Comparison of Clinically Relevant Oncolytic Virus Platforms for Enhancing T Cell Therapy of Solid Tumors
Victor Cervera-Carrascon, Dafne C A Quixabeira, Riikka Havunen, Joao M Santos, Emma Kutvonen, James H A Clubb, Mikko Siurala, Camilla Heiniö, Sadia Zafar, Teija Koivula, Dave Lumen, Marjo Vaha, Arturo Garcia-Horsman, Anu J Airaksinen, Suvi Sorsa, Marjukka Anttila, Veijo Hukkanen, Anna Kanerva, Akseli Hemminki, Victor Cervera-Carrascon, Dafne C A Quixabeira, Riikka Havunen, Joao M Santos, Emma Kutvonen, James H A Clubb, Mikko Siurala, Camilla Heiniö, Sadia Zafar, Teija Koivula, Dave Lumen, Marjo Vaha, Arturo Garcia-Horsman, Anu J Airaksinen, Suvi Sorsa, Marjukka Anttila, Veijo Hukkanen, Anna Kanerva, Akseli Hemminki
Abstract
Despite some promising results, the majority of patients do not benefit from T cell therapies, as tumors prevent T cells from entering the tumor, shut down their activity, or downregulate key antigens. Due to their nature and mechanism of action, oncolytic viruses have features that can help overcome many of the barriers currently facing T cell therapies of solid tumors. This study aims to understand how four different oncolytic viruses (adenovirus, vaccinia virus, herpes simplex virus, and reovirus) perform in that task. For that purpose, an immunocompetent in vivo tumor model featuring adoptive tumor-infiltrating lymphocyte (TIL) therapy was used. Tumor growth control (p < 0.001) and survival analyses suggest that adenovirus was most effective in enabling T cell therapy. The complete response rate was 62% for TILs + adenovirus versus 17.5% for TILs + PBS. Of note, TIL biodistribution did not explain efficacy differences between viruses. Instead, immunostimulatory shifts in the tumor microenvironment mirrored efficacy results. Overall, the use of oncolytic viruses can improve the utility of T cell therapies, and additional virus engineering by arming with transgenes can provide further antitumor effects. This phenomenon was seen when an unarmed oncolytic adenovirus was compared to Ad5/3-E2F-d24-hTNFa-IRES-hIL2 (TILT-123). A clinical trial is ongoing, where patients receiving TIL treatment also receive TILT-123 (ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT04217473).
Keywords: T cell therapy; adenovirus; gene therapy; herpes simplex virus; immunotherapy; oncolytic virus; reovirus; solid tumor; tumor microenvironment; vaccinia virus.
© 2020 The Authors.
Figures
References
- Kelly E., Russell S.J. History of oncolytic viruses: genesis to genetic engineering. Mol. Ther. 2007;15:651–659.
- Pikor L.A., Bell J.C., Diallo J.S. Oncolytic Viruses: Exploiting Cancer’s Deal with the Devil. Trends Cancer. 2015;1:266–277.
- Hoster H.A., Zanes R.P., Jr., Von Haam E. Studies in Hodgkin’s syndrome; the association of viral hepatitis and Hodgkin’s disease; a preliminary report. Cancer Res. 1949;9:473–480.
- Huebner R.J., Rowe W.P., Schatten W.E., Smith R.R., Thomas L.B. Studies on the use of viruses in the treatment of carcinoma of the cervix. Cancer. 1956;9:1211–1218.
- Southam C.M., Moore A.E. Clinical studies of viruses as antineoplastic agents with particular reference to Egypt 101 virus. Cancer. 1952;5:1025–1034.
- Asada T. Treatment of human cancer with mumps virus. Cancer. 1974;34:1907–1928.
- Chiocca E.A. Oncolytic viruses. Nat. Rev. Cancer. 2002;2:938–950.
- Ikeda K., Ichikawa T., Wakimoto H., Silver J.S., Deisboeck T.S., Finkelstein D., Harsh G.R., 4th, Louis D.N., Bartus R.T., Hochberg F.H., Chiocca E.A. Oncolytic virus therapy of multiple tumors in the brain requires suppression of innate and elicited antiviral responses. Nat. Med. 1999;5:881–887.
- Kambara H., Saeki Y., Chiocca E.A. Cyclophosphamide allows for in vivo dose reduction of a potent oncolytic virus. Cancer Res. 2005;65:11255–11258.
- Thomas M.A., Spencer J.F., Toth K., Sagartz J.E., Phillips N.J., Wold W.S. Immunosuppression enhances oncolytic adenovirus replication and antitumor efficacy in the Syrian hamster model. Mol. Ther. 2008;16:1665–1673.
- Qiao J., Wang H., Kottke T., White C., Twigger K., Diaz R.M., Thompson J., Selby P., de Bono J., Melcher A. Cyclophosphamide facilitates antitumor efficacy against subcutaneous tumors following intravenous delivery of reovirus. Clin. Cancer Res. 2008;14:259–269.
- Lun X.Q., Jang J.H., Tang N., Deng H., Head R., Bell J.C., Stojdl D.F., Nutt C.L., Senger D.L., Forsyth P.A., McCart J.A. Efficacy of systemically administered oncolytic vaccinia virotherapy for malignant gliomas is enhanced by combination therapy with rapamycin or cyclophosphamide. Clin. Cancer Res. 2009;15:2777–2788.
- Hemminki O., Hemminki A. A century of oncolysis evolves into oncolytic immunotherapy. OncoImmunology. 2015;5:e1074377.
- Rehman H., Silk A.W., Kane M.P., Kaufman H.L. Into the clinic: Talimogene laherparepvec (T-VEC), a first-in-class intratumoral oncolytic viral therapy. J. Immunother. Cancer. 2016;4:53.
- Cervera-Carrascon V., Havunen R., Hemminki A. Oncolytic adenoviruses: a game changer approach in the battle between cancer and the immune system. Expert Opin. Biol. Ther. 2019;19:443–455.
- Guo Z.S., Lu B., Guo Z., Giehl E., Feist M., Dai E., Liu W., Storkus W.J., He Y., Liu Z., Bartlett D.L. Vaccinia virus-mediated cancer immunotherapy: cancer vaccines and oncolytics. J. Immunother. Cancer. 2019;7:6.
- Sanchala D.S., Bhatt L.K., Prabhavalkar K.S. Oncolytic Herpes Simplex Viral Therapy: A Stride toward Selective Targeting of Cancer Cells. Front. Pharmacol. 2017;8:270.
- Miliotou A.N., Papadopoulou L.C. CAR T-cell Therapy: A New Era in Cancer Immunotherapy. Curr. Pharm. Biotechnol. 2018;19:5–18.
- Watanabe K., Kuramitsu S., Posey A.D., Jr., June C.H. Expanding the Therapeutic Window for CAR T Cell Therapy in Solid Tumors: The Knowns and Unknowns of CAR T Cell Biology. Front. Immunol. 2018;9:2486.
- Rohaan M.W., Wilgenhof S., Haanen J.B.A.G. Adoptive cellular therapies: the current landscape. Virchows Arch. 2019;474:449–461.
- Met Ö., Jensen K.M., Chamberlain C.A., Donia M., Svane I.M. Principles of adoptive T cell therapy in cancer. Semin. Immunopathol. 2019;41:49–58.
- Ping Y., Liu C., Zhang Y. T-cell receptor-engineered T cells for cancer treatment: current status and future directions. Protein Cell. 2018;9:254–266.
- Darvin P., Toor S.M., Sasidharan Nair V., Elkord E. Immune checkpoint inhibitors: recent progress and potential biomarkers. Exp. Mol. Med. 2018;50:1–11.
- Hou B., Tang Y., Li W., Zeng Q., Chang D. Efficiency of CAR-T Therapy for Treatment of Solid Tumor in Clinical Trials: A Meta-Analysis. Dis. Markers. 2019;2019:3425291.
- Lee S., Margolin K. Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in melanoma. Curr. Oncol. Rep. 2012;14:468–474.
- Hu-Lieskovan S., Ribas A. New Combination Strategies Using Programmed Cell Death 1/Programmed Cell Death Ligand 1 Checkpoint Inhibitors as a Backbone. Cancer J. 2017;23:10–22.
- Moon E.K., Wang L.C., Dolfi D.V., Wilson C.B., Ranganathan R., Sun J., Kapoor V., Scholler J., Puré E., Milone M.C. Multifactorial T-cell hypofunction that is reversible can limit the efficacy of chimeric antigen receptor-transduced human T cells in solid tumors. Clin. Cancer Res. 2014;20:4262–4273.
- Bonaventura P., Shekarian T., Alcazer V., Valladeau-Guilemond J., Valsesia-Wittmann S., Amigorena S., Caux C., Depil S. Cold Tumors: A Therapeutic Challenge for Immunotherapy. Front. Immunol. 2019;10:168.
- Rosenberg S.A., Yang J.C., Sherry R.M., Kammula U.S., Hughes M.S., Phan G.Q., Citrin D.E., Restifo N.P., Robbins P.F., Wunderlich J.R. Durable complete responses in heavily pretreated patients with metastatic melanoma using T-cell transfer immunotherapy. Clin. Cancer Res. 2011;17:4550–4557.
- Peranzoni E., Lemoine J., Vimeux L., Feuillet V., Barrin S., Kantari-Mimoun C., Bercovici N., Guérin M., Biton J., Ouakrim H. Macrophages impede CD8 T cells from reaching tumor cells and limit the efficacy of anti-PD-1 treatment. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 2018;115:E4041–E4050.
- Fry T.J., Shah N.N., Orentas R.J., Stetler-Stevenson M., Yuan C.M., Ramakrishna S., Wolters P., Martin S., Delbrook C., Yates B. CD22-targeted CAR T cells induce remission in B-ALL that is naive or resistant to CD19-targeted CAR immunotherapy. Nat. Med. 2018;24:20–28.
- Guedan S., Alemany R. CAR-T Cells and Oncolytic Viruses: Joining Forces to Overcome the Solid Tumor Challenge. Front. Immunol. 2018;9:2460.
- Rosewell Shaw A., Suzuki M. Oncolytic Viruses Partner With T-Cell Therapy for Solid Tumor Treatment. Front. Immunol. 2018;9:2103.
- Guedan S., Alemany R. CAR-T Cells and Oncolytic Viruses: Joining Forces to Overcome the Solid Tumor Challenge. Front. Immunol. 2018;9:2460.
- Tähtinen S., Grönberg-Vähä-Koskela S., Lumen D., Merisalo-Soikkeli M., Siurala M., Airaksinen A.J., Vähä-Koskela M., Hemminki A. Adenovirus Improves the Efficacy of Adoptive T-cell Therapy by Recruiting Immune Cells to and Promoting Their Activity at the Tumor. Cancer Immunol. Res. 2015;3:915–925.
- Kaufman H.L., Kim D.W., DeRaffele G., Mitcham J., Coffin R.S., Kim-Schulze S. Local and distant immunity induced by intralesional vaccination with an oncolytic herpes virus encoding GM-CSF in patients with stage IIIc and IV melanoma. Ann. Surg. Oncol. 2010;17:718–730.
- Russell L., Peng K.W., Russell S.J., Diaz R.M.J.B. Oncolytic Viruses: Priming Time for Cancer Immunotherapy. BioDrugs. 2019;33:485–501.
- Zamarin D., Holmgaard R.B., Subudhi S.K., Park J.S., Mansour M., Palese P., Merghoub T., Wolchok J.D., Allison J.P. Localized oncolytic virotherapy overcomes systemic tumor resistance to immune checkpoint blockade immunotherapy. Sci. Transl. Med. 2014;6:226ra32.
- Woller N., Gürlevik E., Fleischmann-Mundt B., Schumacher A., Knocke S., Kloos A.M., Saborowski M., Geffers R., Manns M.P., Wirth T.C. Viral Infection of Tumors Overcomes Resistance to PD-1-immunotherapy by Broadening Neoantigenome-directed T-cell Responses. Mol. Ther. 2015;23:1630–1640.
- Brown M.C., Holl E.K., Boczkowski D., Dobrikova E., Mosaheb M., Chandramohan V., Bigner D.D., Gromeier M., Nair S.K. Cancer immunotherapy with recombinant poliovirus induces IFN-dominant activation of dendritic cells and tumor antigen-specific CTLs. Sci. Transl. Med. 2017;9:eaan4220.
- Kanerva A., Nokisalmi P., Diaconu I., Koski A., Cerullo V., Liikanen I., Tähtinen S., Oksanen M., Heiskanen R., Pesonen S. Antiviral and antitumor T-cell immunity in patients treated with GM-CSF-coding oncolytic adenovirus. Clin. Cancer Res. 2013;19:2734–2744.
- Nakano K., Todo T., Chijiiwa K., Tanaka M. Therapeutic efficacy of G207, a conditionally replicating herpes simplex virus type 1 mutant, for gallbladder carcinoma in immunocompetent hamsters. Mol. Ther. 2001;3:431–437.
- Hirano S., Etoh T., Okunaga R., Shibata K., Ohta M., Nishizono A., Kitano S. Reovirus inhibits the peritoneal dissemination of pancreatic cancer cells in an immunocompetent animal model. Oncol. Rep. 2009;21:1381–1384.
- Tysome J.R., Li X., Wang S., Wang P., Gao D., Du P., Chen D., Gangeswaran R., Chard L.S., Yuan M. A novel therapeutic regimen to eradicate established solid tumors with an effective induction of tumor-specific immunity. Clin. Cancer Res. 2012;18:6679–6689.
- Bunuales M., Garcia-Aragoncillo E., Casado R., Quetglas J.I., Hervas-Stubbs S., Bortolanza S., Benavides-Vallve C., Ortiz-de-Solorzano C., Prieto J., Hernandez-Alcoceba R. Evaluation of monocytes as carriers for armed oncolytic adenoviruses in murine and Syrian hamster models of cancer. Hum. Gene Ther. 2012;23:1258–1268.
- Siurala M., Vähä-Koskela M., Havunen R., Tähtinen S., Bramante S., Parviainen S., Mathis J.M., Kanerva A., Hemminki A. Syngeneic syrian hamster tumors feature tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes allowing adoptive cell therapy enhanced by oncolytic adenovirus in a replication permissive setting. OncoImmunology. 2016;5:e1136046.
- Andtbacka R.H., Kaufman H.L., Collichio F., Amatruda T., Senzer N., Chesney J., Delman K.A., Spitler L.E., Puzanov I., Agarwala S.S. Talimogene Laherparepvec Improves Durable Response Rate in Patients With Advanced Melanoma. J. Clin. Oncol. 2015;33:2780–2788.
- Tähtinen S., Kaikkonen S., Merisalo-Soikkeli M., Grönberg-Vähä-Koskela S., Kanerva A., Parviainen S., Vähä-Koskela M., Hemminki A. Favorable alteration of tumor microenvironment by immunomodulatory cytokines for efficient T-cell therapy in solid tumors. PLoS ONE. 2015;10:e0131242.
- Havunen R., Siurala M., Sorsa S., Grönberg-Vähä-Koskela S., Behr M., Tähtinen S., Santos J.M., Karell P., Rusanen J., Nettelbeck D.M. Oncolytic Adenoviruses Armed with Tumor Necrosis Factor Alpha and Interleukin-2 Enable Successful Adoptive Cell Therapy. Mol. Ther. Oncolytics. 2016;4:77–86.
- Cheng J., Zhao L., Zhang Y., Qin Y., Guan Y., Zhang T., Liu C., Zhou J. Understanding the Mechanisms of Resistance to CAR T-Cell Therapy in Malignancies. Front. Oncol. 2019;9:1237.
- Goins W.F., Huang S., Hall B., Marzulli M., Cohen J.B., Glorioso J.C. Engineering HSV-1 Vectors for Gene Therapy. Methods Mol. Biol. 2020;2060:73–90.
- Watanabe K., Luo Y., Da T., Guedan S., Ruella M., Scholler J., Keith B., Young R.M., Engels B., Sorsa S. Pancreatic cancer therapy with combined mesothelin-redirected chimeric antigen receptor T cells and cytokine-armed oncolytic adenoviruses. JCI Insight. 2018;3:e99573.
- Havunen R., Santos J.M., Sorsa S., Rantapero T., Lumen D., Siurala M., Airaksinen A.J., Cervera-Carrascon V., Tähtinen S., Kanerva A., Hemminki A. Abscopal Effect in Non-injected Tumors Achieved with Cytokine-Armed Oncolytic Adenovirus. Mol. Ther. Oncolytics. 2018;11:109–121.
- Echavarría M. Adenoviruses in immunocompromised hosts. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 2008;21:704–715.
- Leen A.M., Christin A., Khalil M., Weiss H., Gee A.P., Brenner M.K., Heslop H.E., Rooney C.M., Bollard C.M. Identification of hexon-specific CD4 and CD8 T-cell epitopes for vaccine and immunotherapy. J. Virol. 2008;82:546–554.
- Haveman L.M., Bierings M., Legger E., Klein M.R., de Jager W., Otten H.G., Albani S., Kuis W., Sette A., Prakken B.J. Novel pan-DR-binding T cell epitopes of adenovirus induce pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines in healthy donors. Int. Immunol. 2006;18:1521–1529.
- Munder M., Schneider H., Luckner C., Giese T., Langhans C.D., Fuentes J.M., Kropf P., Mueller I., Kolb A., Modolell M., Ho A.D. Suppression of T-cell functions by human granulocyte arginase. Blood. 2006;108:1627–1634.
- Munder M. Arginase: an emerging key player in the mammalian immune system. Br. J. Pharmacol. 2009;158:638–651.
- Rath M., Müller I., Kropf P., Closs E.I., Munder M. Metabolism via Arginase or Nitric Oxide Synthase: Two Competing Arginine Pathways in Macrophages. Front. Immunol. 2014;5:532.
- Frankel T., Lanfranca M.P., Zou W. The Role of Tumor Microenvironment in Cancer Immunotherapy. Adv. Exp. Med. Biol. 2017;1036:51–64.
- Datta M., Coussens L.M., Nishikawa H., Hodi F.S., Jain R.K. Reprogramming the Tumor Microenvironment to Improve Immunotherapy: Emerging Strategies and Combination Therapies. Am. Soc. Clin. Oncol. Educ. Book. 2019;39:165–174.
- Hope H.C., Salmond R.J. Targeting the tumor microenvironment and T cell metabolism for effective cancer immunotherapy. Eur. J. Immunol. 2019;49:1147–1152.
- Smith G.L., Benfield C.T.O., Maluquer de Motes C., Mazzon M., Ember S.W.J., Ferguson B.J., Sumner R.P. Vaccinia virus immune evasion: mechanisms, virulence and immunogenicity. J. Gen. Virol. 2013;94:2367–2392.
- Bahar M.W., Graham S.C., Chen R.A., Cooray S., Smith G.L., Stuart D.I., Grimes J.M. How vaccinia virus has evolved to subvert the host immune response. J. Struct. Biol. 2011;175:127–134.
- Andtbacka R.H.I., Collichio F., Harrington K.J., Middleton M.R., Downey G., Ӧhrling K., Kaufman H.L. Final analyses of OPTiM: a randomized phase III trial of talimogene laherparepvec versus granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor in unresectable stage III-IV melanoma. J. Immunother. Cancer. 2019;7:145.
- Gujar S., Pol J.G., Kim Y., Lee P.W., Kroemer G. Antitumor Benefits of Antiviral Immunity: An Underappreciated Aspect of Oncolytic Virotherapies. Trends Immunol. 2018;39:209–221.
- Parviainen S., Ahonen M., Diaconu I., Kipar A., Siurala M., Vähä-Koskela M., Kanerva A., Cerullo V., Hemminki A. GMCSF-armed vaccinia virus induces an antitumor immune response. Int. J. Cancer. 2015;136:1065–1072.
- Mattila R.K., Harila K., Kangas S.M., Paavilainen H., Heape A.M., Mohr I.J., Hukkanen V. An investigation of herpes simplex virus type 1 latency in a novel mouse dorsal root ganglion model suggests a role for ICP34.5 in reactivation. J. Gen. Virol. 2015;96:2304–2313.
- Snijder B., Sacher R., Rämö P., Liberali P., Mench K., Wolfrum N., Burleigh L., Scott C.C., Verheije M.H., Mercer J. Single-cell analysis of population context advances RNAi screening at multiple levels. Mol. Syst. Biol. 2012;8:579.
- Cervera-Carrascon V., Siurala M., Santos J.M., Havunen R., Tähtinen S., Karell P., Sorsa S., Kanerva A., Hemminki A. TNFa and IL-2 armed adenoviruses enable complete responses by anti-PD-1 checkpoint blockade. OncoImmunology. 2018;7:e1412902.
- Small E.J., Carducci M.A., Burke J.M., Rodriguez R., Fong L., van Ummersen L., Yu D.C., Aimi J., Ando D., Working P. A phase I trial of intravenous CG7870, a replication-selective, prostate-specific antigen-targeted oncolytic adenovirus, for the treatment of hormone-refractory, metastatic prostate cancer. Mol. Ther. 2006;14:107–117.
- Zeh H.J., Downs-Canner S., McCart J.A., Guo Z.S., Rao U.N., Ramalingam L., Thorne S.H., Jones H.L., Kalinski P., Wieckowski E. First-in-man study of western reserve strain oncolytic vaccinia virus: safety, systemic spread, and antitumor activity. Mol. Ther. 2015;23:202–214.
- Karapanagiotou E.M., Roulstone V., Twigger K., Ball M., Tanay M., Nutting C., Newbold K., Gore M.E., Larkin J., Syrigos K.N. Phase I/II trial of carboplatin and paclitaxel chemotherapy in combination with intravenous oncolytic reovirus in patients with advanced malignancies. Clin. Cancer Res. 2012;18:2080–2089.
Source: PubMed