveness of community engagement approaches and methods for health promotion interventions. 2008. Available from: [cited 20 June 2015].
    1. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, The PRISMA Group Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 2009;6:e1000097. doi: .
    1. Renzaho A, Romios P, Crock C, Sonderlund AL. The effectiveness of cultural competence programs in ethnic minority patient-centered health care – a systematic review of the literature. Int J Qual Health Care. 2013;25:261–9.
    1. Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D, CONSORT Group CONSORT 2010 statement: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials. BMC Med. 2010;8:18.
    1. von Elm E, Altman DG, Egger M, Pocock SJ, Gøtzsche PC, Vandenbroucke JP, et al. The Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studies. PLoS Med. 2007;4:e296. doi: .
    1. Letts L, Wilkins S, Law M, Stewart D, Bosch J, Westmorland M. Guidelines for critical review form: qualitative studies (Version 2.0) Ontario, Canada: McMaster University Occupational Therapy Evidence-Based Practice Research Group; 2007.
    1. Long AF, Godfrey M, Randall T, Brettle A, Grant MJ. Part 3: feasibility of undertaking systematic reviews in social care. Leeds: Nuffield Institute for Health; 2002. Developing evidence based social care policy and practice.
    1. IAP2. IAP2 Public Participation Spectrum. 2015. Available from: [cited 12 May 2015]
    1. Rifkin SB, Muller F, Bichmann W. Primary health care: on measuring participation. Soc Sci Med. 1988;26:931–40.
    1. Israel BA, Schulz AJ, Parker EA, Becker AB. Review of community-based research: assessing partnership approaches to improve public health. Ann Rev Public Health. 1998;19:173–202.
    1. Wallerstein N, Oetzel J, Duran B, Tafoya G, Belone L, Rae R, editors. What predicts outcomes in CBPR. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass; 2008.
    1. Bender MS, Nader PR, Kennedy C, Gahagan S. A culturally appropriate intervention to improve health behaviors in Hispanic mother–child dyads. Child Obes. 2013;9:157–63.
    1. Pazoki R, Nabipour I, Seyednezami N, Imami SR. Effects of a community-based healthy heart program on increasing healthy women's physical activity: a randomized controlled trial guided by Community-based Participatory Research (CBPR) BMC Public Health. 2007;7:216.
    1. Parker EA, Israel BA, Robins TG, Mentz G, Lin X, Brakefield-Caldwell W, Lewis TC. Evaluation of community action against asthma: a community health worker intervention to improve children's asthma-related health by reducing household environmental triggers for asthma. Health Educ Behav. 2008;35:376–95.
    1. Nápoles AM, Ortíz C, Santoyo-Olsson J, Stewart AL, Gregorich S, Lee HE, et al. Nuevo Amanecer: results of a randomized controlled trial of a community-based, peer-delivered stress management intervention to improve quality of life in Latinas with breast cancer. Am J Public Health. 2015;105(Suppl 3):e55–63.
    1. Baqui AH, El-Arifeen S, Darmstadt GL, Ahmed S, Williams EK, Seraji HR, et al. Effect of community-based newborn-care intervention package implemented through two service-delivery strategies in Sylhet district, Bangladesh: a cluster-randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2008;371:1936–44.
    1. Gao MY, Wang S. Participatory communication and HIV/AIDS prevention in a Chinese marginalized (MSM) population. AIDS Care. 2007;19:799–810.
    1. Tripathy P, Nair N, Barnett S, Mahapatra R, Borghi J, Rath S, et al. Effect of a participatory intervention with women's groups on birth outcomes and maternal depression in Jharkhand and Orissa, India: a cluster-randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2010;375:1182–92.
    1. Wright AL, Naylor A, Wester R, Bauer M, Sutcliffe E. Using cultural knowledge in health promotion: breastfeeding among the Navajo. Health Educ Behav. 1997;24:625–39.
    1. Harvey I, Schulz A, Israel B, Sand S, Myrie D, Lockett M, et al. The healthy connections project: a community-based participatory research project involving women at risk for diabetes and hypertension. Prog Community Health Partnersh. 2009;3:287–300.
    1. Ferrera MJ, Sacks TK, Perez M, Nixon JP, Asis D, Coleman RWL. Empowering immigrant youth in Chicago: utilizing CBPR to document the impact of a youth health service corps program. Fam Community Health. 2015;38:12–21.
    1. Chomitz VR, McGowan RJ, Wendel JM, Williams SA, Cabral HJ, King SE, Hacker KA. Healthy living Cambridge kids: a community-based participatory effort to promote healthy weight and fitness. Obesity. 2010;18(Suppl 1):S45–53.
    1. Cohen DA, Han B, Derose KP, Williamson S, Marsh T, McKenzie TL. Physical activity in parks: a randomized controlled trial using community engagement. Am J Prev Med. 2013;45:590–7.
    1. Kim KHC, Linnan L, Campbell MK, Brooks C, Koenig HG, Wiesen C. The WORD (wholeness, oneness, righteousness, deliverance): a faith-based weight-loss program utilizing a community-based participatory research approach. Health Educ Behav. 2006;35:634–50. doi: .
    1. Goldberg B, Frank V, Bekenstein S, Garrity P, Ruiz J. Successful community engagement: laying the foundation for effective teen pregnancy prevention. J Child Poverty. 2011;17:65–86.
    1. Fialkowski MK, DeBaryshe B, Bersamin A, Nigg C, Guerrero RL, Rojas G, et al. A community engagement process identifies environmental priorities to prevent early childhood obesity: the children's healthy living (CHL) program for remote underserved populations in the US affiliated pacific islands, Hawaii and Alaska. Matern Child Health J. 2014;18:2261–74.
    1. Collie-Akers VL, Fawcett SB, Schultz JA. Measuring progress of collaborative action in a community health effort. Rev Panam Salud Pública. 2013;34:422–8.
    1. Chung B, Jones L, Jones A, Corbett CE, Booker T, Wells KB, et al. Using community arts events to enhance collective efficacy and community engagement to address depression in an African American Community. Am J Public Health. 2009;99:237–44.
    1. Undie CC, Van Lith LM, Wahome M, Obare F, Oloo E, Curtis C. Community mobilization and service strengthening to increase awareness and use of postabortion care and family planning in Kenya. Int J Gynecol Obstet. 2014;126:8–13.
    1. Greenwald HP, Pearson D, Beery WL, Cheadle A. Youth development, community engagement, and reducing risk behavior. J Prim Prev. 2006;27:3–25.
    1. Phillips G, Bottomley C, Schmidt E, Tobi P, Lais S, Yu G, et al. Well London phase-1: results among adults of a cluster-randomised trial of a community engagement approach to improving health behaviours and mental well-being in deprived inner-city neighbourhoods. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2014;68:606–14. doi: .
    1. Milton B, Attree P, French B, Povall S, Whitehead M, Popay J. The impact of community engagement on health and social outcomes: a systematic review. Community Dev J. 2011;47:316–34. doi: .
    1. Wallerstein NB, Duran B. Using community-based participatory research to address health disparities. Health Promot Pract. 2006;7:312–23.
    1. Verhagen I, Steunenberg B, de Wit NJ, Ros WJG. Community health worker interventions to improve access to health care services for older adults from ethnic minorities: a systematic review. BMC Health Serv Res. 2014;14:497.
    1. Staten LK, Gregory-Mercado KY, Ranger-Moore J, Will JC, Giuliano AR, Ford ES, et al. Provider counseling, health education, and community health workers: the Arizona WISEWOMAN project. J Womens Health. 2004;13:547–56.
    1. Krieger J, Collier C, Song L, Martin D. Linking community-based blood pressure measurement to clinical care: a randomized controlled trial of outreach and tracking by community health workers. Am J Public Health. 1999;89:856–61.
    1. South J, Phillips G. Evaluating community engagement as part of the public health system. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2014;68:692–6.
    1. Jensen PS, Hoagwood K, Trickett EJ. Ivory towers or earthen trenches? Community collaborations to foster real-world research. Appl Dev Sci. 1999;3:206–12.
    1. Sanson-Fisher RW, Bonevski B, Green LW, D'Este C. Limitations of the randomised controlled trial in evaluating population-based health interventions. Am J Prev Med. 2007;33:155–61.
    1. Durlak JA, DuPre EP. Implementation matters: a review of research on the influence of implementation on program outcomes and the factors affecting implementation. Am J Community Psychol. 2008;41:327–50.
    1. Fagan AA, Hanson K, Hawkins JD, Arthur MW. Bridging science to practice: achieving prevention program implementation fidelity in the community youth development study. Am J Community Psychol. 2008;41:235–49.
    1. Rifkin SB. Examining the links between community participation and health outcomes: a review of the literature. Health Policy Plan. 2014;29(Suppl 2):ii98–106. doi: .
    1. Israel BA, Krieger J, Vlahov D, Ciske S, Foley M, Fortin P, et al. Challenges and facilitating factors in sustaining community-based participatory research partnerships: lessons learned from the Detroit, New York City and Seattle Urban Research Centers. J Urban Health. 2006;83:1022–40.
    1. Schultz J, Collie-Akers V, Fernandez C, Fawcett S, Ronan M. Implementing community-based participatory research with two ethnic minority communities in Kansas City, Missouri. Int J Migrat Health Soc Care. 2009;5:47–57.
    1. Kegler M, Malcoe LH. Results from a lay health advisor intervention to prevent lead poisoning among rural native American children. Am J Public Health. 2004;94:1730–5.

Source: PubMed

Sponzoři a spolupracovníci

Zdravotní podmínky

Drogové intervence

3
Předplatit