Valuing the work of unpaid community health workers and exploring the incentives to volunteering in rural Africa

Frida Kasteng, Stella Settumba, Karin Källander, Anna Vassall, inSCALE Study Group, Karin Källander, Sylvia Meek, James Tibenderana, Zelee Hill, Daniel Strachan, Frida Kasteng, Betty Kirkwood, Raghu Lingam, Seyi Soremekun, Anna Vassall, Frida Kasteng, Stella Settumba, Karin Källander, Anna Vassall, inSCALE Study Group, Karin Källander, Sylvia Meek, James Tibenderana, Zelee Hill, Daniel Strachan, Frida Kasteng, Betty Kirkwood, Raghu Lingam, Seyi Soremekun, Anna Vassall

Abstract

Community health worker (CHW) programmes are currently being scaled-up in sub-Saharan Africa to improve access to healthcare. CHWs are often volunteers; from an economic perspective, this raises considerations whether reliance on an unpaid workforce is sustainable and how to appropriately cost and value the work of CHWs. Both these questions can be informed by an understanding of CHWs' workload, their opportunity costs of time and the perceived benefits of being a CHW. However, to date few studies have fully explored the methodological challenges in valuing CHW time. We examined the costs and benefits of volunteering in a sample of 45 CHWs providing integrated community case management of common childhood illnesses in rural Uganda in February 2012 using different methods. We assessed the value of CHW time using the minimum public sector salary rate and a CHW-elicited replacement wage, as well as the opportunity cost of time based on CHW-estimated annual income and alternative work opportunities, respectively. Reported monthly CHW workload, a median of 19.3 h (range 2.5-57), was valued at USD 6.9 (range 0.9-20.4) per month from the perspective of the healthcare system (applicable replacement wage) and at a median of USD 4.1 (range 0.4-169) from the perspective of the CHWs (individual opportunity cost of time). In a discrete choice experiment on preferred work characteristics, remuneration and community appreciation dominated. We find that volunteering CHWs value the opportunity to make a social contribution, but the decision to volunteer is also influenced by anticipated future rewards. Care must be taken by those costing and designing CHW programmes to acknowledge the opportunity cost of CHWs at the margin and over the long term. Failure to properly consider these issues may lead to cost estimations below the amount necessary to scale up and sustain programmes.

Keywords: Child health; Uganda; community health workers; integrated community case management; opportunity costs; volunteers.

© The Author 2015. Published by Oxford University Press in association with The London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.

References

    1. Adams JS. 1965. Inequity in social exchange. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 2: 267–99.
    1. Agyei-Baffour P, Hansen KS, et al. 2012. The amount and value of work time of community medicine distributors in community case management of malaria among children under five years in the Ejisu-Juaben District of Ghana. Malaria Journal 11: 277.
    1. Alam K, Tasneem S, et al. 2012. Performance of female volunteer community health workers in Dhaka urban slums. Social Science & Medicine 75: 511–5.
    1. Amouzou A, et al. 2014. Assessing the impact of integrated community case management (iCCM) programs on child mortality: review of early results and lessons learned in sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Global Health 4: 020411.
    1. B-Lajoie M-R, Hulme J, et al. 2014. Payday, ponchos, and promotions: a qualitative analysis of perspectives from non-governmental organization programme managers on community health worker motivation and incentives. Human Resources for Health 12: 66.
    1. Becker GS. 1965. A theory of the allocation of time. The Economic Journal 75: 493–517.
    1. Bénabou R, Tirole J. 2003. Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Review of Economic Studies 70: 489–520.
    1. Bénabou R, Tirole J. 2006. Incentives and prosocial behavior. American Economic Review 96: 1652–78.
    1. Blaauw D, Erasmus E, et al. 2010. Policy interventions that attract nurses to rural areas: a multicountry discrete choice experiment. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 88: 350–6.
    1. Blau PM. 1964. Exchange & Power in Social Life. New York: Wiley.
    1. Bosch-Capblanch X, Marceau C. 2014. Training, supervision and quality of care in selected integrated community case management (iCCM) programmes: a scoping review of programmatic evidence. Journal of Global Health 4: 020403.
    1. Carrell MR, Dittrich JE. 1978. Equity theory: the recent literature, methodological considerations, and new directions. The Academy of Management Review 3: 202–10.
    1. Chandler CI, Chonya S, et al. 2009. Motivation, money and respect: a mixed-method study of Tanzanian non-physician clinicians. Social Science & Medicine 68: 2078–88.
    1. Das J, Hammer J, et al. 2011. The Impact of Recall Periods on Reported Morbidity and Health Seeking Behavior. Impact Evaluation Series No. 51. Washington, D.C.: The World Bank.
    1. De Sousa A, Tiedje K, et al. 2012. Community case management of childhood illnesses: policy and implementation in countdown to 2015 countries. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 90: 183–90.
    1. Drummond MF, Sculpher MJ, et al. 2005. Methods for the Economic Evaluation of Health Care Programmes. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
    1. El Ansari W, Phillips CJ. 2004. The costs and benefits to participants in community partnerships: a paradox? Health Promotion Practice 5: 35–48.
    1. Frey BS, Jegen R. 2001. Motivation crowding theory. Journal of Economic Surveys 15: 589–611.
    1. George A, Young M, et al. 2012. Community health workers providing government community case management for child survival in sub-Saharan Africa: who are they and what are they expected to do? The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 87(5 Suppl): 85–91.
    1. Gilroy KE, Callaghan-Koru JA, et al. 2013. Quality of sick child care delivered by health surveillance assistants in Malawi. Health Policy and Planning 28: 573–85.
    1. Glenton C, Colvin CJ, et al. 2013. Barriers and facilitators to the implementation of lay health worker programmes to improve access to maternal and child health: qualitative evidence synthesis. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 10: CD010414.
    1. Gopalan SS, Mohanty S, Das A.2012. Assessing community health workers' performance motivation: a mixed-methods approach on India's Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHA) programme. BMJ Open 2: e001557.
    1. Hagberg LA, Lindholm L. 2010. Measuring the time costs of exercise: a proposed measuring method and a pilot study. Cost Effectiveness and Resource Allocation 8: 9.
    1. Hamer DH, Brooks ET, Semrau K, et al. 2012. Quality and safety of integrated community case management of malaria using rapid diagnostic tests and pneumonia by community health workers. Pathogens and Global Health 106: 32–9.
    1. Hensher DA, Rose JM, Greene WH. 2005. Applied Choice Analysis: A Primer. New York: Cambridge University Press.
    1. Herzberg F. 1987. One More Time: How Do You Motivate Employees? Harward Business Review 65: 109–20.
    1. Kalyango JN, Alfven T, Peterson S, et al. 2013. Integrated community case management of malaria and pneumonia increases prompt and appropriate treatment for pneumonia symptoms in children under five years in Eastern Uganda. Malaria Journal 12: 340.
    1. Kimbugwe G, Maghanga M, Oluka D, et al. 2014. Challenges faced by village health teams (VHTs) in Amuru, Gulu and Pader districts in Northern Uganda. Open Journal of Preventive Medicine 4: 740–50.
    1. Kironde S, Bajunirwe F. 2002. Lay workers in directly observed treatment (DOT) programmes for tuberculosis in high burden settings: should they be paid? A review of behavioural perspectives. African Health Sciences 2:73–8.
    1. Kolstad JR. 2011. How to make rural jobs more attractive to health workers. Findings from a discrete choice experiment in Tanzania. Health Economics 20: 196–211.
    1. Källander K, Strachan D, Soremekun S, et al. 2015. Evaluating the effect of innovative motivation and supervision approaches on community health worker performance and retention in Uganda and Mozambique: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials 16: 157.
    1. Lehmann U, Sanders D. 2007. Community Health Workers: What Do We Know About Them? The State of the Evidence on Programmes, Activities, Costs and Impact on Health Outcomes of Using Community Health Workers. Geneva: WHO. , accessed 20 May 2015.
    1. Ludwick T Brenner JL Kyomuhangi T Wotton KA Kabakyenga JK. . 2014. Poor retention does not have to be the rule: retention of volunteer community health workers in Uganda. Health Policy and Planning 29: 388–95.
    1. Maes K. 2012. Volunteerism or labor exploitation? harnessing the volunteer spirit to sustain AIDS treatment programs in urban Ethiopia. Human Organization 71: 54–64.
    1. Maes K, Kalofonos I. 2013. Becoming and remaining community health workers: perspectives from Ethiopia and Mozambique. Social Science & Medicine 87: 52–9.
    1. Malaria Consortium. 2013. Improving access for under-fives to life saving treatment through integrated community case management for malaria, pneumonia, and diarrhoea: programme completion report submitted to Canadian International Development Agency. Kampala, Uganda: Malaria Consortium, , accessed 6 May 2015.
    1. Mangham LJ, Hanson K. 2008. Employment preferences of public sector nurses in Malawi: results from a discrete choice experiment. Tropical Medicine & International Health 13: 1433–41.
    1. Miller GA. 1956. The magical number seven, plus or minus two: some limits on our capacity for processing information. Psychological Review 63: 81–97.
    1. Nonvignon J, Chinbuah MA, Gyapong M, et al. 2012. Is home management of fevers a cost-effective way of reducing under-five mortality in Africa? The case of a rural Ghanaian District. Tropical Medicine & International Health 17: 951–7.
    1. Posnett J, Jan S. 1996. Indirect cost in economic evaluation: the opportunity cost of unpaid inputs. Health Economics 5: 13–23.
    1. Prado TN, Wada N, Guidoni LM, et al. 2011. Cost-effectiveness of community health worker versus home-based guardians for directly observed treatment of tuberculosis in Vitoria, Espirito Santo State, Brazil. Cadernos de Saúde Pública 27: 944–52.
    1. Rahman SM, Ali NA, Jennings L, et al. 2010. Factors affecting recruitment and retention of community health workers in a newborn care intervention in Bangladesh. Human Resources for Health 8: 12.
    1. Rose JM, Bliemer MCJ. 2005. Sample optimality in the design of stated choice experiments. Working paper: ITLS-WP-05‐13. Sydney: The University of Sydney.
    1. Rose JM, Bliemer MCJ. 2013. Sample size requirements for stated choice experiments. Transportation 40: 1021–41.
    1. Sahlen KG Lofgren C Brodin H Dahlgren L Lindholm L. . 2012. Measuring the value of older people's production: a diary study. BMC Health Services Research 12: 4.
    1. Salamon LM, Sokolowski SW, Haddock MA. 2011. Measuring the economic value of volunteer work globally: concepts, estimates, and a roadmap to the future. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics 82: 217–52.
    1. Smith R, Lagarde M, Blaauw D, et al. 2013. Appealing to altruism: an alternative strategy to address the health workforce crisis in developing countries? Journal of Public Health 35: 164–70.
    1. Soremekun S, Kasteng F. 2013. The inSCALE Baseline Survey Uganda. London: Malaria Consortium, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UCL Institute of Child Health. , accessed 20 May 2015.
    1. South J, Purcell ME, Branney P, Gamsu M, White J. 2014. Rewarding altruism: addressing the issue of payments for volunteers in public health initiatives. Social Science & Medicine 104: 80–7.
    1. Strachan DL, Källander K, Ten Asbroek AH, et al. 2012. Interventions to improve motivation and retention of community health workers delivering integrated community case management (iCCM): stakeholder perceptions and priorities. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 87(5 Suppl): 111–9.
    1. Swidler A, Watkins SC. 2009. Teach a man to fish: the sustainability doctrine and its social consequences. World Development 37: 1182–96.
    1. Train KE. 2009. Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
    1. Tranmer JE, Guerriere DN, Ungar WJ, Coyte PC. 2005. Valuing patient and caregiver time: a review of the literature. Pharmacoeconomics 23: 449–59.
    1. Uganda Bureau of Statistics. 2010. Uganda National Household Survey 2009/2010: Socio-Economic Module. Kampala: Uganda Bureau of Statistics; , accessed 6 May 2015.
    1. Uganda Ministry of Health. 2010a. Integrated Community Case Management of Childhood Malaria, Pneumonia and Diarrhoea - Implementation Guidelines . Kampala: Uganda Ministry of Health/WHO/UNICEF; , accessed 6 May 2015.
    1. Uganda Ministry of Health. 2010b. Operational Guidelines for Establishing and Scale up of Village Health Teams: Updated Strategic and Operational Guidelines. , accessed 6 May 2015.
    1. Uganda Ministry of Public Service. 2013. Salary Structure for 2012/2013 Financial Year. Kampal: Uganda Ministry of Public Service: , accessed 10 February 2014.
    1. UN Volunteers, I. S. a. 2001. Measuring volunteering: A practical toolkit. A. Dingle. Washington, DC: Independent Sector and United Nations Volunteers; , accessed 6 May 2015.
    1. van den Berg B, Brouwer W, van Exel J, et al. 2006. Economic valuation of informal care: lessons from the application of the opportunity costs and proxy good methods. Social Science & Medicine 62: 835–45.
    1. WHO. 2006. The World Health Report 2006: Working Together for Health. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO; , accessed 6 May 2015.
    1. WHO. 2008. Task Shifting: Rational Redistribution of Tasks Among Health Workforce Teams : Global Recommendations and Guidelines. Geveva: WHO; , accessed 6 May 2015.
    1. WHO/UNICEF. 2012. Integrated Community Case Management (iCCM): An Equity-Focused Strategy to Improve Access to Essential Treatment Services for Children. Geveva: WHO; New York: UNICEF. , accessed 6 May 2015.
    1. Ziemek S. 2006. Economic analysis of volunteers’ motivations – A cross- country study. Journal of Socio-Economics 35: 532–55

Source: PubMed

Sponsors en medewerkers

Medische omstandigheden

Geneesmiddelinterventies

3
Abonneren